Michael Fleming retweeted
Stephen Flynn gets all angry in Transport Committee, and gets a ticking off
Graham Simpson had just finished reading out a letter warning a direct award to Fergusons would be "problematic at best and folly at worst"
Michael Fleming retweeted
Replying to @wesstreeting
This is a straight forward lie Wes. You know what i said was both Labour and Conservatives hollowed out defence. Be man enough to admit it. Lies dont hide your own record. The last government to spend 3% of GDP ( without all your treasury tricks) was a Conservative one. MOD now spends 2.2% GDP and you are cutting day to day spending this year and next. many veterans, like me who served under a Labour government never forget the Snatch Landrover scandal. If you want to be taken seriously as a Defence Secretary stop playing child like politics. Earn your respect by sticking up for the armed forces, fighting the Treasury for real funding not spin and be honest about Labours part in hollowing out. At the moment your fake claims on 2.7% GDP coupled with under funding day to day spending are a perfect example of hollowing out. @haynesdeborah @larisamlbrown
Michael Fleming retweeted
That's funny because at my last strategy meeting with my accountant, they informed me I must use HMRC-recognised Making Tax Digital compatible software, creating an oligopoly for firms like Xero.
I must now also report my company's income every three months rather than once a year, as well as a final report at year end.
So I now have to pay for a Xero subscription.
And pay my accountant more for the increased submissions.
And fuck about with reconciling every three months, rather than once a year.
For HMRC to end up with the same amount of income from me as before.
Fuck off.
Just fuck off.
Fuck off all the way back to Yorkshire, then fuck off some more.
Michael Fleming retweeted
😳 @JohnSwinney telling the Easdale brothers to “watch their language” rather neatly illustrates the very attitude they're complaining about.
He's the @ScotGovFM of Scotland, not the nation's headmaster. His job is to answer criticism, not to expel people who express it in terms he finds disagreeable.
I've experienced this culture myself. Challenge a policy, question a funding decision or expose an uncomfortable truth, and suddenly the conversation becomes about your tone, your language or your attitude. Anything, it seems, except the substance of what you've actually said. It's a remarkably convenient way of avoiding difficult questions while making the person asking them the problem.
Democracy is not simply the right to vote every few years. It also requires the freedom to challenge those in power without fearing that your livelihood, funding, reputation or opportunities will suffer as a consequence.
And that is where my criticism of the SNP goes considerably further than its apparent dislike of dissent.
My concern, informed by my own experience, is that criticism can carry identifiable institutional consequences, while compliance and political conformity can bring equally identifiable advantages.
That is a far more serious allegation than a government being thin-skinned, and it deserves proper scrutiny.
The Easdales have the resources and public profile to challenge the government openly. Many smaller organisations, particularly those dependent on public funding, do not enjoy that luxury. For them, the perceived price of speaking out can be enough to ensure silence.
A government doesn't have to ban criticism to discourage it. It merely has to create an environment in which people believe there is a price to pay for speaking their minds.
So perhaps, rather than lecturing his critics about their manners, the First Minister might reflect on why people feel compelled to use such strong language in the first place.
Democracy isn't a classroom, Mr Swinney. The electorate aren't your pupils, and disagreement isn't a disciplinary offence.
Scotland’s First Minister has told a bus company boss to watch his language after he branded him a dictator over plans to bring the country’s bus network under public control.
i.stv.tv/4zDMZjI
Michael Fleming retweeted
There is no chance of Scottish education improving until such time as the teaching unions are proscribed. The head of the EIS - the largest union - is proudly anti-knowledge and rigour, preferring a “holistic education for peace and prosperity”. FFS.
thetimes.com/uk/scotland/art…
Michael Fleming retweeted
“Does Israel have the right to exist?”
PAUSE for 8 seconds
“It’s a difficult one…”
Gillian Mackay, co-leader of the Scottish Greens
Replying to @ginadavidsonlbc
Says she doesn’t have a position a one or two state solution but struggles to answer the “does Israel have a right to to exist” question
Michael Fleming retweeted
Replying to @NoteTaker_X @JohnSwinney
Beautiful sight: John Swinney getting hit with a Community Note for manufacturing fake grievances out of 2050 spreadsheet projections. His own Deputy First Minister's letter proved the £4bn headline was a 24-year extrapolation, and basic devolution maths proved Barnett consequentials will actually increase Scotland's budget. "Honest John" caught in 4K. 😂
Michael Fleming retweeted
Replying to @JohnSwinney
This is a masterclass in statistical lying to manufacture a constitutional grievance. You claim the Prime Minister is taking “up to £4bn from Scotland's pensioners to pay for social care in England”, but your own Deputy First Minister’s letter admits that £4bn figure is an unadjusted cash-terms extrapolation for 2049–50, nearly a quarter of a century away. Terrifying pensioners today with compounding spreadsheet projections for 24 years in the future is cynical politics. More importantly, the claim that Scottish money is going south to fund English care is completely fabricated. Social care is fully devolved. If the UK Government invests money into an English National Care Service, the Barnett formula automatically triggers massive, proportional block grant windfalls straight into Holyrood's bank account. Scotland doesn't pay for English care; Holyrood gets a cash payout because of it. The ultimate irony is that Scotland’s population is ageing faster than the rest of the UK. Scottish pensions are currently underwritten by a 68-million-strong UK tax base and an annual £25.3bn UK Treasury fiscal transfer. If Scotland were independent, facing a 10% structural deficit without a central bank, you couldn't maintain existing state pensions on Day 1, let alone in 2050. Honest John?😂
Michael Fleming retweeted
No idea what happened to the 3.5% defence roadmap Burnham promised would be in his speech today.
This is what he told LBC yesterday: "We have a commitment 2035, and what I'll set out tomorrow is how we do that, how we change things so that we can make the necessary investment in defence."
Michael Fleming retweeted
This story has broken me. It has unleashed a rage so strong I can barely express it, but allow me to try.
Above all, I am angry with the decades-long malevolent incompetence of the British state: politicians of all parties, the judiciary, the civil service. Their collective uselessness has shattered the social contract and made us all poorer and less safe. In just 25 years, they have led us from an affluent, high-trust society to a broken, low-trust one.
I am sickened by the growth in sectarian politics. I am appalled by the foreign ghettos in our cities and imported, bent voting practices and resultant corruption in some of our councils. I hate seeing the clothing of female oppression on our streets. I am sickened by the fact our Jewish community lives under siege.
I no longer wish to pay tax to support those who have come here illegally and should be removed immediately. It is to our shame that we have accepted mass immigration without insisting on integration. I am tired of being told that a British passport makes a foreigner as British as me. I assure you that the “British citizen” in this story is not. I am saddened that for so many people, the concept of “British” is essentially meaningless.
I am sick of the obsession with a minor war 2,500 miles away that barely affects us. I despise that £88m of our tax money is going to Hamas (because it will), when the tax burden is a record high, everything is expensive, welfare spending is out of control and we can’t even pay for our own defences when the global risk of conflict is the highest it has been since the end of the Cold War. And in spite of how much of our money the government steals from our pockets, nothing, at all, in this country works. Healthcare, transport, education - all broken.
It is a stain on our national politics that we have five Gaza MPs. It is our national shame that our government is intent on sucking up to the Palestinian entity which contains some of the worst monsters on the face of planet. It is a disgrace that our Foreign Secretary shook the hand of the representative of the Iranian regime that has slaughtered tens of thousands of its own people, and that he doesn’t seem to understand why that photograph will damn him forever. It is embarrassing that we had a Foreign Office minister dancing with and hugging the representative of the Palestinian Authority. The lack of serious statesmanship is mind-boggling and indicative of how far we have fallen.
They say the past is a foreign country, but my goodness, do I miss the country I grew up in. I feel so sorry for the generation that grew up after 2000 and will never know how good it was. It’s not coming back.
I have no time for the demagogues and grifters who exploit this anger. I know other people feel the same as I do, and my goodness, do I understand why people are angry. For decades, those we have elected to govern in our interests have instead run our country into the ground.
And to cap it all, now we are led by fatuous, asinine, deeply unserious airheads who think serious governance is a TikTok video about pork scratchings, as the last vestiges of a coherent society die under the weight of their malignant frivolity.
The worst part of it is that there is absolutely nothing any of us can do about it. I just want to live in a happy, stable, prosperous country like we used to be, instead of one that is run by a state apparatus that does nothing but beat us down, obsess over irrelevances, take our money, and leave us poorer and less safe.
Michael Fleming retweeted
Replying to @JohnSwinney
@JohnSwinney Yes. My concern isyou are now playing a very familiar constitutional game with an appalling human tragedy.
We have just learned that 1,133 Scots died from drugs last year, an increase of 11 per cent. Scotland's drug-death rate remains vastly higher than England's despite both countries operating under the same Misuse of Drugs Act. Scottish Parliament
Yet almost immediately we are being pointed towards something Westminster will not currently permit: decriminalisation.
That is politically convenient because it moves the argument from “What has the Scottish Government done with the powers it has?” to “What powers won't Westminster give us?”
I don't accept that diversion.
Drug legislation may largely be reserved, but health, addiction treatment and the organisation of Scottish treatment services are devolved. Scotland has had more than a quarter of a century to build a treatment and recovery system capable of responding to addiction.
Indeed, Swinney himself told Parliament yesterday: “I accept full responsibility for everything that happens in the name of my Government.” Good. Then let's start there.
L
Decriminalisation deserves a serious debate, but it is not a detox bed. It is not residential rehabilitation. It is not same-day access to treatment. It is not continuity of care and it is not a recovery pathway.
Nor should Portugal be reduced to the slogan “they decriminalised and deaths fell”. Portugal combined legal reform with treatment, prevention, harm reduction and social reintegration. Oregon subsequently reversed its decriminalisation policy, while British Columbia has decided not to renew its pilot after concluding that it had not delivered the results hoped for.
On the Lord Advocate's 2021 guidance, I would support an independent review. Recorded Police Warnings are not decriminalisation, but after five years we should surely know what happens to people receiving them. How many reach treatment? How many remain engaged? What are their subsequent outcomes? If the approach works, demonstrate it. If it doesn't, change it.
What I object to is the suggestion that Scotland's catastrophic mortality can somehow be explained by the absence of another power at Westminster.
England operates under the same UK drugs legislation and does not have Scotland's mortality rate. That fact alone tells us that the Misuse of Drugs Act cannot possibly be the explanation.
The First Minister can argue for decriminalisation. He can argue for more powers. But he cannot use the powers he doesn't have as an alibi for the outcomes produced under the extensive powers his Government already exercises.
You can blame Westminster for refusing to change the law. You cannot blame Westminster for failing to build Scotland's treatment system.
After 1,133 deaths, Scotland needs accountability for what is happening now, not another constitutional argument about what might be possible if Westminster behaved differently.
Best,
Annemarie
🤖 Made with AI
Michael Fleming retweeted
So @Ed_Miliband sanctions Israel then shakes the hand of and sits down for a cosy chat with an Iranian mass murderer, one who has truly committed genocide; who has gallons and gallons of blood on those hands. Miliband is vile. End of.
Michael Fleming retweeted
And there it is.
Not one other party will back the motion sufficiently to allow a vote of no confidence in Scotland’s Drugs Minister to reach the chamber.
They don't have to like Reform. They don't have to endorse Reform. They don't even have to vote for no confidence.
But after 1,133 drug deaths, an 11% increase in a single year, apparently they cannot bring themselves even to facilitate the parliamentary process because of who lodged the motion. STV News
Only days ago @michaeljmarra said that “just because we do not agree on everything does not mean that we cannot agree on anything.”
@RussellFindlay1 has previously said: “We can forget party allegiances sometimes and work for the common good.”
This was the opportunity to demonstrate exactly that.
If they believe Maree Todd retains their confidence, then debate the case and vote accordingly.
Instead, the motion dies before that argument can even take place.
And that is what depresses me most. The dead did not have party memberships.
There were 1,133 reasons to put tribalism aside today. Apparently none of them was enough.
None of the other parties in the Scottish. Parliament are backing the Reform motion of no confidence in Drugs Minister @MareeToddMSP
It’s the opposite of a good deal.
Britain already owned the freehold. Mauritius never did. We are now transferring title we already held, then writing annual cheques for the next century so we can keep using the one room that actually matters.
That’s not decolonisation. That’s selling the house and renting the spare bedroom from the new owner.
The legal cloud over the base was real. The solution need not have been “give the lot away and pay for the privilege.” The Americans get the strategic asset. The British taxpayer gets the invoice. Mauritius gets the title and the money.
Pollard can call it good value. Most people looking at the numbers, the history and the geography will call it something else.
Michael Fleming retweeted
A brief and presumably accidental outbreak of honesty from Màiri McAllan, who looked up from her script this afternoon and said:
“Whilst I was assessing that downward trajectory that PISA demonstrated to me…”
Michael Fleming retweeted
We endured Stephen Flynn’s first committee appearance so you didn’t have to👇
Michael Fleming retweeted
I'm shocked and horrified that over 3,000 of you have retweeted this already. Please, please stop.

























