Pinned Tweet
As part of trying to find my voice on here, I'm going to take a shot at writing some longform pieces. The first is up now: a very personal and (I hope) diverting account of my relationship and its demise. Please share and subscribe (link in thread)
Many people are saying
My Unpopular Opinion: DO NOT BE AN ADVENT NAZI.
I went overboard with the liturgical correctness and ended up making December bleak and Christmas Eve seriously stressful for my family when we were raising our son because of buying and decorating the tree at the last possible minute.
I was ridiculous about Christmas music. We used to play Bach's "Wachet Auf" on the First Sunday of Advent and no Christmas carols until Gaudete Sunday.
Now I have gone to the opposite extreme, and I recommend it to everyone:
The day after Halloween, start up the secular Christmas music--e.g., Frank Sinatra's version of "Let It Snow" ("He doesn't care if it's ten below / He's sitting by the fire's cozy glow"), "I'm Driving Home for Christmas," "Jingle Bell Rock," and the Gene Autry and Elvis versions of "Here Comes Santa Claus":
He doesn't care if you're rich or poor
He loves you just the same
Santa Claus knows we're all God's children
That makes everything right
So fill your hearts with Christmas cheer
'Cause Santa Claus comes tonight
The day after Thanksgiving, make the Johnny Cash Christmas specials the background of your life.
The first Sunday of Advent, add in the religious Christmas carols.
Gaudete Sunday, festoon the house with holly and ivy and lights and decorate the tree.
Keep up the tree, greenery, lights, and Christmas music until the Feast of the Presentation on February 2nd.
This way you get THREE MONTHS of Christmas. And don't you think "we need a little Christmas, right this very minute"?
1
1
202
All weekend theyβve been playing Songs for Christmas 5.B, just resetting the needle over and over, Sister Winter β Star of Wonder β Holy, Holy, Holy, the most sublime sequence in the whole corpus
128
Austin π»π¦ retweeted
the Vatican Museum does something cool which is it puts the whole thesis of its 70,000+ piece collection inside this one image for easy reference
My version of βis everyone hanging out without meβ is periodically wondering if all the Catholics I know are secretly in Opus Dei and they just havenβt tried to recruit me because my life is pretty much screwed up beyond repair
3
21
867
Itβs weird how little attention the Opus Dei story seems to get on here. Are yβall all supernumeraries orβ¦?
Replying to @peterswindal
You aren't familiar with the allegations at all? Off the top of my head:
- using aggressive social pressure to recruit young people (many under 18) to be numerary members, in a way that would be canonically forbidden to a religious order
- pressuring young numeraries to make lifelong promises of loyalty that are tantamount to religious vows without any novitiate period or other canonical protections to ensure vows are freely made
- recruiting numerary assistants from poor populations to be an internal servant class, moving them between countries in a way that severely impairs their personal agency, illegally not paying into government entitlement programs on their behalf, etc
- a pervasive internal culture of secrecy and tightly controlled flow of information
- intimidation tactics, an internal surveillance network, any slight indication of disloyalty reported upward, etc
- strong pressure that confession only be made to an opus dei superior, with at least circumstantial evidence of confessors violating the seal
- highly extractive fundraising methods (e.g. taking over that spanish bank and driving it to failure, causing considerable downstream economic fallout)
- systematically obfuscating their presence and identity (bland "cultural center" terminology, etc)
- having two completely different sets of constitutions, one actually used internally and another presented to the vatican
- constantly lobbying the vatican for special treatment and less oversight, while also jockeying for influence
- aggressively intimidating any ex-members who criticize the prelature, extremely defensive posture toward outside critics
- maintaining an army of supernumerary members who aren't subject to any of the above and kept unaware, who provide a cover of normality in public discourse
I'm willing to hear defensive arguments, but there's a lot of smoke here and imo Gore has done the church a considerable service in tracking it all down and presenting it in an organized fashion. Other Catholic religious orders and lay movements don't have the volume of ex-members describing their experience in terms of psychological coercion. I find it deeply troubling.
4
6
890
the reformed 2cv thing is always funny to me but maybe I understand the feeling, I was recently in the basilica gift shop in dc and they were selling a bracelet that had depictions of non-canonical angels whose veneration was suppressed by pope st zachary in 745 and I was like π
119
I am βitβs really cool when a woman maintains a stylish hairstyle while going naturally grayβ years old
1
18
495
This is trad, Nov 11 is the beginning of St Martinβs Lent
Spotted in DC tonight. An absolute travesty.
I canβt wait to launch our Philosophy of Time course at the Cluny Academy.
Birthdays should be celebrated on the date of birth, anniversaries on the actual date, and Christmas trees should never be seen in early November.
Go ahead and give me your excuses of convenience, and I will tell you why they are wrong.
98
βMarital idolatryβ I know thereβs a similar idea in the CCC but describing every disordered love as idolatry feels latently iconoclastic to me. An idol must be destroyed, but participating in divine worship is the thing that will allow all other loves to find their proper order
4
223
Itβs a silly article but the backlash really does highlight the latent divisions and even mutual incomprehension among TGCβs audience over what church services are, and what they are for. It is a parachurch βcoalitionβ after all, shouldnβt come as a surprise
"As Julie and I discussed it, we thought it was worth calling Christian couples to re-imagine what itβs like walking into church on your own, and then to think of church less like a date and more like a deployment."
βDave Moore
au.thegospelcoalition.org/arβ¦
1
3
383
such a letdown when a word has to be deitalicized for ""emphasis"" some upstart type designer needs to invent a font with real superitalicsβ¦ swoops and ribbons, curly qβs etc
1
97
piling into a van with four of your best friends and driving five hours to see a band youβre obsessed with and then crashing at someoneβs house just to drive home the next day is a thing I experienced for the first time at 39 (the friends being of course my kids)
10
203















