S.D. Homnick (@querynotfound) header
S.D. Homnick (@querynotfound) profile picture

Eclectic dabbler pursuing the modest goal of omniscience. Striving for Hasidic annihilation of self. Aramaic/Yiddish preferred but Heb/Eng are okay, I guess

Brooklyn, NY
Joined March 2017
Btw Bernstein misses that the Arizal (writing in Zoharic Aramaic) is in fact quoting from... Zohar
1
92
ויאכל - האט עשו גיגעסין אין האט זיך נישט גיװאשין וישת - אין ער האט גיטרינקין אין האט קײן ברכה נישט גימאכט ויקם - אין ער איז אויף גישטאנן אין ער האט נישט גיבענשט וילך - אין ער איז אװעק גיגאנגין אין ער האט דיא מזוזה נישט גיקישט
6
4
22
1,879
כבר הקדימך ר' מנחם די לונזאנו בספרו 'דרך חיים' לפני כ450 שנה
1
78
Replying to @IsqaDeQofaya
Rabbeinu Bechaye documented and critiqued
7
631
The Previous Rebbe – apparently NOT a fan of 'Sholem Aleichem' and 'Arbeter Ring' schools
3
364
וצעק מרה על מנהג זה, שהוא מנהג נעאלאגען
4
4
636
The Constitution of the Reformed Society of Israelites, Charleston, 1825: Finally, they rejected out of hand the practice of public purchase of certain synagogue honors in the midst of services, a practice they disdained for both its “uselessness and impropriety.”
1
1
4
788
I enjoyed the article and shared it with others. I would just note that this lullaby, far from being 'strange and unfamiliar,' is actually recognizable as the "The Best-Known Jewish Lullaby" (the other two Yiddish songs cited here also have known parallels)
19
Replying to @a_a_viswanath
Btw this is a topic where halachic works provide useful early documentation of terms in use
1
2
190
Replying to @pruzhaner
Found this from a Rishon (who discusses the positive uses of a number of generally negative midos)
3
43
I’ve noticed that our musical Hallel on Chol Hamoed Sukkos is being discussed on social media. Many were inspired by it. Others criticized it as being some sort of “reformation” of our Avodas Hashem. The specific, technical question is not a new one. There is room for legitimate debate in the realm of halacha and minhag. But something else has crept into this conversation, and I think it needs to be called out. Musical Hallel is suddenly being dismissed by some as “a Modox invention.” As a “Zionist” phenomenon. As something that belongs to a supposedly “less serious” stream of Orthodox Judaism. And that is not a Torah argument. There is an enormous difference between a halachic debate and saying, “Of course those kinds of Jews would do something like this.” The first is a machlokes. The second is using Torah language as cover for contempt toward other frum Jews. And we should be intellectually honest enough to know the difference. You are completely entitled to believe that another Torah community is mistaken. Torah Judaism has never had full uniformity of minhag, hashkafah, or practice. But disagreement in this realm demands enough respect for another Torah community to actually engage its position. And no - labels are not arguments. “Modox” is not a mareh makom. “Zionist” is not a legitimate rebuttal. Our mesorah contains fierce machlokes. Beis Hillel and Beis Shammai were not engaged in a campaign of “let’s all get along.” They believed that matters of Torah were worth arguing about. But they argued about Torah. That distinction matters. Because there is something deeply unhealthy about reaching for Torah language when what you really want to say is that you do not respect the religious world of the Yidden standing across from you. We can argue more seriously. We can insist that Torah ideas be defended with Torah substance rather than sociological cudgels. If there’s one thing that we can learn on this 3rd anniversary of October 7th, it is perhaps that we need to recover more honest machlokes. The art of holy disagreement while still loving and respecting our brothers and sisters who might not agree with every one of our opinions.
1
2
411
Replying to @adcohen15
*bizarre expression "The present author explains the crucial phrase ניתלה בידו אחת on the basis of a piyyut published from a Genizah manuscript. This piyyut . . reveals that תלוי יד in Medieval Hebrew had the connotation of 'impoverished,' 'beggarly.'..."
1
3
113
Replying to @JewishGenomics
Note the following interesting tie-in that gets at the very nature and self-conception of Ashkenazi identity in the halachic context
2
130
Replying to @a_a_viswanath
Big 'sugya' :)
3
5
146
Did the Czar of Russia pass through the fields and towns of Belarus shortly before the Alter Rebbe said the parable of the "king in the field"? And what are the similarities between the AR's parable and R. Nachman's tale of the "humble king"? 👇 youtu.be/O7OOkYaYBhc
2
1
6
875
Like why does a use like "yedovevu" in piyut suggest the possibility of a leap to "davenen" in vernacular. What about the rest of the list? Maybe "lab(v)enen"?
3
52
And as the 'taytsh guy' I'll add the following as a data point, these taytshn of "dovev" in 'Reuchlin 8' and 'Reuchlin 9' certainly do not indicate any special meaning and usage beyond regular "redn"
2
2
69