Robert Froese (@robfroese) header
Robert Froese (@robfroese) profile picture

🇺🇸🇨🇦Forester/Professor/Consultant. I prefer being outside. My tweets are mine alone. Nothing I post necessarily endorsed by anyone, including me.

One or the other side of 49
Joined November 2008
Photo by Robert Froese (@robfroese)Photo by Robert Froese (@robfroese)Photo by Robert Froese (@robfroese)Photo by Robert Froese (@robfroese)Photo by Robert Froese (@robfroese)Photo by Robert Froese (@robfroese)Photo by Robert Froese (@robfroese)Photo by Robert Froese (@robfroese)Photo by Robert Froese (@robfroese)Photo by Robert Froese (@robfroese)
Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms prohibits discrimination but permits preferential treatment for disadvantaged groups—without generally requiring it. The consequence? Governments can choose which disadvantages to remedy and which to leave unaddressed. Equity becomes a selective policy choice, not a uniform obligation. In other words, constitutionally permissible inequitable equity.
24
The @nationalpost numbers aren’t a vibe. If 20-somethings decided the election it would be a Conservative blowout. If 60+ decided it, Liberals cruise. That’s not because Canada got more compassionate with age. It’s because the people who already own the house and collect the pension vote to keep the scarcity that made them whole — and the people paying $2,400 rent are the ones funding CPP. Polite, egalitarian Canada is, at the ballot box, an asset-protection scheme with good manners. Build more. Permit faster. Stop treating incumbent real estate like a moral achievement. nationalpost.com/opinion/fir…
2
47
Stefan Hupperts and I are recruiting an MSc student starting in summer/fall 2027 to quantify links between fire regime, canopy type, and ecosystem nitrogen balance in boreal forests. See ad below for details.
4
8
226
Inspired by @nspector4’s post this morning. In 1999 I moved to Idaho for grad school. When asked “what does it mean to be Canadian” I gave it some thought. The two cultures are very much alike, though I acknowledge there are some important differences. We more or less watch the same TV, eat the same food, drive the same cars, etc. I remembered an old quote apparently from Trudeau Sr. about living next to the US is like sleeping next to an elephant, and no matter how benign you feel every twitch and grunt. Vancouverites back then drove to Bellingham for cheap gas and milk and we’ve always had snowbirds. Vacationing in the US was 2nd nature and we treated the border like a brief inconvenience. Yeah we had the CBC and they had NPR but we really weren’t that different save all the guns and military and a different day for thanksgiving. I realized that one of the ways Canadians differentiated themselves was that while all this travel and purchasing and consuming in and from the US was going on they still had this smug satisfaction that they were “better” than Americans somehow. I lived in the US for 23 years and came to realize that Americans really didn’t think about Canadians very much. Canadians were friendly people to the north and they had some really nice national parks and expensive milk and apparently cheap healthcare? This all became a bit embarrassing with time. What does it say about Canadians if the key defining nature of their identity is a negative: “what makes us Canadian is that we aren’t American”? That’s kinda sad. But we can’t stop. All this “elbows up” nonsense is nonsense. In a bar fight, if you get beat to hell, is it enough to lie there and say “yeah, but at least I’m not American”? Sometimes I think we really are not a serious country.
1
2
3
94
“If writing accurately about what the courts are doing risks undermining confidence in the judiciary, the problem is not the people who are reporting what is going on in the legal system. There is nothing mystical about judges that puts them above criticism.”
The Canadian Bar Association wants us, specifically @sarkonakj, to "disagree responsibly." And by that, she means, never criticizing a judge. No thanks. The CBA has far too much influence over our legal system, which it uses to advance a progressive political agenda. The CBA, like the courts we write about week in and week out, is not neutral. The CBA isn't engaging with our arguments to illustrate why they think we are misguided in our reasoning, they just don't want us to express these opinions in the first place. Here is our editorial from April when they first tried to advise us about what we should and shouldn't say. nationalpost.com/opinion/np-…
1
36
Bang on take from @kinsellawarren. Shout from the rooftops!
Carney's Liberals were right to walk away from the little we know of the "deal." Poilievre's Conservatives are right to want to know what was in it. Lewis' New Democrats are nowhere to be seen, and no one can be bothered to send out a search party to locate them. #cdnpoli
1
302
AI has ended the term paper and the take-home exam.
1
55
This is a category error. A professional certificate teaching health workers how to critically evaluate, govern, and use AI in clinical systems is not the same thing as students outsourcing their assignments to ChatGPT. One is workforce literacy (including ethics and Indigenous data sovereignty) for a public system already drowning in data. The other is academic dishonesty. Conflating them lets the “AI has no place in universities” claim stay standing. They are not the same problem.
Today @pinglamjoeip and I argue in University Affairs that university obsession with AI is a symptom of the chronic disease in higher ed Universities as nothing more than an arsenal for private businesses and government I give you the perfect example: ualberta.ca/en/graduate-prog…
4
97
Robert Froese retweeted
Not long ago, being a Republican was associated with intelligence even while being conservative was not. Now, both are negatively correlated with intelligence.
215
176
56
3,029
303,126
Robert Froese retweeted
"LLM answers sound right—the machine provides confident prose—but to get the correct answer, you would need to know to press it in ways that are not obvious to most people." Exactly. When LLMs are wrong, they’re wrong in ways that are so subtle and slick, and that sound so confident and competent, that it’s VERY hard not to fall for them. You have to slow down and read carefully to realize that you’re looking at non sequiturs or incoherent verbiage. And often you need a lot of background knowledge to call out their bullshit. substacktools.com/sharex/ghB…
3
12
2,729
This ⬇️
Canada’s oil should be used as a carrot, not a stick, in trade negotiations. We would never cut off flows to USA for the following reasons: 1. We have nowhere to store it and nowhere else to ship it (bc of lack of pipelines). So we would just have to stop production, losing revenues, royalties and taxes, and probably damage wells. It would be as economically painful for us as for them. 2. There are already three global oil crises happening right now (Hormuz, Russia and Bab el-Mandab). Curtailing millions of barrels of Canadian crude would compound that and be very bad for everyone that uses oil, ie. everyone in the world. 3. This is a geopolitical moment for Canada to lean into its reliability and trustworthiness as a trade partner, and we will reap rewards from that reputation. Weaponizing our oil and minerals - as our adversaries do - would have all sorts of negative repercussions for future trade. Even floating it creates risk. That’s why Smith and Moe kiboshed it immediately. 4. Cutting off oil is about 1000x more serious than taking booze off of shelves. Right now Canada has the moral high ground in this dispute. Cut off energy (and fertilizer) and all the good will we have earned from the majority of Americans would evaporate.
2
72
The pathetic is self inflicted. I don’t think we talk a good game though. The only response to strength is strength. If we wanted to be strong, we’d build pipelines fast and straight to the port with the shortest shipping route to overseas customers.
Replying to @jengerson
I can't even be really angry at the Americans anymore. The pathetic is self-inflicted. We talk a good game; but ultimately this government is just Trudeau with a (marginally) better comms strategy. It's all symbolism. We're choosing weakness for ourselves.
2
58
Robert Froese retweeted
I can't even be really angry at the Americans anymore. The pathetic is self-inflicted. We talk a good game; but ultimately this government is just Trudeau with a (marginally) better comms strategy. It's all symbolism. We're choosing weakness for ourselves.
32
18
9
174
22,588
Is it me, or does this sound a lot like a certain US President? “They’ve been treating us very poorly. We don’t need their oil. They should pay us for the privilege of us letting their benefits in.”
We’ve just signed a landmark, multi-billion-dollar agreement with the federal government that sets BC on a generational path to prosperity.   For too long, British Columbia hasn’t received our fair share. But today, that is changing.
2
38
“We let it persist because we don’t see its costs—or we’re weirdly proud of them.” Something I didn’t appreciate until I left Canada for 20 years to live and work in the US. It’s absolutely true, and inexplicable.
This whole episode is an example of what @reihan calls “punitive egalitarianism.” We let it persist because we don’t see its costs—or we’re weirdly proud of them. As @tylercowen has observed, one of the main reasons why Canada has less inequality than the U.S. is because we export inequality there. If Musk had stayed and created his companies in Canada, our Gini co-efficient would be higher. But so would our employment, incomes and national wealth.
1
1
74
Or maybe not? Perhaps it’s an example of luxury beliefs, sensu @robkhenderson. Or not, as I’ve witnessed many lower income Canadians vigorously defend supply management.
2
24
Robert Froese retweeted
Great milestone from Cameco who have just surpassed $5 billion in spending on northern and Indigenous businesses in SK. As a young researcher, I went on my first mine tour to Rabbit Lake in 2005 and saw first hand what good industry-community relations could look like. No one had ever taught me at university it was even possible. Cameco was a front runner and continues to be an industry leader in Indigenous/local relations 👏 cameconorth.com/partnerships…
5
27
2
191
10,835
“Panic is a poor guide for public policy. Focusing on innovation, adaptation, and economic development can do far more to help both people and the climate—at a fraction of the cost.”
20 years ago, An Inconvenient Truth put climate change at the center of global debate, shaping politics, influencing leaders, and inspiring a generation of activists. Two decades later, we can assess not just its impact, but its accuracy. Many of the film’s most alarming predictions did not materialize, while many of the policies it inspired have proven costly and ineffective. The lesson? Panic is a poor guide for public policy. Focusing on innovation, adaptation, and economic development can do far more to help both people and the climate—at a fraction of the cost. financialpost.com/opinion/bj…
1
30
Quoting @chrisbrunet on the 3 new UAlberta Medicine tenured prof positions (1 open to all, 2 restricted to self-identified women/gender minorities): @AndieWinnipeg Your Edmonton Journal column and reply to @jkenney claim modest 2019–2023 EDI shifts at U of A prove “little evidence of EDI hiring policy in practice.” This misses key realities of how such policies operate in low-turnover academia. 1/6
The University of Alberta (@UAlberta) just posted 3 new jobs for tenured professors of medicine For 1 of the jobs, anyone may apply For the other 2 slots, applications are restricted to "persons who self-identify as a woman and/or gender minority" @jkenney @ABDanielleSmith
1
115
In Medicine — where competence directly impacts lives — @jkenney’s distinction is correct. Open merit-based competition for all qualified candidates should be the standard. Restricted postings create per-competition inequities (excluding strong applicants from 2/3 of the openings) without producing transformative demographic change. 5/6
1
1
32
U of A’s move away from strong identity-based restrictions toward “Access, Community & Belonging” is a prudent step for maintaining excellence. Aggregate data and specific postings together show why rhetoric outpaced results — and why fully open, merit-focused hiring is the better path. 6/6
26