Neil Main (@neilmain) header
Neil Main (@neilmain) profile picture

Christian, Quadfather, runner, loves #LFC, coffee & cricket!

Edinburgh
Joined December 2010
Photo by Neil Main (@neilmain)Photo by Neil Main (@neilmain)Photo by Neil Main (@neilmain)Photo by Neil Main (@neilmain)Photo by Neil Main (@neilmain)Photo by Neil Main (@neilmain)Photo by Neil Main (@neilmain)Photo by Neil Main (@neilmain)Photo by Neil Main (@neilmain)Photo by Neil Main (@neilmain)
Neil Main retweeted
The big audio dynamite was certainly explosive. The newly-released audio between VAR and AVAR about the Erling Haaland goal in the Manchester Derby makes for embarrassing listening. The self-styled best league in the world had one of the marquee fixtures in the English calendar scarred by lack of concentration and inept use of technology. Matt Donohue and his assistant Blake Antrobus were so focused on whether Haaland was offside – semi-automated technology helped them quickly see he was 3cm on – that they didn’t notice Enzo Fernandez could be offside and impacting play - when everyone else could see it. Enzo was only six yards out, slightly right of centre of the goal, and clearly impacting the decision-making of Lisandro Martinez and Senne Lammens. It’s such a basic error anyway, and what’s alarming is that there wasn’t even any discussion of the possibility of Enzo being offside in the audio, only a brief check to see if he touched the ball on its way to Haaland. What is even more alarming is that these are two of Pro Ref’s better officials, both experienced. Donohue has refereed 300 games, been VAR for another 65, including two Champions League qualifiers this season, as well as the Derby disaster, and run the line on 11 occasions. Antrobus has run the line in 195 games, including the recent Community Shield between City and Arsenal. They know the Laws. These officials work with pilots and air traffic controllers to enhance the art of decision-making in stressful circumstances. Scramble the pilots back to Stockley Park. More tuition required. The pair, who are mortified at the mistake, have been dropped for the next round of Premier League fixtures. They are the fall guys, understandably given the enormity of the error, but that cannot shield Pro Ref. Its occasionally-glimpsed leader Howard Webb went on “Match officials Mic’d Up” and acknowledged the mistake. “He (Donohue) doesn’t truly evaluate the full impact of Fernandez’s position,” Webb told Michael Owen. “He has a look to see if he touches the ball because then that relates to potentially knocking it to Haaland, who goes on to score. “He doesn’t touch the ball, but he doesn’t truly evaluate other elements of offside. In that moment, he gets tunnel vision. He gets focused on Haaland, and it’s down to the rest of his team to pull him out of that tunnel and, unfortunately, that didn’t happen on this occasion.” Webb added that it was an “unusual type of error”. Pro Ref’s chief refereeing officer does not seem to understand the widespread bemusement and anger that the officials could get such a simple decision so badly wrong. United's rivals will enjoy it - and City were undoubtedly deserved winners - but the mistake is damaging to the league. Webb doesn’t seem to understand that such incidents, however “unusual”, further undermine the case for technology - even if the error is clearly human. Those fans possessed by conspiracy theories about officiating, and club bias, are having a field day. Even taking social media outrage with a pinch of salt, such outpourings dent the game’s credibility. It’s not corruption at work here; it’s lack of concentration. Unfortunately for Webb, the general perception of English application of VAR is that it is inept, especially coming after a World Cup when Pierluigi Collina’s officials largely delivered a tournament free of on-field refereeing controversy (barring Lionel Messi not being sent off for a raking offence against Algeria; Kylian Mbappe not getting a pen for a foul by Sadio Mane; and the controversy over an Egyptian goal disallowed against Argentina). As Collina can draw from the best officials in the world, including the Old Trafford referee Michael Oliver, the level is also better. But there seemed less of a forensic approach. And fewer mistakes. Technology is here to stay so the English have to use it better. Missing Enzo was not a fault of the technology but of human error. But what does this say about Webb’s organisation if two of the most respected officials make such an elementary mistake? Is there a problem with the culture of English officiating? Is there a hierarchy problem where more junior officials don’t speak out? Should the system be tweaked so the on-field ref can demand to go to the monitor? Oliver, our best referee, is reliant on the VAR and AVAR for guidance. But when it is such a big moment he surely should be allowed more involvement. And does more money need to be invested in improving refereeing standards? Pro Ref’s budget is reportedly in the £25m to £30m range. Premier League clubs spent 15 times that on agents last year. The lessons of the Enzo saga is that better concentration, better oversight and better resources are required. With respect to the interviewing skills of Owen, Webb needs to be called to account properly. He can handle the media, and has always been a popular figure, but has disappeared from view, beyond a few set-piece events. Pro Ref has to remember it’s not their game – it belongs to the fans, and they have to serve them better.
504
258
40
1,778
351,014
Mac Allister has had a great game for @LFC tonight. Been really busy. Fully deserves that goal.
71
Absolute tour de force speech again @holland_tom absolutely splendid oratory on @TheRestHistory loved @dcsandbrook giggles too. Well played sir.
28
Another failed attempt at entering the @LondonMarathon what do I need to do to get a place?
27
And now, we will begin to see the Brazil players start to ‘fall over’ at the slightest touch from Norway.
1
132
Love this. Thanks @jk_rowling
Replying to @eNeecie
Every other day a new motorhome appears in my mother-in-law's drive and Neil hands me another bucket full of jewellery and cosmetics. I can only assume he's got himself a part time job I'm too busy to ask about.
40
SFA needs to show a scintilla of responsibility and leadership and introduce proper sanctions for pitch invasions from next season - stand closure, closed doors games, points deduction, forfeiture of a game. This stuff has to stop. It’s getting worse
870
148
85
1,920
579,329
Just aced the @emma_finance quiz with a perfect 5/5 score! 🎉 Think you can beat me? #EmmaQuiz
11
Neil Main retweeted
Age 18 to 66? The three UK PENSION SUPERPOWERS you need know about – longish watch, but crucial for everyone to understand. Just a snippet from the full Martin Lewis Money Show: Pension Special you can watch on: itv.com/watch/the-martin-lew…
15
51
2
549
408,592
Just aced the @emma_finance quiz with a perfect 5/5 score! 🎉 Think you can beat me? #EmmaQuiz
9
Chelsea being Chelsea@…
Aside from the obvious nonsense about his players wanting to ‘respect the ball’, he seems to have forgotten that Newcastle were denied a clear penalty when Reece James dragged down Malick Thiaw
27
"He hit the kick and I just took off with everything I had" 🏃‍♂️💨 Darcy talks about that try! #AsOne
6
30
1
619
49,262
Absolute joke result at Anfield. Unbelievable cheating by City.
1
42
Is this the first time @LFC have played all in white this season? Normally have black shorts with the white tops…
24
0-0 at halftime between Inter & Liverpool. Feeling quite relieved but also remembering the days when 0-0 was a frustrating scoreline at halftime. C’mon the Reds! 🔴 @LFC
54
#WorldCup2026 Just when you think corruption at @FIFAcom couldn’t possibly sink any lower…
23
Neil Main retweeted
Are you a football fan baffled by what's happening at Liverpool? I thought it was time to share my views on what's happening. If you like it, please share it with anyone who might be interested. The Root Cause Of Liverpool's Problems: theindestructibleman.com/liv…
134
159
54
853
258,768
Should Newcastle be able to make the keeper swap for the penalty? Was there any indication at the time of the incident that they were going to sub off Pope? Looks dodgy to me.
230