earthdrifted (@earthdrifted) header
earthdrifted (@earthdrifted) profile picture

assessing the future

Austin, Texas
Joined November 2016
Photo by earthdrifted (@earthdrifted)Photo by earthdrifted (@earthdrifted)Photo by earthdrifted (@earthdrifted)Photo by earthdrifted (@earthdrifted)Photo by earthdrifted (@earthdrifted)Photo by earthdrifted (@earthdrifted)
Milburn says autism "responds to treatment". - Paragraph 652
1
33
It is not just the case that he accidentally put autism in this paragraph, he systematically presents autism as variable across time, treatable - which is a necessary precondition for his proposal to push autistic young people into work.
1
12
We know its systematic because he explicitly outlines a general course of treatment for autistic people covering "sensory demands, communication, [dealing with] transitions" (Paragraph 562). These are all problems associated specifically with Autistic Spectrum Disorder.
7
The Milburn report seriously says that autistic communication and sensory needs are something that can [and implicitly should] be changed by clinical therapies. False and harmful.
6
30
436
This is genuinely an insane claim and its one of the central arguments of Milburn's report. The media hasn't even picked up on it because they’re not looking at the detail and are largely have absorbed inaccurate and simplistic stereotypes about autism.
Replying to @earthdrifted
Step 1 Autism is defined as a condition where support needs "could change" and "fluctuate and respond to treatment" - paragraph 652
1
7
42
669
earthdrifted retweeted
Replying to @LeftieStats
Sadly the inevitable consequence of the 24/7 demonisation of disabled people in the media and from politicians. I'm hearing about this sort of thing a lot.
3
1
48
3,134
earthdrifted retweeted
Here's the call to evidence page btw. However, answering this is depressing work. It's dark when you go into the report for hours at a time and see how they talk about disabled people. So, take care all ye who gaze into this particular abyss: committees.parliament.uk/com…
3
7
35
earthdrifted retweeted
What makes the #Milburn call to evidence so crap, is the question that asks: "How do we respond to the report? What do we do first? How do we avoid just being Thatcher?". Milburn got a whole-ass year to work that out, we get until the 16th December. Yay us.
2
6
17
347
Analyizing the 563 footnotes of the Milburn report, he cites almost no condition-specific clinical or occupational medicine research on autism, ADHD, ME/CFS or Complex PTSD.
4
34
162
1,557
You can genuinely think of a million ways work could be harmful. Alan Milburn refuses to think of just one in his report.
1
1
18
169
If an individual has bipolar disorder, for example, circadian disruption associated with the demands of work can trigger episodes of hypomania or mania.
1
19
165
After reflecting on his report, I've decided to post a recording of my attempt to interview #AlanMilburn at #Labour conference in Sept about his failure to address the safeguarding risks of his #NEETs approach. It contains adult language. He starts to get angry about 50 secs in:
29
208
47
354
28,776
The Milburn reports tries to dress itself up as reasonable by avoiding the kind of scapegoating language of the media, but there's a reason that the media have been so warm in their reception - it fundamentally agrees with a the same essential diagnosis...
2
8
21
491
is applied with the threat of having their income set to 0 if they do not participate. He repeatedly refuses to consider that autism and ADHD are enduring conditions. Milburn's report states that work is axiomatically always suitable for people with conditions such as C-PTSD
1
2
6
61
or chronic fatigue or anxiety, when the medical literature clearly says otherwise. Milburn never explains the discrepancy or articulates that the wrong work for the wrong people can cause serious medical harm, which most people instinctively know is true.
1
7
50