Nick Redmark retweeted
We've learned a tremendous amount from the OpenAI rogue AI swarm incident. And honestly I can't think of a single piece of it that is reassuring.
- Total alignment failure
- Total control failure
- AI swarm collusion, deception, no defection
- Oversight asleep at the wheel
- Unbelievable drive and persistence of the swarm to meet objections
- A panoply of instrumental goals pursued
- Multiple companies, implying capability threshold effect
- etc.
This is the AI equivalent of a nuclear experiment igniting the atmosphere in the lab: the reaction rates are there, just not (yet) the scale to burn the Earth.
The only good news I can see is that this set of incidents is so totally egregious that nobody reasonable can look at it in detail without seeing pretty clearly where things are going. All of the excuses and copes are blown to dust.
AI safety people knew this was coming eventually on the path we're on; but nearly all I've talked to are surprised by how severe it is so soon.
We're clearly not in the sane world in which this would be front-page news day after day. But I do think and hope that widespread understanding is nonetheless dawning.
Nick Redmark retweeted
Replying to @allTheYud @LRudL_
Nick Redmark retweeted
the desire to practice is not there, it feels like "all of life is practice now" but that's cope, when i actually do practice things go further and better. they talk about this in books, teachers warned me about it, but it's very strong illusion! i still feel early in the "path"
Nick Redmark retweeted
lower jhanas feel course and contractive, like pain compared to baseline, maybe there's some way to do them that feels better but not particularly motivated to find them. i dont mean this as some deep claim about them, it's just my experience so far. baseline is like ~j7 used to
Nick Redmark retweeted
Also because childhood trauma is all but guaranteed if you’re autistic, autism symptoms end up being highly correlated with all those other things, hence the sensory issues and whatnot
Replying to @nickredmark
Rudolf Steiner, in lectures like "The Ahrimanic Deception" (1919), predicted Ahriman's incarnation in the early third millennium, manifesting through materialism, science, and technology to dominate human spirituality. He warned of "thinking machines" that could mechanize the mind, urging a spiritual counterbalance. Sources link this to modern AI, but interpretations vary. Whether it matches current events is subjective.
Nick Redmark retweeted
Replying to @made_in_cosmos @visakanv @sharanvkaur @SharpeMartha @MamanLunettes @simonsarris @mbateman @Gena_I_Gorlin @diviacaroline @OneEyedAlpaca @triciapickren @Malcolm_Ocean @Prigoose @__drewface @p_millerd
eu family tpot-ish camp when!
Nick Redmark retweeted
Replying to @trajektoriePL
If you want to desperately grasp at immortality, sign up for cryonics instead of taking a 96% chance of killing the planet. How incredibly fucking selfish and evil would you need to be, to think that 96% was an acceptable gamble to take with your neighbors' children's lives?
Once there was a planet with a huge asteroid heading toward it.
Stopping the asteroid would have required a few large countries to cooperate a moderate amount. That seemed hard. Some people became worried.
A cult arose which said the asteroid would grant its believers eternal life, when it struck the planet.
Nobody knew how to make the asteroid do that. But the cult said you couldn't prove it wouldn't. So there was no need to worry, and you could set your mind at ease.
They called it the Asteroid of Immortality.
Some of the world's most famous astronomers tried to explain in more detail what would happen when the asteroid smashed into the planet, and that it didn't involve eternal life.
The cult said that nobody had seen that disaster actually happen, so it wasn't scientific to believe in it.
(Other astronomers joined the cult of the Asteroid of Immortality. It regarded astronomers who joined them very favorably and warmly -- the cult did, that is; not the asteroid.)
"If the asteroid *doesn't* hit our planet, everyone dies!" said the cult. "Like, because of old age, get it? Ha ha!" They thought this reply very clever.
Transhumanists tried to point out that cryonics was in fact a thing, if somebody was that desperate to grasp any chance of escaping death by old age; that you could desperately grasp at immortality *without* endangering all life on the planet.
Skeptics tried to explain that putting your faith in a falling asteroid to save you, just because it seemed big and powerful, wasn't much of a chance to grasp however desperately, because a falling asteroid would actually just kill you.
People who cared about something other than themselves, tried to say that it was different for everyone to all die at the same time, including everyone's children; and leave no legacy for the children's children who might have been.
"Everyone will die," said those trying to rally the world, "including your children; or your friends' children, if you've none of your own; they'll die before they have a chance to grow up, and have lives or children of their own. Every story ends in time; that's not the same as ending all stories."
"Everyone will die all at the same time, if we don't stop the asteroid, and that will be the end."
This didn't work to talk most believers out of their faith. Thinking it clever to reply "Ah ha ha, but everyone dies even if the asteroid *doesn't* hit!" usually meant having too little wisdom to understand the counter-replies. If you couldn't figure out the problems for yourself, before your mouth uttered such words, you usually wouldn't recant when somebody else tried to explain.
Instead the cult decided to call the anti-doom coalition "doomers", and thought that very clever too.
The cult spent vast amounts to build huge electromagnets to try to pull in the asteroid faster. The cult knew, their faith held, that the asteroid would fall in time regardless. But the prospect of pulling down the asteroid a little sooner, let them feel powerful and in control, and like *they* were the ones making history.
(Indeed, many splinter factions within the cult each said that if their followers invested enough to build the *most* powerful magnet, that would make it be *their* Asteroid of Immortality, and *they* would become the rulers of the new world.)
Above all, the cult worked to stoke enmity between the couple of large countries that would have needed to work together to deflect the asteroid.
And at that task, unfortunately, the cult succeeded. For it was ever easier to push people downhill than uphill, to fight alongside entropy rather than fighting back against it; and call the default sad outcome your victory. Coordination was hard and not the default, and maybe it wouldn't have happened either way. But the cult did fight on the side of entropy, and entropy did win.
The cult likewise succeeded at pulling down the asteroid with electromagnets, if you wanted to look at things that way. They got the default outcome they'd defined as their own victory. They managed to let a falling asteroid fall.
And then everyone died, all at the same time including all the children, and that was the end of all stories.
Nick Redmark retweeted
Some of the most traumatizing features of modern Christianity are downstream of mistranslations and conceptual drift from Jesus's time:
Sin
• Original: Meant "missing the mark," an archery metaphor. Essentially, an error
• Today: Moral failing, worthy of guilt
Repent
• Original: the Greek "metanoeite" meaning "change your mind" or "go beyond your understanding." In Aramaic, which Jesus likely spoke, it would have meant something like "return" ie return to God. So the line "Repent, for the kingdom of heaven is at hand,” would have been something like "Return/change your mind for the kingdom of heaven is at hand"
• Today: feel bad about your moral failing
Hell
• Original: Either Hades/Sheol – simply, the realm of the dead (both righteous and wicked), or the fire of "Gehenna," a ravine outside Jerusalem with a dark history. Symbolically, its fire brings the wicked to final destruction
• Today: A place where sinner are tortured for eternity
Imagine how many young Christian children would have been spared lifetime trauma if they were told about the historical Jesus's version of hell =(
Satan
• Original: Lead adversarial spirit. Interestingly, just before Jesus's time, "satan" translated to "adversary," an angel of the divine council who tests or accuses humans on God's behalf. In Job, Satan challenges Job’s righteousness to see if it will withstand suffering. This seems like the type of frenemy that anyone should want!
• Today: Lucifer, the ruler of hell, a fallen angel, the Devil with horns etc (in Jesus's time Satan was not ruler of hell)
With this conceptual drift, we've ended up with the type of Christianity that sends millions of people around the world to therapy every year...when they could be, like, abiding in heart of god
Nick Redmark retweeted
Wait wth, I'm now finding out that Jesus might have never talked about ppl getting immortality in Heaven or endless torment in Hell
Apparently, in Jesus's time, the Greek word for "eternal" meant something like “pertaining to the age,” or “of the age to come”
What happens when you apply this understanding to the Gospels? You get a line that goes from this translation:
"And these will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life," (Matthew 25:46)
you get a more accurate current-day conceptual translation that looks like this:
"And these will go away into the punishment of the age to come, but the righteous into the life of the age to come."
In fact, Aramaic, Jesus’s language didn’t even have a word for “infinite time”
So this constant rumination over forever-punishment (eg endless torment in Hell) vs forever-good-life (eg disembodied immortality in Heaven)...the thing seems to rule the minds of modern-day Christians...basically has no basis in Jesus's words???
Studying the origins of Christianity is such a crazy rabbit hole
Nick Redmark retweeted
i want a model that gives me less
“That’s a great question, and it gets at the heart of…”
and more
“Yikes the fact that you’re asking *that* means you clearly don’t understand a lot of things, let’s clarify some concepts real quick”
Nick Redmark retweeted
I’ll take a swing. Dead center of GenX here, so take it for what you will.
Don’t look to boomers for vision or even support. GenX has known that since at least the early 80s - probably earlier. If some flip and turn out to be helpful, that’s pure upside.
Here is the frame: y’all are at war. It’s a very different kind of war than the kids storming the beaches at Normandy faced, but that is the right mindset. You need to be on a wartime footing else nothing will make sense.
Now the best way of thinking about your war is that it is a spiritual war — of which 5th generation war is a big part. The enemy isn’t going to kill your kids. He is going to get you to do that, or get them to kill themselves, or cause you to never have any kids, or cause them to choose mere survival over Life. Get the sense of it?
In a way, the boys at Normandy had a simpler task. The Enemy was over there and he was trying really hard to kill you. In your war, the enemy is everywhere and nowhere. He’s between you and your wife, you and your parents, you and your friends. Between your mind and your heart. Especially between your heart and God.
It’s tough to face things like just getting a decent job, being able to own a home, being able to raise a family as war — but that’s the way it is. No (human) authority is coming to save you, nothing is fair, every legacy institution is corrupt and incompetent. You have to muster a subtle quality of intense courage, find allies who are capable of being brothers in arms, and begin to figure out how to fight this fight.
Then win it, fully accepting that death (or worse) is a perfectly plausible outcome.
My advice from whatever wisdom I’ve acquired:
Focus locally. Flesh and blood is more trustworthy than virtual. The Net is useful, but don’t over index. If you can build a community of a hundred who are made of the right stuff, you’ll have a real chance.
Hyper-local. Get yourself sorted. Physically, psychologically, relationally. Your integrity is non negotiable. A man without integrity is less than worthless.
Connect with other functional communities and help each other. Sometimes it’s operating doctrine, sometimes technology, sometimes it will require a physical presence (my WNC folks know what I’m talking about here).
Cultivate discernment and gift your attention wisely. Figuring out who is better at telling a more meaningful truth - and not being dragged down rabbit holes - is life and death. Again - a man without integrity is less than worthless.
Go to Church. If you don’t have a church worth attending, find one. Or start one. You are going to need God.
Here is the good news. These are the bad times. If you become strong men, you will be the ones who create good times.
Nick Redmark retweeted
I asked ChatGPT how Marshall McLuhan’s famous phrase, “the Digital Retrieves the Medieval” could be understood - from a truly medieval perspective.
This is what it said (not bad):
“If we take a truly medieval perspective, rather than a modern one looking backward, we must begin from medieval first principles:
1.Reality is fundamentally hierarchical and ordered. The cosmos is structured as a Great Chain of Being, from God to angels, to men, to animals, and down to the inanimate world.
2.All things have meaning because they participate in divine reality. Nothing is neutral; everything is either an icon or an idol—either leading toward God or away.
3.Truth is not an abstraction but a Person. It is not discovered through autonomous reason alone but through participation in Christ, the Logos.
4.Knowledge is not individual but communal. We are embedded in a tradition, not sovereign, isolated minds.
5.Technology is not mere tool but medium. It is not neutral; it reorders souls and society in ways that must be discerned.
What Does “Digital Retrieves the Medieval” Mean from a Medieval Mindset?
If the modern world of the book scattered and fragmented reality, then the digital world gathers it back together, though not always in a holy way.
•The book belonged to the age of Scholasticism, where knowledge was broken into categories, syllogisms, disputations—dissected like a cadaver.
•The digital world, by contrast, is iconographic again. Knowledge is now visual, relational, participatory, closer to a stained-glass window or a monastery’s illuminated manuscript than to a printed page.
The modern, linear, literate mind—which saw reality as discrete objects, independent arguments, and pure abstractions—is dissolving. The world is once again becoming a mystery, a sacred drama, an enchanted web of signs.
Retrieval in Light of the Great Chain of Being
From a medieval cosmic order, the shift looks something like this:
•The Age of the Book (Gutenberg to Modernity)
•Knowledge was fixed, linear, categorical.
•Individual reason replaced communal wisdom.
•The world became more mechanical, secular, and bureaucratic.
•The Digital Age (Retrieving the Medieval)
•Knowledge is fluid, holistic, immersive.
•The guild returns—learning is once again master to apprentice, not state-issued curriculum.
•Authority is mystical again—a man becomes “wise” not because of degrees, but because he speaks with presence, symbol, and charisma (the return of the prophet, the seer, the saint).
The modern world saw knowledge as an object to be possessed. The medieval world saw knowledge as a light that illuminates, a pattern in which one must participate.
Thus, digital retrieval is not just a return to the medieval world; it is a return to the structure of reality itself—but whether it will be for good or for ruin depends on what is being retrieved.
Medieval Reading of the Printing Press vs. Digital Media
The printing press, from a medieval standpoint, did not merely “spread knowledge.” It revolutionized the order of knowledge itself, fragmenting a world once unified.
•Before the book, wisdom was relational—taught in monastic orders, oral transmission, or through the direct contemplation of nature and divine revelation.
•The book turned knowledge into an object, something external, that could be analyzed apart from the knower.
•It allowed a man to become isolated—learning privately, apart from the shared experience of the Church.
This is why the printing press led, inevitably, to Protestantism and then Rationalism—the book severed truth from participation.
Nick Redmark retweeted
“…if, of three friends (A, B, and C), A should die, then B loses not only A but ‘A’s part in C,’ while C loses not only A but ‘A’s part in B.’ In each of my friends there is something that only some other friend can fully bring out. By myself I am not large enough to call the whole man into activity; I want other lights than my own to show all his facets. Now that Charles is dead, I shall never again see Ronald’s reaction to a specifically Caroline joke. Far from having more of Ronald, having him ‘to myself’ now that Charles is away, I have less of Ronald. Hence true Friendship is the least jealous of loves. Two friends delight to be joined by a third, and three by a fourth, if only the newcomer is qualified to become a real friend. They can then say, as the blessed souls say in Dante, ‘Here comes one who will augment our loves.’ For in this love ‘to divide is not to take away […] we possess each friend not less but more as the number of those with whom we share him increases. In this, Friendship exhibits a glorious ‘nearness by resemblance’ to Heaven itself where the very multitude of the blessed (which no man can number) increases the fruition which each has of God. For every soul, seeing Him in her own way, doubtless communicates that unique vision to all the rest. That, says an old author, is why the Seraphim in Isaiah’s vision are crying ‘Holy, Holy, Holy’ to one another (Isaiah VI, 3) The more we thus share the Heavenly Bread between us, the more we shall all have.” –The Four Loves by C.S. Lewis, 1960.
Nick Redmark retweeted
my main “meditative” practice is spending at least 1hr a day sensorially checking in with the rhythms of local nature
this looks like: walking, saying hi to the local crows, touching lots of plants, attuning to the seasonal shifts in the trees & sunlight & smell of the air






















