Simon Davies retweeted
Be in no doubt - this week's news on disgraced expert witness Peter Hindmarsh could collapse the entire case against Lucy Letby and lead to her acquittal.
As @drphilhammond says in my film here, the prosecution likely did NOT have a strong enough case without him. (1/8)
Simon Davies retweeted
"Christopher Morris talks about one of the most significant British legal cases of the 21st Century"
Thrilled that @CPMorris1234 will be discussing his book about Lucy Letby with @johnsweeneyroar at the Oxford Literary Festival: oxfordliteraryfestival.org/l…
Simon Davies retweeted
“The Government must urgently prioritise reforms, without jeopardising the UK’s reputation for stability and respect for the rule of law.” @RFAssociation
You are playing your part in @FleeceholdPlay just as predicted.
SHAME ON YOU ❗️❗️
@AngelaRayner @mtpennycook #LeaseholdScandal
Simon Davies retweeted
A new FOI response reveals that the statistical analysis behind the flawed roster chart used in court in the Lucy Letby case was done by a police analyst. It's astonishing that neither the police nor the CPS recognised the need to employ a qualified statistician.
Simon Davies retweeted
This is beyond astonishing bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm5y…
and surely grounds for an appeal, even if there weren't any others.
Simon Davies retweeted
This is momentous!
At the start of our National Leasehold Campaign the 2003 Commonhold legislation was a dead duck and reinvigoration not on any political agenda.
We knew that #leasehold couldnt be killed off without a viable, workable alternative.
The Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill might just provide that, and I am pleased @mtpennycook
kept his promise to present the Bill before Christmas.
Now the real work begins for MPs to ensure those devilly details are not watered down in the wrong direction.
@NLC_2019
@LKPleasehold
💥💥EYE NEWSFLASH! Government unveils sweeping leasehold reforms as campaigners celebrate and industry backlash erupts
Campaigners want affordable routes out of leasehold. Investors want protection for existing contracts. Agents and conveyancers need clarity about how the changes will affect transactions.
For leaseholders, however, tonight’s announcement represents a significant step towards ending a system that has shaped property ownership for centuries.
@propertyjourno
propertyindustryeye.com/eye-…
Simon Davies retweeted
Without fail, every time something of vital importance emerges that undermines any aspect of the prosecution’s case in the Lucy Letby trial, we can be sure the reactions of guilters will follow the same predictable pattern, and here we go again with the latest Guardian article: skipping the actual content, attacking the writers, claiming they’re hunting for a scandal, and inaccurately bringing in the Helen Webberley issue. Same playbook every time - take something major and try to shrink it to nothing. If you actually engage with the substance of the article, this is why it matters to Hindmarsh’s credibility as an expert witness:
1. It’s not a trans issue: Dr Hindmarsh made a completely unrelated complaint about Helen Webberley in 2016. It has absolutely nothing to do with the 2022–23 actions by GOSH and UCLH, which were strictly about patient safety in his core specialty: managing insulin and blood sugar in children.
2. Hospitals raised alarms over insulin safety before and during the trial: GOSH terminated his contract in July 2022, four months before he testified. He didn't clarify this on the stand. Then, while the trial was still active in early 2023, UCLH barred him from treating patients over safety risks involving paediatric insulin and diabetes management, before a GMC tribunal put him under supervision.
3. The clinical concerns directly mirror his trial testimony: UCLH flagged that he was "over-focusing on rare causes of hypoglycaemia" - the exact same bias critics point to in his trial evidence, where common clinical explanations were dismissed in favour of poisoning.
4. At trial, immunoassay results were treated as definitive proof of poisoning without flagging their reliability issues, despite Hindmarsh telling a family in his own practice that an insulin-related test was an "erroneous, fallible test."
5. None of the above was disclosed to the jury. Instead he was described as “the pre -eminent expert” in insulin. With no physical evidence of tampered bags, the jury took his judgment on trust, so keeping them and the defence in the dark about his clinical ban is a major failure of process.
Simon Davies retweeted
Let's not forget that Professor Hindmarsh came up with the unproven sticky insulin theory, which he admitted was based on no research whatsoever, and additionally was well outside his field of expertise.
Yes, insulin does stick to IV bags and tubing which practitioners need to be aware of, but scientifically it can be shown that it doesn't unstick in the presence of a dextrose solution - a fact that as a paediatric endocrinologist Hindmarsh would not have known. His testimony on this should be thrown out.
Yet the prosecution relied on this in order to show how Letby could have been responsible for Baby L's insulin poisoning for the period of a day and a half, when she was off-duty and new "uncontaminated" dextrose bags were hung.
But Hindmarsh even admitted in cross-examination that his hypoglycaemia calculations would have required more insulin added to the new bags over this period (that Letby wasn't there), something the prosecution made no attempt to explain.
I've also pointed out that the giving set was undoubtedly changed with the next bag change after Letby went off-duty, so the theory is completely irrelevant anyway.
For a longer read on this ⬇️
nitter.cf/JabesAllowed/status/20…
1/3
Baby L And The Flawed Case of Alleged Insulin Poisoning
Following on from my previous post, here I will debunk the "sticky insulin" theory proposed by Professor Hindmarsh, which was endorsed by Nick Johnson KC as the sole explanation for Baby L’s persistent hypoglycaemia after Lucy Letby had gone off shift.
I will also argue that this undermines the allegation of insulin poisoning at any point in the case of Baby L.
See the attached chart for a visual representation of Baby L’s blood glucose readings over the relevant period, set against the timing of dextrose bag changes and other key events.
The prosecution alleged that Lucy Letby injected insulin into multiple bags of dextrose solution on 9th April, resulting in a 53-hour hypoglycaemic episode.
But there was a major problem with this allegation. The hypoglycaemic episode, which Professor Hindmarsh attributed to exogenous insulin, continued for nearly two days after Lucy Letby had gone off duty. During that period, two new dextrose bags were hung which she could not have poisoned. The only insulin blood test done was on 9th April.
How, then, could the prosecution attribute the continuing hypoglycaemia to alleged insulin poisoning by Lucy Letby?
Nick Johnson KC relied on Professor Hindmarsh’s sticky insulin theory. According to Hindmarsh, insulin from a spiked dextrose bag, which had stuck to the plastic inner surface of the giving set, could later be released into the dextrose infusion after a new, uncontaminated bag was connected.
(A giving set is the sterile tubing that connects an infusion bag to a cannula or long line; trial testimony indicated that it isn't necessarily changed when a dextrose bag is replaced.)
No calculations — in fact, no figures of any kind — were provided to support this suggested mechanism. Aside from the obvious flaws in the theory itself, it also depended on the giving set not being changed through two bag changes - something that was never established.
Here, I will show that not only is the sticky insulin theory scientifically invalid, it’s also inapplicable, because the giving set definitely was changed when a new dextrose bag was hung after Lucy Letby had gone home.
Firstly, a quick run-through of the key events:
9th April 2016
(See chart for the timings of the dextrose bags and blood glucose readings.)
Lucy Letby was accused of spiking 3 bags with insulin on 9th April, though she was not Baby L’s designated nurse; there was no evidence that she actually did so.
Baby L (and his twin Baby M) had been born on the morning of the previous day, 8th April, and he was receiving dextrose to bring his blood glucose levels up. By midnight, a normal reading of 3.6 was recorded.
The allegation was that Lucy Letby spiked this dextrose bag the next day, 9th April, at some point between starting shift at 7.30am and 9.30am. This would have been while it was hanging, which is implausible in itself, especially as Letby wasn't his designated nurse on that day.
This was Bag #1.
At 10am Baby L’s blood glucose reading was low at 1.9, and this is where the 53-hour hypoglycaemic episode identified by Professor Hindmarsh began.
Bag #1 was replaced at midday on 9th April, after having been in use for the standard 24 hours. The replacement bag was hung by Lucy Letby and Mary Griffith, Baby L's designated nurse.
This was Bag #2. The prosecution alleged that Lucy Letby also poisoned this bag, though no explanation was given as to how or when.
At some point before 3.45pm (the exact timing was uncertain), a blood sample was taken and sent to Liverpool for insulin testing. Several days later, the results came back showing a high insulin level alongside low C-peptide — findings associated with the presence of exogenous insulin. This formed the basis of the allegation that Lucy Letby had poisoned Baby L with artificial insulin.
At 4.30pm that same day, the dextrose bag was changed again, this time to a more concentrated 12.5% dextrose solution. This bag was hung by Belinda Williamson (Simcock) and Ashleigh Hudson.
This was Bag #3. The prosecution alleged that Lucy Letby also poisoned this bag with insulin after it had been hung, though again no explanation was provided as to how or when.
Throughout this period, Baby L continued to record abnormally low blood glucose readings.
Lucy Letby finished her shift on 9th April at 8pm, remaining for another hour or so to complete her nursing notes. This was her fourth consecutive day of work following which she was then off duty for several days.
10th – 11th April 2016
In the early hours of 10th April, at around 2.30am, the dextrose bag was changed again, this time to a 15% dextrose solution.
This was Bag #4. The prosecution did not allege that Lucy Letby poisoned this bag as she had already been off shift for several hours by then. Nevertheless, low blood glucose levels continued at roughly the same level throughout the night and into the following morning.
From this point onwards the only explanation given for the continuing hypoglycaemia was the sticky insulin theory: that insulin from the previous bag, Bag #3, had stuck to the inner surface of the giving set and was now being released into the infusion.
There was a further bag – Bag #5 – hung up 24 hours later on 11th April; the low blood glucose readings persisted but later in the day spontaneously returned to a normal level.
To summarise:
1.We have a 53-hour hypoglycaemic episode, identified by Professor Hindmarsh, running from 10am on 9th April 2016 until 3pm on 11th April.
2.Professor Hindmarsh had no explanation for this episode other than the presence of exogenous insulin throughout the entire period.
3.Lucy Letby was only on shift during the first day, 9th April, until 8pm.
4.On 9th April there were three different dextrose bags in use, all of which the prosecution alleged Lucy Letby had poisoned.
5.Two further bags were hung in the early hours of 10th and 11th April, producing no marked change in glucose levels until the afternoon of 11th April.
6.Since Lucy Letby could not physically have poisoned those last two bags, Professor Hindmarsh relied on the sticky insulin theory to explain the continuing hypoglycaemia.
Evidence that the giving Set WAS changed
If it could be proven that the giving set was changed with Bag #4 then that would nullify the sticky insulin theory, wouldn't it?
Well, it can be proven, because prior to Bag #4 being hung there was a long line put in by Dr A specifically to be used with the next dextrose bag. And when a long line is connected up a new, sterile giving set is always used to prevent infection!
This is well known and there's no doubt about it. There was even trial testimony confirming this practice from two nurses, in relation to the stock bag used for Baby F. Dr Sandie Bohin also confirmed it.
Dr A’s reason for inserting the long line was that he was intending to increase the dextrose concentration to 15%, which is above the maximum level of 12.5% which can be infused through a catheter, which is what had been used up to then.
The long line was put in at around 1am on 10th April, and following this Bag #4 was hung at 2.30am. (See chart – the timing of the long line insertion is shown as blue line.)
Therefore, the sticky insulin theory — that "stuck" insulin was being released from the giving set after Bag #4 was hung — cannot possibly account for the continuation of hypoglycaemia after this bag-change event, because the giving set previously used was no longer in place!
The prosecution’s case that this mechanism explained the continuing hypoglycaemia is completely invalid.
References:
Dr A’s medical notes from that night which refer to the long line can be seen here at page 2 (he was cyphered as Dr U at Thirlwall):
thirlwall.public-inquiry.uk/…
The long line insertion was also brought up in his Thirlwall Inquiry oral testimony (see pages 223–226):
thirlwall.public-inquiry.uk/…
And it was also reported by the Chester Standard’s live trial reporting at the time (see entry at 12.13pm):
chesterstandard.co.uk/news/2…
Simon Davies retweeted
With each new jaw-dropping revelation about Lucy Letby's shambolic trial, more people have to entertain genuinely terrifying thoughts:
What if she was totally innocent all along?
Could that happen to someone I love?
Could that happen to me?
theguardian.com/uk-news/2026…
Simon Davies retweeted
"Lawyer calls for urgent review of Letby convictions after expert witness revelations"
"Failure to disclose Peter Hindmarsh's exclusion from practice raises 'fundamental questions' over nurse's case"
✍️ More from @david_conn & @lawrencefelic: theguardian.com/uk-news/2026…
Simon Davies retweeted
I'll tell you about "respect for the law". The law has allowed leaseholders to be ripped off for decades..... enough is enough.
Stop hiding behind the law. The law is changing 💪💪💪
You really are sounding pathetic RFA🎻🎻
Simon Davies retweeted
💥A momentous moment 💥
The Commonhold & Leasehold Reform Bill first reading in parliament.
Second reading Monday 23rd November 👏👏
#GetCommonholdDone #Leasehold #LeaseholdersTogther
Simon Davies retweeted
Okay. Well since you asked... Buckle up.
Our poisoned chalice of Right to Manage.
"Well, have you thought about Right to Manage (RTM)?" I get asked this so many times, and with good intentions.
So you're struggling with excessive service charges and poor management, so why not? I've put off addressing it because the situation with our building is considerably more complicated than it might first appear.
On the face of it, RTM sounds perfectly reasonable. Take control away from the housing association, appoint our own contractors, scrutinise expenditure and make decisions in the interests of the people who actually live here.
But what happens when the problem isn't simply poor management?
In our case, we'd be taking responsibility for a Grade II listed Victorian building with serious, longstanding problems involving the roof, recurrent issues with damp, the cellar and deteriorating original fabric. Problems that were never properly addressed when the building was converted into apartments and sold as modern homes.
And that's a crucial distinction. We bought modern conversions within an older building, reasonably assuming that the same diligence applied to the new accommodation had also been applied to the Victorian structure housing it.
The surveys commissioned by purchasers did not cover vast areas of the communal building. And therein lies another problem: the residential accommodation actually represents a relatively small proportion of the overall structure we're now financially responsible for maintaining.
The enormous roof, the cellars, the communal spaces and the original fabric all require maintenance, regardless of how much of the building is actually occupied by our homes.
When a surveyor visiting my flat candidly remarks that the building should never have been converted into homes in the first place, it raises some profoundly uncomfortable questions. Particularly when you consider how much of the original Victorian structure was left untouched.
These aren't simply routine maintenance issues. They're the legacy of a conversion that left enormous future liabilities embedded in the building itself.
And RTM wouldn't make any of those problems disappear.
We'd gain control over management, certainly, but we'd also inherit the responsibility for organising repairs, collecting service charges, managing contractors and finding the money to keep an increasingly expensive building functioning.
I can almost imagine the housing association rubbing its hands together.
"Go on then. Knock yourselves out. One less headache for us."
Of course, RTM wouldn't automatically absolve the housing association of existing legal obligations or liability for historic defects. But it could leave leaseholders carrying the practical and financial burden of managing problems they neither created nor knowingly agreed to inherit.
Worse still, it could turn neighbours against one another. Instead of challenging the housing association over unaffordable bills, we'd potentially find ourselves issuing those bills to each other.
We already experienced how difficult collective financial responsibility can be during our First-tier Tribunal case. Even raising the money for legal representation became a bone of contention. Many leaseholders who had signed up to challenge the freeholder simply didn't have the money readily available when it was needed.
That wasn't a lack of commitment. It was the financial reality of ordinary people already struggling with the costs of their homes.
Now imagine those same neighbours having to agree on, fund and administer potentially hundreds of thousands of pounds in future repairs.
RTM can be a valuable solution where the fundamental problem is inefficient or exploitative management.
But what if the fundamental problem is the building itself?
We didn't buy an unfinished restoration project. We bought what we believed were completed homes, with modest and manageable service charges.
Now we're being asked to finance the consequences of decisions made long before we understood what we'd inherited.
We can challenge the charges. We can fight over management. We can take control of the administration.
But none of that changes the condition of the building or the enormous cost of putting right what should arguably have been diligently addressed before the first flat was sold.
If anyone with relevant legal expertise feels they could help us navigate this predicament, or identify avenues we may not yet have explored, please do get in touch by DM. We would be genuinely grateful for any informed guidance.
Is @BBCNews going to be brave enough to dip their toe in the water, or is not "annoying the Establishment" a higher priority these days ?
"DOCTOR WHO HELPED CONVICT LETBY WAS BARRED FROM TREATING PATIENTS"
@LawrenceFelic / @David_Conn for @Guardian
A senior doctor whose evidence helped convict Lucy Letby was barred from treating patients during her trial over safety fears.
#TheGuardian
#TomorrowsPapersToday
Simon Davies retweeted
Lucy has been told she will die in prison.
She has no possibility of parole.
Her life, and those of her elderly parents, have been destroyed.
Their only hope is the Criminal Cases Review Commission.
To the CCRC - enough. Refer her case to the Court of Appeal NOW. (6/6)
Simon Davies retweeted
A senior doctor whose evidence helped to convict Lucy Letby and who was held up by prosecutors as a pre-eminent expert was barred from treating patients during the trial over fears he posed a risk to their safety
theguardian.com/uk-news/2026…
Simon Davies retweeted
Replying to @david_conn
@david_conn
theguardian.com/uk-news/2026…
His reasoning about the hypoglycaemia cases was also badly wrong.
youtu.be/whAYdUubMKw?is=UhZ-… – at Inverlochy Castle, Scotland
Simon Davies retweeted
So the #LucyLetby Prosecution Paediatric Endocrinology 'expert,' at the time that he gave his evidence was clinically barred by his employing Trust from seeing patients due to concerns of patient safety related to the use of insulin!
You really couldn't write this stuff! 😳
"Doctor whose evidence helped to convict Lucy Letby was barred from treating patients during trial."
"Among the reasons for UCLH's decision was that his advice to child patients relating to insulin was not considered safe."
"Jury was never told"
theguardian.com/uk-news/2026…






















