Arturo Estrella (@intheyield) header
Arturo Estrella (@intheyield) profile picture

Economist, recession forecaster. Prof Emeritus at RPI. Former Senior VP, NY Fed. PhD in economics, Harvard.

Joined January 2022
How does raising interest rates hold back inflation? It restrains aggregate demand, which also puts downward pressure on jobs. If inflation is driven by supply (eg, oil prices, tariffs), inflation control comes at the expense of jobs. Central banking is hard.
1
2
11
561
The fact that the HEM rule is flashing recession should be of concern to policymakers, including the Fed. Even if a recession has not been officially called, households are reporting a significant loss of jobs.
3
1
8
540
Evidence of a 2026 recession is provided by the HEM indicator (Household Employment Meltdown). The 'HEM rule' is that it crosses -1% during each NBER recession, starting from 0 just before and bottoming out toward the end (-17.6% in April 2020 falls off the chart).
2
3
14
661
The Phantom Recession of 2026 drags on. Each month so far this year, civilian employment (household survey) has been lower than 12 months before. The widely reported payroll survey is not picking this up and the NBER has been silent, but households are feeling the pinch.
1
1
1
11
465
Something big happened to the relationship between payroll and household employment numbers after covid. They used to move together. Now the signals can be completely different, even over a year. Was there a 2024 recession? Is there one now?
1
11
575
Was today's 29K payroll employment drop a big deal? Not at all. The series is noisy and the number is well within recent readings. More interesting is that changes got smaller every year from 2022 to 2025, dipping into minus in 2025. 2026 remains to be seen.
2
15
1,500
Q1 real GDP is down by .3%. Is this the recession the bond market had been predicting? Could be but seems like a stretch. Good forecasts depend on good data and manageable uncertainty and we haven't had much of either in recent times.
1
5
995
Employment increased in February by 151K as per the establishment survey, less than expected, and DECREASED by 588K as per the household survey. Quite frankly, it's getting harder to make sense of the monthly fluctuations and revisions in these numbers.
2
2
1
22
1,804
Here's the inflation side over the last 30 months. Both CPI and PCE have been picking up since the lows in September 2024.
1
12
1,630
Worried about tariffs, inflation and recession? Here's a new way to track the NBER 6 recession indicators. Shows the last 30 months scaled to the peak of each series. Employment (household) and industrial production already look fragile. The rest look OK for now.
1
10
1,111
When did it become clear that the 2022 Fed tightening was unlikely to lead to a recession? Chances of recession tumbled on 9/27/2024 when the BEA revised some of the NBER 6 recession indicators retroactively. Rational forecasts were bound to change dramatically that day.
1
9
905
My previous 6 graphs show that Fed tightening that started Mar 2022 was followed by performance of the NBER 6 indicators that fell generally short of the prior 8 tightening episodes, 2 followed by soft landings and 6 by recession. No recession perhaps but not a model expansion.
1
7
1,093
Industrial production clearly stalled from the start of Fed tightening. We all know the issues with "post hoc..." but this looks bad anyway. It's worse than in the 2 soft landings and all 6 recessions.
1
4
568
Employment from the household survey (no double counting) grew at first when Fed tightening started but then flattened out. At this point, it's worse than in the 2 soft landings and 5 of the 6 recessions in the sample.
1
1
7
523
Personal consumption kept growing through the Fed tightening, but total growth so far is worse than in both soft landings and all 6 recessions.
2
5
514
Personal income grew almost from the start of tightening, but the result so far is worse that in 2 soft landings and 5 of 6 recessions.
1
8
624
Sales eventually grew, but so far less than in 2 soft landings and 4 of 6 recessions.
1
3
498
From the start of Fed tightening, employment (establishment) kept rising, but less than in 2 soft landings and 2 recessions since 1977.
4
352
What did the most recent Fed tightening episode accomplish? Looking at the NBER 6 indicators, industrial production was paralyzed and employment (HH) was flattened, but the others mainly grew. How does this compare to previous tightenings? Let's see 1 by 1.
1
5
560