Rahul Agarwal retweeted
Question 1: Wasn't Aadhaar launched specifically for welfare benefit payments? With biometrics.
Question 2: Do we now have to do biometrics again for Voter ID?
Question 3: Will we then have to link Voter ID to PAN, Bank Account, this, that, and everything under the sun?
Question 4: What da???
Aadhaar to be replaced by voter ID, biometrics for benefit payments: Minister indianexpress.com/article/in…
Citibank was good for 25 years, @AxisBank is a shame. Clear culture of customer can go to hell. RM is just not bothered. His manager too. difficult to understand the mindset when there is no differentiation in the industry and only relationship matters. IDFC so much better
1
264
Spot on @dmuthuk
‘I told you so’ is not something to mention cheerfully, especially when what was said is negative.
From the time long term capital gains tax was brought back, I have been tirelessly pointing out how unfair it is to have both STT and long term capital gains tax.
Even when I was a BJP supporter, I criticised how disastrous the 2019 budget was. From that time, I have been consistent in saying that Nirmala Sitharaman is unfit to be a finance minister.
She reduced corporate tax but kept the individual tax rate as it is. In fact, the individual tax rate went as high as 42 percent and is now around 39 percent.
Income tax is paid by a tiny fraction of the population. Still, the amount they pay is more than what all corporates in India put together pay.
Individuals paying cumulatively more than corporates started only during the period of the current Finance Minister. This is a travesty of justice.
This government has no clue about capital markets or risk capital. Prime Minister’s most trusted officer Hasmukh Adhia said making profits from markets requires no effort. Then why do very few create wealth and most get wiped out from capital markets?
Neither Hasmukh Adhia nor Nirmala Sitharaman would have ever invested even a single rupee in capital markets.
All asset classes are not equal because the nature of risk is different. In a capital starved country, risk capital needs to be incentivised.
For those who say it is only the secondary market, without ease of entry and exit in secondary markets, the primary market would cease to exist. And without that, there would be zero risk capital.
The odds of success in trading are already very low. The government has kept increasing STT, making trading unviable.
The government simply does not understand that trading provides two important things for markets: liquidity and price discovery. Without liquidity and price discovery, secondary markets would become practically useless.
Even in 2024, after NDA won the elections, I tagged the Prime Minister multiple times stating that anyone other than Nirmala Sitharaman should be considered for Finance Minister because she would prove to be economically disastrous for the country. And unfortunately, I am proven right.
The Finance Ministry is only good at setting narratives like poverty has been rooted out in India, we would become a developed superpower by 2047, and the latest narrative of how economically powerful we are becoming on a PPP basis.
I have repeatedly shown with data and facts how every single narrative is false and disconnected from reality. The Finance Ministry lives in a completely different reality.
Even developed nations understand how important foreign capital is. But our finance minister said in Parliament it is ok if foreign capital goes away because we have domestic retail investors. Certain statements are coming back to haunt us.
As I have said in the past, it is not that this government did not do anything positive. But given the huge mandate, the last twelve years are wasted opportunities on an overall basis. And the contribution of the Finance Ministry to these wasted opportunities is significant.
For many years, I have been trolled, criticised, and abused for questioning the finance minister and the government’s economic policies.
Now every well meaning individual realises how disastrous the Finance Minister has been for both the economy and capital markets.
My views stand vindicated now. Still, you do not feel happy when your negative views come true.
1
174
Rahul Agarwal retweeted
‘I told you so’ is not something to mention cheerfully, especially when what was said is negative.
From the time long term capital gains tax was brought back, I have been tirelessly pointing out how unfair it is to have both STT and long term capital gains tax.
Even when I was a BJP supporter, I criticised how disastrous the 2019 budget was. From that time, I have been consistent in saying that Nirmala Sitharaman is unfit to be a finance minister.
She reduced corporate tax but kept the individual tax rate as it is. In fact, the individual tax rate went as high as 42 percent and is now around 39 percent.
Income tax is paid by a tiny fraction of the population. Still, the amount they pay is more than what all corporates in India put together pay.
Individuals paying cumulatively more than corporates started only during the period of the current Finance Minister. This is a travesty of justice.
This government has no clue about capital markets or risk capital. Prime Minister’s most trusted officer Hasmukh Adhia said making profits from markets requires no effort. Then why do very few create wealth and most get wiped out from capital markets?
Neither Hasmukh Adhia nor Nirmala Sitharaman would have ever invested even a single rupee in capital markets.
All asset classes are not equal because the nature of risk is different. In a capital starved country, risk capital needs to be incentivised.
For those who say it is only the secondary market, without ease of entry and exit in secondary markets, the primary market would cease to exist. And without that, there would be zero risk capital.
The odds of success in trading are already very low. The government has kept increasing STT, making trading unviable.
The government simply does not understand that trading provides two important things for markets: liquidity and price discovery. Without liquidity and price discovery, secondary markets would become practically useless.
Even in 2024, after NDA won the elections, I tagged the Prime Minister multiple times stating that anyone other than Nirmala Sitharaman should be considered for Finance Minister because she would prove to be economically disastrous for the country. And unfortunately, I am proven right.
The Finance Ministry is only good at setting narratives like poverty has been rooted out in India, we would become a developed superpower by 2047, and the latest narrative of how economically powerful we are becoming on a PPP basis.
I have repeatedly shown with data and facts how every single narrative is false and disconnected from reality. The Finance Ministry lives in a completely different reality.
Even developed nations understand how important foreign capital is. But our finance minister said in Parliament it is ok if foreign capital goes away because we have domestic retail investors. Certain statements are coming back to haunt us.
As I have said in the past, it is not that this government did not do anything positive. But given the huge mandate, the last twelve years are wasted opportunities on an overall basis. And the contribution of the Finance Ministry to these wasted opportunities is significant.
For many years, I have been trolled, criticised, and abused for questioning the finance minister and the government’s economic policies.
Now every well meaning individual realises how disastrous the Finance Minister has been for both the economy and capital markets.
My views stand vindicated now. Still, you do not feel happy when your negative views come true.
Rahul Agarwal retweeted
More than a decade ago, I read 'A Colossal Failure of Common Sense' by Lawrence G. McDonald. If my memory serves me right, I first heard of it because Charlie Munger mentioned it somewhere.
Two years ago he published his second book, 'How to Listen When Markets Speak'. I bought it immediately then and was impressed by the analysis.
The historical perspective, the insights drawn from it, and the argument about how the global economy and therefore investing is likely to change were well made.
The surprising part is that the world is now moving in the direction he pointed to a few years ago.
No one can predict the future. But it is better to have an idea of the likely scenarios.
Worth reading.
Rahul Agarwal retweeted
The Western Thappa That Turned Indian Buildings Into Ovens.
We copied a Western idea.
A towering, fully sealed glass building with central air-conditioning.
It looks modern. It looks global.
But is it designed for India? 🧵1/13
Rahul Agarwal retweeted
Once you visit random cities in China and come back to Indian streets, you realize how much you’ve been scammed by your local MLAs, MPs, IAS and the whole system.
Rahul Agarwal retweeted
After massive outrage online over kids being stuck in traffic for hours, Varthur Road is being fixed -but by traffic police.
Where are the GBA/Bengaluru East Corporation/B-SMILE----KRDCL officials who are actually responsible for it?
To support safer & smoother traffic movement,our personnel, with the local assistance,have carrying out temporary filling at critical points Varthur Gunjur Rd.
ಸುರಕ್ಷಿತ ಹಾಗೂ ಸುಗಮ ಸಂಚಾರಕ್ಕಾಗಿ, ಸ್ಥಳೀಯ ಸಹಕಾರದೊಂದಿಗೆ ನಮ್ಮ ಸಿಬ್ಬಂದಿಯವರು ಈ ರಸ್ತೆ ಭಾಗದ ಅಗತ್ಯವಿರುವ ಸ್ಥಳಗಳಲ್ಲಿ ತಾತ್ಕಾಲಿಕವಾಗಿ ಮುಚಿಸುತ್ತಿದ್ದಾರೆ .
ಸ್ಥಳದ ಪರಿಸ್ಥಿತಿಯನ್ನು ನಿರಂತರವಾಗಿ ಗಮನಿಸಲಾಗುತ್ತಿದೆ. ವಾಹನ ಸವಾರರು ಎಚ್ಚರಿಕೆಯಿಂದ ಸಂಚರಿಸಿ, ಸ್ಥಳದಲ್ಲಿರುವ ಸಿಬ್ಬಂದಿಗೆ ಸಹಕರಿಸುವಂತೆ ವಿನಂತಿ.
#WhitefieldTraffic
Rahul Agarwal retweeted
Replying to @krishnabgowda
@krishnabgowda - we need you to visit Whitefield and speak with the children who have to sit in buses for 3-4 hours everyday. Without access to food or toilets.
When are you coming to meet them?
Rahul Agarwal retweeted
2+ hours. Every single day. That's how long kids from Whitefield spend on Varthur Road for a 5km commute. My own daughter is stuck right now as I post this. Whitefield deserves better than this. @blrcitytraffic @DKShivakumar @krishnabgowda @PCMohanMP @MALimbavali #Varthur
Rahul Agarwal retweeted
Today my daughter’s school bus took 2 hours to travel just 2 km in Varthur/Gunjur road.
For those 2 hours, I sat there as a parent feeling completely helpless.
I work hard. My wife and I pay lakhs in taxes every month. We took a huge home loan mainly so we could live close to our daughter’s school and give her a safer, easier childhood.
And yet, this is what “2 km from school” means here.
In the last year alone, we have seen a school bus topple, a woman suffer serious injuries after a fall, a biker almost lost his life after falling because of a pothole, and many more incidents that never become headlines.
Every day, ordinary people here tweet, email, complain, follow up and plead with authorities.
We are not activists.
We are not fighting for a political party.
We are parents, employees, families and taxpayers asking for one basic thing:
Please give our children a safe road to come home on.
Today, more than the traffic, what broke me was the feeling that despite doing everything a responsible citizen is supposed to do, I had absolutely no power to protect my own child.
If anyone knows how ordinary citizens of Varthur/Gunjur can reach someone with the authority to actually intervene, please help us.
@krishnabgowda @DKShivakumar @MALimbavali @ArvindLBJP @GBA_office @BECCUPDATES @ChristinMP_ @RamSNarayan @GunjurCharan @RisingVarthur @BDAOfficialGok
#varthurisbleeding
Rahul Agarwal retweeted
Around 15 months ago the Finance Ministry said claims that MDR would be charged on UPI were "completely false, baseless and misleading, and reaffirmed its commitment to promoting digital payments through UPI."
Today there is a U turn. From 15 October a 0.4% MDR will apply to specified person to merchant UPI transactions above Rs 2,000.
When STT was introduced, Parliament was told it was in lieu of capital gains tax on listed equities.
We now pay both STT and capital gains tax.
Dividends, once taxed at the company level, are now taxed in shareholders hands at slab rates.
What happened to Dream11?
Courts treated fantasy sports as a game of skill. Rules were later framed for permissible real money games. Then a law banned online money games.
Who allowed it, who banned it, and what material change occurred in those few years?
The problem is consistency and credibility. That is why so many people keep questioning official GDP growth rate to inflation numbers.
If the government had enough credibility, this level of scepticism would not exist.
Rahul Agarwal retweeted
Top 10% of Indians earn 57% of national income.
The remaining 90% earn 43%.
GDP per capita of India is about $2,700.
If you set aside the top 10%, the balance 90% has an implied GDP per capita of only about $1,300. That is below the national averages of Pakistan and sub Saharan Africa. It shows how much the national average is pulled up by the top.
If you are not among the top 150 million and are part of the remaining 1.3 billion, daily life is extremely hard for a very large share of people.
Because 150 million is itself a huge number, the country looks more prosperous than it is for most citizens.
As the Indus Valley report from Blume Ventures pointed out, around 1,000 million Indians have almost no room to spend beyond very basic needs. They are not a market for discretionary goods. Public support matters a great deal for survival at that level.
As a country, we have a very long way to go.
Loving the country does not mean ignoring reality. Some people say that in every country only the top 10% thrive and the rest struggle.
That does not make India typical. India is unusual in both the depth of poverty and the concentration of income.
I mentioned that the top 10% of Indians earn about 57% of national income. In countries such as Germany, Italy, Japan, South Korea and France, household survey data put the top 10% closer to around 25% of national income. Even in the United States, survey data put that share near 30%.
Below are approximate GDP per capita figures for 10 large rich countries. The first number is the national average, meaning total income of the country divided by its whole population.
The second number is a rough figure for the bottom 90%, meaning what the average looks like if you leave out the richest tenth.
In these countries the second number stays high. In India it collapses.
United States: $89,105 and $68,800
Germany: $55,911 and $47,100
United Kingdom: $54,949 and $45,100
Canada: $53,558 and $45,800
France: $46,792 and $41,200
South Korea: $34,642 and $28,000
Japan: $33,956 and $27,900
Italy: $41,091 and $33,700
Australia: $64,547 and $52,300
Spain: $36,192 and $31,900
We not only create less income and wealth per person, and what we create is far more concentrated.
Rahul Agarwal retweeted
People came with problems. We sat down with them to find solutions.
At the first #PrajaaSeve in Bidarahalli, hundreds of citizen grievances were heard by government officials and taken up for quick resolution.
Governance works best when citizens are heard.
Rahul Agarwal retweeted
- Water Issues in Lahuria village, UP for 75 yrs
- New IAS Divya steps in, delivers tap water
- MLA not invited in Jal Ceremony
- MLA complains to CM, Divya transferred.
- Pipeline vandalized by unknown men
- Water stops again.
- She Resigned after put on Wait list
Well, that's India for you😭





























