Muhammad Sani Garba (@____msg) header
Muhammad Sani Garba (@____msg) profile picture

Stay true to yourself.

Abuja, Nigeria
Joined September 2020
Photo by Muhammad Sani Garba (@____msg)Photo by Muhammad Sani Garba (@____msg)Photo by Muhammad Sani Garba (@____msg)Photo by Muhammad Sani Garba (@____msg)Photo by Muhammad Sani Garba (@____msg)Photo by Muhammad Sani Garba (@____msg)Photo by Muhammad Sani Garba (@____msg)Photo by Muhammad Sani Garba (@____msg)Photo by Muhammad Sani Garba (@____msg)Photo by Muhammad Sani Garba (@____msg)
Replying to @Kaita26_27
Daer brother.
1
1
7
Replying to @LordKachi1
Big name Kachi.
3
Thank you for this. It appears to me that you did not get the crux of my argument. My argument is not that taking criminal defence briefs is bad. No! I believe that when doing so, Lawyers must not merely bank on a loophole in the prosecution and have someone who is meant to be behind bars walk free and continue to be a menace to society. Especially when they know that the suspect committed the crime. Rule 1 of the Rules of Professional Conduct for Legal Practitioners states in clear terms that a Lawyer shall... PROMOTE AND FOSTER THE CAUSE OF JUSTICE... I have experienced how 'dirty' some criminal defence Lawyers can be, and that is what made me have reservations about criminal matters.
I agree counsel; And I love your argument. That law can not be entirely divorced of morality. But there's a difference between morality and duty. Allow me to ask, flowing from your position on the defence lawyer doing his work, do you then want a defence lawyer to try his own client or see to the conviction of his own client simply because he knows he is guilty? Should a defence lawyer be doing both prosecution and defence together? I know you will agree otherwise. Prosecution should "prosecute" while defence should "defend". Also, let it be firmly on record that it is in fact not the defence lawyer who "frees" or has the power to discharge or set a defendant free. It is the Judge. Should a Judge apply morality and conscience too or apply the law and evaluation of evidence placed before him towards the discharge or conviction of an accused? I do not agree that it is hard to prosecute. I put it to you that it is more harder proving innocence than it is to convict. This will bring me joining issues with you on conscience and morality. Conscience and morality is not one sided. It applies to the prosecution too. All over the world, we have seen cases of unjust incarcerations. So it is also an issue of conscience to ensure that an innocent person is not punished. And that is the duty of the defence. The entire jurisprudence of criminal law rests on the doctrine of the law preferring an acquittal of 99 guilty persons than a conviction of one innocent person. - William Blackstone Also in fact, the job of a prosecution is to prosecute and not persecute. It's not to secure conviction by all means. The law provides ingredients to secure conviction for each crime. Same law provides ingredients to prove innocence. Any party can exploit loopholes. But I maintain that it is both parties duties to not leave gap for loopholes. A prosecution should in fact not file a charge if they haven't gotten watertight proofs in support. Again, even if loopholes were exploited, a lot of the time, it only reduces the degrees of the sentence and not outright acquittal. It's hard getting discharged and acquitted. And 9 out of 10, if a defendant secured an acquittal, then they likely didn't commit the offence.
1
11
Replying to @FabianSani8
What is even there in litigaton to be afraid of? I ask.
7
Replying to @maleek_mukhtar
Oh, my dear Katsina.
2
Replying to @Kaita26_27
Abu bai yi yau ba. Allah ya ji kan ta da gafara.
1
1
10
All that we are, God made us. All that we have, God gave us.
2
9
19
293
Replying to @ibeobinna444
I don't think so. The law as I know it is that, an exhibit/annexure is part of an Affidavit and MUST be looked at by the court before it arrives at a conclusion.
15
"...it is not the job of any lawyer, in criminal or civil to apply morality or conscience." The above statement made me recall the principle of law and morality and it never ending relationship as propounded by Lord Coleridge R v. Dudley and Stephens. His exact words were: "Though law and morality are not the same, and many things may be immoral which are not necessarily illegal, yet the absolute divorce of law from morality would be of fatal consequence." I'd argue that prosecuting a matter can sometimes be difficult, especially where there is gap (no matter how little) that is not filled during trial. However much the defence lawyer hides behind the excuse that he is merely "doing his job", there is a voice that will not leave him alone whenever he leans on a "loophole" to free a defendant who has already confessed to him that he committed the alleged crime. That voice is conscience. And conscience is the greatest hunter of the man who refuses to listen to it. It does not shout. It waits. It follows him home, sits with him in silence, and hunts him down in the quiet moments when the courtroom applause has faded. I like your last paragraph.
Solid position. But I totally disagree to the extent that it is not the job of any lawyer, in criminal or civil to apply morality or conscience. As there are loopholes in criminal matters, there are same in civil matters. That there may be loopholes in the prosecution's case doesn't always result to the Defendant's discharge. Also, what we often call loopholes, is just a dignifying way of saying the other party has not done their job well as they should or they outrightly lacks competence. And it will be totally unfair to hold a criminal defence lawyer in a cage of conscience and morality for doing his job as a defence lawyer and excusing the prosecution for failing to prove their case to the strictest requirements of the law. The ingredients required to secure conviction are there for a reason. That a prosecution leave the door open for loopholes is totally a cross for him to carry. And more often than not, what a defence lawyer does is not always to allow a guilty person go unpunished but to ensure he doesn't get punished "beyond the extent of his culpability."
1
1
121
Replying to @egi_nupe
Fight ke? It shall never be heard.
18
Replying to @ellwahabb
Good luck.
474
This is why I have reservations about criminal defence. For me, the moral criticism is that legal ethics can excuse conduct that morality still judges. The fact that a rule permits a lawyer to test the prosecution or exploit a "loophole" does not by itself make the defendant innocent in most cases. And from my experience in law practice thus far, prosecutors mostly do not do an all-round excellent job when handling matters. I know it is the law to exploit a loophole, but conscience asks harder questions in the long run. In other words, civil litigation is my choosing. I pray @Chinaluemmanuel doesn't see this.
Yes they do. But we do not have the ethical right to tell the court they do. Our communication with them is confidential. It’s for the state to prove their guilt except they choose to plead guilty. Even if they plead guilty in capital offence, the court must record not guilty for them and we go into full trial. Unlike what people think, defense attorneys don’t tell lies on behalf of their client. We only find loopholes in the case of the prosecution that are favourable to our clients and as the law requires, once the loopholes create reasonable doubt, the court must resolve it in favour of the accused not minding that they pleaded guilty.
2
4
2
10
1,181
Muhammad Sani Garba retweeted
Luqmān said to his son: “O my son increase in saying 'Allāh forgive me' for indeed Allāh has hours in which He does not reject a beggar." ● [شعب الإيمان للبيهقي ١١٣٠]
6
29
711
Muhammad Sani Garba retweeted
Luqmān said to his son: “Speak the truth even if it is against yourself and do not care about who is getting angry.” ● [أداب الشريعة ٧٤/١]
1
22
98
1,357
Replying to @Uzzy_of_Law
Interesting.
1
55
Replying to @egi_nupe
Kpele, sir. Directly or indirectly, criminal matters have a way of frustrating someone in a special way.
1
160
Thank you, sir. May God continue to enrich you in knowledge and wealth.
1
16
Replying to @INothing202
Some days are like that sha.
1
1
11