
ALT The New York State Legislature has just passed a bill (S4091/A04873) that would lock New York Cityβs transit system in the past. This bill, which would require a conductor to be on board every train operated by New York City Transit, is the technological equivalent of requiring every elevator in the city to still be staffed by an elevator operator. If you take other transit systems both across the country and around the world, you'll quickly realize that two-person train operation (TPTO) is an outdated practice that is used almost nowhere elseβand in the few cities where it is used, it is generally being phased out. Indeed, in order to provide more frequent service for more passengers, many cities across the world are moving to fully automated trains. New York should be a world leader in transportation; this 30-year-old bill would be akin to mandating pagers in the age of smartphones.

ALT If signed into law, S4091 would immediately impact riders by reducing service and raising costs on lines that already have no conductor. It would hamstring the MTA by making automation illegal on new lines, raising costs and decreasing safety for all New Yorkers moving forward. It is also an egregious example of legislative micromanagement that undermines the ability of the MTA to modernize, innovate, and efficiently serve the public. In order to have a transit system that is able to meet the needs of millions of both current and future New Yorkers, Governor Hochul must veto this bill.

ALT In a recent study, however, Amtrak has claimed that through-running is impossible in the current Penn Station footprint, and that the region instead needs to spend $16.7 billion to demolish a block of Midtown Manhattan and build Penn Expansion. This project adds 7β12 stub-end tracks, maintaining an antiquated operational status quo. ETA's own analysis shows that Amtrak's report is simply incorrect. It builds on faulty assumptions and poor understanding of how through-running rail systems operate across the world. Even the separate $7 billion Penn Reconstruction project to rebuild the track and concourse levels within the stationβs footprint, while perhaps desirable for passenger experience, is unnecessary for through-running in our analysis. ETA's analysis, based on an examination of best practices from peer cities across the globe, shows that today's Penn Station can handle the ridership that Gateway will bring if the region simply changes the way it operates its trainsβand it can do

































