ATTLEE (@_attlee) profile picture

Rawdogging the decline of capitalism

Joined September 2015
Photo by ATTLEE (@_attlee)Photo by ATTLEE (@_attlee)Photo by ATTLEE (@_attlee)Photo by ATTLEE (@_attlee)Photo by ATTLEE (@_attlee)Photo by ATTLEE (@_attlee)Photo by ATTLEE (@_attlee)Photo by ATTLEE (@_attlee)Photo by ATTLEE (@_attlee)Photo by ATTLEE (@_attlee)
ATTLEE retweeted
irrational). Given Feser’s track record of intellectual mendacity—one of the most formidable in modern history—what is more likely?
1
1
ATTLEE retweeted
acquainted with the theory and can articulate a refutation of it—Feser must either be unacquainted with the theory—in which case his silence bespeaks ignorance rather than irrationality—or he's acquainted with the theory but can’t articulate a refutation (in other words, he’s
1
1
1
ATTLEE retweeted
Replying to @FeserEdward
Conservatism is a straightforwardly irrational and utopian project if there are epistemic reasons to take the implications of the labor theory of value seriously, namely that the overthrow of world capitalism is an existential necessity. Thus, barring the inconceivable—Feser is
1
1
1
ATTLEE retweeted
Richardson and Jay Joseph, to take two recent examples—so she resorts to vilification and other diversionary tactics, but no amount of vilification can mitigate the fact that the assumptions that ground her positions do not withstand scientific scrutiny: psyarxiv.com/kgz2t/
1
1
ATTLEE retweeted
THE GENETIC LOTTERY is a tissue of sophistries, deceptions, self-deceptions, distortions, omissions, half-truths, and unsubstantiated assertions. Harden is unable to respond honestly and seriously to the most cogent critiques of behavioral genetics—those advanced by Ken 1/2
unavailable
1
1
ATTLEE retweeted
I take it that for a concept to be incoherent is for it to entail a contradiction, so what contradiction does the concept of gender identity entail?
ATTLEE retweeted
Replying to @peterboghossian
Given your training in philosophy, I was expecting a demonstration of the claim that gender identity is incoherent, rather than the mere assertion that it is. "Claims about gender identity fail to rise to the level of being truth-apt or minimally coherent" What's the argument?
1
1
ATTLEE retweeted
It looks like Fukuyama is just begging the question that civilization can survive under “liberal democracy” (capitalism), which contradicts the implications of the labor theory of value. Does Fukuyama have a refutation of the labor theory of value?
ATTLEE retweeted
Replying to @artcarden @aier
Would you concede that “Not real socialism” doesn’t have any force against those who draw a distinction between deformed/degenerated workers’ states and who deny that it’s possible for socialism to exist in a single country?
ATTLEE retweeted
Replying to @_attlee @IzaTabaro
convictions. So unless you think free speech is not purposive, you’re not opposed to censorship, you just oppose particular instances of censorship, which aren’t really censorship, but just criticisms of ideas that you’re sympathetic to. 3/3
ATTLEE retweeted
Replying to @_attlee @IzaTabaro
tolerated. Free speech is not an “absolute value” then, but a pragmatic value that advances the partisan convictions of some individuals over and against the partisan convictions of others. The purpose that governs free speech will necessarily reflect these partisan 2/3
1
1
ATTLEE retweeted
Replying to @IzaTabaro
Free speech is a meaningful notion only in relation to a purpose that constrains and, by constraining, informs its exercise. If free speech has a purpose it just follows that one has a commitment to censoring ideas that threaten that purpose when they can no longer be 1/3
1
1
ATTLEE retweeted
advance your own partisan beliefs about what constitutes “historical truth”, but then I don’t understand why you would think that there is a principle (in the sense of an absolute value) at work unless by “principle” you just mean your own partisan convictions. 3/3
ATTLEE retweeted
believe that tolerating Holocaust deniers would hinder or jeopardize the advancement of historical truth (the goal that free speech promotes) but in that case, you would not be acting pursuant to an absolute value, i.e. a principle, but rather would be acting pragmatically to 2/
1
1
ATTLEE retweeted
I imagine you would agree that free speech ought to exclude Holocaust denial if the risks of tolerating Holocaust denial were more costly than the risks of constraining it, that is, muzzling Holocaust deniers would be justified—in fact would be necessary—if you had reason to 1/
1
1
ATTLEE retweeted
meanings of their own concepts doesn’t commit you to anti-realism about your own intentional states. 3/3
ATTLEE retweeted
equivocation fallacy here, or if you’re not equivocating, how you’re not changing the subject. Or thirdly—supposing you’re not equivocating or changing the subject—perhaps you can explain how adopting the view that trans women who identify as lesbians are mistaken about the 2/
1
1
ATTLEE retweeted
Replying to @kathleen_stock1
@docstockk “Lesbians” is ambiguous between two concepts—a concept that includes those assigned male at birth and a concept that excludes such individuals—but “We’re” in the second statement refers to the second concept, so perhaps you can explain how you’re not guilty of an 1/
1
1
ATTLEE retweeted
predictive power and other explanatory virtues.