Todd De Ryck (@tder2012) header
Todd De Ryck (@tder2012) profile picture

Humanist, carbon intensity of energy, GHG emissions, pollution, environmental impacts, reliable energy for all, nuclear, member of Canadians for Nuclear Energy

Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada
Joined September 2012
Photo by Todd De Ryck (@tder2012)Photo by Todd De Ryck (@tder2012)Photo by Todd De Ryck (@tder2012)Photo by Todd De Ryck (@tder2012)Photo by Todd De Ryck (@tder2012)Photo by Todd De Ryck (@tder2012)Photo by Todd De Ryck (@tder2012)Photo by Todd De Ryck (@tder2012)Photo by Todd De Ryck (@tder2012)Photo by Todd De Ryck (@tder2012)
Todd De Ryck retweeted
.@janrosenow's new paper says the view that replacing fossil fuels with renewables is unrealistic ‘rests on a systematic misinterpretation of energy system size’. It gets its own numbers wrong: its storage losses are 56 TWh, not 30, and the table it takes them from assumes a quarter of demand is met by steady baseload. Its electrified world still uses 101 EJ of fossil fuel a year. Electrification is necessary. Necessary is not sufficient. He’s blocked me and closed comments on his essay, so my reply is on my own site: richardlyon.net/blog/necessa…
6
12
3
44
1,345
“World’s Dumbest Energy Policy.” That was the headline of a 2019 Wall Street Journal editorial about Germany’s plan to quit coal after deciding to give up nuclear power. In the first nine months of 2026, Germany still mined about 61 million tonnes of lignite to power plants serving the public grid. Lignite, hard coal, gas and imports helped meet demand when wind and solar output fell. How often does that happen? Uniper counted 1,435 periods from 2016 to 2025 when wind and solar together delivered less than 10% of installed capacity for more than ten hours. Day-long events occurred almost monthly. Three-day events occurred about twice a year. The longest lasted a week. Even with biomass and hydropower, the gap can reach tens of gigawatts. A gap of 40 GW over five days amounts to 4,800 GWh. At €250 per kWh, that much battery capacity would cost €1.2 trillion. Once empty, the batteries still need to be recharged. Germany’s first two auctions for capacity that can deliver for extended periods cover 9 GW, with delivery planned by 2031. That is less than a quarter of the 40 GW in this example. Calling gas plants a “reserve” understates their role. As coal plants close, gas will have to cover shortfalls on ordinary days too. That requires a reliable supply of affordable gas. Before Germany closes more coal plants, it should be able to say what will fossil free supply its factories on the seventh day of a #Dunkelflaute. @bundeskanzler @larsklingbeil @schneidercar #COP31 #ChangeAtG @BadumLisa @peter_simone @OlafLies @MonaNeubaur @cem_oezdemir @thekla_walker
7
126
11
385
14,821
Todd De Ryck retweeted
During the last ~15 years of this trainwreck (called Energiewende), I have made projections on what might end up happening in Germany when Energiewende slams into reality. My takes have not been pretty, and they have often been laughed at. I have never hated to nail it every step of the way (and when I have not nailed it, I have been too f*****ing optimistic). Yeah, it feels great to be right about stuff with a bag full of "I told you so's" now under my bed, but in this case I would really have preferred to be utterly wrong and disproven.
German energy ministry needs to bring some coal power plants back online. Temporarily, as usuall. It has become somewhat of a tradition to go back to coal in winter. Majority of Germans already think nuclear phaseout was a mistake.
6
17
1
81
2,824
Here is Johan Rockstrom promoting fatally flawed Callahan & Mankin 2025 today at COP31 Details: rogerpielkejr.substack.com/p…
Ocean heat uptake, accelerating sea-level rise, continental drying, and more: at #COP31, PIK Director @jrockstrom has just been speaking on the “10 new insights in #ClimateChange” report co-authored by PIK (see our former news item here: pik-potsdam.de/en/news/lates…).
7
26
82
5,369
This is crazy talk It is infeasible to reduce emissions by 6% per year Below are the implications Explore the realism of fantastical demands for emissions reductions here: decarbonization.thehonestbro…
“One message we have for the #COP31 is that our only chance to minimize overshoot and avoid a disastrous, unmanageable outcome, is to start reducing global emissions by 6% per year from this year onwards,” says PIK's @jrockstrom on CNN’s Amanpour: edition.cnn.com/2026/11/10/t…
13
35
2
147
5,445
Todd De Ryck retweeted
Phasing out existing nuclear plants and replacing them with renewables is literally anti-environmental policy. Best case, it costs additional CO2 to manufacture and install the replacing wind/solar to generate the same amount of clean power. Meanwhile, those wind/solar installations could alternatively have been used to displace fossil energy. And more likely than not, the timing and magnitude of renewables replacing nuclear would be imperfect, with added gas generation filling in the gaps.
It is not possible to lead a proenvironment policy and advocate a phaseout of nuclear power at the same time. Several reports and analysis show this would not only waste current low carbon energy generation in France, it would also increase CO2 emissions. Misguided!
3
8
2
53
1,904
Todd De Ryck retweeted
UCS's Ed Lyman (@NucSafetyUCS) is wrong. He claims, without evidence, that the NRC made a mistake by approving the construction permit for DOW's Long Mott project. His issue is that X-Energy's (@xenergynuclear) Xe-100 reactors don't have a traditional containment structure. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (@NRCgov) – staffed with thousands of reactor safety professionals and charged with protecting the public – decided that the design was safe enough to build. He's mad that the NRC didn't kill the project by adding a consequential, unnecessary time and cost burden to the plant's construction by requiring a thick walled, steel lined, pressure tight containment. There are several reasons why they determined the conventional structure was unnecessary . 1. Xe-100 uses a qualified TRISO design that is proven to retain fission products even at temperatures well above those that can be achieved during any credible accident scenarios. 2. Helium, which Xe-100 uses as the heat transfer fluid (reactor coolant), is inert and cannot be activated by neutrons. It is a terrible solvent – unlike hot water and steam – that cannot carry radioactive particles out of the plant in the unlikely event of fuel damage AND a leak in the coolant system. 3. Unlike the pressurized, superheated water used as a coolant in many conventional reactors, helium is always a gas and does not change phase in the event of a leak. It is never subject to the kind of immediate phase change – aka steam explosion – that was a fundamental cause of the damage at Chernobyl. The phase change from water to vapor (steam) was the driving force that led to radioactive material distribution during the 3/11/11 accident at the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant. 4. Xe-100 has passive reactor safety that is designed in as a result of physics and heat transfer. If the fuel temperature increases, physics ensures that the fission reaction slows and then stops. Once fissions stop, there is still a predictable quantity of heat being released by fission product decay. But Xe-100 reactors have a low power density and plenty of surface area. At their rated thermal power output of 200 MWth, there is enough surface area to transfer all of the decay heat out of the reactor core. Heat production is always decreasing as isotopes decay, and heat transfer speeds up as temperature increases. The combination leads to a predictable maximum temperature that cannot be exceeded. The public is being adequately protected by the NRC's decision to approve the Long Mott construction permit without requiring a conventional containment structure. Lyman and the UCS are just doing the job that their donors tell them to do – resist all nuclear projects – even the ones that safely contribute to the nation's energy security and improve the cleanliness of the environment. Serious question for Dr. Lyman: What other power source could possibly replace the combustion fuels DOW is currently using to supply heat and electricity to its chemical plant in Seadrift, TX? When you add ultra low emissions as a requirement, the option list narrows even more. Final note: We all have a vested interest in avoiding unnecessary requirements that add a heavy cost and schedule burden on nuclear projects. That is ESPECIALLY true in the case of a project that has received ~$2 B of US government (taxpayer) support.
9
12
5
72
3,824
Todd De Ryck retweeted
OPG Acknowledges the West’s First SMR is Behind Schedule Ontario Power Generation has acknowledged that “DNNP Unit 1 is no longer expected to achieve the previously disclosed commercial operation date target of October 2030 or be completed within the previously disclosed estimated cost of $7.7 billion.” OPG explicitly identifies unfinished engineering by GE Vernova Hitachi as the primary contributing factor, going on to say... “This reflects GE Vernova Hitachi Nuclear Energy's ongoing engineering for its first-of-a-kind SMR, which has impacts on construction execution and supply chain performance.” Detailed engineering is falling behind construction, causing costly delays, rework and lost productivity. These pressures are compounded by the departure of several senior engineers at a critical stage of the project, when GVH’s already stretched resources are needed most. Meanwhile, GVH is pursuing an expanding portfolio of projects, including Clinch River in Tennessee, where TVA aims to begin construction with a design more than 95% complete and benefit directly from lessons learned at Darlington. Ontario is thus absorbing the risks of pioneering the first BWRX-300 while the vendor prepares to deliver its successors. Having committed billions to pioneering an American reactor design, Ontario now depends on a foreign vendor whose scarce engineering resources are being pulled in competing directions. Ontario’s immediate priority must be getting Darlington back on track. GE Hitachi needs to hear an unequivocal message from Queen’s Park and Ottawa: completing the engineering required to deliver Canada’s first BWRX-300 must take precedence over the company’s expanding international ambitions. Canada is hardly powerless. OPG’s Integrated Project Agreement provides broad audit rights, performance-based financial incentives and contractual protections where project partners fail to meet the required standard of care. Ontario also retains substantial commercial leverage through three additional planned BWRX-300 reactors that have yet to reach final investment decision. The province should use this leverage to demand an independently verified engineering recovery plan, backed by dedicated senior personnel, binding delivery milestones and transparent reporting. Where contractual obligations have been breached, OPG should pursue the remedies available under its agreements. The larger lesson concerns the next generation of Canadian nuclear construction. Canada has deployed the full weight of its public balance sheets to establish the BWRX-300, an American reactor design, as an international commercial product. We cannot afford to repeat this naive arrangement with the Westinghouse Electric Company AP1000, committing billions of dollars and decades of energy planning to another foreign vendor whose scarce engineering resources and strategic priorities ultimately lie elsewhere. It is time to be Maîtres chez nous. Canada’s next reactors must be CANDU.
17
25
10
147
12,213
Todd De Ryck retweeted
OPG update on the BWRX300: "DNNP Unit 1 is no longer expected to achieve the previously disclosed commercial operation date target of October 2030 or be completed within the previously disclosed estimated cost of $7.7 billion"
14
20
18
89
27,456
Todd De Ryck retweeted
September cost a record £553 million to keep Britain’s grid in balance. Most of it went on switching Scottish wind off and paying plants further south to stand in, and gas made half of all the extra power NESO bought. This week’s Week in Energy: richardlyon.substack.com/p/t…
21
112
11
303
8,156
Ugh. Georgia is blessed with 80% hydropower and even exports when the conditions are favorable. The rest of the time ok it burns a little gas. Does it make sense to cut the mountains to make the large pads for the foundation and the access corridor for transporting the blades etc? Not to mention a LOT of migratory birds come through Georgia apparently. I dunno I’m not against wind energy per se. Just hope they did all the studies and it actually make sense.
You don't realize how unforgiving the Georgian terrain is until you try moving a massive wind turbine through it. ​We’ve had wind farms before, but getting them this deep into the mountains requires a "Blade Lifter" just to angle the blades into the sky so they don't hit the cliffs on these extreme hairpin turns. ​Absolute logistical madness 🇬🇪
12
7
76
5,042
Todd De Ryck retweeted
“Atlantic Canada has seen this pattern before: large wind-powered visions, public money up front, and a pivot when buyers fail to materialize. Wind West deserves scrutiny in that light. It is a first-of-its-kind offshore wind project in Canada, built with other people’s money, with no guaranteed buyer, producing electricity for export at more than $200/MWh, plus about $70/MWh for new transmission to reach buyers. Each of those features is a risk, and federal taxpayers are being asked to carry it ….”
Nova Scotia’s proposed Wind West offshore energy project promises to transform the province into a major electricity exporter, yet its enormous scale, uncertain buyers, and rising costs raise serious questions about its economic viability “Atlantic Canada has seen this pattern before: large wind-powered visions, public money up front, and a pivot when buyers fail to materialize. Wind West deserves scrutiny in that light. It is a first-of-its-kind offshore wind project in Canada, built with other people’s money, with no guaranteed buyer, producing electricity for export at more than $200/MWh, plus about $70/MWh for new transmission to reach buyers. Each of those features is a risk, and federal taxpayers are being asked to carry it ….” In “Wind West: Nova Scotia’s offshore wind gamble with Ottawa’s money,” economist Edgardo Sepulveda (@E_R_Sepulveda) examines the project’s underlying assumptions, arguing that its projected costs are too optimistic, its export market too uncertain, and the electricity it generates will struggle to compete with cheaper, more reliable alternatives. Read full commentary here⬇️ macdonaldlaurier.ca/wind-wes…
6
19
2
61
3,268
Todd De Ryck retweeted
I was involved in proofreading this doc for Edgardo. As is typical for him, this is top-shelf work, well worth the read! 👏
Nova Scotia’s proposed Wind West offshore energy project promises to transform the province into a major electricity exporter, yet its enormous scale, uncertain buyers, and rising costs raise serious questions about its economic viability “Atlantic Canada has seen this pattern before: large wind-powered visions, public money up front, and a pivot when buyers fail to materialize. Wind West deserves scrutiny in that light. It is a first-of-its-kind offshore wind project in Canada, built with other people’s money, with no guaranteed buyer, producing electricity for export at more than $200/MWh, plus about $70/MWh for new transmission to reach buyers. Each of those features is a risk, and federal taxpayers are being asked to carry it ….” In “Wind West: Nova Scotia’s offshore wind gamble with Ottawa’s money,” economist Edgardo Sepulveda (@E_R_Sepulveda) examines the project’s underlying assumptions, arguing that its projected costs are too optimistic, its export market too uncertain, and the electricity it generates will struggle to compete with cheaper, more reliable alternatives. Read full commentary here⬇️ macdonaldlaurier.ca/wind-wes…
3
6
23
785
A win for fossil gas. Not a single battery storage project was able to win capacity auction in Germany. Gas power plants won instead. In theory these are marketed as "hydrogen ready", but there are no specs and penalties in contracts which would make it viable.
Major energy companies dominate in Germany’s first backup power plant auction Grid regulator awards support to 4.5 GW of new gas plants in first auction round, including converted coal plants, while battery storage is shunned cleanenergywire.org/news/maj… cleanenergywire.org/news/maj…
3
14
3
45
5,144
Todd De Ryck retweeted
imo this is some quality reporting by Matthew McClearn, and exemplary tanking of actual thought from the ignorant yet pious Pembina [subscription: theglobeandmail.com/business… ]
1
8
1
15
1,289
Todd De Ryck retweeted
Thanks to @ScottLuft for sharing this Matthew McClearn article featured in the Globe and Mail. This little block stood out for me. Yes, the batteries froze, and the solar facilities were a net load.
1
4
15
554
Our @Dr_Keefer testified at today's Standing Committee on Natural Resources meeting for Canada's Nuclear Future. See 11:16:15 in the linked video and also the question period thereafter. #CANDU 🍁 #NuclearEnergy 🇨🇦 parlvu.parl.gc.ca/Harmony/en…
2
9
1
42
1,423
Todd De Ryck retweeted
Nice wind lull going on. If you follow the white Ontario demand line, we never stop running gas, so we are charging batteries with gas and then discharging that gas-generated energy during the peaks. The emissions savings of gas-powered batteries? 🤷🏻‍♂️ 😂
Rolling 14-day Ontario power mix🦇🎃🧙♀️👻:
3
8
2
15
690
Todd De Ryck retweeted
Chris Bowen is playing games here. Cheap wholesale electricity generation is not the same as cheap electricity delivered to Australian homes and businesses. The energy regulator’s 2026–27 figures show that wholesale electricity represents just 36% of a South Australian household’s bill. Network infrastructure accounts for nearly 42%. In fact, SA wholesale costs fell 1.9%, yet network costs increased 8.6%. That’s the problem with continually celebrating wholesale prices while ignoring the full cost of delivering reliable electricity. Australians don’t pay a wholesale spot price. We pay for generation, transmission, distribution, system reliability, storage and retail services. And businesses must recover those energy costs through their products, reducing competitiveness and putting even pressure on productivity. Cheap generation is not the same as cheap, reliable, delivered power. And the labor party know that. The proper measure of energy policy is the total cost of reliable electricity to households and industry, not a selectively presented wholesale price chart.
18
31
3
111
2,594
Belgium restored nuclear power output Belgium’s two remaining nuclear reactors are back online, restoring 2GW of reliable power after months shut down. Under Bart De Wever, the government has also scrapped the nuclear phase-out law and lifted the ban on new reactors. Concrete action to reverse the damage inflicted by energy-illiterate fools. Germany threw away more than 20GW of nuclear capacity under Merkel, enough to supply roughly 30% of its electricity. Not just IMHO, 8GW can still be recovered at minimum cost and in short order. Merz must halt dismantling and launch a serious programme to restore capacity - asap. Removed equipment can be replaced. Political paralysis is a choice. That’s the difference between De Wever’s pragmatism and Merz’s catastrophic inability to correct past energy mistakes quickly and decisively, even with a highly capable Katherina Reiche as energy minister. Well done, @Bart_DeWever and team. @_FriedrichMerz @BMWE_
België en @ENGIE_energie zijn erin geslaagd de kerncentrales Doel IV en Tihange III in een half jaar volledig te reviseren, alle veiligheidsprocedures te doorlopen en weer op te starten. Terwijl sluiting gepland was. Dat is een applausje waard, vindt u niet? #grafiekvandedag
3
220
27
1,374
56,988