
ALT Key findings: It flatly prohibits the State of Arizona or any local government from contracting with any labor union. As such -- and as Intervenors stipulate -- its inclusion in HCR 2040 violates the Separate Amendment Rule. When a proposed ballot measure violates the Separate Amendment Rule, severance of the offending provision is not an option. The entire measure fails. Clean Elections Institute, Inc. v. Brewer, 209 Ariz. 241, ¶ 8 (2004). Because the Court agrees with Plaintiffs’ interpretation of HCR 2040, the Court does not reach Plaintiffs’ alternative arguments, including whether the Act’s title violates the Single Subject Rule. Rulings IT IS ORDERED: 1. Declaring that House Concurrent Resolution 2040 violates Article XXI, §1, of the Arizona Constitution (Separate Amendment Rule). 2. Enjoining the Arizona Secretary of State from including HCR 2040 on the 2026 General Election Ballot.




























