Pinned Tweet
Thanks so much @zoeharcombe for helping save all of us and for never forgetting. @bigfatsurprise @CarynZinn
Wow! I had never seen this before! Andy and I just watched it on Prof Noakes day. So emotional ❤️
youtube.com/watch?v=rtmK8ZBs…
We address all your concerns in our publications.
Also long-term bone health was optimal in carnivorous populations like the American Plains Indians before their food supply (buffaloes) was exterminated. Read @WestonAPrice's suppressed and forgotten work.
westonaprice.org/physical/#g…
Osteoporosis, poor bone health and shrinking stature (plus reduced brain size) begins when grains enter the food chain and replace animal produce as the primary energy source.
A week long laboratory study cannot undo milennia of human dietary experience.
The problem with modern dietary advice (ie the dietetics profession) is that it begins to gain traction in the 1960/70s with the promulgation of the 1977 US Dietary Guidelines the goal of which was to secure the future of grain production in the US (not to make everyone more healthy).
So all the historic dietary wisdom accumulated by societies eating the traditional - largely animal-based diets for tens of thousands of years (as reviewed by Weston Price) had to be hidden
It was not surprising to see that pre-exercise diet did not influence subsequent exercise performance where the intensity is 70% VO2max according to the study design. It's relatively easy. If you exercise you should be aware that trained people can go run or bike for hours fasted. I thought I wanted to see the performance by time trial or power output at higher intensity like >85% VO2max when first reading the study.
And It was surprising to see the performance benefit (22%) by just taking 10g/h carb even at that low intensity, which made me wonder what if the carb intake were higher like >90g/h. At the same time, I got simply curious why the authors did not add the experimental group with higher carb intake, assuming they should know the recent standard dosage in real fields as the experts.
It is fascinating to see the twin glucose pool theory and that the study explained it. But still when it comes to performance, although the study quoted in the discussion section,
“The overall conclusion seems to be that performance benefits can be observed with relative small amounts of CHO (16 g/hr), but no further improvements have been observed with the ingestion of larger amounts of CHO. And to our knowledge no studies have demonstrated that ingesting larger amounts of CHO that will result in higher exogenous CHO oxidation rates will also enhance performance. "
I found another recent study (below) that stands against the argument.
journals.physiology.org/doi/…
I would like to hear your thoughts about it.
Finally, the reason I would not recommend low-carb diet to athletes who seek performance is the health concerns that might hinder training consistency.
Low energy availability in sports is huge problem that can ruin athletes' career. And low carb diets that meet sufficient daily energy needs are not so easy without lab environment. I would suspect the possibilities are quite high for athletes to trap that mistake and be forced to set back.
There are some recent studies that suggest low carb diets independently have some negative effects on bone turnover and anabolic process, which even stands back my thoughts.
Well, I might be wrong and will be so happy to see new findings in fueling science, especially ones can involve brain and nervous systems.
Thanks.
The problem with the "metabolic explanation" is that exogenous carbohydrate oxidation increases as a stepwise function of the increasing ingested carbohydrate dose. But there is zero good evidence that exercise performance follows the same pattern - ie increases in a stepwise fashion as the dose increases from say 10 to 120g/hr. Similarly no evidence for a stepwise reduction in muscle glycogen use with increasing rate of carbohydrate ingestion - in fact, in some studies muscle glycogen use increases with increasing carbohydrate ingestion (as seems probable as blood insulin concentrations increase with increasing carbohydrate ingestion, reducing lipolysis and fat oxidation).
@LoreofRunning1 @PaulBLaursen @PhilipPrins11 @Brady_H @sweatscience
運動時の大量の糖質摂取(90 g/時超)が持久パフォーマンスに影響する新たな神経メカニズム
を提唱したMedical Hypothesesの論文
近年、トップ持久系選手では120 g/時以上の糖質摂取も行われている
確かに糖質摂取量を増やすと、摂取した糖質の酸化量は増加するが、パフォーマンスが比例して向上するわけではない
筋グリコーゲンの節約効果も一貫して認められていない
著者らは、口腔や腸での糖質の感知が中枢神経系に作用し、脊髄運動ニューロンの興奮性や筋の活動時の硬さを維持することで、長時間運動後半の筋機能低下を抑える可能性を提案
このメカニズムは未検証であり、今後の実験的検証が必要
大量の糖摂取の効果は、単なる代謝への影響だけでなく、神経系も含めて考えたほうが良いかもしれません
sciencedirect.com/science/ar…
"At The Noakes Foundation, we’re passionate about translating nutrition science into practical approaches that make a meaningful difference in people’s lives. This publication is another encouraging step in that direction." @TheNoakesF @LoreofRunning1
Published! And we couldn’t have asked for better timing.
November is Diabetes Awareness Month, and with World Diabetes Day having just passed, we’re delighted to share some exciting news from The Noakes Foundation!
Our latest research, conducted in collaboration with Triba Health, has officially been published in the Journal of Metabolic Health.
The study explored the feasibility and metabolic outcomes of a digitally delivered lifestyle programme supporting South Africans living with type 2 diabetes.
And the results are encouraging!
Over six months:
86% of participants with follow-up HbA1c measurements improved their blood glucose control.
61% achieved a clinically meaningful HbA1c reduction of at least 0.5 percentage points.
Average HbA1c decreased from 7.8% to 7.0%.
Improvements were also observed in weight and waist circumference. and blood pressure.
Beyond the numbers, this research reinforces an important message during Diabetes Awareness Month: managing type 2 diabetes involves more than medication alone. Practical nutrition education, personalised lifestyle guidance and ongoing support can help people take greater ownership of their metabolic health.
What makes this study particularly exciting is its real-world South African healthcare setting, demonstrating the potential of combining digital technology with human support alongside conventional medical care.
At The Noakes Foundation, we’re passionate about translating nutrition science into practical approaches that make a meaningful difference in people’s lives. This publication is another encouraging step in that direction.
Read the study: Feasibility and metabolic outcomes of a digital lifestyle intervention for type 2 diabetes in South African managed.
journalofmetabolichealth.org…
#tribahealth
#DiabetesAwarenessMonth #WorldDiabetesDay #Type2Diabetes #MetabolicHealth #TheNoakesFoundation #TribaHealth
So cheating is fine when you play a South African rugby team. This is an absolute tragedy for World Rugby because it shows the sport is run by those whose interests are not truth and fair competition.
Not as if it just happened now. Remember the 2011 Rugby World Cup quarter final between South Africa and Australia.
Dear World Rugby, you can suspend the coach but you can't suspend the footage. 17 tackles. We all saw them. Some of us counted more. FREE UNCLE RASSIE 🇿🇦 @WorldRugby @IrishRugby
THE FOOTAGE SPEAKS!!
#ScrumAtMe #FreeRassie #Springboks #WorldRugby
Hi Tetsuji @Tkambara_miler. How do you explain that the majority of properly conducted randomized controlled trials find that the carbohydrate or fat content of the pre-exercise diet does not influence subsequent exercise performance pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/article… whereas ingestion of carbohydrate during exercise has a very large effect. Are you aware of the twin glucose pool theory that perfectly explains this common finding which is well shown by the study you cite (but rather incorrectly)? Important not to be selective in your readings. @LoreofRunning1
こういった糖質制限ダイエットや逆に高糖質補給戦略によるエネルギー代謝への影響に関する海外論文を読むとき、‘efficiency’という言葉の意味をしっかりと理解する必要はある。
炭水化物1gで4kcal, 脂質1gで9kcalという数字が頭にあれば、「脂質を使った方がエネルギー効率は良い!」
さらに、糖質制限やケトジェニック志向のバイアスがかかっていれば、「脂質代謝の割合が増える=良いこと」となるのかもしれない。
でも、「じゃあ逆に糖質代謝の割合が増えたら果たしてだめなの?」という疑問もわく。
この研究でもサイクリングテストにおける出力は、低糖質グループの方が低くなっている。
こういった糖質制限ダイエットにともなう運動テストで出力やパフォーマンスが低下する傾向は、この研究だけでなく、ここ10-20年近くのの研究で一貫して指摘されている。
20年程前は糖質制限が主流だったサイクリング界が今や高糖質摂取のフードファイトの様相を呈しており、バイクでの出力が昔と比較にならないレベルになっているのが何よりの証拠。
つまり、カロリーと言う数字上の‘energy efficiency’は糖質代謝<脂質代謝である一方で、運動強度が上がり高い出力が求められる局面での‘energy efficiency’は糖質代謝>脂質代謝と言える。
ここで更に疑問が湧く。
「瞬発系・パワー系の運動において、出力はパフォーマンスやトレーニング効果に直結する生命線であり、それを犠牲にしてまで脂質代謝に固執する意味なくない?」
「パフォーマンスを求めない健康フィットネス層でも、低強度の有酸素運動を継続してたら、脂質代謝の能力なんて自ずと上がりますよ?それを食事制限なんて(人によってはストレスフルな)方法で、目先の効率を求めるから長続きせず、健康維持も破綻するケースもあるんじゃないですか?」
※比較的有酸素能力のある400mスプリンターでも、800m, 1500mくらいまでは走れても、5000m以上になると、面倒くさがらずジョグして脂質代謝能力を上げないと高いパフォーマンスは望めない (走るかは知らないかは別にして)のとちょっと似てる。
糖質制限を推したい (と思われる) 研究者グループが昨年、「糖質摂取10g/hでも0g/hよりもトライアスロンパフォーマンスが22%も良かった」という研究結果 (写真1枚目)を発表し、その分野で年間最もインパクトの大きかったという。
journals.physiology.org/doi/…
「なんで糖質10g/hなん?近年のスタンダードである、>90g/h (90g, 120g, 150g)とも比較しようよ。10g/hをコントロールとして」という研究が写真2枚目。
結果は、「>糖質90g/hのグループいずれも、10g/hよりも有意にバイクパフォーマンスは良かった (>120g/hになると差は見られなかった)」
ovid.com/10.1249/MSS.0000000…
つまり、改めて近年のパフォーマンス向上のための糖質補給戦略における一つのスタンダード90-100g/hの正当性が示されたと言える。
‘パフォーマンス’と言っても、例えば、ランナーでフルマラソン3-4時間くらいを目指すレベルであれば、わざわざ脂質代謝を上げるために糖質制限などせず糖質を普段から積極的に摂取した方が恩恵は大きいと思う。
以下その理由(上記と重複するが)
・そのレベルを目指すランナーであれば、普段のジョグにより脂質代謝 (有酸素システム)は構築されている
・ランニングはパワースポーツである以上、トレーニングであれレースであれ、わざわざ出力が下がる手段を選ぶ必要性が薄い
・昔と違い、今はフルマラソンでもエネルギージェルなど糖質を摂取する手段が増えた = 低血糖などのリスクが減った
・普段のトレーニング中などで高糖質摂取をすることで、レース中も糖質の吸収・代謝効率を高めることができる
私自身、10年ほど前に3年程の期間、試しに糖質制限をしていたが、出力 (スピード)が本当に出ない、出せないことを身を以って体験した。
この2-3年は積極的に高糖質補給を取り入れ、当然考えにバイアスがかかっているのは承知で、でも研究データなんかは公平に見ているつもり。
そのうえで、今、身近な競技者に「糖質制限ってどう思いますか?」って相談されたら「パフォーマンス向上を目指すのであればアホなことはしなさんな」と言う。
そして、誤解や不確かな情報を広めないためにも、論文をきちんと読まずに安易にAIに投げて曖昧な要約図を作らせたりしないようにするのは大事だと思う。
I read the literature.
link.springer.com/article/10…
And you?
When one considers the total evidence - not selected studies and ignoring the rest - there is no evidence that either the low-carb or the high-carb diet is superior in exercise lasting up to about 4 hours. That's where the evidence ends. The high carb intake during exercise likely improves performance by a non-metabolic mechanism as @PaulBLaursen has proposed in his recent article.
pdf.sciencedirectassets.com/…
Thus whether you are carb- or fat-adapted should not influence how you respond to very high carb intakes during exercise. However, since this effect is similar to a drug-effect, it might be more effective in those who are infrequently exposed because they live on a low-carb diet.
I'm just speculating.
Replying to @ProfTimNoakes
Thank you! Another question please... Do we know how the equation changes in LCHF-adapted athletes, and have any good studies demonstrated they perform better versus HCLF-adapted athletes that get ideal fuel during competition (e.g., 90 g/hr of glucose/fructose solution)? Said another way, have low-carb endurance athletes performed better because high-carb athletes weren't fueled sufficiently, or is there something else at play?
And what about the 40+ contentious decisions in the 2011 Rugby World Cup quarterfinal between SA and Australia referred by Bryce Lawrence?
Probably something to do with narcissism and grandiosity.
More support for the theory that a falling blood glucose concentration, prevented by low rates of carbohydrate ingestion during exercise, is an important (preventable) cause of fatigue/impaired durability during more prolonged exercise. (But still the idea that muscle glycogen (large glucose pool) is more important than blood glucose (small glucose pool) persists). @philipprins11 @AKoutnik @PaulBLaursen @LoreofRunning1 @Brady_H @sweatscience
運動中の糖質補給、実は少量でも疲労によるパフォーマンス低下を抑えられる
可能性を示すSJMSSの論文
長時間運動後も運動能力を維持する力(Durability)に着目
サイクリスト・トライアスリート13名を対象に、以下の3条件で運動能力を比較。
① 運動なし
② 150分間の自転車運動+糖質(15 g/時)
③ 150分間の自転車運動+糖質なし
※②③は運動後にテストを実施(運動強度はVT1の90%)。
結果:
・糖質なしでは、第1換気性閾値(VT1)に相当するパワーが193→176 Wに低下
・糖質摂取では189 Wとなり、糖質なしより有意に高値
・運動後の血糖値も糖質摂取で高値
・一方、クリティカルパワー(CP)には糖質摂取の有意な効果なし
結論:
少量の糖質摂取でも、長時間運動後のVT1に相当するパワーの低下を軽減できる可能性を示唆
糖を大量にとるべきか?少量で血糖を維持する程度で十分なのか、まだまだ議論が続きそう
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/…
3
26
2,379
Wow. This is unexpected. We were promised that it's impossible for players to fix a rugby match. Looks like we forgot something. @RassieRugby
Also need to keep muscle glycogen levels low to reduce 24-hour blood insulin concentrations. @LoreofRunning1
Insulin resistance can begin within days of overeating, and the first warning sign is a rise in insulin, well before blood glucose or the scale gives anything away.
Healthy men with normal metabolism were fed a large surplus of a typical American diet, about half of it carbohydrate, for a single week. Their blood was checked every morning after an overnight fast, and their fasting glucose never budged, which by the usual standards would mean their metabolism was perfectly fine.
Their insulin told a very different story. Fasting insulin rose by the second day and kept climbing every day after that, ending the week about two and a half times higher than where it started, and by then the men's bodies were taking up only about half as much glucose in response to insulin as they had at the beginning.
This is the pattern I see over and over, where a steady flood of food, much of it carbohydrate, pushes insulin up and keeps it up, and the cells respond by turning down their sensitivity to it, so that chronically high insulin is driving the very insulin resistance it later gets blamed on.
It also shows why fasting glucose is such a poor early test, since these men would have passed a routine checkup at the very moment their insulin was climbing and their cells were becoming resistant to it.
If someone wants to protect their insulin sensitivity, it's clear that keeping insulin from running high, by not overeating, and particularly not overeating carbohydrate, matters well before blood glucose or body weight shows any change.
1
22
1,766
Note: Subjects in the dehydrated group became increasingly thirsty during the event. So they were not following drinking guidelines which are "drink to thirst". Instead they were actively restricting their fluid intakes.
An additional control group in these studies should always be a group that drinks to thirst. Otherwise it is possible that incorrect conclusions will be drawn.
@LoreofRunning1 @sweatscience @Brady_H @theplews1 @philipprins11
Drinking enough on long rides may help you use more of the carbohydrate you take in.
9 trained male cyclists rode 160 minutes taking 60g/h of glucose. When they drank only the fluid in their carbohydrate drink and lost 2.8% of body mass, they oxidised 16% less of that glucose than when water matched their sweat loss. The gap was largest at 60 minutes, at about 1% body mass loss. No performance test was done, so the effect on race times is still unknown.
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4242…
Who benefits from the match fixing, @scrumming_ten? Remember the 2011 Rugby World Cup quarter final between South Africa and Australia? How was the referee selected for that match? History repeating?
Something to think about when promoting 120g carbohydrate per hour for athletes during competition? @LoreofRunning1
I used to think Alzheimer's was bad luck.
A disease that picks you at random. Something you pray does not come for your family.
I was wrong.
A study published in the Journal of Clinical Investigation used glucose clamps to measure what happens inside the brain when blood sugar spikes.
One blood sugar spike from a single meal increased amyloid-beta production in the brain by 39%.
Amyloid-beta is the plaque protein that accumulates in Alzheimer's.
That increase persisted for at least 16 hours after blood sugar returned to normal.
One meal. 16 hours of plaque building up in your brain.
Now add genetics. APOE4 carriers cannot clear amyloid-beta efficiently. Every blood sugar spike dumps plaque into the brain for 16 hours. The APOE4 brain cannot clean it up. Meal after meal. Year after year.
This is not random. This is metabolic damage accumulating in silence.
Alzheimer's is increasingly being called Type 3 Diabetes by researchers who see the same pattern: insulin resistance, chronic inflammation, and a brain starving for energy while drowning in sugar.
No one is born to lose their mind. But three meals a day of processed food for 40 years will do what no gene alone ever could.
Genetics loads the gun. Lifestyle pulls the trigger.
Macauley et al. (2015). Journal of Clinical Investigation, 125(6). PMC4497756
A simple point that is frequently overlooked. The initiation of muscle contraction always occurs BEFORE (additional) fuel is oxidised and ATP is produced/consumed,
There is little physiological evidence that simply by taking in more fuel during exercise, this will force the skeletal muscle mitochondria to produce more ATP leading to an increase in athletic performance. Any increase in performance requires an increase in motor unit recruitment in the active muscles (or related changes). Why ketones should be able to do this is unclear and looks as if it doesn't happen based on the findings of this study. Which might be what one expects when one considers the basic physiology. @LoreofRunning1 @sweatscience
10
1,484
There is little physiological evidence that simply by taking in more fuel during exercise, this will force the skeletal muscle mitochondria to produce more ATP leading to an increase in athletic performance. Any increase in performance requires an increase in motor unit recruitment in the active muscles (or related changes). Why ketones should be able to do this is unclear and looks as if it doesn't happen based on the findings of this study. Which might be what one expects when one considers the basic physiology. @LoreofRunning1 @sweatscience
Replying to @PhilipPrins11 @GroveCtyCollege @MARCACSM @ACSMNews @ketone @drinkLMNT @ProfTimNoakes @AKoutnik
On the ketone arm: taken just before hard exercise, ketones appear to slightly worsen performance, though dosing after training points the other way. The evidence is small, mostly single-dose studies. evipedia.ai/exogenous_ketone…
Because burning more carbohydrate is less important than all the other adaptations? @LoreofRunning1
Heat acclimation is supposed to be the fix for hard work in the heat. Your heart rate comes down, core temperature comes down, plasma volume goes up…
The question is whether those adaptations also restore your ability to burn the carbohydrate you ingest.
It turns out, they don’t.
physiologicallyspeaking.com/…
1
14
2,852
Just imagine if this diet had been included for study in the (failed) Women's Health Initiative, the (failed) Sydney Diet Heart Study, the (failed) Minesotta Coronary Experiment, the (failed) Look AHEAD trial etc etc including the other studies reviewed by @garytaubes, @bigfatsurprise and @zoeharcombe amongst others.
The diet-heart debate would have been resolved already in 2-3 decades ago.
KETO CUTS HEART ATTACK RATE IN HALF
Dr. Baker is right. This is the study that should end the keto heart attack scare.
For 50 years doctors have warned that cutting carbs and eating more fat would give you a heart attack. This study checked what actually happened. 4,877 adults with type 2 diabetes or obesity cut their carbs with Virta. They were matched with 4,877 people on usual care.
Heart attack, stroke or death: 4.1 per 1,000 people a year on low carb. 9.3 on usual care.
Less than half.
Study:
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/4282…
American Heart Ass’n CAVES on Low-Carb Diet! (KETO protects Heart)
youtube.com/watch?v=2VhFIRxb…
























