Jeremy Menicucci (@jmenicucci) header
Jeremy Menicucci (@jmenicucci) profile picture

Presuppositional apologetics & nouthetic counseling. Pastor @realnacmin · PhD cand., OT, Westminster · @BooksAtAGlance reviewer

Joined January 2010
Photo by Jeremy Menicucci (@jmenicucci)Photo by Jeremy Menicucci (@jmenicucci)Photo by Jeremy Menicucci (@jmenicucci)Photo by Jeremy Menicucci (@jmenicucci)Photo by Jeremy Menicucci (@jmenicucci)Photo by Jeremy Menicucci (@jmenicucci)Photo by Jeremy Menicucci (@jmenicucci)Photo by Jeremy Menicucci (@jmenicucci)Photo by Jeremy Menicucci (@jmenicucci)Photo by Jeremy Menicucci (@jmenicucci)
Regarding the TGC article telling married folks not to sit together anymore, I've struggled more with the thought that if I saw a husband and wife separated, even just by one or two of their own kids, that they were having marriage problems. For sure, I would've thought they were on the verge of divorce if they sat separately, with singles. It's fine to identify a problem: how do we make visitors and singles feel welcome? That doesn't mean we break something that isn't a problem in order to fix that.
1
30
This is an incredible project; you definitely want to follow along for when it's complete.
The more I've worked on this project for @crossway, the more I've become convinced that the New Testament use of the Old dismantles the case for slow incremental development and utterly vindicates "early high Christology." Here we have Peter (casually!) replacing YHWH with Christ, in a passage that's not even making a wider point about Christology.
1
95
Roman Catholics want us to believe that they've been perfectly unified with Christians throughout all time, but when you point out that the current Pope believes the opposite of some of the past Popes, then those Christians in the past all of a sudden become irrelevant.
1
79
"Hey Calvinists, if God is the way you think He is, why isn't He the way I think He would be in your theology?"
Hey Calvinists, why wasn’t God honest with Cain and just tell him “you’re a born unelect reprobate and I wouldn’t accept your sacrifice if you were the only man on earth.”
1
53
Grok is extremely helpful to clear up issues.
48
I mean... I'm not the one who has to account for changing doctrine on this subject.
115
The sheer irony of so many Roman Catholics in this thread, who in other contexts would tell me the Catholic Church gave me the Bible, but who in this context tell me not to worry about what Genesis teaches.
1/ It is difficult to comprehend how it is that the Pope could be the vicar of Jesus Christ, when he contradicts what the Bible says: “Whoever sheds the blood of man, by man shall his blood be shed, for God made man in his own image.” (Genesis 9:6 ESV)
2
192
1/ It is difficult to comprehend how it is that the Pope could be the vicar of Jesus Christ, when he contradicts what the Bible says: “Whoever sheds the blood of man, by man shall his blood be shed, for God made man in his own image.” (Genesis 9:6 ESV)
Pope Leo XIV: “Someone who says, ‘I’m against abortion,’ but says, ‘I’m in favor of the death penalty,’ is not really pro-life.”
225
2
23
48
44,371
2/ You can try to alter the definition of pro-life, but you can't alter the Bible's clear testimony. I'd rather agree with the Bible than the pope's definition of pro-life.
14
1
4
5,528
My biggest complaint with Anti-Calvinist arguments, especially of this type, are that they create problems with Calvinism that their own positions don't solve, "It is quite possible that God created you, knowing one day you will experience destruction," is the same problem.
It’s beyond comprehension that a Calvinist would look at this beautiful child and think it’s biblically accurate to say, “It’s quite possible God created you for destruction.” That is the end result of their reasoning.
2
182
It's actually more like: Atheist: Evil is a problem for God's existence Anti-Calvinist: Evil is a problem for the existence of the Calvinist God. These have far more in common with each other on the problem of evil.
Why does horrendous evil occur in the world? Atheist: Because there’s no God. Calvinist: Because God wanted it to happen, so He decreed it. Christian: Because humans have the God-given gift of free will that can be used for good or for evil.
1
143
God loves nations... just apparently is indifferent towards who's in them.
Romans 9 has nothing to do with the election of individuals to salvation it has to with the election of the nation of Israel.
1
3
136
Uh oh. He just quoted the sole infallible voice and representative for all of Protestantism. Game over y'all.
There it is. I rest my case.
8
1
12
2,629
This is the literal definition of refusal to believe in Sola Scriptura.
Same Bible. Different doctrines. Different churches. Different moral teachings. Different "gospels." The fruit of sola Scriptura is chaos, anarchy, and disunity. The one true Church is not found in Protestantism, because Protestantism is the antithesis of "one."
2
143
Jerome's use of books "as authoritative" is not the issue. Jerome held to two registers of what is "scripture," but Jerome EXPLICITLY states that the apocrypha are not CANONICAL. That's the issue.
Utterly false, Jerome never treated the Deuterocanonical books as Apocrypha. He used them authoritatively throughout his entire life minus a brief window of about five years where he held to a personal opinion because he never found them in the original language. Even post Latin Vulgate 382AD, he uses the Deuterocanonical books as authoritative. (images attached, years 399ad, 404ad) At the time of Jerome 380 years after Jesus, it is true that these Jews (380 years after Jesus) did not accept these 7 books as Scripture. However, they also rejected all the New Testament books, Jesus Himself, and the entire Christian faith. Why would you appeal to them for authority on Scripture? When Pope Innocent issued the decree affirming the 73 book canon Jerome did not protest. We have nearly all of his surviving works, there is no record of him protesting this decision. If Jerome had been bullied into including these books as @WesleyLHuff suggests, wouldn't he have written about it? Doesn't this demonstrate that the 73 book Bible was in fact established in the year 382AD? Wouldn't that mean that Protestants later deleted the 7 books?
1
108
In what ways does a non Calvinist have a monopoly on this? Especially, for example, in the case of those loved ones who walk away from the faith? It seems that whatever standard you apply for assurance is equally or even more fully wrong in those situations. Is it because they "made a decision?" And in what cases would that be more reassuring that a Calvinist saying "its because God made a decision?"
The Calvinist has no objective assurance for his loved ones: his wife, his children, his friends, his siblings, his parents, his relatives. What if God doesn’t prefer to save any of the Calvinist’s loved ones? If God doesn’t prefer to save them, does this mean that the Calvinist loves these folks more than God does?
1
170
Cuz all the people he asked to pray directly to Jesus were still alive?
Why didn’t Paul “Only Pray to Jesus” as some Protestants say… Why did Paul ask others to pray for him? Did he not get Luther’s Memo?💧
2
119