Muneer S.Godil 穆尼尔 (@godil01) header
Muneer S.Godil 穆尼尔 (@godil01) profile picture

A Professional Engineer with 35 years of strategic , financial & diversified experience comprising Alternative Energy solution for Industrial Sector.

Karachi, Pakistan
Joined December 2010
Pakistan's grid is losing over Rs400bn a year because cheap power from the south cannot reach the north. Thar coal, nuclear and wind plants sit idle while expensive RFO and RLNG plants run in their place, and industry and households pay for both. Nepra has documented NGC's failures for years, yet the penalty was a token Rs10m fine. Industry is right to demand that the NGC MD be summoned. The bigger problem is policy: the government wants industry back on the grid, taxes captive generation, stalls B2B wheeling, and then cannot deliver the cheap electricity it promises. This is not a technical problem. It is a governance failure protected by vested interests. Fix the transmission bottlenecks with deadlines and real accountability, open the market, and let industry build renewables near its own load. Competitiveness cannot wait another planning cycle. #Pakistan #Energy #NEPRA #PowerSector @APTMAofficial @TextilePtea @PakTexCouncil @PTJ_Textile @akleghari @AliPervaiz450 Over Rs400bn annual loss: Industry urges Nepra to summon NGC MD brecorder.com/news/40446988
2
1
2
143
The plan to sell #FESCO, #GEPCO and #IESCO in the first quarter of 2027 is a step in the right direction, but the order of the sales says a lot. These three are the strongest of the distribution companies, with the lowest losses and the best bill recovery. Investors will want them, and the government gets an early headline win. The real test is the #Hyderabad, #Sukkur, #Peshawar and #Hazara companies, where losses, theft and poor recovery are deep and long-standing. If the state sells its best assets and keeps the worst, it may end up with a smaller but more concentrated loss problem on the public books. Bidding has also already slipped from December, which suggests the timelines for the later batches are ambitious. The structure of the deal is better than in past efforts. Returns will be paid in rupees, linked to inflation and calculated through CAPM, which avoids the dollar-indexed guarantees that turned the IPP contracts into a long-term burden. Setting multi-year tariffs and investment plans before bidding, with penalties and rewards tied to smart metering, loss reduction and recovery, is a sound approach. Still, the K-Electric experience shows that performance rules only work if the regulator enforces them independently. Without a credible and firm NEPRA, a privatised DISCO can become a private monopoly with guaranteed returns, while consumers carry the cost of weak delivery. The bigger issue is that the adviser links privatisation to lower tariffs and stopping industry from leaving the grid. Distribution efficiency matters, but most of the industrial tariff is not set by the DISCOs. It is driven by capacity payments, expensive generation contracts and the circular debt held up by entrenched interests. Changing who owns the distribution network will not fix that. Industry is moving to captive solar, wind and storage because grid power cannot compete, and a change in ownership alone will not bring it back. The most important part of the announcement may be the reform paper due in mid-November, which proposes moving away from the uniform tariff toward competing suppliers, with a supplier of last resort. For industry, that matters more than the privatisation itself, if it brings fair wheeling charges, open access and real choice of supplier. If the paper ends up diluted in consultations, privatisation risks becoming a change of owner rather than a change in the sector. The protections for employees are also understandable politically, but they will limit how quickly any new owner can improve efficiency. @MoWP15 @APTMAofficial @TextilePtea @PakistanTextile @PakTexCouncil @akleghari @AliPervaiz450 #Discos #energysecurity #privatisation brecorder.com/news/40446814/…
3
139
Pakistan's winter gas crunch is no longer a warning. It's here. QatarEnergy has extended its LNG force majeure to December 29, and the government has lined up only 10 cargoes for December and January against a need of 20. That leaves Pakistan half short just as household demand peaks, and once again industry, fertiliser, power and CNG will absorb the cut. We go through this every winter. Depending on a single supplier with no storage cushion is a policy failure, not bad luck. The real fix is diversified supply, gas storage and industry moving its heat and power to solar , Wind , BESS and waste heat recovery. Energy security can't keep being negotiated every December. #RLNG #EnergySecurity #gasCrisis #Pakistan #SSGC #SNGPL @akleghari @AliPervaiz450 @MoWP15 @Financegovpk @APTMAofficial @TextilePtea
86
NEPRA has now questioned whether the Power Division's data is reliable. The numbers filed with the regulator don't match the ones presented at the hearing. Oil supplied only 3.6% of energy but cost Rs 25bn, while cheap southern generation sat idle. The transmission constraint behind this is reported at just Rs 14m, which doesn't add up. Tariffs can only be as honest as the data behind them. Until the numbers are transparent and verified, every FCA passes inefficiency straight to consumers and industry. #NEPRA #FCA #PakistanEnergy @Financegovpk @MoWP15 brecorder.com/news/40436812/…
3
102
Indigenous gas costs Rs 1,173/MMBtu. Add 50,158 BBTU of diverted RLNG and the cost of gas rises to Rs 1,393. Include opex, depreciation and return on assets, and SNGPL's full current-year requirement comes to Rs 1,683. The shortfall for this year is just Rs 1,545 million, only Rs 5.49/MMBtu. Yet in May 2026, captive industry paid an effective Rs 5,523/MMBtu: a 25:75 system gas and RLNG blend at Rs 4,433, plus a Rs 1,090 levy. That is 3.3 times the utility's own requirement and 4.7 times the cost of indigenous gas. Even if you load the entire Rs 567.7 billion of past shortfall onto this single year, the price reaches Rs 3,696. Industry still pays Rs 1,827 more than that. So who is industry really paying for? Cross-subsidies, diverted RLNG, accumulated inefficiency, and a levy designed to force captive users onto an expensive grid. This is not gas pricing. It is a tax on production. Exporters cannot compete on these numbers. Pakistan needs cost-reflective, transparent gas pricing, not one that bails out vested interests. #Pakistan #GasPricing #SNGPL #OGRA #Industry #Exports @APTMAofficial @PBCIpk @TextilePtea @akleghari @AliPervaiz450 @MoWP15 @Financegovpk
1
4
1
7
4,053
MMG Engineering has successfully completed and commissioned two 7.5 MW wind turbines and a 19 MW solar power system integrated with a microgrid at Premium Textile, contributing to an estimated 50,000 tonnes of carbon emission reduction. With a combined installed capacity of 34 MW across wind and solar, the project demonstrates how integrating renewable energy sources can support more sustainable industrial energy generation and management. For Pakistan, the transition towards renewable energy is an important step towards a cleaner, more sustainable future. Harnessing wind and solar power helps reduce reliance on conventional energy sources, lower carbon emissions and support more responsible energy use across industries. MMG Engineering remains committed to delivering integrated energy solutions that support industrial progress while contributing to a more sustainable future for Pakistan. #MMGEngineering #RenewableEnergy #WindEnergy #SolarEnergy #SustainableFuture
1
3
96
Indigenous gas costs Rs 1,173/MMBtu, and even after RLNG diversion SNGPL's own petitioned requirement is only Rs 1,683.The jump happens in pricing policy, not supply cost. Industrial process gas is Rs 2,300 and captive gas is Rs 3,500, which is already double the revenue requirement.The blend and the levy close the deal. Captive users pay a 25% system gas + 75% RLNG blend (Rs 4,433), plus a Rs 1,090 levy, for Rs 5,523.The gap is Rs 3,840/MMBtu above what SNGPL says it needs. That is cross subsidy, RLNG burden and levy loaded onto industry. The extra Rs 3,840 is not the cost of gas. It is cross subsidies, the RLNG burden and levies, all loaded onto exporters. We can't compete globally while paying for everyone else's inefficiency. #Pakistan #Energy #Gas #Industry #Exports @APTMAofficial @TextilePtea @PakTexCouncil @akleghari @Financegovpk @AliPervaiz450 @MoWP15 @SSGC_Official @SNGPLofficial @FPCCIOfficial
1
1
98
Circular debt of Power: Rs1,675 bn &
Gas: Rs3,631 bn That's over Rs5.3 trillion stuck in the system. Gas is now more than double power, and still no one talks about it. Every year it's the same: tariff hikes, more borrowing, and a plan that never touches the real leakages. Consumers keep paying. The losses keep growing. Until theft, losses and the vested interests behind them are tackled, this circle won't break. @APTMAofficial @kcci_official @FPCCIOfficial @UNICEF_Pakistan @Financegovpk @akleghari @MoWP15
1
3
159
The @MoWP15 Ministry of Energy has informed Parliament that Rs. 2.935 trillion was paid to IPPs during the first eleven months of the last fiscal year. Of this, only Rs. 1.168 trillion covered electricity actually supplied, while Rs. 1.565 trillion (53 % ) went to capacity payments, charges owed whether or not a single unit was generated. When the nation pays more for idle capacity than for consumed energy, the problem is not tariffs but contract architecture. Renegotiation must go beyond optics. #IPPs #EnergyPolicy #Pakistan @APTMAofficial @akleghari @TextilePtea @ThePBC_Official
159
The Cabinet Committee on Energy’s approval of the National Integrated Energy Plan 2027–2060 is a positive step for Pakistan’s energy future. We’ve already seen industries move ahead with large-scale solar and wind projects on their own. Now, we need to look at the bigger picture for how solar, wind, storage and the grid can work together. Good energy planning is about connecting all the pieces, not looking at them one by one.
72
Sustainability is for future generations
1
63
Pakistan paid Rs 2.94T for electricity — 61% was capacity payments for plants running at 42.5% utilization. We’re paying Rs 14.3/unit for idle steel vs Rs 9/unit for actual energy. Industry can’t wait for reform. It’s already voting with its feet: - Rooftop & captive solar + wind turbine - BESS + hybrid systems including microgrid - 30-50% energy cost reduction At @MMGEngineering , 28+ years of industrial energy expertise now goes into one mission: helping factories exit the capacity-payment trap. The grid bills you for contracts. The sun & wind doesn’t. #SolarPakistan #IPPs #EnergyIndependence #MMGEngineering #windturbine #BESS
1
71
It was an honour to meet @siddiquidaniyal receive this recognition from @dsgenergypk. While awards are always appreciated, what I value most is the opportunity to work alongside organizations that share a common vision for advancing renewable energy and building a more sustainable future. Every project reminds me that meaningful progress is achieved through strong partnerships, thoughtful engineering, and a shared commitment to creating lasting value. My sincere thanks to the @dsgenergypk team for this recognition. I look forward to continuing our journey together and contributing to Pakistan's evolving energy landscape.
41
It was a pleasure meeting with Raza @HashimRazaaa and the @KSolarPK team to exchange perspectives on where Pakistan's industrial energy sector is headed and the role that Captive Power Plants (CPPs), Private Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs), wind energy, and Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) will play in shaping that future. What made this discussion particularly valuable wasn't just the technology but the shared focus on making renewable energy technically sound, commercially viable, and practical for industrial users. I'm looking forward to building on these discussions and turning them into projects that create long-term value for Pakistan's industries. #RenewableEnergy #WindEnergy #CPP #PPA #BESS #IndustrialPower #Engineering #Pakistan
35
Tax concession lapses from July 1 ,2026 hybrids taxed like gas guzzlers. Price hikes up to Rs 25 lakh ,Deliveries suspended, invoicing frozen & Fastest-growing auto segment — stalled The irony? Same govt drafting an NEV policy to promote green mobility. Promote efficiency on paper. Tax it in practice. You can’t build a 5-year industry on 12-month tax certainty. That’s not fiscal discipline !! that’s policy whiplash. @MoWP15 @Financegovpk @akleghari @betterpakistan @kschehzad @MiftahIsmail @kcci_official @LahoreChamber @IslamabadCCI @FPCCIOfficial @SMTanveerpk @APTMAofficial @ThePBC_Official #Pakistan #AutoPolicy #TaxPolicy #EnergyTransition #sustainability GST hike pushes up hybrid vehicle prices epaper.dawn.com/DetailNews.p…
77
Why Fuel prices in Pakistan are not coming down with International Prices. Post 2023 IMF deal, govt’s room to subsidise fuel is sharply limited. Petroleum levy is revenue tool !!! Not a buffer for consumers; it’s fiscal cover for the state. Every 5% PKR depreciation adds an equal % to import cost, regardless of crude prices. Carbon tax just doubled Rs 2.5 to Rs 5/litre, quietly offsetting any levy relief. Pass-through lag .Falling global prices reach consumers slowly, partially, and always after a delay. Net effect a Rs 1.97 cut is optics, not relief. The structure is designed to protect fiscal targets not the commuter. #Fuellevy #fuelprices #Pakistaneconomy #aptma #prmga #KCCI #LCCI
47
Why levy on Furnace oil still there ???? We export cheap Furnace Oil at ~$10/MMBtu, then import spot LNG at $17+/MMBtu. That’s a $6.5–9.7/MMBtu leak, straight out of the economy. Refineries are pushed into distressed FO exports, worsening our forex position instead of easing it. High effective FO costs are hurting export industries and backup power generation ,right when competitiveness matters most. The levy itself is self-defeating ,it suppresses domestic FO demand and erodes its own revenue base. The fix isn’t blanket removal it’s a targeted, time bound suspension of PL + CSL on FO, only where it directly displaces costly imported LNG, backed by merit-order dispatch, efficiency standards, and transparency. Smart energy policy means fixing structural leaks, not taxing our way into deeper ones. #Pakistan #EnergyPolicy #FurnaceOil #LNG #EnergySecurity @APTMAofficial @akleghari @SMTanveerpk @GovtofPakistan @AliPervaiz450 @Financegovpk @TextilePtea
80