This! A 4-factor explanation of the "dumbing down" phenomenon? Interesting indeed.
To update my slide decks for my course “The Political Economy of Early America,” I picked up the latest edition of a mainstream U.S. college history textbook I had used before as source material. (I have no wish to start a fight, so no names; suffice it to say the book is as mainstream as mainstream gets.) I wanted to check whether I was missing any recent developments in scholarship or shifts in coverage.
I was struck by how much the prose and content had been dumbed down. In places, it truly read like a middle-school textbook. I went back to the older editions I had kept, and a side-by-side comparison from 2000 forward shows a clear deterioration with each revision. In 2000, students were reading a serious work. The current edition is not.
As an economist, I suppose I should not be surprised. Four rational agents shape the outcome, and not one of them has any reason to defend quality.
The publisher maximizes revenue per student, not learning. Simpler prose and lighter material may reduce what students learn, but they raise adoption rates: instructors find the book “easier to teach with” and students complain less. Learning outcomes are an externality.
The instructor worries about teaching evaluations and grade inflation. Assign an easy textbook, and students are content; you hand out A’s to most of them, and your workload drops. The instructor who assigns the harder book and earns lower evaluations bears a private cost for a public good. A textbook collective action problem.
The student, given limited information, optimizes for the grade rather than for human capital accumulation. If the exam tests recall from a simplified textbook, the simplified textbook is the rational choice. The cost of shallow learning surfaces only years later, too distant and diffuse to weigh much on today’s decision.
The university cares about retention and graduation rates, not about what anyone learns. A textbook that cuts the failure rate in introductory courses looks good on those metrics, even when it achieves the cut by lowering the bar.
The result is what one would predict: a steady decline in textbook quality that no rational agent in the chain has any motive to reverse.
The only way forward is to break the collective action problem: get universities to curb grade inflation (I am open to suggestions on how; caps on A’s bring their own troubles) and to care about what students learn, rather than about some inane comment on a teaching evaluation.
John Paul Brousssard retweeted
Gemini 3 + Claude + N8N is absolutely INSANE
This combo just replaced the entire operations team.
No manual work. No $200K/year salaries. No coordination chaos.
Just three AIs working together to run business 24/7.
Here's how it works:
→ Gemini 3 handles multimodal inputs (emails, docs, videos, images)
→ Uses 1M token context to understand the ENTIRE business at once
→ Claude does deep reasoning and strategic analysis
→ N8N orchestrates both AIs to automate workflows
→ System runs continuously without me touching it
Real workflows this can handle:
- Email triage and response drafting
- Meeting transcription → action items → task assignment
- Customer support (understands text + screenshots + videos)
- Research and competitive analysis
- Document generation and review
- Project management and updates
The magic: Gemini 3's agentic abilities + Claude's reasoning + N8N's automation = unstoppable.
While others hire 5-person ops teams, this stack does it better for pennies.
I documented the complete system:
✓ N8N workflow ideas
✓ When to use Gemini vs Claude (and why)
✓ API setup and best practices
✓ Real examples business
✓ How to handle 1M token context
Like, RT + reply "GEMINI" and I'll DM you the guide
(Must be following so I can DM)
Skip this and keep paying $200K/year for ops teams that work 8 hours/day.
John Paul Brousssard retweeted
That's a wrap!
If you enjoyed this thread:
1. Follow me @quantscience_ for more of these
2. RT the tweet below to share this thread with your audience
Now this is what you call "reproducible research!" openbondassetpricing.com/
1
86
Is the attention to energy usage finally being paid? Technology is great, but its benefits come at a cost - mainly insatiable energy appetite!
wsj.com/articles/artificial-…
92
Why is this issue not getting as much attention as it did when crypto mining was the culprit?
wsj.com/articles/electric-gr…
68
Is HAL coming for the financial markets? Hmm..... #garp #garpfrm #garprisksymposium2024
instagram.com/p/C4LQsLCuXw08…
74
Make sure your AI is doing what you think it's supposed to do! #garp #garpfrm #garprisksymposium2024
instagram.com/p/C4LX0KGrm3_u…
66
Hype or Reality? Difficult to determine hype from reality due to the pace of change being so frenetic. #garp #garpfrm #garprisksymposium2024
instagram.com/p/C4Lep-VLdsDo…
58
Has anybody wondered why crypto miners were faulted by the amount of energy being consumed for coins but AI tools have yet to be? Things that make you go "Hmmm...."
on.ft.com/3Ur2J8B via @FT
How many times has the "24-hour" trading idea raised its ugly head? Let's see if this attempt works. on.ft.com/3TH8Uoy via @FT
1
52
What a great run! Thanks for everything @gilliantett The @FT will continue to benefit from your periodic contributions, and @Kings_College will benefit more from your leadership. I look forward to seeing how your "Anthro Vision" benefits academia! on.ft.com/3F1tHe7 via @FT
1
61
Data are everywhere!
"The driving force behind this progress is the astounding advance of our ability to produce, manipulate, store, retrieve and transmit data."
Another Medical Revolution Is UnderWay
wallstreetjournal-ny.newsmem…
For all my friends in the academy, read this FT article, and then maybe you will have a better sense as to the 'threat' of ChatGPT. To summarize: "What ChatGPT deals in is not truth; it is plausibility." on.ft.com/3RVcHvK
1
59
This is an interesting approach. What do my academic colleagues think? nitter.cf/alliekmiller/status/16…
We need to share more about how teachers are adapting to ChatGPT.
One of my favorite new policies comes from Professor Ethan Mollick, Associate Professor at @Wharton.
What do you think?
1
69
"Perhaps the idea is that banking clients are like a crew of pirates, sailing round the Spanish Main and continuing to plunder booty until their cannons run out?" - Be careful in what you invest, and how you measure the outcomes. on.ft.com/3D34PSt via @FT
1
68









