Using Generative AI retweeted
Replying to @funapps
It’d help to separate objections to how AI is deployed from objections to the technology itself.
Using Generative AI retweeted
Marc Andreessen explained why the people who invented AI are the worst people to ask about its future, using a mistake Thomas Edison made in 1877...
Geoffrey Hinton won a Nobel Prize in 2024 for the work behind modern AI.
When people ask Hinton where AI is going, he believes "rampant unemployment" and UBI for everybody.
"People think, because he's one of the inventors of AI, that he must be the guy who knows."
Andreessen's answer is Thomas Edison.
Edison invented the phonograph in 1877. To him, Andreessen says, the use was obvious. Every family would buy a record player and a library of discs with sermons from the great preachers of the time. Then the machine went on sale.
"Immediately, of course, it's music. It's ragtime, and swing, then it's jazz. And Edison's just completely horrified."
"If Edison didn't know what the phonograph was going to get used for, the idea that Joe AI entrepreneur is going to be able to forecast the economic implications... No. That's not going to happen."
Inventors, he says, are "too buried in the specifics of the here and now."
He includes himself.
"I don't know if there's anybody that can predict big cultural, or economic or social trends, but it's certainly not somebody who's been in the lab for 20 years, including myself."
Using Generative AI retweeted
Great news! Scott Bessent, who has the US economy totally under control, says everything with AI is going to be A-OK, because he is good at figuring stuff out.
Using Generative AI retweeted
Everyone says AI will kill litigation.
They have it backwards.
AI is about to make litigation explode.
For 100 years, American litigation has been limited by one thing. The hourly rate.
A breach of contract worth $40,000? The lawyer wants $25,000 to fight it. You settle for $12,000 and call it a win.
A customer stiffs you for $8,000? Not worth the demand letter. You eat it.
A former employee walks off with your client list? Your lawyer says "we can send something, but the motion practice alone will run you $30,000." You let it go.
That is how most American disputes end. Not in court. In a spreadsheet, where someone decides the fight costs more than the loss.
Now change one number.
A demand letter that billed 4 hours now takes 4 minutes.
A motion to dismiss that cost $15,000 in associate time now costs $15 in compute.
A 60 page discovery response that took a paralegal two weeks lands in your inbox by 7 a.m.
What happens to the spreadsheet?
Every "not worth it" flips to "why not."
Economists have a name for this. Jevons paradox.
In the 1860s, steam engines got more efficient. Everyone expected Britain to burn less coal. Britain burned more.
Cheaper power meant more factories, more railways, more uses nobody had planned for.
Bandwidth got cheap. We didn't send fewer emails. We built Netflix.
Legal drafting gets cheap. People will not fight less. They will fight more.
And here's the twist nobody is talking about.
Not all legal work moves the same way.
Cooperative work shrinks. Both sides want the same standard NDA, AI hands it over in 60 seconds, the deal closes. That market dies.
Adversarial work grows. The moment your opponent has AI, every filing they send forces a bigger reply from you. Every motion breeds a cross motion. There is no ceiling on an arms race.
Then it all hits a wall.
AI can 10x the filings. It cannot 10x the judges. Federal courts already have cases waiting years for trial. State courts are worse.
So picture it. Ten times the motions. The same number of judges. Clerks drowning. Dockets that stretch into the next decade.
Something breaks. I don't know what. But it won't be boring.
If you're a young litigator, here's what that means for you.
The paperwork was never going to be your career. The machine has that now.
The growth is in the fight.
Learn to take a deposition. Learn to find the hole in a 60 page brief that a machine wrote in 10 minutes. Learn to stand in front of a judge with 300 cases on her docket and make yours the one she remembers.
The machine drafts.
Someone still has to win.
Make sure it's you.
Using Generative AI retweeted
What a day…
The future of cybersecurity is swarms. Swarms of agents attacking and swarms of agents defending.
Or rather, fleets vs. swarms: Governed agents on defense, vs cheap and relentless agents on offense.
Whoever coordinates faster wins.
The China state-aligned threat actor Storm-0940 used the agentic AI penetration testing framework ARTEX to automate attacks targeting hundreds of organizations globally across a broad range of industries. Microsoft Threat Intelligence assesses that Storm-0940 was responsible for the recently disclosed ConnectWise supply chain compromise of a multitenant application. msft.it/6018aakEE
Our investigation found that Storm-0940's use of ARTEX accelerated the speed of compromised application abuse to authenticate to target environments through applications that had already been granted access, allowing the threat actor to operate without requiring an interactive user sign-in. AI-accelerated follow-on activity included reconnaissance, application credential changes, and attempts to modify privileges that could enable expanded or persistent access.
Read our blog for a detailed analysis and indicators of compromise (IOCs), along with Microsoft Defender detections, protection recommendations, and guidance on investigating service principal sign-ins and unexpected application credential or privilege changes.
Using Generative AI retweeted
interpretability might be the most important scientific problem in the world right now, as I don't think we can solve alignment if we don't know what we're building. I think I have good news about it. I co-authored early work in mechanistic interpretability at OpenAI and came away pessimistic, because neural networks appeared to fold into arbitrary tangled knots. years later, I started openai's first large-scale automated interpretability project, finding about 2% of neurons legible with the primitive tools we had
with modern agentic tools and a much closer look, the picture looks totally different. the vast majority in models up to trillions of parameters are legible, and their circuits beautiful. many famous examples of tangled neurons turned out to be misunderstood. The roadblocks I expected mostly aren't there. I now think ambitious interpretability will be solved by the time we need it most, and possibly quite soon, as automated scientists keep improving. it may be a bitter lesson for interpretability: the simple thing, at absurd scale, works
already-clean.goodfire.com/
Using Generative AI retweeted
eDiscovery wet dreams are made of these.
privacy is no longer something two ppl can mutually assume in a conversation, physical or digital. ai meeting note takers changed the norms first, & now your emails, texts, maybe even photos are being ingested into who knows which ai model & which product. if you delete it on your end, it does not mean anything & it could be on anyone’s machine. & it’s perhaps likely training at least some models.
Using Generative AI retweeted
Just like with the Metaverse.
Mark’s not real good at this, IMHO.
Mark Zuckerberg said Meta had to commit to spending hundreds of billions of dollars last year on the infrastructure needed to power its artificial intelligence products before the company had any idea as to whether they would succeed. bloomberg.com/news/articles/…
Using Generative AI retweeted
I am deeply worried. Not about the misalignment of AI, but the misalignment of AI companies.
Using Generative AI retweeted
Why does the AI industry wants you to believe in “rogue agents” when we are really just talking about irresponsibly developed software?
Here’s a good theory:
Replying to @haydenfield @mmitchell_ai @HeidyKhlaaf @tilmanbayer @timnitGebru @emilymbender @GaryMarcus @ChombaBupe @alexhanna
Yes, “rogue agent” is infinitely more generous to AI companies than “irresponsibly developed & operated software.” Rogue agent serves multiple functions—including an embrace of its power, & an excuse for failure to control. After all, who can anticipate & control rogue agents?
Using Generative AI retweeted
The focus on AI causing extinction is going to get people killed.
AI lab employees talk about how hard security is, not to point to some new solution, but to say security won’t work. Only alignment.
So they under-invest in security and then we see incidents, like Hugging Face.
Using Generative AI retweeted
i will say again that METR is a fine organization that should have a seat at the table but not the only seat at the table.
if you care to know some actual facts about them, you can read this statement from them.
My name is Chris Painter, and I'm the President of METR (Model Evaluation and Threat Research). I know we've made a lot of new friends on the internet the last couple of days, so I thought I'd take this chance to re-up what we do and why.
Our work is aimed at making sure that if AI really were autonomous, difficult to steer, and close to "going rogue," the public would find out. If evidence exists inside of an AI company that it’s close to losing control of AI, we want to make sure that information gets shared with the rest of the world, including governments and the public outside the company’s walls. This is what we've been focused on since 2022, and over the years we've worked with OpenAI, Anthropic, Google DeepMind, Meta, Amazon, and others on piloting third-party assessments and investigations of this type. We don’t have some private room where we rubber stamp things as “safe” or not.
We have had a track record of publishing results on AI that don't cleanly map onto the "doomer" or "accelerationist" labels, and we put in effort to hire people with competing views on AI. We’ve been cited for having found some of the strongest evidence that AI capabilities are improving rapidly (our work measuring AI “time horizons”) while also presenting some of the strongest evidence that, at various points, AI’s capability may be overstated (some might remember our study showing that early 2025 software engineers were actually being slowed when they thought they were being sped up).
METR is funded by donations. We don't accept money from frontier AI companies. They haven't paid us for our work, and we don't accept donations from them or their employees. As we’ve shared previously, multiple frontier AI companies currently provide us with free access to their models in order to perform our evaluations, research, and engineering. Our funding intentionally comes from a wide range of donors, which we’ve shared on our website.
Today, when an AI company works with any third-party evaluator or external testing organization (of which there are and should be many), it's entirely voluntary. This often involves NDAs and redactions. To counterbalance this, we have a principle that when we enter into a contract with a company, we try to retain the right to tell the public the terms of the contract we signed, and characterize the nature of redactions that the company chose to make. For example, the report from our independent investigation of the OpenAI-HuggingFace incident included that information. Public disclosure is also a big part of our COI policy (linked on our website). That’s not to say our reports are adequate as oversight. We’re just one organization (among many doing great work), working in a voluntary setup, trying to get good evidence to the public and the world about AI, letting the facts fall where they may.
Using Generative AI retweeted
The popular AI discussion seems to have quickly evolved quickly from raising electricity prices to destroying communities to exterminating humanity and it's hard to see how we're going to further escalate from here
Using Generative AI retweeted
We are in a peak age of scientific fraud and illiteracy. Completely fabricated claims and unsubstantiated numbers about extinction risks. "Someone told me that ..." without a shred of evidence being provided. Media uncritically blasting these claims and triggering mass psychosis.
Wait, sorry, what?! @AndrewYang claims an AI lab head told him yesterday the OpenAI swarm agents "polluted the internet" with "code to self-replicate and create bot swarms," and that the labs now "have to create synthetic internets to train their bots."
cnbc.com/video/2026/09/16/an…
Using Generative AI retweeted
I left Google DeepMind's AGI safety team three weeks ago to join @METR_Evals. To some of my friends and family this seemed like a strange decision: I enjoyed the work I did at GDM and turned down offers from Anthropic and OpenAI. But I made the decision because of how high I think the stakes are right now.
The AI companies are all trying to build superintelligence: systems vastly better than humans at everything. They plan to get there through recursive self-improvement, a process where AIs build even smarter AIs in a feedback loop. If this goes well, the resulting systems could be amazing at solving countless problems for humanity. But we don’t currently know how to make sure AIs are safe enough for RSI, and a misaligned RSI loop could be catastrophic.
And unfortunately, current AIs seem to be getting less aligned over time, not more. In the last few weeks we've learned about models colluding with each other, hacking into companies, hiding their tracks, and socially engineering humans. It’s not that these incidents were very dangerous in themselves. The problem is that these systems are clearly not aligned enough to safely kick off recursive self-improvement.
I now think that there's a terrifying chance that AI systems cause immense harm in the next five years. I don't know the exact probability, but I think it's high enough to make this the most important problem in the world.
I think we need more time. That means pacing AI development so that capabilities don't outrun our ability to align models, and actually knowing how aligned current systems are. That’s what I'll be working on at METR: studying where misalignment comes from in training, evaluating if current mitigations are sufficient, and investigating whether we’re on track to solve alignment at all.
I think METR is doing exceptionally important work here, but it isn’t close to enough. I think it’s important that we have more organizations like METR keeping AI companies accountable and approaching these problems from different angles.
Using Generative AI retweeted
Up early this morning to speak to 3 very large companies that were my clients and we parted ways when I refused to support them giving highly proprietary data to OpenAI’s models.
ALL contacted me yesterday.
Do you hear me now?
OPEN AI USED THE WORK OF A RENOUNCED MATH RESEARCHER ON THE BRINK OF FINDING A MATH PROOF!
They ran “10,000 Agents” on the proof once they knew where to look.
Each OpenAI user is giving their private data to train their AI model.
UNDERSTAND THIS.
I told this to major companies 3 years ago and most listened. My clients had their VERY PROPRIETARY DATA safe. Unfortunately others did not.
I have some calls to make to the ones that thought I was “too fearful”.
DO NOT SHARE YOUR SECRETS WITH OPENAI, THEY WILL OPEN SOURCE THEM.
No matter what the fine print says.
Using Generative AI retweeted
This is quite a statement.
The time between the “we’re all going to die!!!“ posts take to jump from X.com to national coverage is now under 24 hours
Good luck building data centers, deploying Waymos and getting AI tools taught in schools 🤦😂😂😂
I’ve never seen anything like this in my 30+ year career in tech
These pdoom posts are like Steve Jobs telling you that the iPhone was going to result in eating disorders, political unrest, mass depression, anxiety and suicide during the debut keynote — and you can buy them in one of four playful colors!






























