Will Hodson (@hodsonwill) profile picture

@lfg_uk energy campaigner @ycombinator alum

London
Joined April 2010
I love clean energy but I hate Clean Power 2030. It’s time for the Chancellor to clarify how HE feels about it. At the Budget, John Healey said he would “only buy or build clean energy if it lowers bills”. Clean Power 2030 is the litmus test on his integrity. Did he actually mean it? At present, the Government buys clean energy with casual indifference to its hidden costs. Those extra costs are picked up by us, the billpayers – and they run to billions. That’s because we continue to procure wind north of a transmission bottleneck. Our cables can only carry limited energy to the south. When we can’t use all the wind that government has bought, billpayers have to pay wind giants to turn off and gas plants to turn on. These are called ‘constraint costs’, and they’ve topped £2bn this year. They are directly attributable to wind farms. And yet the Government is unwilling to reveal expected constraint costs from renewable energy contracts before they sign off. Probably because it’s a national embarrassment. Perhaps because they are expected to near £8bn a year by 2030. Well if John Healey is going back up his words at the Budget, now is the perfect opportunity. Renewable energy generators are currently bidding for contracts under Britain’s Allocation Round 8. Healey can insist that before the Government signs any contracts, they publish the likely constraint costs they’ll incur. DESNZ doesn’t lack smart people, so it’s easy enough to do. You’d take a wind farm with a similar location… You’d calculate the money we paid to turn it off when there was too much wind… Then you’d calculate the money we paid to fire up gas plants to replace it…. Next you’d discount those constraint costs to the degree that you expect to open the transmission bottleneck… And finally, you'd bring those total costs before Parliament. Then, as a democracy, we would decide whether it was worth it. Cheap energy takes clear thinking. At the very least, it demands the calculation and publication of full costs before contracts are entered. That's called transparency. But DESNZ refuses to do it. Perhaps they don’t trust the public to back their spending decisions Why not? Surely if they saw that a wind farm incurred huge constraint costs, they’d consider a different source of energy. Why would they keep buying wind power with billions of hidden costs for the billpayer? Answer: because DESNZ is not incentivised to lower your bills. They are incentivised to procure clean energy, at almost any cost, because of Clean Power 2030. Clean Power 2030 mandates that 95% of UK electricity must come from clean sources by the end of the decade. Here’s why I love clean energy but hate Clean Power 2030: 1. It’s a completely arbitrary target. 2. It means we are in a weak negotiating position with renewable energy giants. 3. It’s making electricity so expensive that people won’t use it for heating or transport, leaving us addicted to gas and petrol. No one wins except big renewable companies. The Chancellor must clarify whether he supports Clean Power 2030. He said he would only buy or build clean energy if it lower bills. Prove it. As a first step, he must have DESNZ reveal the full expected costs of new wind contracts, including constraint costs. This will reveal many contracts to generate huge additional costs for the billpayer. That will turn pressure onto DESNZ. Why are you entering these contracts, knowing that you are dumping billions of extra cost onto the billpayer? And they will reply: Because we have to. Because of Clean Power 2030. And that’s where John Healey will be judged. If he truly wants to only buy clean power where it lowers bills, it’s time for the Government to scrap Clean Power 2030. From now on, let’s negotiate clean power on our own terms only. Let’s accelerate the infrastructure that allows us to use more. Let’s stop paying for energy that we can’t use. Britain is in an Energy Emergency. It's time for our Government to act like it. What do you think? Tweet below: lookingforgrowth.uk/saveus/
3
6
646
Exciting times!
🚨 ANNOUNCEMENT THE LFG BOARD 1️⃣ Scarlett Maguire One of Britain’s leading political pollsters and commentators, founder of Merlin Strategy, with a decade of experience in Westminster. 2️⃣ Josh Simons Co-founder of the Labour Growth Group. Former MP for Makerfield, Director of Labour Together & AI researcher at Meta. 3️⃣ Peter McCormack Campaigner & entrepreneur. Podcaster with over 350,000 YouTube subscribers. Chairman of Real Bedford FC. All three will take up non-executive roles. LFG is the political movement to END decline & RESCUE Britain. More to come. LFG 🚀
1
7
1,279
Trust in UK energy policy is low, because our bills are high. It's time for the Govt to show its working before it enters any more energy contracts. They come w so many added costs: not least the £2bn we spend turning off wind and replacing w gas. @lfg_uk demands transparency.
£10 BILLION is on the line. John Healey promised in the Budget to only buy & build new projects when they lower bills. So… what’s the issue? The Government is signing contracts for wind power without admitting the true cost. Last year, the British people paid £1.5 BILLION to turn turbines off. This year, we’ll pay over £2 BILLION. And in 2030? It’ll be around £10 BILLION that’s added to our bills. Every penny matters right now to families and households. Nothing is being produced and the British people are paying the price. This system is BROKEN. We have some of the highest costs in Europe. The Government must tell us the true cost of renewables before they sign new contracts. Use our ready-made email to tell your MP to demand the truth 👇
2
8
800
So sloppy from @KatieJWhite MP @TimesRadio: Will £12bn of new offshore wind incur constraint costs? (£2bn YTD to turn wind off/gas on) KJ: No cos they have a grid connection?🥴 Does she understand the issue? The Govt must PUBLISH EXPECTED CONSTRAINT COSTS for EVERY CONTRACT
1
4
10
1,641
Curtailment cost £35m on 6/9/26, £505m in September. @lfg_uk is calling for transparency. Our Emergency Energy Bill: no new CfDs without each contract’s full system cost, curtailment included. The Chancellor says he agrees. Prove it in AR8: Publish full costs before signing.
5
8
850
Britain's energy is becoming another way to raise tax from some and hand money to others. I fear we are losing focus. Energy is a utility shared by ALL. Effective government shd make it cheaper for ALL. That's the foundation of a high growth economy. This is managed decline.
🚨 Exclusive Labour gives energy companies powers to snoop on tax records ‘Big Brother’ tactics alleged as bill paves way for levy on wealthier households to subsidise others telegraph.co.uk/politics/202…
5
221
Govt snatching defeat from the jaws of victory here. They approved new gas from Jackdaw, as we called for in the @lfg_uk Energy Bill. "BUT THAT'S IT!" they boom now. Mixed messages. Is saving face for Ed Miliband more important than showing pragmatism to the British public??
Britain’s international climate leadership is backed by strong action at home. The Energy Independence Bill is vital to that effort. Delivering warmer homes, lower bills and energy security through clean power we control, and legislating for no new oil and gas licences. This is what leadership on climate and the clean energy transition looks like. gov.uk/government/news/energ…
3
14
1,286
In @lfg_uk's Emergency Energy Bill, we demanded the Govt drop the constraint of Clean Power 2030 It obliged us to procure more clean power, at any cost, to hit targets We should be free to buy clean power ONLY if it lowers bills, said LFG Did the Chancellor just meet our ask?
3
4
904
For anyone who wants cheaper energy in the UK, there is much to like about this Budget. Most of all, the bloke delivering it isn't Ed Miliband.
1
208
Another way to work within a rigid grid? Offload more energy we can't carry to southern GB. Zonal pricing might stimulate demand north of the bottleneck. Locating growth zones there definitely would. So too datacentres. This is what levelling up could look like by the way.
18
Oof! Britain paid £50m in balancing costs yday, within a whisker of our £52m record. It all goes on the billpayers' tab. Reason: too much wind generation north of a transmission bottleneck. This means we often pay to throw away 1/3 of the wind power we generate. Thoughts 🧵:
1
1
206
In the meantime, grind more out of the existing network. The limit to our cables' capacity to carry energy is set by heat. If the weather is cooling them, in theory you can make them carry more - this is called dynamic line rating.
1
45
At present, we assume a *fixed* line rating. We don't recognise cables' ability to carry more energy when cooled. This means we push no more power through them in winter sleet than we would in a heatwave. Dynamic line rating is a hack, but we have our backs to the wall here.
1
51
It's time to pull the beaver lever.
Now Yorkshire brings back beavers to help reduce flooding. The return of native beavers - after an absence of centuries - is one of the most exciting things happening in conservation (and flood and drought mitigation) in Britain today: theguardian.com/environment/…
74
🎯
Why is the City Bridge Foundation funding “social justice” instead of fixing all of London’s bridges? The charity was set up in 1282. Today, it’s worth almost *£1.5 billion*. Yet… London’s bridges are falling apart. Why? The Foundation’s rules only require it to maintain 5 bridges. Funds can also be spent on “other charitable purposes” for the benefit of Londoners. So what are some of these “other charitable purposes”? 👉 A “poet-in-residence”. 👉 Trans and sex worker sector capacity. 👉 A historian examining connections to the slave trade (they found links were “limited”). 👉 “Systems change”, islamic charities, migration support, climate crisis research… and a group campaigning against a new river crossing. ENOUGH. Governments have failed to fix London’s bridges and one of our oldest institutions has not been directed to step in. The City of London Corporation is the sole trustee of the Foundation. They have changed the rules before. The rules must change AGAIN to make all of our bridges the priority. Change the rules. Fix the bridges. Our research in The Times 👇
1
3
678
Deep down, I love Caroline – she is a throwback to the Green Party as a voice on climate. But her views have not moved with the time. UK climate 'leadership' is a delusion. No-one is following a country whose policies have lumbered it w the highest elec prices in the world.
Government support for drilling at #Jackdaw takes a wrecking ball to any pretence of UK climate leadership & pours fuel on an overheating world - and for what? It’s equivalent to just 2 months of UK gas demand, creates just 27 direct jobs & has *no* impact on energy bills🧵1/4
1
5
55
1,990
It *could* mean cheaper bills... ... IF North Sea tax revenue is put towards bill support for all, as per @lfg_uk Emergency Energy Bill. It must not be squandered on dubious projects / backhanded to certain voters. North Sea reserves belong to us all They must benefit us all.
‘Will this mean cheaper energy bills?’ ‘No.’   @NickFerrariLBC quizzes @Miatsf about the government’s controversial decision to approve drilling in the Jackdaw North Sea gas field.
3
185
A win for LFG and our Emergency Energy Bill. We campaigned hard for new licenses. Britain is in dire economic straits and a cash-strapped populace will no longer accept virtue-signalling. New tax revenue must fund bill support + the energy transition bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvze…
2
9
734