Russell Funk (@russellfunk) profile picture

Russell Funk is a professor at the University of Minnesota's Carlson School of Management, where he studies information and communication networks.

Minneapolis, MN
Joined January 2011
Photo by Russell Funk (@russellfunk)Photo by Russell Funk (@russellfunk)Photo by Russell Funk (@russellfunk)Photo by Russell Funk (@russellfunk)Photo by Russell Funk (@russellfunk)Photo by Russell Funk (@russellfunk)Photo by Russell Funk (@russellfunk)
For anyone following our 2023 disruption paper—at our request, Nature has released the peer review file for Holst et al.’s Comment and our Reply. Reviews of the Comment were not shared with our team during review. Both sets are now public. nature.com/articles/s41586-0…
5
7
1,649
New blog post (link below): 👉 LLMs Are Proof That Unix Won 👈 A short exegesis on the Unix philosophy & why LLMs finally proved that "text reigns supreme." I've been using Unix-like OSes for the better part of my life now, and I love that these concepts are "vindicated." 1/2
2
1
5
520
Sergi says his citation-weighted index made the decline disappear. What he doesn't tell you: his own measure—and his own analysis—show the decline. We implemented his index as defined in his Eq. (3) and ran it in SciSciNet and PubMed. It falls as much or more than ours in both.
Replying to @svalver
In 2023, @ralexbentley , @BlaiVidiella , colleagues, and I reanalysed these data. One obvious problem was scale. Publications & citations grow approximately exponentially, while the annual CD5 average gives equal weight to papers with very different impacts.
1
1
1
655
A further point on the data source: nitter.cf/russellfunk/status/208…
Also worth noting the finding in the Bentley–Valverde reanalysis @svalver keeps promoting is explained by a misattributed data source in their published paper. Not citation inflation. Not their adjustment. The paper describes its data as "the same dataset" as ours. It is not.
65
Also worth noting the finding in the Bentley–Valverde reanalysis @svalver keeps promoting is explained by a misattributed data source in their published paper. Not citation inflation. Not their adjustment. The paper describes its data as "the same dataset" as ours. It is not.
1
1
3
303
The weighting their paper adds changes nothing. On their own data, it correlates with the plain CD index at r = 0.97. We ran the comparison their paper never did, and we sent it to them in March 2024. nitter.cf/russellfunk/status/208…
Sergi says his citation-weighted index made the decline disappear. What he doesn't tell you: his own measure—and his own analysis—show the decline. We implemented his index as defined in his Eq. (3) and ran it in SciSciNet and PubMed. It falls as much or more than ours in both.
2
170
@svalver spent the weekend combing our paper's open peer-review file. Good, that's what transparency is for. Will they release the reviews of their reanalysis? Were they asked to show their result correlates 0.97 w/ ours? Critics owe their work the scrutiny they demand of others.
1
91
The critics of our 2023 paper have posted an unreviewed FAQ on our exchange. The reviewed record is the two papers Nature published together as a pair—rerun with their own dataset, metric, exclusions, and regression model, the decline persists, and their own regression shows it.
1
1
252
Their FAQ also gives an account of the 32-month editorial process — one that inverts the record. The delays it attributes to our team, and the transparency concerns it raises, run in the other direction, as the correspondence documents in detail.
1
133
That correspondence was confidential and mediated by Nature, and we intend to respect that, so we have reached out to Nature's editorial team on how to proceed before saying more here. The Reply: doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-1… Thread: nitter.cf/russellfunk/status/208…
1/ In 2023, we showed in Nature that science and technology are becoming less disruptive. Evidence of declining disruptiveness now appears in nearly 100 studies. Today, Nature publishes our reply to a critique by Holst et al. Their own analysis corroborates our finding.🧵
167
A note for anyone following our 2023 Nature paper on declining disruptiveness. Nature published a Comment by Holst et al. alongside our peer-reviewed Reply. But the Comment's page gives no sign a Reply exists, and the shared PDF opens on the Comment, with the Reply at the end.
1
1
2
590
The practical effect is several journalists have written to me for comment unaware that a Reply exists at all, and some coverage has presented only one half of the exchange. Nature's editors have been responsive and are working on a fix.
1
91
Until then, the Reply is here: doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-1…—using the Comment's own dataset, metric, exclusions, and regression model, a large and substantively meaningful decline remains. Summary with figures: nitter.cf/russellfunk/status/208…
1/ In 2023, we showed in Nature that science and technology are becoming less disruptive. Evidence of declining disruptiveness now appears in nearly 100 studies. Today, Nature publishes our reply to a critique by Holst et al. Their own analysis corroborates our finding.🧵
96