Michael Bailey retweeted
Wow. This is a fantastic summary of the study of social mobility! I had never heard of this guy. I particularly like that he goes all the way back to Sorokin, a brilliant early sociologist whose 4-volume Social and Cultural Dynamics is criminally under appreciated.
Replying to @charlesmurray
@charlesmurray I wonder if you read this Substack. Recommended to anyone who followed the Bell Curve’s actual arguments. Link in next post.
Replying to @charlesmurray
@charlesmurray I wonder if you read this Substack. Recommended to anyone who followed the Bell Curve’s actual arguments. Link in next post.
Michael Bailey retweeted
I think there should be some stigma attached to writing that is almost entirely AI-generated, with little human intervention. But there should be no stigma attached to using AI in the writing process, whether to generate initial drafts, polish sentences, come up with better analogies, etc.
More generally, I think much of the bias against AI in writing comes from treating AI use as a proxy for "the author was lazy and produced subpar work".
But this is a bad proxy! I use AI heavily at every stage of my writing workflow, either because it enables me to produce writing of the quality and style I aspire to in less time, or because it enables me to produce better writing than I could without AI.
From this proxy-for-quality-and-effort perspectives, some stigma against almost entirely AI-generated writing makes sense, since in almost all such cases the author could probably produce something significantly better by working on it some more themselves, possibly with AI assistance.
But even this justified stigma rests on a proxy that may be fairly reliable today but will become less so as AI improves. In the long run, quality based judgement is the only thing that will make sense -- at least in academic writing.
Tracey on the Brand case
open.substack.com/pub/mtrace…
4
534
Are we trying to discover true things and write good papers? If so, use AI when it helps (which is always, if you do it right). Collaborate with Claude.
Warning about potential X scam: Got a DM from someone with this message. Last time I clicked on something like this, I lost my account for several days. Beware:
VI am writing a proposal around AI and have to apply via LinkedIn. I am creating a LinkedIn page. Please could you connect with me there?
Briefly, my proposal will look at:
Democratising access to knowledge.
AI and individualised education.
Identifying overlooked talent.
Meritocracy and opportunity.
Risks and limitations.
Many thanks!
The person who DM'd me (@PaulaWright ) confirmed that this was legitimate. No scam.
1
1
238
Kudos
Hot take: “The great feminization” and the cattiness of wokeness/call-out culture stem from women not learning how to argue.
I’m trying to learn how to argue my points, listen openly to opposition, allow for possible shifting—rather than retreat, apologize, get emotional or feel offended.
Basic skills we all should learn, but women are less likely to.
2
15
2,032
Thank you! It isn't best because it's less offensive (though it is), but because it is an original and persuasive intellectual contribution. The implications (against anti-Jewish evolutionary conspiracy theories) is a bonus.
You're all obsessed with @nathancofnas's work on race and IQ and totally sleeping on his most important paper. (We are not the same.)
link.springer.com/article/10…
10
1,039
Today we published one of the best things I've read on the trans debate. Free of the usual acrimony that surrounds these issues, it's compassionate, clear-eyed, and a partisan only of evidence and reason. By @Edokwin. Check it out:
freeblackthought.substack.co…
Michael Bailey retweeted
It is truly an amazing time to build something new.
I sort of realized this when I left AV to start my own thing in June. But because I’d used AI so little at that point I completely underestimated how much it approximates having a full team. What a time to be alive.
I asked Claude how much it would have taken to develop Econvitals pre-coding agents. It's answer: a team of about 50 people working for three years with a budget of $20 million.
Is this correct or too high? I'm not sure.
econvitals.org/about/before-…
“Every revolution changes the nature of a calling, and whom it calls.” Beautifully stated truth.
Btw, the DEI revolution calls completely different people than traditional scholars. We’ll have to see if that revolution can be reversed.
I disagree with many parts of this response, but I will focus on one in particular.
The anonymous PhD student wrote:
"seeing mathematicians greet this release of papers with excitement and joy is beyond confusing. Many celebrate the possibility that AI will relieve them of the burden of difficult calculations, technical lemmas, and other supposedly tedious aspects of mathematical research...I love technical work...I can tell you that I entered graduate school fully intending to pursue a career as a research mathematician. The actions of October 6th have reversed this, and I’m probably not the only one."
Lozeno-Robledo responds: "We need to make sure students do not abandon mathematics because they think it has become unrecognizable."
I disagree.
We are going through a revolution in mathematics. It will change many aspects of what it means to be a mathematician. I believe mathematicians will continue to have a key role in mathematical discovery, at least in the near term, and the profession will continue to be one that attracts many people of the highest calibre. And yes, training these people will include us finding ways of making them struggle, perhaps in line with Niall Ferguson's "the cloister and the starship" suggestion.
But there is no reason to expect that the people for whom the new mathematics will be the right profession are necessarily the same people for whom mathematics as we have known it was the right one.
If a student finds that the profession is becoming unrecognisable, and that what it is becoming no longer appeals to them, then it may well be that the best course for them is to leave mathematics and pursue something else. That is not necessarily something we should seek to prevent.
Every revolution changes the nature of a calling, and whom it calls.
Finding neurological differences in transgender people does NOT establish that there is some innate “gender identity” that we all possess.
Look at depression. We could hypothetically identify specific changes in neural circuitry associated with depression, but this doesn’t mean we’ve identified some dedicated “depression circuit” that everyone possesses. Instead, these differences may reflect alterations in systems involved in a wide range of other functions.
Why should we interpret neurological differences in transgender populations any differently?
Even if we identified consistent neurological differences, these could reflect variation in neural systems involved in numerous other functions, rather than evidence of a dedicated “gender identity” mechanism that everyone possesses.
Finding neural correlates of a phenomenon does not establish that it represents a distinct, universal psychological characteristic.
Michael Bailey retweeted
I keep coming back to this: who would I be had I been born in Gaza? This doesn't mean I blame Israel. I blame Iran and I blame the wider world and the whole antizionist ideology that so many are keen to promote—so long as it's the Palestinians dying for the cause, not them.
Replying to @IonaItalia @gambarian
I disagree that Israel is a fascist state. Am Yisrael Chai. But in a way my heart is also with the Palestinians because they are trapped in a hell, partly of their own making, but still unimaginably horrific. Whereas the Israelis are inventive and resilient; they will be OK.


















