Fair Voting BC (@fairvotingbc) profile picture

We are a BC-based organization dedicated to democratic reform. Join us and change the future of BC politics!

British Columbia, Canada
Joined November 2009
Photo by Fair Voting BC (@fairvotingbc)Photo by Fair Voting BC (@fairvotingbc)Photo by Fair Voting BC (@fairvotingbc)Photo by Fair Voting BC (@fairvotingbc)Photo by Fair Voting BC (@fairvotingbc)Photo by Fair Voting BC (@fairvotingbc)Photo by Fair Voting BC (@fairvotingbc)
We have a history of regionalized parties (including the so-called national parties, which historically have been anything but) in part because FPTP rewards parties that bunch their votes geographically.
Replying to @acoyne
The problem is there are no countries similar to Canada with PR. So it's hard to say hard to say how PR would work here. We are a decentralized federation with a history of regional parties. If ๐Ÿ‡จ๐Ÿ‡ฆ was a unitary state or a centralized federation, I'd have fewer concerns about PR
8
6
2
14
Whereas under PR, thereโ€™s no such โ€œleverageโ€: a small change in the vote for each party only means a small change in the number of seats it gets. So thereโ€™s no point in triggering a snap election. Instead, people get on with governing. /5
3
31
4
101
Minority govts (FPTP) are unstable because it only takes a swing of a few points in the popular vote to make a major change in seats. So everyonesโ€™s got their finger on the button the whole time: whoeverโ€™s up in the polls is looking for any excuse to trigger an election. /4
1
18
2
63
Theyโ€™re inherently unstable, but itโ€™s wrong to associate them with PR, not only because minority governments โ€” as opposed to coalitions โ€” donโ€™t tend to happen under PR, but because the political incentives implied by the two systems are totally differentโ€ฆ. /3
2
13
1
44
What it does mean, typically tho not always, is government by multi-party coalitions. โ€œMinority governments,โ€ where one party, lacking a majority of either seats or votes, nevertheless tries to nerve its way through, alone, by sheer brinksmanship, are a thing only in FPTP. /2
1
20
66