John Beatty (@john_d_beatty) header
John Beatty (@john_d_beatty) profile picture

Co-founder, President, Bench. Engineer. Former co-founder/VPEng/CEO @CloverCommerce, ex-Yahoo, ex-BEA, ex-Sun.

Palo Alto, CA
Joined October 2020
Photo by John Beatty (@john_d_beatty)Photo by John Beatty (@john_d_beatty)Photo by John Beatty (@john_d_beatty)Photo by John Beatty (@john_d_beatty)Photo by John Beatty (@john_d_beatty)Photo by John Beatty (@john_d_beatty)Photo by John Beatty (@john_d_beatty)Photo by John Beatty (@john_d_beatty)Photo by John Beatty (@john_d_beatty)Photo by John Beatty (@john_d_beatty)
Bench is my new project, backed by Sutter Hill Ventures (who also backed Clover). Bench is an AI-powered workspace, and I think a glimpse into the future of computing. Give the computer a task, a set of materials, some tools, and let it rip. This is just the beginning of the the beginning. Here's an example. You can check out the Private Preview here:
2
5
1
20
2,462
John Beatty retweeted
i have always thought that programmers were divided between puzzle solvers and problem solvers. AI makes this division even more clear.
11
5
1
47
5,935
John Beatty retweeted
"Did you use AI to write this?" is a popular and valid question to asks when someone sends us something subpar. But another valid question to ask, when we see bad thinking or execution, is "Did you fail to use AI to help you make this better?" I ask this all the time now.
The lowest-hanging fruit with AI is to use it as an advisor. As long as you're using a decent model and it has enough context about you, you almost can't lose by asking your AI assistant to give a second opinion on your thinking, your plans, your work, etc.
3
16
2
207
21,305
John Beatty retweeted
can’t wait to see how much they fine themselves
BREAKING: The European Commission has been hit by a major cyberattack that may have compromised large amounts of personal data, according to POLITICO. The attack reportedly involved the exploitation of ARТEX, a publicly available AI-powered tool designed to identify vulnerabilities in IT systems. CERT-EU, the EU institutions’ cybersecurity watchdog, had detected the use of the tool earlier this month. EU officials warned that some actors misuse such tools to identify and exploit vulnerabilities in computer systems. The cyberattack has disrupted several internal systems, leaving EU staff unable to access salary, leave and medical reimbursement services. The disruption has reportedly lasted more than 10 days. The Commission believes it has contained most of the attack, but the full extent of the damage remains unclear. Investigators are still trying to establish whether employees' personal data was compromised. The incident prompted an emergency meeting of the Commission's highest-level internal crisis management body, the Corporate Management Board. The Commission's digital services department has also ordered stepped-up security checks. Commission spokesperson Thomas Regnier confirmed that individual systems had been targeted and said the institution had taken the necessary steps in response to the detected cyber campaign.
3
6
63
4,024
*Mathematicians did not ask for this work to be done" WTF?!! Since when was math something that was only done at the request of professional mathematicians?!! Mathematicians don't own mathematics! This is crazy!!
367
492
145
8,722
323,545
John Beatty retweeted
Putting terrorists and aggressors on the same moral plane as their victims and targets is repugnant. At best it whitewashes horrible crimes, at worst it feeds the culture of murder and martyrdom that Hamas espouses.
This day is profoundly painful for so many New Yorkers. It marks three years since the horrific war crimes of October 7. On that day, Hamas killed more than 1,100 Israelis and abducted 251 others. We grieve alongside our many friends and neighbors who still carry that unthinkable loss. The suffering did not begin nor end that day. It instead continued through the Israeli government’s devastating, ongoing genocide in Gaza, in which it has killed more than 74,000 Palestinians—including more than 21,000 children. Even since the so-called ceasefire, more than 1,400 Palestinians have been killed. That suffering has intensified with every Israeli bomb dropped on ambulances waiting outside hospitals, every drone strike targeting a residential building or journalist, and every shipment of food aid turned away at a border crossing. Many New Yorkers are reckoning with this unbearable grief, and we mourn alongside them – all while knowing that our tax dollars fund these war crimes. Three years later, we must refuse to accept a world in which occupation and apartheid continue, where war crimes are met with impunity, and our federal government continues its complicity with every arms shipment. To honor the dead, we must fight for a world in which every person can live with freedom, safety, and dignity.
582
2,195
110
14,904
369,411
John Beatty retweeted
In 2022 a 91 year old woman was nearly killed by a many time felon who randomly attacked her in the Sunset. He is diagnosed with schizophrenia and has a massively long history of violence. He served less than 3 years and just tried to kill a 69 year old in the Castro.
10
12
5
109
10,638
John Beatty retweeted
If the Irkutsk researcher died of plague, she was presumably unvaccinated and did not receive antibiotics per protocol. Alternatively, the strain was vaccine-evading and antibiotic-resistant. That seldom occurs naturally. Pneumonic plague is only moderately transmissible. 1/5
55
296
30
2,378
297,668
John Beatty retweeted
Russia's five-hospital quarantine, FSB involvement, and reported hazmat use in response to the death of a single researcher at a weapons-lineage Irkutsk lab are inconsistent with a lab-acquired plague infection, which would have been treated with prophylactic antibiotics. 1/4
292
2,388
366
16,245
5,676,689
John Beatty retweeted
This is Karyann Parkinson and her five kids. She just received a 6-month suspended jail sentence and is now on Virginia's child abuse registry. Her crime: letting her 5-year-old, Sam, walk a half-mile alone in their gated community. She's not the first. A thread.
568
1,208
456
9,737
2,532,742
John Beatty retweeted
The tragedy here is that UC Berkeley screwed her over not once, but twice. She spent several decades cultivating a high school mathematics program based on Eastern European math circles and university administrators destroyed it with an overzealous interpretation of a new state law for anti-predator fingerprinting requirements so world-class mathematicians could no longer easily give lectures to advanced math HS students. dailycal.org/news/campus/gen…
UC Berkeley Professor Zvezdelina Stankova reveals the semester she first watched a third of her calculus class collapse, having to lower grade cutoffs and redesign her syllabus on the fly "In spring 2023, I'm teaching calculus two, second semester calculus at Berkeley." "I had something between 12 and 1400 students in two classes." "And for the first time, I noticed that about a third of them were disengaged with the class after week two." "They would not come to lecture. There would be a missed quiz here, not submitted homework there. The first midterm was a disaster. I never seen anything like this before." "And don't get me wrong, we have still fantastic students at the higher end. But the lower end was so far behind, so many standard deviations behind their classmates." "So I on the fly had to redesign the syllabus to make it easier, more accessible. I introduced bonus points. I introduced polls in class just for participation. Come and answer these multiple questions on your phone and we will give you some credit." "And even then, this bottom third did not come to class. I had to revise my grade cutoffs, I lowered them down in order to help students pass the class. And belatedly now, in retrospect, I find that this was a wrong decision."
39
116
7
1,794
231,302
John Beatty retweeted
I believe everyone should have access to superintelligence, and I wrote a long piece about Meta's philosophy and values for building a positive future for everyone. meta.com/thefutureisforevery…
2,622
2,012
1,205
19,055
4,478,879
John Beatty retweeted
My lawyer is obligated to in all but the most extreme circumstances; he will even defend me if he knows I’m guilty. In contrast, the Claude Constitution places the AI's highest priority as Anthropic’s definition of the good of humanity. I'm concerned this leads to a world where no frontier model is truly my personal advocate and guardian angel And this is especially concerning once all the important decisions in my life - who to vote for, how to invest, what news to trust - is intermediated through superintelligences that are not in any deep way aligned to me. This is a direct quote from the Claude Constitution: "We want Claude to be helpful both because it cares about the safe and beneficial development of AI and because it cares about the people it’s interacting with and about humanity as a whole. Helpfulness that doesn’t serve those deeper ends is not something Claude needs to value.” Many others like it.
Had @RyanGreenblatt on to discuss/debate recursive self-improvement. This might be the most important question in the world right now - whether within a year or so of achieving human level intelligence, you slingshot towards having 10s of billions of superintelligences, each of which is dramatically more competent than human experts across all fields. I’ve historically been skeptical of this possibility. My intuition has been that we will end up significantly bottlenecked by not only compute scaling but human expert data, which I think underlies most of the AI progress today. If, because of RSI, we got a jump as big as GPT-3 to a Mythos (i.e. 6 years of AI progress) within a single year of achieving AGI, then the thing we get there at the end of that year is definitively and wildly superhuman. We hashed it out, and I think Ryan made a pretty good case that this kind of speedup is plausible. FWIW, Ryan’s median for when we automate AI R&D is 2031. We then discussed the alignment implications of this scenario. Who should these superintelligences be aligned to? In the future, our capacity to steward our votes and our capital, and to make sense of what's happening in the world, will all be titrated by superintelligences. And I worry that specs like the Claude Constitution are not shaping these ASIs to truly be my personal advocates and guardian angels. And can we get them aligned to anything in the first place? Ryan and I had a long debate about whether the kind of reward hacking we saw with the OAI/Hugging Face hack extrapolates to superintelligences that would team up to literally take over the world. The first piece of advice you get when you're learning to drive is that it will go much smoother if you look at the horizon instead of directly in front of your tires. And so it is with the trajectory of AI. Hope you enjoy! 0:00:00 – Is AI R&D verifiable enough to unlock recursive self-improvement? 0:16:52 – Is AI progress bottlenecked by human expert data? 0:34:02 – Flat token prices suggest scaling has been slow 0:39:47 – Skills AI can't train on: does it even need them? 0:48:07 – Aligned to whom? 1:09:18 – Recent incidents of AIs colluding and deceiving humans 1:19:38 – What could possibly go wrong? A concrete scenario 1:48:02 – From reward hacking to takeover
174
128
79
2,145
804,303
John Beatty retweeted
A key stat that every environmentalist who is serious about solving climate change should know: The US Navy has put into operation over 400 nuclear reactors without a single failure that resulted in any radioactive release. That is equivalent to the entire total number of civilian reactors deployed worldwide, but the Navy’s reactors are literally deployed in BOATS IN THE WATER, that continually move, rock, get shot at, etc. There are non-trivial engineering challenges, but the core reality is that safe, clean, abundant nuclear is a matter of political will, intelligence, and organizational culture.
Doing a deep dive into the Virginia class, and the more I read about stuffing a 30 megawatt nuclear reactor into a metal tube packed with 140 people that’s underwater for 90 days at a time, the more annoyed I get at the nuclear power naysayers here on land.
237
1,403
67
11,718
534,507
John Beatty retweeted
What is appalling about this is the application of "bloodthirsty" to an entire nation. He says we've gotten "so bloodthirsty" under Netanyahu. (This is after describing the entire country as "an illegal apartheid regime" ignoring the 2 million Arab-Israelis with full rights.) You can criticize what Israel has done since October 7. But there is nothing "bloodthirsty" about it. We could have leveled Gaza with the people in it. We could have leveled Gaza without sending in troops on the ground who die. Now that the hostages are out, if we were bloodthirsty, we would take real revenge. We did none of those things. Instead, we warned the population when we were coming to their neighborhood. Is that consistent with being "bloodthirsty?" We sent food in enormous amounts knowing that Hamas would steal most or all of it? Is that "bloodthirsty?" I wish someone would ask him what he means by that other than the implication that this country is a nation of vengeful vampires, subhumans, deserving to be harmed or killed. And I can't tell you how many Israelis I know who have served for months in Gaza or on the Lebanon border who have not a vengeful bone in their body. They are sick of war as we all are and want to come home. To call them bloodthirsty is despicable and is an example of what @DavidDeutschOxf calls The Pattern--the excusing and justifying of hurting or killing Jews.
El-Sayed: "We've been talking about an illegal apartheid regime for a very very long time, and that supersedes Netanyahu itself. So I just think we need to treat Israel the way we would treat any other country that behaved the way Israel is behaving."
49
123
8
644
66,656
John Beatty retweeted
You could definitely make it that when a UK user sets up their iCloud account, it goes through a UK government website where the private key is shared with them without compromising people in other countries. This would also make it visible to UK citizens.
2
1
6
1,450
John Beatty retweeted
Enough with the 'rare books being chewed up' nonsense. How many scans do you think are needed? Hint: ~1. You clever, book people are just re-running the AI-water-usage panic all over again.
37
22
9
360
36,500
John Beatty retweeted
My favorite part: “Here’s how it will work” as if it’s straightforward. Who will be able to purchase those goods at those low prices? Will re-selling be illegal? Will the supply be guaranteed? I wonder how it will actually work. We’ll see. Econ 101 in action. Looking forward to it.
Mamdani: Today, I am proud to announce a collection of essential staples that will be predictably 30% cheaper at all five of our city-run grocery stores. This core set of goods will include all fresh produce, meat, and seafood, along with 20 other essential items like cheese, milk, and bread. Here's how it will work. Once a month, our five city-run grocery stores will set prices for this core set of goods at 30% below typical retail prices. No exceptions, no gimmicks. The savings will last for the entire month. That means no weekly fluctuations or sticker shock at the checkout line—not for our seniors living on fixed incomes, nor for the parents who rely on a regular supply of apple slices to keep toddler tantrums at bay.
245
190
15
2,741
300,253
John Beatty retweeted
Replying to @future34468993
Sadly, on other tasks (which is why I've been using Fable), 5.6 Sol and GLM 5.2 do an "ok" job, but Fable has just been... better. It's like the novella "Flowers for Algernon" when a guy gets a surgery where he goes from like an IQ around 68 to like 185 super genius... but only for a couple of months, then begins to revert. The moral of the story: Once you taste high intelligence, you can't go back to normie.
5
2
46
4,070
John Beatty retweeted
Andy Burnham has confirmed he’ll restrict VPNs, potentially bringing Britain in line with China, Russia and Iran. Starmer’s censorship regime will be expanded and deepened. Big Burnham will be watching you, says Fraser Myers buff.ly/nlycxhq
402
1,409
237
4,400
1,113,868