Pinned Tweet
Where the Commission adopts a tobacco tax proposal without releasing the economic studies it is based on, ESTA publishes the NEW 2025 London Economics Study on fine-cut tobacco on which its public positions are based.
esta.be/london-economics-stu…
On Monday, the Council of Ministers was unable to reach a unanimous compromise on the Tobacco Tax Directive. Had it adopted the compromise text promoted by the Irish Presidency - and, even more forcefully, by the European Commissioner - the European tobacco market would have been distorted for years to come.
The Commission and the Presidency billed the proposal as needing to bring new nicotine products within the scope of the Directive setting minimum rates in many cases well above national rates. Contradicting its objectives, the outcome of the final compromise is that only the minimum rates for niche traditional European products such as pipe tobacco, nasal snuff, and chewing tobacco are now disproportionately high.
These niche traditional products are manufactured in Europe by small and mid-sized European companies, with, according to the Commission ‘insignificant market shares’ and no need to assess the impact of the proposal on these. Europe’s heritage SMEs would therefore have been placed at a competitive disadvantage, even though the Directive itself states that it must ensure neutral conditions of competition.
The Presidency could have put a better compromise on the table had it simply listened to Member States. Differentiated taxation is a cornerstone of the Directive, whilst concerns on uptake have apparently now become a relevant parameter as well. Logically, this should mean that pipe tobacco and traditional smokeless products are taxed at lower rates because sales are continuously decreasing, and its consumers are mainly older adults. Yet the compromise on the table does exactly the opposite.
If illicit trade is a concern, then it must be acknowledged that raising tax rates will lead to more illicit trade unless smokers are offered more affordable alternatives, including hand-rolling tobacco. If neutral conditions of competition are to be ensured, this should be achieved not only by removing Swedish snus from the Directive’s scope, but also by excluding Bavarian nasal snuff and traditional chewing tobacco. At the very least, their tax rates should be set at the same level as those for new nicotine products.
Instead, the compromise became reactive rather than principled. The compromise is riddled with inaccuracies and contradictions simply to get a compromise over the finish line – any compromise.
That a compromise is necessary is clear. But throwing internal-market principles over-board and Europe’s small and medium-sized companies under the bus demonstrates, once again, that for all the talk on Europe’s competitiveness, better regulation and SME tests, the reality is that those are merely afterthoughts and not guiding principles.
More than 120,000 people are employed as a result of the tobacco businesses of ESTA’s small and mid-sized member companies. They deserve a better compromise - one that does not unnecessarily put their jobs at risk.
1
50
ESTA retweeted
Nice one Malta!
🚨 BREAKING: Malta blocks Brussels' tobacco tax hike!
At yesterday's EU finance ministers' meeting, Malta stood alone against a plan to raise tobacco taxes and impose EU-wide taxes on vaping and nicotine pouches.
Higher taxes on safer alternatives punish smokers trying to quit and risk fuelling Europe's already booming black markets.
The EU needs harm reduction, not higher taxes!
The irony could not be greater. Brussels police raided an illegal tobacco factory on the Commission’s doorstep, while this week the same Commission is defending its proposal to hike tobacco taxes and is minimising the risk of illicit tobacco trade.
Illicit tobacco trade has reached 24.8% in Belgium, coinciding with a series of tobacco tax hikes over recent years. The evidence of the effects of tax hikes is staring everyone in the face, yet EU politics today is guided less by evidence and facts than by political opportunism.
Perhaps Member States can pull the brake and request that the Court of Auditors’ Recommendation to conduct a study into illicit tobacco trade is undertaken before embarking on a policy of tobacco tax hikes.
bx1.be/categories/news/une-e…
#PermReps #EUCourtOfAuditors #TobaccoExcise #IllicitTrade #EUPolicy
Further to our post on the Financial Times' Australian tobacco-tax debacle, we want to clarify that the data the newspaper cited come from the Australian Bureau of Statistics. Belgian media attributed the information on Belgium to the country’s customs and police authorities.
We provide this clarification because certain stakeholders in the tobacco-policy debate have challenged specific facts and data while advocating the exclusion of legitimate tobacco-industry representatives. When accurate information is dismissed, and opposing perspectives are excluded, the debate risks becoming an echo chamber, thereby increasing the likelihood of legislation that is neither proportionate nor effective.
Disregarding a ruling by the Court of Justice of the European Union, which interprets the World Health Organisation Framework Convention on Tobacco Control rules on industry participation in policy development and implementation, fits this pattern of exclusion. Although some associate this disregard for court rulings with contemporary politics in the United States, it also appears in Europe.
The Financial Times has further highlighted what many already recognise: hiking tobacco excise duties expand illicit markets, fuel criminal activity, deprive governments of billions in revenue and require hundreds of millions in additional enforcement spending, without reducing nicotine-use rates. Australia provides a clear example, while France, the Netherlands, Ireland and Belgium are fast moving in the same direction. In the first ten months of this year alone, Belgian authorities shut down 12 illicit cigarette factories. Although this demonstrates intensified enforcement, it also underscores the profitability of the black market: closing one factory may simply create an opportunity for another to emerge.
The point bears repeating: when will the Commission and the Member States recognise that the current proposal to increase tobacco excise duties across the EU risks producing damaging consequences on every policy front? Has the Commission abandoned its much-vaunted commitment to better, evidence-based regulation in favour of populism at any cost? As Australia demonstrates, the financial and enforcement costs are substantial—and Member States will face them sooner rather than later.
ft.trib.al/d8i3ure
#EU #FinancialTimes #IMCO
The tobacco control community, including governmental officials, regularly calls for total exclusion of the tobacco industry in tobacco policy and legislative development. Such calls claim exclusion must be all encompassing including refusing meeting with representatives of the tobacco industry, including those representing small and mid-sized European companies. The exclusion is to be based upon Art. 5.3. of the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control.
The Court of Justice of the European Union however clarified in its judgment in Case C-160/20 that Article 5(3) of the FCTC provides that, “in setting and implementing their public health policies with respect to tobacco control, the parties to that convention are to act to protect these policies from interests of the tobacco industry in accordance with national law”.
And the Court continues: “It is clear from the very wording of that provision that it does not prohibit all participation of the tobacco industry in the establishment and implementation of rules on tobacco control but is intended solely to prevent the tobacco control policies of the parties to the convention from being influenced by that industry’s interests”.
Art. 5.3 should therefore not be used by governments or the EU Institutions to justify a blanket exclusion of lawful economic tobacco operators from any regulatory discussions that directly affect them. Unfortunately, and contrary to a couple of years ago, the European Commission seems to have embraced the concept of exclusion and is not organising any meaningful dialogue with ESTA or its companies when developing its proposal for the Tobacco Excise Directive or the revision of the Tobacco Products Directive.
The Commission appears to consider such exclusion as compatible with democratic principles, a view that is consistent with its broader tendency to disregard expressions of public dissatisfaction with the EU.
1
54
The Financial Times has further highlighted what many already recognise: hiking tobacco excise duties expand illicit markets, fuel criminal activity, deprive governments of billions in revenue and require hundreds of millions in additional enforcement spending, without reducing nicotine-use rates. Australia provides a clear example, while France, the Netherlands, Ireland and Belgium are fast moving in the same direction. In the first ten months of this year alone, Belgian authorities shut down 12 illicit cigarette factories. Although this demonstrates intensified enforcement, it also underscores the profitability of the black market: closing one factory may simply create an opportunity for another to emerge.
The point bears repeating: when will the Commission and the Member States recognise that the current proposal to increase tobacco excise duties across the EU risks producing damaging consequences on every policy front? Has the Commission abandoned its much-vaunted commitment to better, evidence-based regulation in favour of populism at any cost? As Australia demonstrates, the financial and enforcement costs are substantial—and Member States will face them sooner rather than later.
ft.trib.al/d8i3ure
#EU #FinancialTimes #IMCO
More than half of the cigarettes consumed in Belgium are now either not taxed in Belgium or counterfeit.
The latest Q2 2026 Empty Pack Survey records a non-domestic incidence of 50.6%, up from 44.4% in Q4 2025 and 33.1% one year earlier. The survey covered 2,800 packs collected across 18 Belgian cities.
According to Cimabel, these products could have generated around €2.6 billion in Belgian tax revenue if they had been legally purchased domestically. Counterfeit cigarettes alone represented 4.6% of the sample, while Bulgaria accounted for 30% of all cigarettes identified.
This is more than a fiscal problem. Illicit tobacco undermines legitimate retailers, bypasses legal controls and provides a revenue stream for criminal networks.
The traditional tobacco industry supports stronger enforcement and greater investment in customs. But policymakers must also recognise that sharp excise increases and widening price gaps have now clearly shown pushing consumption towards illicit markets as evidenced also in the Netherlands, Ireland and France.
Belgium needs a coordinated response – combining enforcement, European cooperation and an evidence-based approach to tobacco excise.
Read more: cimabel.be/stopillegalehande…
45% of cigarettes. 61% of fine-cut tobacco. Billions in lost revenue.
Those are not abstract figures. They describe the scale of tobacco purchased outside the regulated Dutch market, according to the Nationale Smokkel Monitor.
The Nationale Smokkel Monitor’s new book and video examine how cross-border purchasing, illicit sales, social-media distribution and illegal manufacturing are reshaping the tobacco market. In 2025-26, the figures showed that 45% of cigarettes and 61% of fine-cut tobacco consumed in the Netherlands came from abroad. The resulting loss to the Dutch Treasury is estimated at up to €3billion a year.
This is a challenge for public finances, legitimate retailers, age controls and law enforcement – and a warning for policymakers in the EU and across Europe.
Effective enforcement is essential. So is a coordinated, evidence-based excise policy that recognises how consumers respond when legal prices diverge sharply from those in neighbouring countries.
Read the book and watch the video: smokkelmonitor.nl/e-book-vid…
ESTA welcomes the EU Court of Auditors’ report on the scope and scale of the illicit tobacco market in the EU. For years, ESTA has been highlighting the economic, fiscal and social impacts of illegal trade - from lost tax revenues to the empowerment of criminal networks. The Report shows how difficult it is to combat illicit tobacco trade, and the Australian experience offers the EU a stark warning of what happens when excise policy ignores market realities.
The evidence is clear: dogmatic and abrupt hikes in tobacco excise rates have helped fuel this problem, not solve it. EU institutions and Member States can no longer pretend otherwise. It is time for a smarter, evidence-based approach that protects public finances, supports legal businesses, and effectively tackles illicit trade.
eca.europa.eu/en/publication…
3
57
Reality is slowly dawning in those countries that tried and failed with excessive tobacco taxes - this time the UK. What more does the European Commission need to change its proposal?
Tax policy has consequences beyond the till.
As excise rates push legal tobacco prices higher, illicit cigarettes - sold for as little as £3.50 a pack - are flooding high streets, undermining legitimate retailers and depriving governments of tax revenue. The profits fuel organised crime.
A balanced, evidence-based approach to tobacco taxation must be part of the solution. Read more: telegraph.co.uk/gift/06cb4ba…
3
61
France was the example for the Commission’s proposed tax hikes in the EU's Tobacco Tax Directive. However, tax hikes have caused illicit trade to skyrocket. 1 in 2 packs consumed in France is from illicit sources. When faced with the choice between either €13 for a legal packet of cigarettes and €3.50 for one on the street, online, or behind the counter, many would choose the cheaper option. The French media are now also exposing the problem of too high tobacco taxes that make outpriced consumers seek their cigarettes in the illicit circuit. Member States need to think twice before accepting the Commission's massive increases in tobacco taxes. #illicittobacco
youtube.com/shorts/UTjo7I2ZA…
1
75
Following the European Parliament vote on Wednesday, ESTA published the following Press Release yesterday.
#TED #EUParliament
2
45
Today’s vote in the European Parliament confirms a broader institutional stalemate. The Commission’s Tobacco Excise proposal has failed to gain traction across all fronts – criticised by the EESC, blocked among Member States in Council, and now lacking support in Parliament. This reflects fundamental flaws in both its design and its assumptions.
The Commission’s approach to revising the Tobacco Excise Directive, themed as 'ambitious,' is actually disconnected from economic and market realities understood by the other institutions. Proposing a one-size-fits-all model of tax rates higher than applied today in member states and, as such, overlooking significant differences between member states it has proposed a framework that cannot command consensus across a diverse European Union. Its denial of illicit trade and of economics at play did not leave much room other than to advise and vote against the proposal.
1
50
ESTA’s June 2026 submission on the Tobacco Products Directive calls for evidence-based policymaking, a full impact assessment, careful respect for the internal market legal base, and a rigorous SME test. European traditional tobacco products deserve regulation that is proportionate, workable and grounded in science.
ec.europa.eu/info/law/better…
3
69
Replying to @edjegasothy
Australia is teaching us a difficult lesson, which the EU Commission and several EU member states are failing to learn. Sudden and excessive excise hikes might play to your populist health dogma, but they ruin your state income and make gangsters rich, while assumed health targets are missed.
#EUCom #DG_GROW #DG_TAXUD
Commissioner Hoekstra is yet another Commissioner who appears to misunderstand his brief.
His recent comments in the Luxembourg Times on so-called “tobacco tourism” are not only shockingly uninformed and undiplomatic, they are also strikingly hypocritical coming from a former Dutch finance minister now presenting himself as the champion of tax fairness in Europe.
At ESTA, we believe policy should be grounded in facts, evidence, and respect for Member State sovereignty – not slogans, moral grandstanding, or failed economic theories recycled in Brussels.
Let’s be clear: Luxembourg did not create cross-border tobacco purchasing.
What Commissioner Hoekstra calls “tobacco tourism” is in reality a predictable consequence of certain neighbouring countries – most notably the Netherlands, France, and Belgium – choosing to raise excise duties to unsustainable levels. When governments deliberately widen price gaps far beyond what consumers can bear, people naturally seek legal alternatives across borders.
That is not market distortion caused by Luxembourg. It is the result of poor tax design elsewhere.
Luxembourg, by contrast, has operated within the framework of the EU Tobacco Excise Directive and has maintained a stable, lawful, transparent market. It has not “undermined” anyone. It has simply chosen a more balanced fiscal approach.
If high taxation were the silver bullet Brussels claims, then countries with the highest prices should enjoy the lowest smoking prevalence and the best outcomes.
Yet reality tells a different story.
Luxembourg – despite being regularly criticised for lower prices – has reported comparatively low smoking prevalence relative to several higher-tax neighbours. That strongly suggests that prevention, education, cessation support, and sensible regulation matter far more than blunt tax escalation alone.
This is precisely why simplistic “tax more, problem solved” policymaking fails.
Commissioner Hoekstra repeats a familiar line often promoted through WHO and World Bank frameworks: raise taxes aggressively and consumption will fall while revenues rise.
But the European evidence increasingly shows the limits of that model.
France has pursued repeated steep excise hikes over recent years. Yet instead of eliminating smoking, it has seen large-scale displacement into non-domestic channels and illicit trade. Consumers do not disappear because prices rise. They adapt.
When taxation moves beyond affordability and realism, demand is redirected – not removed.
That means:
Fewer legal sales
Less government revenue
More organised crime
Less product control
Greater enforcement costs
Worse public policy outcomes
This is not theory. It is observable reality across multiple markets.
Europe should also look beyond its borders.
Australia’s extreme tobacco tax strategy is frequently praised in abstract policy circles, yet the practical outcome has been a flourishing illicit market, criminal networks, counterfeit products, and massive tax leakage.
When legal products become unaffordable, illegal operators step in.
That is the real danger of Commissioner Hoekstra’s approach: he risks creating a criminal windfall while claiming a public health victory.
Luxembourg is a sovereign EU Member State operating within agreed European rules. It should not be publicly lectured for refusing to copy the policy mistakes of others.
Differences in taxation across the EU are not a flaw – they are a reflection of different economies, income levels, consumer realities, and democratic choices.
Trying to erase those differences through forced harmonisation is neither smart economics nor smart politics.
ESTA supports evidence-based regulation that genuinely reduces harm and protects public finances. That means:
Maintaining proportionate taxation that avoids rising illicit trade
Fighting illicit trade with real enforcement
Respecting subsidiarity and national competence
Using data, not ideology
Final Thought:
Ignoring the facts, disregarding data, and relying on economic models that repeatedly fail in practice – all in the name of political theatre – is not becoming of a European Commissioner.
Europe deserves better than moralistic soundbites. It deserves serious policymaking.
#ESTA #EU #TaxPolicy #ExciseDuty #SinTaxErrors #IllicitTrade #Luxembourg #TobaccoPolicy #SingleMarket #EvidenceBasedPolicy #DG_TAXUD
3
83
The European Commission appears to be disregarding Better Regulation principles in its approach to tobacco legislation.
First, the Tobacco Excise Directive, adopted in July 2025, was based on a 2022 opinion from the Regulatory Scrutiny Board and introduced a new policy option that had not been assessed in the Impact Assessment. But, apparently, this is overlooked when it comes to tobacco.
Now, in its Evaluation Report on the “tobacco acquis,” the Commission initially failed to publish the Regulatory Scrutiny Board’s opinion alongside the report. That opinion was only released yesterday - and its contents are striking.
It is a negative opinion from December 2025, containing scathing criticism (the RSB Report is now included in an amended Evaluation Report). A review of the Evaluation Report suggests that many of these concerns have been brushed aside: the evidence remains weak, and the “lessons learned” appear to have been shaped around pre-determined policy conclusions ahead of a proposal expected later this year.
We are monitoring this closely. The Commission’s assumption-driven approach to legislation must be addressed - if only to ensure that future measures are proportionate and genuinely effective in achieving their objectives.
#DGSANTE #TPD3
3
61







