Best QBs in NFL History: 1. Josh Allen when he’s on 2. Everybody else

Sep 18, 2026 · 1:57 AM UTC

210
18
50
299
39,731
RelevantRecentLikes
Well until Allen can take the mantle from Mahomes I don’t know anyone can claim Allen is on the same level as Mahomes. Mahomes is “on” when it matters and is 4-0 vs Allen in the playoffs, 5 AFC Titles, has 5 Super Bowls, 3 rings, 2 mvps, & 3 Super Bowl MVPs. Why is this a conversation?
4
14
623
A QB will never be considered the best without any rings.
4
67
1,307
Until he plays Patrick Mahomes in any big game……….
5
1
14
569
Allen's all time playoffs 2019: w/c lost to Texans 2020: AFC champ. lost to Chiefs 2021: Div. lost to Chiefs 2022: Div. lost to Bengals 2023: Div. lost to Chiefs 2024: AFC champ. lost to Chiefs 2025: Div. lost to Broncos I guess he wasn't "on" for all those playoffs.
1
1
17
Best QBs in NFL History: 1. Mahomes 2. Josh Allen when it doesn’t matter.
4
5
1
65
1,162
Ever heard of Lamar Jackson; fuck right off 😂
4
22
801
I'm PRETTY SURE that the "best QB on NFL history" made it to at least 1 Super Bowl! Allen has NOT.
4
Can’t wait to see him fail again
110
If he wins a SB and doesn’t make horrible turnovers in huge spots (ex. end of half vs. Denver in playoffs) he’ll have a rightful argument to the top spot.
28
With due respect: where is the Super Bowl for Buffalo? I don’t want to hear it’s a team game. For some aspects true but when the QB gets paid over $50M a year then a Super Bowl trophy is a must.
79
Just need him on when it counts most.
248
Over saucing it lmao he might not even win this fsme
199
Can’t say that until he wins (or at least reaches) a Super Bowl
2
21
1,493
1. Mahomes 2. Stafford 3. Allen “when he’s on” aka regular season.
60
How high are you p? This is such a prisoner of the moment. He is not that good. Here’s a list of QBs that have been better when A game is being played. 1. Mike Vick 2. Ben Roethisberger 3. Peyton Manning 4. John Elway 5. Randall Cunningham 6. Aaron Rodgers
1
542
Shut the fuck up. It’s Tom Brady when he’s on. Do you forget 4 TDs in a quarter lmfao. Josh Allen makes way too many Mental Errors it’s his kryptonite. Brady managed games much better. Even this game, it got way too close and last game, Josh Allen made the dumbest throw ever.
1
1
142
i bet if we went through @theblockspot search history we would find searches like "josh allen replica dildo", "does josh allen like bald weak men?"
166
How about the guy who owns the league in EPA, QBR and air yards per attempt? How about the guy who carried his team last year when all he had was his practice squad? How about the guy who has made the Super Bowl and if it wasn’t for the refs , he would be a Super Bowl MVP.
3
52
recency bias hasn't seen A-Rod, Marino, Montana, Luckman in their primes
7
Based on what exactly? Seriously? beating a nonexistent Dan Campbell defense? He's definitely a great player but nothing all-time right now at this point in his career so far.
1
175
Sadly he’s never on in Late January.
3
41
931
I respect Bills Mafia, new stadium is cool and Josh is probably the most likeable franchise QB rn. But Lamar Jackson is a tier of his own when he's on. Josh is just slightly more consistent being "on" than LJ...for now 👀☕. Next 4 years of battles between the two will be 🤌🏼😈🐦‍⬛
1
1
489
Dude has never been to a Super Bowl
8
This is one those "I need attention" post. Nobody in their right mine will agree to this. A QB that has never won a Superbowl nevertheless been to one 🤣🤣 the T-bagging of Josh Allen just cross into a new level. 🤡
2
76
I just said the same thing
2
274
the thing is, he’s only “on” when he’s beating horrible teams and it’s still September lol
37
You mean...when he's not facing Mahomes?🤣
8
please tell me how a single one of those touchdown plays wouldn’t be made by any top 15 qb in the league rn
162
Best at crying 😥
7
158
Yeah for September, but when pressure is on he’ll fold like he normally does
3
This is why I root against the Bills. They are delusional sociopaths.
1
74
Jesus Christ. What are we doing here. Just the dumbest tweet ever.
7
Alright now get his shit out your throat. He’s amazing but relax
58
If we’re going “when they’re on” he’s not even top 5
1
200
They had QBs before the year 2000, you know. And he's not even in the top 20.
39
Loading Caleb Williams…
182
Load more replies