Indonesian academia, including the higher education ministry, must read this.
There’s pressure across academia: “Publish in Q1 and Q2 journals - anything less is not good enough.”
It’s a familiar mantra in many institutions. But it’s worth asking whether this expectation genuinely serves scholarship?
Here’s why you should not just focus on Q1 and Q2 journals.
1. Quartiles are not a measure of quality - only of journal-level performance.
A Q1 journal can publish weak papers. A Q3 journal can publish groundbreaking ones. Quartiles reflect citation distributions, not journal/article quality. Treating quartiles as a proxy for quality oversimplifies the complexity of research evaluation.
2. “Best fit” often matters more than “best quartile.”
A highly specialised paper may have its natural home in a niche journal that sits outside Q1/Q2. Forcing it into a top-tier venue can dilute its relevance, slow down publication, or push it into journals that are not read by the scholars that should be reading your article.
3. Impact comes from usefulness, not quartile labels.
A paper can transform industry practice or shape local policy, but appear in a Q3 or Q4 journal, or even one that is not indexed. Real-world impact rarely aligns neatly with journal-level metrics.
4. Over-emphasis on quartiles can distort behaviour.
It can encourage scholars to chase metrics instead of questions that genuinely matter. It can push early-career researchers into risk-averse strategies, narrowing creativity and discouraging interdisciplinary work that doesn’t fit the traditional mould.
5. It creates inequities - globally and institutionally.
Not all disciplines have the same availability of Q1/Q2 journals. Not all countries or universities have the same access or resources. The expectation of “Q1 or nothing” often disadvantages scholars working in emerging fields or developing regions.
For an alternative view, see: nitter.cf/fake_journals/status/1…
218
Ternyata negara kita sudah menjadi anggota NATO...
linkedin.com/pulse/indonesia…
124
Miftahul Ilmi retweeted
From doubters to believers… 🫶
#DankeJürgen
Miftahul Ilmi retweeted
How hard is it to do science in a language that’s not your first language? We quantified the severity of #languagebarriers for non-native English speakers when reading/publishing papers and attending/presenting at international conferences.
doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio…
1/9
Miftahul Ilmi retweeted
Ketika semua orang berpikir bahwa hasilnya akan berakhir imbang.
Namun keangkeran Anfield terus berlanjut, kali ini Tottenham Hotspur korbannya.
One of the best atmosphere & stadium in the world, This is Anfield!🙌🔥
Setelah MDPI, sekarang giliran Frontiers...
predatoryreports.org/news/f/…
211
It is been a while since I posted here. Just wanna tell everyone that I will be more active here: @mifilmi@mstdn.id – at Banguntapan, Indonesia
1
166
Do you remember when you joined Twitter? I do! #MyTwitterAnniversary – at Mlati, Indonesia
374
Guest dan gift autorship merupakan pelanggaran etika yang "normal" di Endonesiah, dan sering dialami peneliti junior. Mental "pekewuh" mungkin salah satu penyebabnya. #literasihayati laboratoryequipment.com/5939… – at Banguntapan, Indonesia
128
Halo @PemkotJogja @JogjaPemkot, mengapa parkir di timur Taman Pintar dipalang oleh jukir setempat seperti ini? Mau parkir di situ malah diarahkan ke sebelah timur Taman Budaya yang tarifnya 2x lipat. Mohon ditertibkan... @JogjaUpdate – at Gondomanan, Indonesia
3
406
Miftahul Ilmi retweeted
Yakk! dhass dhess Dab!
Rebo Pahing memanggil, semua jenis sepeda boleh turut serta.
Miftahul Ilmi retweeted
➡Gecko is an open source tool to help you find the most relevant papers to your research and give you a more complete sense of the research landscape.
🔗citationgecko.azurewebsites.…
#Bioinformatics #neuroscience #RStats #AcademicTwitter #postdoc #OpenAccess #bibliometrics #SNA





















