i think both of these are fine, but they were obviously trying to do different things and comparing them is just plain silly.
1
23
i like how you cant keep up with cavill because its his first time and hes having fun in the fact that he can fly, so hes just seeing what he can do with it: a crater on launch, crazy maneuvers, quickly changing direction, then getting the hang of it at the end
1
7
J-bitch retweeted
I'm so confused at why for some reason everyone's deciding to turn on Shintani art direction because it's not as.....detailed as Yamamuro art direction?? bro im so confused at the argument here because is the implication, more detail = better??
lets not try and discredit either artist here, yamamuro has excellent work from his past in DBZ and even from the yo son goku and his friends return OVA, that's where his art and direction was at its strongest.
In super there was a bunch of over complex shading, plasticy highlights, and rigid lines whereas in his old 90s artwork, he had a certain level sharpness and grit to his artwork, which always made it a pleasure to see him pop up. (not to mention the most commonly brought up disproportionate character settei)
Shintani's style is very capable of replicating Toriyama's style very accurately to a fault and with his art direction there comes a certain level of fluidity and finesse with the motion. His style simply put is a lot more animator friendly in comparison to modern Yamamuro. That's why DBS Beerus gets a lot of praise for the corrections and the recomp
Y'all ever heard the saying less is more? That saying is especially true when it comes to art direction and animation, especially when you compare the art direction of Chikashi Kubota (Dragon Ball Super: Super Hero) and Maya Kasai/Katsuyoshi Nakatsuru (Dragon Ball Daima) you can really see where 2015 Dragon Ball Super massively falls short when it comes to art direction but also why people massively prefer these art directions in comparison to the former.
And of course this is not to discredit Yamamuro at all, he has a lot of his really good moments where his art direction is genuinely at its peak and shines bright
HOWEVER,
To try and discredit any of these whilst also using examples as to why the art direction is good and works out for the better in some cases is disingenuous as hell.
I'm really trying to figure out where the Shintani hate is coming from because a lot of you are just loud and wrong for no reason lmao
I genuinely believe that each of these creatives have moments where they genuinely shine brightest, however, using straw man arguments to discredit one or the other when they're job is ultimately to bring toriyama's characters to life the best they can is ultimately doing nobody any good.
i need this company to run into financial troubles that will convince them to start having a competent platform people wont talk shit about on the daily
Please help. Anybody please help me. I had my worst nervous breakdown over this just now. I cried sobbing, threw up, I thought I'd end myself. I feel lost. I'm helpless despite knowing I didn't do anything wrong. I didn't do wrong. I didn't do wrong. Goddamn it all, someone help.
43














































