Keith Scott retweeted
Replying to @ME_Beaumont
Michael
Happy to chat to you without a Twitter bunfight. Perhaps, the most important discussion is between yourselves, the DA and where necessary the ANC.
Democracy is about - among many other elements- accepting the outcome of an election and the leadership that won. I am not a fan of your party or the DA. But, the majority of voters correctly turned their backs on my erstwhile political party the ANC.
Moreover, none of the parties anywhere can claim that you represent the “people” or “hold the cards”. No. The majority of people did not vote.
Gauteng’s future, its people cannot be held hostage by past battles.
Believe me, I do not think it is easy to deal with @HermanMashaba or @helenzille but too much is at stake.
Keith Scott retweeted
bbc.com/news/articles/cmq8l2… "TV crime drama 'glamourises drugs' police chief says" Wrong! It shows how drug prohibition has given control of drug production and sales, and the consequent huge profits, to criminals. That's the real problem. @merpolchiefcon @MerseyPolice #druglawreform
Keith Scott retweeted
It's almost a cult mantra among the bulk of SA's political media and commentators that the ANC in the Mbeki years was glorious and beyond reproach, and that Zuma then came and messed things up. In their bubble, you cannot dare point out that the ANC was pretty dreadful all along.
Jonny Steinberg must have been at a different event. My explanation to his reconstruction of events is this: He knows what a hapless facilitator he was. He battled to handle a situation where I did not buy into the unstated premise of the ANC's moral superiority. He has fluttered in the ANC's orbit for decades, and enjoyed being loved for it. He has to find a way to define any resistance to this as "the problem". I love the use of the word "strange". The only strange thing was the fear and resistance to a different perspective being expressed at an "academic seminar" at Yale. But I suppose that summarises American universities right now. As far as SA is concerned, they are stuck in the 1980s. Perfect place for Jonny to be a Professor.
Keith Scott retweeted
Ben Dekker has passed away in Port St. John's at the age of 86. South African actor and Transkei legend... 😢
Keith Scott retweeted
Sacha… I had some dealings with him, and there was a moment that stay with me and that showed me what he is all about.
what i realise about him is this: he is someone who sees further than you. he can be in a situation , but he can also be above the situation, seeing where it is going and what is needed right now. i don’t mean in a rugby sense. I mean in term of emotional intelligence, situational awareness, bigger picture.
people like that often get a hard time because they have to try bring the rest of us along . they can see the path like crystal clear and exactly what is needed, even if we do not yet. Rassie is also like that
so all this talk about cockiness and such is really just k*k for clicks . he is not a shallow person, or your grandpa’s fool. he is a very talented, humble and hard working young guy who in many ways is a little bit ahead of the curve.
that, and the natural enthusiasm of youth , will always get up the noses of some people . but he can back it up. and we must celebrate that he belongs to us 💪🏻
If one reads the whole article and not just the deceptive headline one may see that @clintonV has written extremely favourably about SachaFM.
Replying to @SARugbymag @ClintonV
I was at a lunch with Cheslin Kolbe last week. He sang Sacha’s praises. Not just the performances; the attitude, the work ethic, the seriousness with which he goes about his business. Really rated him. I quite like people who are emotionally expressive. Some people, it seems, don’t.
1
14
Keith Scott retweeted
Also admire Mbeki, who asks how one can continue to lead after being responsible for a catastrophe. Lucky he had no catastrophes, like, say, destroying an anti-retroviral programme that cost actual lives. But lives are less important than votes to Mbeki, we know that now. Brave.
Flowers are plant sex organs
✡️ Jewish History: Why Do Jews Place Stones on Graves Instead of Flowers?
If you’ve ever visited a Jewish cemetery, you may have noticed small stones resting on the headstones instead of bouquets of flowers.
This beautiful tradition has roots stretching back centuries.
In ancient times, Jewish graves were often marked or covered with piles of stones. Adding another stone helped preserve and identify the burial place.
Over time, placing a stone became a meaningful act of remembrance.
In Jewish tradition, flowers eventually wither, but stones endure. They symbolize the lasting memory of someone whose life continues to matter long after death.
Leaving a stone also quietly says, “I was here. You are remembered. You have not been forgotten.”
There is no specific Torah commandment requiring stones on graves, and the custom has several historical and symbolic explanations. Flowers are not universally forbidden, but stones remain the traditional Jewish expression of remembrance.
In Judaism, honoring the dead isn’t simply about mourning their absence. It’s about remembering their lives and carrying their memory forward.
May their memory be a blessing.
זיכרונם לברכה (Zichronam livrachah) 🕯️
15
Isn’t Bafana Bafana over 90% Black African?
TWO BLACK AFRICAN PLAYERS IN A MATCHDAY 23. THE TARGET SAYS SEVEN 🇿🇦
Springboks vs Italy in Turin: 13 white (57%), 10 players of colour (43%), 2 black African (9%) Ox Nche and Siya Kolisi.
The starting XV gets close, 7 of 15. The bench is where it collapses: 6 white, 2 colour, none black African.💀
Is this the most transformed Bok era, or the most transformed-looking one? Be honest
👇👇🏻
#Springboks #TransformationTargets #NationsChampionship #ScrumAtMe
21
“Don’t care if it rains or freezes, long as I got my plastic Jesus, hanging on the dashboard of my car….”
Cool Hand Luke is the coolest Christ allegory.
Newman eats 50 eggs, representing the souls of the 50 prisoners, suggesting he’s taking on his fellow inmates' sins. After the “miracle,” he’s posed on a table like a crucified Jesus.
This film is peppered with biblical symbolism.
18
Before accepting BAT’s narrative on illicit trade in SA, stakeholders should read this.
Researchers examining BAT’s own leaked documents say its anti-illicit trade operations targeted competitors and created commercial opportunities.
The self-proclaimed victim deserves scrutiny too.
"New research into [British American Tobacco] company documents leaked years ago suggests its efforts to combat the black market served a different purpose: creating commercial opportunities, targeting competitors and influencing government policy."
More: ow.ly/JFEo5100EBY
So in order to qualify as an artist you have to be self employed or employed by the private sector? Twaddle.
Javier Milei: “No tengo nada en contra de los artistas. Yo mismo tuve una banda de rock. Mi problema es que si necesitas una subvención del gobierno para hacer arte, ya no eres un artista, eres un empleado público.”
Milei es un número uno.
14
Keith Scott retweeted
Eric Hoffer wrote this article about Israel almost 60 years go. It reads like it was written yesterday.
"The Jews are a peculiar people: things permitted to other nations are forbidden to the Jews.
Other nations drive out thousands, even millions of people and there is no refugee problem. Russia did it, Poland and Czechoslovakia did it, Turkey threw out a million Greeks, and Algeria a million Frenchmen. Indonesia threw out heaven knows how many Chinese-and no one says a word about refugees. But in the case of Israel the displaced Arabs have become eternal refugees. Everyone insists that Israel must take back every single Arab. Arnold Toynbee calls the displacement of the Arabs an atrocity greater than any committed by the Nazis.
Other nations when victorious on the battlefield dictate peace terms. But when Israel is victorious it must sue for peace. Everyone expects the Jews to be the only real Christians in this world.
Other nations when they are defeated survive and recover but should Israel be defeated it would be destroyed. Had Nasser triumphed last June he would have wiped Israel off the map, and no one would have lifted a finger to save the Jews.
No commitment to the Jews by any government, including our own, is worth the paper it is written on. There is a cry of outrage all over the world when people die in Vietnam or when two Negroes are executed in Rhodesia. But when Hitler slaughtered Jews no one remonstrated with him.
The Swedes, who are ready to break of diplomatic relations with America because of what we do in Vietnam, did not let out a peep when Hitler was slaughtering Jews. They sent Hitler choice iron ore, and ball bearings, and serviced his troop trains to Norway.
The Jews are alone in the world. If Israel survives, it will be solely because of Jewish efforts. And Jewish resources. Yet at this moment Israel is our only reliable and unconditional ally. We can rely more on Israel than Israel can rely on us. And one has only to imagine what would have happened last summer had the Arabs and their Russian backers won the war to realize how vital the survival of Israel is to America and the West in general.
I have a premonition that will not leave me; as it goes with Israel so will it go with all of us. Should Israel perish the holocaust will be upon us."
Keith Scott retweeted
Replying to @ChrisHatt11
I think there is some confusion in certain quarters though about the difference between defending a right and supporting the associated cause. I would defend the right to a peaceful march through Skokie while hating everything Nazism stands for. I would defend the right to have a rugby tournament in which people sing Die Stem, but oppose the choice to do so. I would defend the right to form a Communist political party while opposing everything it believes in.
Also, the trouble with making the case that we are oppressed as a group and should therefore resist as a group is it’s exactly the justification for EE and BEE. The challenge for liberals is to recognize that group-based discrimination doesn’t have to be contested from the same premise, and to find ways to protect rights and deliver redress from a different premise.
Keith Scott retweeted
This man didn't care much for the opinion of others when it came to standing with the Jewish people.
His name was Lord Randolph Churchill and yes, he was the father of Winston Churchill.
When he came the parties and big events he was mocked and told: "What, Lord Randolph, you’ve not brought your Jewish friends?!"
To which Lord Randolph would respond by saying: "No, I did not think they would be very amused by the company."
His own family would criticize him for bringing Jewish people into their home for parties, but Randolph did not care. He was a man of principal and integrity.
Why does this matter so much?
Because it is in this home that the great Winston Churchill would be brought up in to be the man who would save Europe and the entire world from the tyranny of Nazism.
We may not be popular right now, but those who stand with the Jewish people through these difficult times will see courage installed in themselves and their families for generations.
We do not forget those who stand with us 💜
Keith Scott retweeted
I suppose SA X will become less deranged after the election. There’s so little to say about the election, though. DA majority governments are quite obviously the best way to maximize the chance of improved service delivery, growth and safety. They won’t all perform equally well, of course, but they will all perform better than the alternatives. I know it. You know it. I know you know it.
Keith Scott retweeted
Traditions in the West.
On the left we have a strand that runs from Rousseau through Robesspire and Saint-Juste and through Marxist-Leninism to Stalin, who had of course stopped any pretense at being for “the people” or the helping the hand of history and exemplified nothing more than the will to power. It ends with the Gulag.
On the right we have a tradition that marries attachment to authoritarianism (the pre-reformation church; monarchy) with the Romantic response to the enlightenment, which gave rise to the identitarian politics of the right, including nationalism, nativism and ultimately fascism. Again, it ends with the naked will to power. It ends with Auschwitz.
Then there is the liberal tradition, with a small “l”. Conservatives, social democrats, many western socialists and of course liberals with a big “L” belong to this tradition, which draws a belief in reason from the enlightenment and a belief in the uniqueness of individuals from Romanticism. This is the tradition that gives us the US Revolution, rather than the French version. It’s the tradition that gives us respect for reason, human rights, separation of powers, market economics, the welfare state (broadly defined) and universal franchise. It’s the tradition that gives us much of South Africa’s constitution, too.
That third tradition is the one that has delivered freedom and prosperity to the West, and for those non-western countries (South Korea, Japan, etc) that have embraced the universal values on which it is founded. And it is the tradition that needs defending now, from both anti-democratic, authoritarian left and ethno-nationalist, authoritarian right. It needs defending in the West, but also right here in South Africa.
This tradition is of course not without its own faults as the history of colonialism shows. Or as the person of Thomas Jefferson reveals. But as Barack Obama put it, it is in this tradition that the arc of history bends towards justice. The other two traditions, not so much.
So when people say they are defending “western civilization” it helps to be clear about which tradition they mean. One of those traditions needs urgent support. The other two need to be defeated, again.
And in South Africa you don’t do that by pitting your ethno-nationalism against someone else’s, or your nativism against someone else’s. You do it by holding the centre: individual rights, separation of powers, democracy, a market economy, a welfare safety net, due process, a dollop of respect for humanity. Basic human decency.
That’s how you stand up for civilization.
Keith Scott retweeted
I found myself thinking about something extraordinary today, and I felt the need to share it.
Judaism is one of the few major world religions with no ambition to convert humanity, conquer the world, or impose its beliefs on others.
In fact, we make it very difficult to convert to Judaism.
Think about the world around us.
Muslim supremacists seek to impose their interpretation of Islam on society, establish a caliphate, and govern people’s lives through Sharia law. They want to dictate how others live.
Christianity has historically sought to spread its faith across the world through conversion, at times using empires and political power to do so.
Communists have historically sought to spread their ideology worldwide, reshaping entire societies according to their political vision.
The Chinese Communist Party extends its authoritarian influence through surveillance technologies, censorship, economic pressure, and political control.
Ideological progressives increasingly demand conformity to their worldview, seeking to determine what people can say, what they should believe, and which opinions society will tolerate.
Qatar, whose citizens represent roughly 0.004% of humanity, invests billions in universities, media, lobbying, and political networks to expand its global influence. A tiny population with enormous resources and ambitions to shape institutions and public opinion far beyond its borders.
Imperialists have spent centuries conquering territories and imposing their cultures, political systems, and beliefs on others.
And then there are the Jews.
We don’t need anyone to become Jewish. We don’t ask Christians to observe Shabbat, Muslims to eat kosher, or the Chinese to study the Torah.
We don’t demand that other countries adopt Jewish law. We have no ambition to dictate how anyone else should live.
We simply want to live as Jews, preserve our traditions, raise our children, and live freely in our ancestral homeland. Nothing less. Nothing more.
Yet for centuries, we have been persecuted, expelled, massacred, and accused of plotting to control the world.
The people who have no ambition to convert the world are constantly accused of controlling it.
The people who simply want to preserve their identity are accused of threatening everyone else’s.
And the world’s one Jewish state is portrayed as a threat to world peace.
Perhaps the problem was never what Jews wanted to impose on the world.
Perhaps the problem is that Jews have consistently refused to surrender their identity to those determined to impose their worldview upon us.
We don’t want to rule the world. We don’t want to convert the world. We simply want the right to live in it as Jews.
And apparently, even that is too much for some to accept.























