ScotFax (@scotfax) header
ScotFax (@scotfax) profile picture

Phil MacDonald, fact checking nationalist claims. Not affiliated to https://nitter.cf/t.co/EsLVGb2OCq, it’s just a bloody marvellous website. Go have a look.

Glorious Aberdeenshire
Joined March 2017
Photo by ScotFax (@scotfax)Photo by ScotFax (@scotfax)Photo by ScotFax (@scotfax)Photo by ScotFax (@scotfax)Photo by ScotFax (@scotfax)Photo by ScotFax (@scotfax)Photo by ScotFax (@scotfax)Photo by ScotFax (@scotfax)Photo by ScotFax (@scotfax)Photo by ScotFax (@scotfax)
The counterfactual oil fund. Why it’s a mirage. In 1980 I borrowed £100 at the 1 year gilt rate. I invested it in the FTSE-all share. Today it’s worth £12,600 after the loan repayment. It’s easy to ‘magic’ money with hindsight.
2
3
5
989
ScotFax retweeted
standing charges are bad - unless they’ve been removed by “Westminster” in which case they were good? 🤦🏻‍♂️
11
27
1
119
4,695
ScotFax retweeted
I’m demanding a stronger Royal Navy. You wish to dismantle Britain’s defences. You have zero interest in military matters. I think we’ll leave it to others to decide who is more ridiculous.
Nothing more ridiculous than a tired Unionist trying to sound robust on defence when they said this just two weeks ago.
96
365
5
3,028
56,745
ScotFax retweeted
Nothing more ridiculous than the SNP trying to sound robust on defence when its policy for defending a separate Scotland is a white flag and a loudspeaker saying ‘we surrender’ in Russian 🤣
Always ready to remind Reform.
103
318
13
2,568
106,428
ScotFax retweeted
RIP Patrick Stewart 🤍
48
351
34
3,271
199,742
OK once more for the slow @weegingerdug at the back. THE MARKETS WONT LET SCOTLAND USE OR PEG TO STERLING. What part don’t you understand?
This is beyond parody. Nationalists having failed yet again to come up with a coherent currency policy tell us all ‘it doesn’t matter’. A 20-30% overnight loss of your income if you are a retired nurse does matter. These people are genuinely nasty.
1
4
12
621
Because other independence movements aren’t terrified of answering the question. What’s the currency going to be?
Scotland is the only country whose independence campaign has been dogged by questions over currency, Paul Kavanagh writes ✍️
2
1
258
Don’t ask permission and try to hold one and the civil service will refuse.
The SNP Government should stop asking for permission to hold another independence referendum, a Scottish political commentator has said. #SNP #Independence #Scotland #News4Scotland #TheScotlandChannel
1
1
10
496
ScotFax retweeted
I would respond to Tim directly, but he unblocked me to send that reply, and then immediately blocked me again. I wonder why?
1
11
1
41
1,626
ScotFax retweeted
Taking inspiration from Emma Harper, SNP councillor Roza Salih has solved the intractable currency problem.
Replying to @ScotNational
Scotland already has its own banknotes, so we could simply carry on printing our own money if we became independent? We can set our own central bank if we have the powers. That’s it simple.
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Scottish banknotes are issued by commercial banks under UK law and fully backed by Bank of England assets, not sovereign currency. An independent Scotland would require new institutions and arrangements for any currency or central bank, per official proposals. bankofengland.co.uk/banknotes/scot… ukfinance.org.uk/CCBI/scotland-… gov.scot/publications/b…
25
58
4
299
9,896
ScotFax retweeted
As an independent country, Scotland would have to put up with energy bills soaring higher still, and budget cuts that would make a £5 billion black hole look like a trifling matter.
As an independent country, Scotland would not have to put up with soaring energy bills and more Budget cuts. We would ensure our wealth works for the people who live here, not Westminster.
10
21
1
79
2,192
ScotFax retweeted
Swinney’s failure to support Rosebank is not simply about emissions. Rosebank is 20% owned by Ithaca Energy, which in turn is controlled by Delek Group - an Israeli company. Swinney cannot support Rosebank without enraging the boycott Israel people. And he is terrified of them.
7
51
178
3,746
CURRENCY is the lever. Nationalists constantly talk about how independence gives us the LEVERS over the economy. What they actually means is currency and monetary policy. Now they tell us it’s just irrelevant. These people are idiots.
This is beyond parody. Nationalists having failed yet again to come up with a coherent currency policy tell us all ‘it doesn’t matter’. A 20-30% overnight loss of your income if you are a retired nurse does matter. These people are genuinely nasty.
3
7
382
Honestly @weegingerdug if it’s baseless how come your entire movement can’t answer it and haven’t been able to for generations.
This is beyond parody. Nationalists having failed yet again to come up with a coherent currency policy tell us all ‘it doesn’t matter’. A 20-30% overnight loss of your income if you are a retired nurse does matter. These people are genuinely nasty.
5
12
1
35
1,290
Independence will devalue your wages and pensions. YOU YES YET?
4
21
66
1,240
nitter.cf/RozaSalih/status/21154… This is not intentional comedy.
unavailable
2
13
522
This is beyond parody. Nationalists having failed yet again to come up with a coherent currency policy tell us all ‘it doesn’t matter’. A 20-30% overnight loss of your income if you are a retired nurse does matter. These people are genuinely nasty.
18
21
3
74
3,999
Please stop WHATEVER you are doing and take one minute to digest the single greatest moment of white savior petard hoisting ever witnessed during Black History Month. The pay off is commensurate of a Scottish civil service cover up NDA cheque.
100
319
25
1,624
115,221
ScotFax retweeted
Excellent use of an archive clip.
So do the SNP support moving standing charges into the unit price - or not?
4
45
1
232
8,581
ScotFax retweeted
This was the moment Barack Obama broke Donald Trump. It was so bad that Trump has not experienced one second of joy since then.
913
3,966
239
23,619
1,630,081
ScotFax retweeted
If independence was so good, these questions would be easy to answer. The reality is that it takes Olympic levels of mental gymnastics to come up with a half baked plan which is debunked within minutes of its release 🤦‍♂️
6
5
24
917