David Saussy (@lermiteVIIII) header
David Saussy (@lermiteVIIII) profile picture

music, drawing, Plato

Joined April 2025
Photo by David Saussy (@lermiteVIIII)Photo by David Saussy (@lermiteVIIII)Photo by David Saussy (@lermiteVIIII)Photo by David Saussy (@lermiteVIIII)Photo by David Saussy (@lermiteVIIII)Photo by David Saussy (@lermiteVIIII)Photo by David Saussy (@lermiteVIIII)Photo by David Saussy (@lermiteVIIII)Photo by David Saussy (@lermiteVIIII)Photo by David Saussy (@lermiteVIIII)
a more accurate rendering…
what it feels like to read Plato…
1
13
2,531
It has been hard to “unsee” this: “It is through the garb of ideas that we take for true being what is actually a method…” Full paragraph: “Mathematics and mathematical science, as a garb of ideas, or the garb of symbols of the symbolic mathematical theories, encompasses everything which, for scientists and the educated generally, represents the life-world, dresses it up as “objectively actual and true” nature. It is through the garb of ideas that we take for true being what is actually a method—a method which is designed for the purpose of progressively improving, in infinitum, through “scientific” predictions, those rough predictions which are the only ones originally possible within the sphere of what is actually experienced and experienceable in the life-world. It is because of the disguise of ideas that the true meaning of the method, the formulae, the “theories,” remained unintelligible and, in the naïve formation of the method, was never understood.” P51-52 David Carr translation of Husserl’s “Crisis of European Sciences”
1
1
4
154
This seems right. But it also seems to me that AI is - or should be regarded as - an occasion for serious thought. Because *its* problems are the problems of modern rationalism as a whole. It is not "AI" we should be thinking about, but AI as the latest iteration or the effects of modern rationalism. The problems are the problems, yet the dazzling successes of modern rationalism somehow bewitches us into thinking they are not. One of more pressing fundamental problems AI raises is stated by Hamilton in the opening of Federalist #1.
Yes. One good response to AI is not letting it steal all the oxygen.
1
47
Listening to Beethoven's complete quartets over the past year (starting in January 2026), just last week I had the strangest experience. I think I've been listening to classical music in the wrong way! What I mean is this: I realized (while actively listening to Bach Violin Partitas without a score) that I have a habit of forcing the music into boxes or frames - into static structures. I have no idea where this came from. I've played music my whole life - but maybe reading musical scores? Tonal harmonic analysis? Maybe because I was also classically trained fine artist and "see" music? I was thinking about the medieval 'nunc stans' and the 'flowing now', the difference between listening with and without reading notation, as well as the principle I realized in the beginning of the year that *feeling* follows *noticing* in this art form, that is, the more you notice, the more you can feel. And there it was, so to speak, as plain as day. This strange habit I've been imposing on the music. I haven't been letting the musical event itself *lead* but have approached it with all sort of hidden expectations - especially static expectations of a kind. The great Simon Fischer advised young violinists to 'hang your ears' on each tone - develop a close, finely grained perception of the tone quality. I've been thinking about that since my poor habit of listening became apparent to me last week. As a listener, I've started hanging my ears on the musical event, as it unfolds each moment - and, what a rush! I'm working less at listening, giving my attention more completely to the moment, and getting more out of it, more than I ever imagined was possible. (What the "moment" is, is rather a mystery to me. It's not what I thought - not forced like single-point concetration, say, in Buddhist meditation.). One can still hear phrases, modulations, voices, themes and variations, etc but the higher order perception and appreciation of the overall event comes into presence quickly - I think because I'm not putting the cart before the horse. So this is what Western art music is supposed to sound like! The experience of listening to music has started changing how I read printed page in books (reading Jane Eyre with my oldest, and re-reading others). I think I've been reading incorrectly or inadequately all along too...
Over the whole of 2026, I’ll be listening to the complete Beethoven string quartets. I’ve organized my plan chronologically by composition, which will let me follow  Beethoven’s unfolding conception. The quartets divide naturally into three periods. My plan is to  listen to each quartet once per week with each of the three recordings below—giving me three weeks per quartet. I’m also following along with a score as I listen.  For Western art music of this kind, it is my conviction that the more you *hear* or can perceive, the more you feel. It’s simply not true that reflection and understanding kills the experience. To develop the ears to hear: Listen with a score in hand, listen to different performances by different groups, and “re-listen” to the same work on multiple occasions. Recordings: 1. Emerson String Quartet (DG, 1997) 1. Takács Quartet (Decca, 2004) 1. Budapest String Quartet (Columbia/Sony, 1951–52) Schedule: One quartet per three weeks, one recording per week EARLY QUARTETS Weeks 1–3 (Jan 6–26): Op. 18 No. 1 in F major Weeks 4–6 (Jan 27–Feb 16): Op. 18 No. 2 in G major Weeks 7–9 (Feb 17–Mar 9): Op. 18 No. 3 in D major Weeks 10–12 (Mar 10–30): Op. 18 No. 4 in C minor Weeks 13–15 (Mar 31–Apr 20): Op. 18 No. 5 in A major Weeks 16–18 (Apr 21–May 11): Op. 18 No. 6 in B-flat major MIDDLE QUARTETS Weeks 19–21 (May 12–Jun 1): Op. 59 No. 1 in F major (“Razumovsky”) Weeks 22–24 (Jun 2–22): Op. 59 No. 2 in E minor Weeks 25–27 (Jun 23–Jul 13): Op. 59 No. 3 in C major Weeks 28–30 (Jul 14–Aug 3): Op. 74 in E-flat major (“Harp”) Weeks 31–33 (Aug 4–24): Op. 95 in F minor (“Serioso”) LATE QUARTETS Weeks 34–36 (Aug 25–Sep 14): Op. 127 in E-flat major Weeks 37–39 (Sep 15–Oct 5): Op. 132 in A minor Weeks 40–42 (Oct 6–26): Op. 130 in B-flat major Weeks 43–45 (Oct 27–Nov 16): Op. 133 (“Grosse Fuge”) Weeks 46–48 (Nov 17–Dec 7): Op. 131 in C-sharp minor Weeks 49–51 (Dec 8–28): Op. 135 in F major
1
5
185
feeling #13 and 14 lately
Italo Calvino's 14 principles for defining a classic.
1
46
Claude Shannon - was Anthropic’s “Claude” named after Claude Shannon?The paper mentioned below is surely one of the primary sources, to be read with Firth and Harris, for a discerning understanding of the technology.
Reading Claude Shannon’s paper “A Mathematical Theory of Communication” (1948) - although there is not a hint in this direction in the paper itself - leads one to recollect the curious way in which the origin of the Greek word “logos” — in “leg-“ — the more primary sense is “gather” or “pick out one by one” or “count”. The act of saying, or of putting things into words, and the act of counting off are distinct but not separate acts. By long habit and training they’ve grown estranged from each other. The mathematicization of language presupposed by LLM challenges this centuries old habit - points back to the ancient Greek.
1
2
97
A gem
The St. John's Review is back! The Review dates to 1974 and is published three times per year by the Office of the Dean. It is led by tutor @zenahitz, and the latest edition includes pieces from Robert Abbott, Louis Petrich, and the late Scott Buchanan. stjohnsreview.org/
1
7
349
Reading Claude Shannon’s paper “A Mathematical Theory of Communication” (1948) - although there is not a hint in this direction in the paper itself - leads one to recollect the curious way in which the origin of the Greek word “logos” — in “leg-“ — the more primary sense is “gather” or “pick out one by one” or “count”. The act of saying, or of putting things into words, and the act of counting off are distinct but not separate acts. By long habit and training they’ve grown estranged from each other. The mathematicization of language presupposed by LLM challenges this centuries old habit - points back to the ancient Greek.
1
1
2
157
David Saussy retweeted
You don't know you're interested in multiplication and need to think about it, but YOU ARE and YOU DO stjohnsreview.org/home/multi…
3
7
2
25
4,095
Given these conditions, there is only *one* book Emile is allowed to read, and only in adolescence: “Robinson Crusoe” by Daniel Defoe. No reading list of great or even good books.
What might a serious education look like for a capable youth? What if, in fact, you paired the best possible tutor with the most apt nature from early on and throughout the child's rearing? Rousseau's Emile
2
164
I enjoyed the article. I just love how Pride and Prejudice displays the range of total human boorishness and cringe with its opposite, when it comes to the problem of picking a suitable partner for marriage. We can get it soooo very wrong; our “pickers” are in poor shape or are broken. I think reading the book could help develop better “pickers”…?
For all you Pride and Prejudice fans out there, I hope you will enjoy my first Substack post on how Jane Austen understood the purpose of marriage. I also wrote it with the idea of hooking those who have not yet caught the incurable Austen fever. jamesbryson44.substack.com/p…
1
1
3
181
An interesting thread. One difficulty I have is the assumption (either Wittgenstein’s or Left Nietzschean’s) that the word “consciousness” is a “perfectly ordinary word we use in everyday.” This position overlooks the phenomenon that large numbers of technical words have drifted over time into the ordinary everyday usage - the technical origins of such terms have been stripped away, forgotten, and leaving behind a meaning that is taken for granted as an obvious fact…at least in terms of *what* is being named. Consciousness is one of those words.
From a Wittgensteinian perspective the AI consciousness debate is a philosophical nadir for culture. Virtually everything said about AI consciousness represents what Wittgenstein called the metaphysical use of language: words acting like an idling engine, doing no real work. 1/11
1
1
8
732
As an experiment, try putting out of play two casual words in your vocabulary: “consciousness” and “experience” (as in “I am having an experience” or “that is a good experience” or “in my experience”) and then try to regard the same matter using other words. In place of “consciousness” try “attention” or “perception”. Maybe “awareness.” (But what is awareness if not attention and perception?) Try restricting the use of “experience” to mean only what comes into being in the mind as a result of having many memories of the same affair or event.
3
79
I appreciate the sentiment, but the difficulty here is that algorithms were invented by human beings, and have been part of a centuries long project of modern rationalism. LLMs have been and are a human project, the result of human artfulness. Restore the full meaning of art, techne. Then we can face the problem.
In this era of artificial intelligence, it is becoming urgent to distinguish human art from what machines produce. There is an ontological difference, even before an aesthetic one, between art and what a machine can generate through statistical calculation based on millions of images created by others. Algorithms lack the spark of humanity. For this reason, the Church wishes to renew an alliance with artists and cultural institutions to safeguard our humanity.
1
100