In every human society, religion appeared as an extension of ancestors' worship, the oldest kind of worship, due to the close relationship with one's parents, and the fact that we’re all sons and daughter of somebody else.
Religion slowly gained complexity as it became both an explainer of natural phenomena, which could easily be described as the gods’ doing, and consolation against the fact that humans are the only animal who knows the awful fact of death awaits in any case, whatever else may happen.
Different features of religion appeared in different regions, partially helped by the success of shamanism – originally created as a way to channel communication with deceased ancestors – in helping cure real or imagined illnesses, or at least making sure that people didn’t fake illnesses by scaring them off with brutally ineffective treatments; and revolutionary monotheisms eventually took roots both in Persia and Palestine, having been first unsuccessfully tried as political expedients for power concentration in Egypt and, more briefly, Assyria.
mankind.substack.com/p/the-a…
67
The vision of the American revolutionary leaders is breathtaking. As hardheaded and practical as they were, they knew that by becoming republican they were expressing nothing less than a Utopian hope for a new moral and social order led by enlightened and virtuous men. Their soaring dreams and eventual disappointments make them the most extraordinary generation of political leaders in American history.
In many respects this revolutionary generation was very modern. They were optimistic, forward-looking, and utterly convinced that they had the future in their own hands. They told themselves that they had the ability, like no people before in modern times, to shape their politics and society as they saw fit. Can America be happy becoming independent? asked Thomas Paine. “As happy as she pleases,” he answered for all American leaders; “she hath a blank sheet to write upon.”1 The American revolutionary leaders had a very modern understanding of culture. For the first time in American history they saw that their culture was exclusively man-made. They alone were responsible for what they thought and believed and for what would be thought and believed in the future by those they often called the “millions unborn.”
It was an awesome responsibility, and they assumed it with a sense of excitement and anxious expectancy. They knew—it was the basic premise of all their thinking—that people were not born to be what they might become. Lockean sensationalism told the revolutionaries that human personalities were unformed, impressionable things that could be molded and manipulated by controlling people’s sensations. The mind, said John Adams, could be cultivated like a garden, with barbarous weeds eliminated and enlightened fruits raised, “the savages destroyed,… the civil People increased.” The revolutionaries believed with Samuel Stanhope Smith, soon to be president of Princeton, that new habitual principles, “the constant authoritative guardians of virtue,” could be created and nurtured by republican laws, and that these principles, together with the power of the mind, could give man’s “ideas and motives a new direction.” By the repeated exertion of reason, by “recalling the lost images of virtue: contemplating them, and using them as motives of action, till they overcome those of vice again and again until after repeated struggles, and many foils they at length acquire the habitual superiority”—by such exertions it seemed possible for man to recover his lost innocence and form a society of “habitual virtue.” Virtue, said Ezra Stiles, was an art to be learned as other arts were learned.2
From these premises flowed the revolutionaries’ preoccupation with education—not just their interest in formal schooling but their concern with a variety of means to create new attitudes and to remake their culture. These comprised everything from the histories they wrote and the advice manuals they read to the icons they created—including Jefferson’s Virginia capitol, John Trumbull’s paintings, and the design of the Great Seal. With the Lockean premises they had about how knowledge was acquired, everything suddenly seemed possible. The revolutionary leaders were faced with the awesome task of creating their own world.
Changing the culture meant pushing back the boundaries of darkness and barbarism and spreading light and knowledge. For the revolutionary generation America became the Enlightenment fulfilled. The settlement of America, said John Adams in 1765, was “the opening of a grand scene and design in Providence for the illumination of the ignorant, and the emancipation of the slavish part of mankind all over the earth.”3 The Revolution was simply the climax of this grand historic drama. Enlightenment was spreading everywhere in the Western world, but nowhere more promisingly than in America. It was an astonishing claim: that these obscure provinces only recently rescued from wilderness, surrounded by “savages,” and perched precariously on the very edges of Christendom, should presume to be in the vanguard of the Enlightenment was enough to boggle the mind. Americans, Thomas Paine told them in 1782, had thrown off the “prejudices” of the Old World (“prejudice, that poisonous bane and pernicious pest of society,” representing everything the Enlightenment hated) and had adopted new liberal, enlightened, and rational ideas. “We see with other eyes; we hear with other ears; and think with other thoughts, than those we formerly used.” Ignorance was being expelled and could not return. “The mind once enlightened cannot again become dark.”4
This pushing back of darkness and what was called Gothic barbarism occurred on many fronts. Some saw the central struggle taking place in natural science and in the increasing understanding of nature. Even the invention of a water pump for ships sent Benjamin Rush into raptures over the hope it promised “that the time will come when, comparatively speaking, ‘evil there shall be none’ upon the surface of the globe.”5 Others saw it occurring mostly in religion with the tempering of enthusiasm and the elimination of superstition. Still others saw it taking place mainly in politics—in driving back the forces of tyranny and in the creating of new free governments. For many Americans this political struggle became the focus of their revolution, the republican prerequisite for all other kinds of enlightenment. But for many other enlightened Americans of the eighteenth century these were just aspects of a larger struggle. For the Enlightenment represented not just the spread of science, or liberty, or republican government—important as these were—but also the spread of what came to be called civilization.
Everywhere in the Western world people were making tiny, piecemeal assaults on the ignorance and barbarism of the past. Everywhere in small, seemingly insignificant ways life was being made easier, more comfortable, more enjoyable. Decrease the pain and increase the pleasure of people: that was the Enlightenment. It seemed at times to be a mere matter of counting, of adding pleasures and subtracting pains. So William Wollaston in his Religion of Nature Delineated set out with mathematical exactness the way to calculate human happiness: “the man who enjoys three degrees of such pleasure as will bring upon him nine degrees of pain, when three degrees of pain are set off to balance and sink the three of pleasure, can have remaining to him only six degrees of pain; and with these therefore is his pleasure finally resolved. And so the three degrees of pain, which anyone endures to obtain nine of pleasure end in six of the latter.”6
Such mathematical exercises were possible because the increments of happiness, the quantities of pleasure and pain, seemed small and measurable. Sometimes they were quite palpable and material—“conveniences” or “decencies” or “comforts” as they were called. Did people eat with knives and forks instead of with their hands? Did they sleep on feather mattresses instead of straw? Did they drink out of china cups instead of wooden vessels? These were signs of prosperity, of happiness, of civilization. Jefferson said that to know the real state of a society’s enlightenment one “must ferret the people out of their hovels,… look into their kettle, eat their bread, loll on their beds under pretence of resting yourself, but in fact to find out if they are soft.”
(From The Radicalism of the American Revolution by Gordon S. Wood)
125
The single, clearest example of massive Freemason influence on highly important political events is the Freemason military coup leading to the independence of most of Latin America.
During the early phases of the Criollo uprisings against Spain, both sides struggled to even field 10,000 men in the important, named battles of the conflict. This explains why the Freemasons became extremely nervous when — with Napoleon already out of the picture for good — Spanish King Spanish King Fernando VII prepared a modern, fully-equipped army of 25,000 to be shipped to the Americas in 1820.
It was clear to all that, after years of successful defense by underfunded, undermanned royalist forces, such an army arriving fresh from the metropolis might very well tip the scales against the already under-pressure rebels in Venezuela and the River Plate.
That’s precisely why a group of anglophile, Freemason liberals rebelled under the leadership of Rafael del Riego, an undistinguished soldier who spent almost the entire war against the French as a prisoner reading radical literature, and who had risen to Grand Master of Grande Oriente National, Spain’s largest Freemason lodge. They took the commanding general hostage and triggered a liberal uprising against the Spanish king.
Years later, Benito Perez Galdós (1843-1920) – Spain’s most popular 19th century novelist – described such events in his deeply researched historical piece “El Grande Oriente,” where he described freemasonry as “far from being a temple of virtues, and more like a great center of intrigue, where plans were hatched and alliances were plotted to dominate politics.”
Riego took advantage of the fact that the Spanish military had been deeply infiltrated by Freemasons, at a time of Freemason agitation rocking other Catholic monarchies, like Portugal’s, Savoy’s and that of the Kingdom of Two Sicilies. He was grandly appointed field marshal, Freemasons took effective control of government, and the expedition to the Americas was cancelled.
The Spanish king, who had delayed ratification of Spain’s treaty with the U.S. on Oregon and Florida, pondering a war instead, was also forced to ratify the deal. In 1821, when the decisive battle for Venezuela was fought in Carabobo, the royalists fielded 6,500 soldiers, of whom almost 3,000 were killed. Bolívar was crowned as leading Libertador and soon the Gran Colombia was established.
mankind.substack.com/p/quick…
96
”Stocks collapse in 16,410,030/share day, but rally at close cheers brokers; bankers optimistic, to continue aid” and then below “Closing rally vigorous,” remarked the New York Times headline when the stock market crashed the last Tuesday in October 1929. Bankers noted that throughout the day periodic lifting spells had pulled the market up. Back on August 20, the Dow had closed at a high of 368. Then the market had gone yet higher, to 381.
109
“The worst curse on mankind is the ability to consider ideals as something quite abstract and detached from one’s everyday life.” Ayn Rand, journal entry dated April 9, 1934.
138
The Battle of Carchemish in 605 BC may have been the most decisive in history. Without Egypt’s defeat and Assyria’s triumph, there would have been no Jewish exile from Palestine: thus, no Bible, no Christianity, no Islam.
Led by Necho II, Egypt’s main army, reinforced with Greek mercenaries and remnants of disbanded Assyrian forces, met a smaller Babylonian army led by crown prince Nebuchadnezzar (soon to become king Nebuchadnezzar II upon his father’s death later that year) and reinforced by Cyaxares’ Medes, Persians and their Scythian allies. Necho II’s army, lacking in pure cavalry and probably still reliant on old-fashioned chariots for mobility, was crushed and forced to withdraw – before the survivors were overtaken by the enemy cavalry and cut down to pieces.
Egypt’s entire position in the Levant collapsed, never to be recovered until the fleeting successes of the majority-Greek armies of Ptolemy’s dynasty over three centuries later. Necho II fled back home, and Palestine fell into Nebuchadnezzar II’s lap, with massive consequences for the future of the Jewish religion.
An anti-Babylonian rebellion there followed in 601 BC, after Nebuchadnezzar II was repulsed in an attempted invasion of Egypt, and revenge was swift: the Babylonian army eventually put Jerusalem under siege, and took it in 597 BC, pillaging the First Temple and sending the Jewish court and many of its most prominent citizens and craftsmen to exile by the rivers of Babylon.
mankind.substack.com/p/the-f…
"Gentlemen, we are declaring war on you", Nikita Khrushchev announced as he surveyed the work of thirteen Abstract and Expressionist artists in a retrospective exhibition of Soviet art in the Moscow Manege in December 1962.
The First Secretary of the Soviet Communist Party's outburst and its repercussions are commonly seen as marking a climax in the decade-long cultural "Thaw" that followed Stalin's death. "The people and the government have taken a lot of trouble with you", Khrushchev raged, "and you pay them back with this shit."
There were nuances, however, even in Khrushchev's Kulturbolschevismus. The sculptor Ernst Neizvestnyi, who was among the vilified artists, famously defended his work, engaging the Soviet leader in an hour of high- octane debate, in which Neizvestnyi accused Khrushchev of knowing nothing about art, while the Head of the KGB (who was in the Party entourage) threatened the sculptor with the Siberian uranium mines. Khrushchev paid gruff tribute to the reckless courage of Neizvestnyi (whom he had branded a "pederast" and a "bastard"), allegedly saying, "You are the kind of man I like".
Neizvestnyi was duly expelled from the Union of Artists, and thus deprived of the right to work as a professional artist. Some years later, however, Khrushchev, who had himself become an official "non-person" soon after the confrontation, chose the sculptor to design his tombstone.
(Olga Grushin in "The dream life of Sukhanov," 2006.)
1
162
Romania had a terrible reputation in WW2.
There’s the story of the Rumanian walking with his German friend down Calea Victoriei – the Rumanian naming the price of every woman they meet? “Good heavens,” says the German, “are there no honest women here?” “Certainly,” replies the Rumanian, “but – very expensive!”’
2
166
Some decades ago, the British politician Enoch Powell wrote that “the supreme function of statesmanship is to provide against preventable evils.” I haven’t found any superior, more succinct definition of what governments are supposed to do.
This definition is important, because a lot of historiographic discussion hinges precisely on what good governance means.
Every student of history has spent years arguing about lists: best generals in history, most important scientists, best novelists, ranks of pre-Raphaelite painters (this one is more of a niche interest, admittedly), etc. These lists are a bit infantile, and yet they are valuable, because they force one to explain the pick: why is, say, Sulla a better general than Pyrrhus? Why is Albert Einstein more important than Isaac Newton?
mankind.substack.com/p/the-t…















