spv (@shalinispv) profile picture

A speck of dust on the sands of time.

Joined February 2014
Photo by spv (@shalinispv)Photo by spv (@shalinispv)Photo by spv (@shalinispv)Photo by spv (@shalinispv)Photo by spv (@shalinispv)Photo by spv (@shalinispv)Photo by spv (@shalinispv)
I decided to audit Audrey Truschke's recent book - India: 5,000 years of History, with AI. Through this exercise I wanted to see if Audrey was actually biased. The goal was to: 1. Check citations for accuracy. 2. Find patterns in her bias and discretions, if any. Both are hard to do by hand, but easily verified if the work is done by AI. I classified the inaccurate ones into 4 levels. Severity 1 and 2 are nitpicks and minor mistakes, that don't hide or change anything that the primary source says. But severity 3 is if the sentence changes the meaning of what the source says. For example, if a monastery is said to be "sacked", but the source says that the monks were killed. Severity 4 is where it's an omission or her cited source says the opposite. For example, she says that Akbar banned enslaving war captives. But her cited source says that the war captives could be enslaved, but not their families. And here's the headline result in this screenshot: 1. Of her 2,310 endnotes, I checked about 1807 because that's what sources were available to me. 2. About 68% of the notes were accurate. But that's a very low number. 3. There are 185 serious finding of severity 3 and 4. This is material omission or serious change in what her source says. 4. Almost 200 findings where she says the exact opposite of what her source says! Of these 12 are at severity 4 and 46 are at severity 3. Clearly, Audrey hasn't paid much attention to detail in this work. Keep watching this space - I'll be tweeting out more examples of my findings!
161
1,127
76
3,358
87,570
Matangi, India's first AI-powered autonomous unmanned surface vessel developed by Sagar Defence Engineering, a Pune based startup founded by former merchant navy officer Capt. Nikunj Parashar! Amazing development 💪
37
1
124
4,339
Launching Samvaad Manch - the Hindu Parenting Conversation Forum. ONLINE 1st session 21 November 5 pm IST Register using the QR code to join Topic: Vivaah - Understanding Love, Compatibility and Marriage. A conversation on how we can support young people in finding partners and building dharmik unions. Hindu families need a space to discuss issues, share ideas and navigate the complex modern world while staying anchored in civilisational values. We are enabling a Hindu space for social problem solving. Participation by registration only. All age groups are welcome.
2
1
227
Balanced review, no subversion agenda, takes artistic liberties based on today's society. Use it as an opening or introduction to spark curiosity - - everything I have been saying from the beginning. youtu.be/RjgPC_KWJKU?si=U0Fi…
1
3
19
807
FINALLY!! FINALLY!! A World leader had the stones to destroy Trumps Ego, live on camera, to his face. That Leader was MODI ji of 🇮🇳 After Modi RESPECTED India's Flag, He disrespected the U.S. president in a way that the tension was so thick you could feel it. I think you can hear them now, Trump @realDonaldTrump From beginning to end, This Rocks! 🇮🇳💪 @narendramodi @DrSJaishankar @SecRubio Modi knows that he will lead India for another 10 years or more, and the guy standing next to him will be irrelevant very soon. Maybe Trump realized today some mistakes he made in his 2.0? Whether Trump gets it or not, I will say that today the people all over the world got it. Modi doesn't play games when it comes to Respect for Bharat. #provemewrong
737
5,242
169
27,760
2,161,805
A child can know every detail of the Valmiki Ramayana and still feel embarrassed about being Hindu. That is hardly a victory. Joy, confidence and pride should be our starting point. Sarcasm and scolding cannot inspire, and constant negativity does not attract the young. hinduparenting.substack.com/…
5
14
546
Isha Foundation (run by Sadhguru), and its volunteers have cleaned up and rejuvenated an abandoned 450 year old Rudra Devaru Kalyani in Chikkaballapura. @narendramodi @ishafoundation
34
582
19
3,444
49,933
For Thai people Ramayan is a compulsory school project. For Indians it is Mughal dynasties. Imagine the most ancient civilization being deprived of education in its own stories.
คนอินเดียอาจจะงงๆ ทำไมคนไทยไฮป์รามายณะ คือคนไทยโตมากับบทเรียนภาคบังคับที่สอนให้อ่านเรื่องรามเกียรติ์ ที่ดัดแปลงมาจากรามายณะ เลยจะมีความคุ้นเคยและผูกพันกับเรื่องราวของรามายณะไปด้วย พอมีหนังฟอร์มยักษ์ที่นำเสนอเรื่องราวที่คุ้นเคยและผูกพัน เลยจะอินและเอ็นจอยไปกับเรื่องได้ง่ายเป็นพิเศษ
28
890
10
3,768
48,528
Many mistakes. Does not include the variety of pre-Christian faiths in Europe (Celts, Druids, other so-called “Pagans”). Reason: those religions were destroyed by Christianity, so it’s best to pretend they never existed. Wicca listed as very recent when in fact was pre-Christian.
Oldest Religions in the World 🌎 1. 🇮🇳 Hinduism — c. 2300 BCE 2. 🇮🇱 Judaism — c. 2000 BCE 3. 🇮🇷 Zoroastrianism — c. 1500 BCE 4. 🇮🇳 Jainism — c. 600 BCE 5. 🇨🇳 Taoism — c. 600 BCE 6. 🇮🇳 Buddhism — c. 563 BCE 7. 🇨🇳 Confucianism — c. 551 BCE 8. 🇯🇵 Shinto — c. 300 BCE 9. 🇮🇱 Christianity — c. 30 CE 10. 🇮🇶 Mandaeism — c. 1st century CE 11. 🇮🇷 Manichaeism — c. 240 CE 12. 🇸🇦 Islam — 610 CE 13. 🇱🇧 Druze — 1017 CE 14. 🇮🇶 Yazidism — c. 12th century CE 15. 🇮🇷 Yarsanism — c. 14th century CE 16. 🇮🇳 Sikhism — 1469 CE 17. 🇮🇳 Ayyavazhi — 1833 CE 18. 🇯🇵 Tenrikyo — 1838 CE 19. 🇰🇷 Cheondoism — 1860 CE 20. 🇮🇷 Bahá'í Faith — 1863 CE 21. 🇻🇳 Cao Dai — 1926 CE 22. 🇯🇲 Rastafari — 1930 CE 23. 🇺🇸 Scientology — 1953 CE 24. 🇬🇧 Wicca — 1954 CE 25. 🇫🇷 Raëlism — 1974 CE 📊 Source: Wikipedia, Britannica & World Atlas (founding dates).
31
461
5
1,506
37,893
My own reading is that the Ramayana travelled west from India to Greece by sea, and shaped Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey. Scholars have noticed the parallels for over a century. In both traditions a wife is carried off across the water, Sita by Ravana, king of Lanka, and Helen by Paris, prince of Troy. An army crosses the sea to bring her back, and an enemy city goes up in flames. Rama, like Odysseus, spends years wandering far from home, and in each story only the hero can string a great bow. Apart from the striking similarities in the story, both are laden with similes and metaphors in formulaic style, an inherited stock of ancient stories and familiar themes of morality. The likeliest route is Phoenician. In the tenth century BC Hiram of Tyre and Solomon sent ships to Ophir, which the historian Josephus placed in India, and they came home with gold, ivory, apes and peacocks. The Phoenicians who sailed those ships traded across the Greek world, and gave the Greeks their alphabet well before the time Homer’s poems were written down. The Ramayana sailed east too, onto the temple walls of Prambanan around 850 AD and Angkor Wat, and today’s King of Thailand reigns as Rama X.
I firmly disagree with your AIT premise as well as the premise that Greek epics influenced Indian. The facts are opposite. The evidence is overwhelming in support of Indian origin. I, too, am against those who valorize the past on the basis that: older is superior. That downplays the role of advancement and freezes a civilization in a museum. It undermines the role of smritis as vehicles for fresh development. However, that is a separate debate for a separate thread and should not hijack this one. The purpose of this thread is to show how I am using the Ramayana film as a door opener here in USA. Have held meaningful discussions in school/college settings in classics studies, to open and expand them with Indian classics. Getting a seat at the table is happening in the few cases where I pushed this strategy. It’s NOT about who is superior, but about giving young minds diverse ideas to consider. So far, Ram beats Odysseus in these small casual settings - as king, human role model. One topic that emerged spontaneously from the students: What if the US were run on similar principles? This makes the Ramayana a relevant socio political contribution to American society. But I don’t want to push the politics prematurely, until the topic of Ramayana is in the door, and then all sides should participate as equals. Mutual respect has brought my fragile efforts some humble success. The biggest threat is not the white folks, but those stupidly closed minded Hindus who can’t think strategically. Jai Shri Ram!
50
444
18
2,040
79,206
Imagine New Delhi becoming home to the world’s largest museum display area? Think scale. Think culture. That is the vision behind the Yuge Yugeen Bharat Museum! Today’s Cabinet decision will give impetus to transform historic North and South Block buildings into a magnificent celebration of Bharat’s civilisational journey. From ancient knowledge systems, mathematics and astronomy to architecture, art, languages and spirituality, the museum will bring thousands of years of our heritage to life through immersive experiences and world-class galleries. Buildings that have been centres of governance will now become a place where millions can discover, experience and celebrate the timeless richness of our civilisation. A historic new chapter for India’s cultural heritage! pib.gov.in/PressReleaseDetai…*
664
3,844
226
17,885
610,514
Taking the Civilizational Debate to the West
31
129
26
414
31,555
Tune in to Hindu Parenting Podcast #66 with Prof. Vamsee Juluri @VamseeJuluri On Media, Propaganda and how parents can bring in media literacy to educate and inform children Must-watch episode for Hindu parents! Listen till the end for great insights! @shalinispv youtu.be/XxC4dLf_0i8
1
1
5
1,239
Hindu Parenting wishes everyone a Shubh Deepavali!
3
40
797
IT'S HUGE! 🔥 It's a sea of people taking to the streets in Thrissur, raising their voices against the anarchy of the Congress and its alliance partners. A massive BJP rally led by @TheSureshGopi Ji, MP from Thrissur. The streets are witnessing a massive show of public participation! 🇮🇳 #ModiKahinNahiJayega
70
773
33
2,897
44,363
2026 Depression Collection
355
866
58
6,128
118,678
क्या वाल्मीकि आदिकवि नहीं हैं? वाल्मीकि आदिकवि नहीं थे, ऐसा एक नवबौद्ध महोदय लिख रहे हैं। क्या सच में संस्कृत के आदिकवि वैदिक धर्मावलम्बी वाल्मीकि नहीं हैं अपितु बौद्ध धर्मावलम्बी अश्वघोष हैं? आइए जानते हैं।
39
564
7
1,615
36,777
Stop scrolling! Take a moment to listen to this beautiful bhajan in praise of Lord Rama. Save it/ listen now. Wishing all Astikas a blessed Ekadashi✨ Jai Shri Ram🚩
6
125
4
627
12,711
This is the best nursery rhyme I have ever heard! Download it and teach your little ones their ABCs through this beautiful devotional version. Their ABCD song will be so much better than the one we grew up with! 😊 Hats off to the creator for this wonderful initiative! 🙏
83
2,174
66
6,380
203,009