Andy Boyd (@ajcboyd) header
Andy Boyd (@ajcboyd) profile picture

Senior research fellow at University of Buckingham specialising in 20th century British naval history.

Joined April 2017
Photo by Andy Boyd (@ajcboyd)Photo by Andy Boyd (@ajcboyd)Photo by Andy Boyd (@ajcboyd)Photo by Andy Boyd (@ajcboyd)Photo by Andy Boyd (@ajcboyd)Photo by Andy Boyd (@ajcboyd)Photo by Andy Boyd (@ajcboyd)Photo by Andy Boyd (@ajcboyd)Photo by Andy Boyd (@ajcboyd)Photo by Andy Boyd (@ajcboyd)
It's out there! Released today, 14 September! Now available from Pen & Sword at discounted price of £28.
9
23
4
86
Interesting piece as ever. REPULSE was on pre-patrol index, preparing to relieve RESOLUTION. She was en-route back to Faslane to ready for deployment when the Victor was detected on her towed array.
On 29 March 1982, the MOD issued a press release on the presence of a Soviet submarine off the British coast doing 'sneaky stuff'. In reality HMS REPULSE was tracking a Soviet VICTOR SSN and HMS SPLENDID & RN/RAF aircraft were in hot pursuit. Thread on a forgotten incident...
3
161
“Dreadnought is late” is code for ‘successive governments decided to delay repeatedly the replacement of the Vanguard class while simultaneously reducing investment in the maintenance facilities.’ Our ships’ companies are paying the price of political cowardice.
5
16
73
2,624
The Royal Navy has released a remembrance film marking 125 years of the Submarine Service, made in memory of the nearly 6,000 submariners and more than 150 submarines that never came home
6
39
1
184
7,326
My review of Edward Abel Smith's 'A Hateful Decision' is here: naval-review.com/book-review… Those historians who provided enthusiastic endorsement should reflect on their motives and judgement in applauding a work which is substantially fiction. As should publisher, Penguin.
2
2
10
650
Now available in paperback: 📖 British Naval Intelligence through the Twentieth Century by @ajcboyd, with a foreword by Andrew Lambert 🔗 buff.ly/LwCcRbY
3
10
375
Thank you!
While @ajcboyd's "The Royal Navy in Eastern Waters" remains one of the best accounts of the @RoyalNavy's Eastern Fleet in the buildup to & early years of the war in Asia #WW2 amazon.co.uk/Royal-Navy-East…
1
1
10
685
Delighted with these two recent reviews: '...the best modern account of the naval war in the Arctic...'   English Historical Review '... essential reading for anyone interested in the subject.  Highly recommended'  Mariner's Mirror
1
1
11
227
Ref my earlier post. The prominent historians who enthusiastically endorsed Smith's book should ask themselves hard questions. They won't because toadying to broadsheet review editors, big publishing houses, and the celebrity circuit takes precedence over historical integrity./1
3
11
1,583
I am not starry eyed about the past but the popularisation of history through podcasts et al is too often promoting a steady dumbing down. And the honest critical review is certainly fast dying out.
9
160
An important, thoughtful and refreshingly honest re-evaluation by @robert_lyman of Edward Abel Smith's 'Hateful Decision'. As this extract from my forthcoming piece for the 'Naval Review' shows, I had already reached the same view on Smith's free resort to fiction: /1
1
8
509
spoke, acted and experienced events. Defenders of this practice, a long established technique in television documentaries, argue that it lends vital colour and renders the past more accessible to a wider audience. In Smith's case too much of his 'colour' ranges between the /3
1
3
108
exaggerated, unsubstantiated, and downright implausible.' In addition to the fiction problem, Smith's knowledge of naval terminology, custom and practice, is woeful. His reconstructed dialogue is not only implausible but often borders on the bizarre. /4
4
81
Look forward to your conclusions! The Enigma 'Red' key used by the GAF was broken in early May 1940 and read currently and continuously by BP for the rest of the war. Hinsley summarises its contribution before and during the Battle of Britain, value and limitations, in British/1
Super excited as im taking delivery of the ULTRA records for the Battle of Britain at the moment. These are interesting as the records for 1940 were declassified a long time after the rest of the ULTRA records for ww2. It will be interesting to see if there is a tangible reason for that from the contents. “Speculation” might be that the government maybe felt that disclosure might harm the “few” legend which has become such a part of British national celebration. But if that was the case why release them at all ? We will see what the contents say, not that anything inside could detract from the fact that someone still has to go and shoot planes down and somehow also not die. SIGINT all goes out the window once the planes engage. Or as succinctly described by Mike Tyson “everyone has a plan until they get punched in the face”…
1
1
9
928
on the actual source. Ironically, it was the Admiralty who could best exploit Red decrypts through 1940 and 41. This was because BP shared all sigint relevant to naval operations with the Admiralty Operational Intelligence Centre. The reasons for this unique relationship are/4
1
4
64
set out in my book:
6
62
UK SSBNs have always had many options to ensure security when deploying on patrol. Despite the fixation of journalists and others on SSN 'delousing', this has never been a necessary requirement either in the Cold War or after. Indeed direct SSN escort was/is vanishingly rare.
With the current SSBN patrol now having passed 140 days, we can guess on recent form, that they have another month or two to go before this boat deploys to replace them. Hopefully by then the RN will have an Astute Class SSN available for delousing duties...
2
2
11
2,481