Rich Howard retweeted
I think I finally figured out why the SEO vs GEO thing sticks in my craw so much.
The things that would have laid the groundwork for good AI search performance today are the things SEOs have been talking about for 10 years.
Next year is the 10-year anniversary of Traffic Think Tank. I know for a fact hundreds of people have been talking about the stuff that’s now making the rounds as “new approaches” for surfacing in ChatGPT, AI Overviews and Claude. (Not Perplexity. Nobody seems to care about Perplexity anymore.)
This should be the victory lap. This is when you look at the CMO who ignored your requests and your advice for a decade and say “I fucking told you so.”
Instead, loud voices in the SEO community are saying we should repackage it. Call it GEO. Pretend to the CMOs (who didn’t want to listen to their SEO teams) that this is all new. That they haven’t heard it for the last 10 years. That they haven’t been sitting in C-level seats knowing nothing about how the channel actually operates.
So instead of telling them we knew better this entire time, the advice is to kowtow. Use the language they want to use. Make believe it’s all new and different, and they’re so smart for finally wanting to do it. “Oh gosh, who could have seen this coming? We better get on this right away.”
Say whatever they want to hear, because they control the money.
Maybe it’s because I’m lucky enough that I don’t need to close X deals in the next three months to pay my mortgage. I’m good. So maybe that’s my privilege showing. I don’t have to make believe, and other people do, because they decided to run an agency and have full-time salaries to pay. If you have to say the shibboleth to make your bills next month, okay. Fine.
But that doesn’t define what’s true. It defines what’s commercially useful.
And I’m entirely uninterested in saying things I don’t think are true just because they’re commercially useful.
If that’s where you are, I feel bad for you, frankly. Every single time I hear the “new” GEO work explained, I can think of five blog posts from seven years ago that describe exactly the same thing.
You’re playing a bullshit game to impress dumb CMOs so they’ll pay you. I get it. Money’s important. But don’t shit a shitter. Don’t pretend when you’re talking to me that this is new or different or revolutionary. It’s the same bullshit you were doing eight years ago. You’re just calling it something else and charging more.
And if you can get more money for the same old shit with a new coat of paint, good for you. I’m as staunchly pro-capitalist as anyone. I respect and applaud your right to get money from dumb people.
Just don’t expect me to pretend publicly that they’re not dumb.
It's still "just" SEO.
And if you’ve been saying this stuff for a decade, take your well-earned victory lap.
Rich Howard retweeted
It’s almost incomprehensible how wide the distance is between someone who’s working at the frontier with AI and basically everyone else right now.
The crazy thing is these lines are not converging, but only growing farther apart. If the curve of AI progress had leveled off, it would certainly have given most people and companies time to catch up or implement their workflows in a standardized way. The technology would have neutralized competitive advantage because everyone would be using it the same way.
But what’s happened is the opposite. The curve of AI progress is basically going vertical right now, which means if you had codified your processes 3-6 months ago you’re likely already behind again. Now imagine most companies that kicked into gear a year ago and thought that they were done. Even further behind now.
I’ve never seen a technology in my life and career that improves at this rate, which consequently means you need to upgrade your expectations at a similar rate. Our brains weren’t wired for this, and our organizational change management processes certainly weren’t either.
With any form of recursive self improvement, things just get wilder. It’s a time when you will need to be constantly reevaluating the things that didn’t work just a couple months ago to see if they now can be solved. AI native companies certainly have a strong advantage due to this right now, so now it comes down to can the bigger companies keep up. Wild times.
Rich Howard retweeted
Some wise words from @lilyraynyc. There's a lot of BS being thrown around regarding GEO/AEO. Be careful out there. :)
"What Lily told CMOs starting from zero: 1) be skeptical, a lot of the loudest voices don't really know what's going on 2) the people best equipped for this are your experienced SEOs, because so much of AI search runs on web retrieval 3) SEO isn't dead, so don't buy that hype."
youtube.com/watch?v=vZFXa-2q…
Rich Howard retweeted
"Why does our top performer get the worst reviews?" the boss asked.
I was reviewing their annual performance data.
"Show me," I said.
She pulled up the ratings.
Diana: 2.8 out of 5.
Below average on "collaboration."
Low marks for "team player."
"What's her actual performance?" I asked.
"Exceeded every target.
Landed our biggest client.
Trained three new hires."
"So why the low scores?"
"Her peer reviews are dragging her down."
I scanned the comments.
"Too direct."
"Challenges ideas too much."
"Not supportive enough."
"Let me talk to Diana," I said.
"I used to give honest feedback," Diana told me.
"Said our pricing model was broken.
Got dinged for 'negativity.'"
"What happened with the pricing?"
"They finally fixed it six months later.
After we lost two major accounts."
"What else?"
"I questioned why we needed
eleven approvals for a simple contract change.
Manager said I wasn't being collaborative."
"Are you still giving feedback?"
"No. I learned my lesson.
Now I smile. Nod. Say everything's great.
My reviews are improving."
"But nothing's actually improving?"
"We're making the same mistakes.
Just with better vibes." She chuckled.
I went back to the boss.
"Your review system doesn't measure performance," I said.
"It measures compliance."
"That's not true."
"When was the last time someone
got promoted for challenging bad ideas?"
Silence.
"When did someone get rewarded for preventing a mistake?"
More silence.
"You've trained your best people to stay quiet.
And your mediocre people to stay nice."
A few months later, they redesigned the system.
Added a category: "Constructive Challenge."
Points for identifying problems early.
Rewards for preventing costly mistakes.
Diana got promoted.
"What changed?" I asked the boss.
"We stopped confusing agreement with alignment.
Stopped mistaking silence for harmony."
"And?"
"Turns out our 'difficult' people
were our most valuable.
They actually cared enough to speak up."
Here's the truth about performance reviews:
Most companies don't reward performance.
They reward performance theater.
The person who says the meeting was great
beats the person who says it wasted an hour.
The person who agrees with bad ideas
beats the person who prevents disasters.
You think you're measuring contribution.
You're measuring conformity.
And your best people?
They've already figured out the game.
They're just deciding whether to play it
or find somewhere that values truth over comfort.
Extraordinary success requires extraordinary sacrifice.
As I hit year 25 in SEO and Growth, this hits home.
In high school, I stayed up all night learning, slept in class, failed English twice, and did not walk at graduation.
I was on my own at 17. Paid my own bills. Said no to parties so I could build.
Twenty-five years later, I still wake up early, work weekends, and read every night.
I have burned out. I have learned balance. I have done it to give my kids opportunities I never had.
The opportunity today feels bigger than ever.
Sacrifice compounds. So does progress.
Extraordinary success requires extraordinary sacrifice.
While your friends are at happy hours drinking and partying, you’re building. While they’re sleeping in, you’re studying.
The price of greatness is everything normal people do for fun.
2
109
Replying to @brodieseo
@brodieseo @glenngabe I am seeing considerable changes to avg pos, impressions & ctr % starting January 4th. Are you'll seeing anything? Looks like Google changed the serps via SEMRush sensor then. Sitelinks significantly changed, AIO, and people also asked.
1
1
90
We’re hiring 2 world class creatives to shape the next iteration of the @elevenlabs marketing website: a Designer and a Design Engineer.
You'll be working (on things like this) alongside myself, @bradlc and @RomaTesla.
If this is you, or someone you know, DMs are open.
Rich Howard retweeted
Introducing Eleven Music. The highest quality AI music model.
- Complete control over genre, style, and structure
- Multi-lingual, including English, Spanish, German, Japanese and more
- Edit the sound and lyrics of individual sections or the whole song
Rich Howard retweeted
Introducing Eleven v3 (alpha) - the most expressive Text to Speech model ever.
Supporting 70+ languages, multi-speaker dialogue, and audio tags such as [excited], [sighs], [laughing], and [whispers].
Now in public alpha and 80% off in June.
Rich Howard retweeted
You can read every book, watch every video, and map out every move - but none of it matters if you don’t take action.
You’ve got to jump in, get hit in the face, fall on your face, and keep showing up.
Ideas don’t win. Execution does.
Rich Howard retweeted
This hits @RobertGreene
Rich Howard retweeted
There’s no amount of strategy or studying that replaces execution.
You’ve got to get on the field, screw up, stay in long enough to figure it out and try again.


























