Ryan (@themdashing) header
Ryan (@themdashing) profile picture

editor & writer | context architect

Joined November 2008
Photo by Ryan (@themdashing)Photo by Ryan (@themdashing)Photo by Ryan (@themdashing)Photo by Ryan (@themdashing)Photo by Ryan (@themdashing)Photo by Ryan (@themdashing)Photo by Ryan (@themdashing)Photo by Ryan (@themdashing)Photo by Ryan (@themdashing)Photo by Ryan (@themdashing)
"The most load-bearing question, then, is the morality of the one who wields the ring."
This is not the correct takeaway from Lord of the Rings
20
208
4
2,637
53,201
It's been a little odd to see philosophers react to Nagel with "????". We all know the view. Consciousness exists in: bats, mice, foxes, cows, etc. It's a subjective feature that arises regarding them: namely, *being them*. None of them use language (as we do as part of our conscious form of life) and none of them (as far as I know) "generate video" (as even we don't do, easily anyway, cool as that may be). What they do share is: being a live in a world, somewhere specifically, with all the stakes that accompany organic living. That makes language patterning and video generation ~without living a life in an environment~ something of a conceptual non-starter for finding consciousness (per Nagel). There's nothing it is *to be* the LLM, because while the LLM patterns our language use, it does not live our, or any, lives. One may disagree with all this, and of course any functionalist does; but it's hardly unexpected territory from Nagel.
Nagel isn’t making some dumb mistake. No one seems to understand what “natural manifestation” means. He likely means two things, both of which are coherent. (1) consciousness comes before language, and language is an abstraction of it. (2) there is no such thing as a “purely linguistic experience” for humans, in that language does not naturally manifest in consciousness. You are conscious of language as heard words (LLMs can’t hear) or as it relates to the actions and dispositions of your embodied self (they aren’t embodied either).
37
44
6
548
23,421
Still Life with Oranges, by Rafael Romero Barros (1863)
14
609
39
2,964
52,864
Ryan retweeted
I find the idea of being relegated to nothing more than a "happy dog" fundamentally distasteful. A future in which the human race is stripped of all autonomy, freedom, and independence is not a good one.
Replying to @patrickc
totally agree on both points: 1. the reason why the positive vision is so hard to articulate for us is that in extremis, it will not be ours. many dogs live in a relative utopia today thanks to the society we’ve built. and while they are happy and fat, this world does not belong to them. they don’t participate (even superficially) in the planning or major decisions, even those that impact them greatly. and yet dogs still have a rich life: they compete for hierarchy, engage in play, have sex, and sometimes procreate. in the face of genuine superintelligence (not the models we have today), we become the happy dogs 1a: one plausible future that avoids us being “pets” to AI would have to include cybernetics. lots of people imagine this future of pure biological humans vs pure artificial intelligences, but it seems likely that humanity more fundamentally merges with ai 2. “If this conclusion is unpalatable…” i’d be more curious to ask people to examine why this is so unpalatable rather than play intellectual gymnastics to reject the 3 very sound underlying premises
6
14
2
134
3,370
you can really tell who doesn't have an actual job by their stance on pangram
Pangram cannot tell the difference between AI-generated and AI-edited text. It has no clue where the actual ideas come from. Yet people weaponize that "100%" label to shame writers and wreck careers, hitting vulnerable people the hardest. It is the exact opposite of everything we’ve spent years teaching about ethical AI deployment. The irony is that Pangram's founder is drinking so much of his own Kool-Aid that he gets mad when committees rightfully ignore his meaningless label.
1
1
102
Ryan retweeted
Flowers cut open · Charles Negre
6
350
11
2,595
48,865
how did we go from dreaming of fully-automated luxury gay space communism to manual-labor poverty queer dilapidated-earth communism?
Going on Bluesky to understand what the cream of the crop thinks about AI
6
1
29
1,299
all these things have a measurable ROI
Learn a dead language. Memorize a poem. Study an ancient civilization. Read a philosopher nobody talks about anymore. Not every pursuit needs a measurable ROI.
3
4
40
1,345
Seeing a lot of deeply condescending “content” recently that’s like “Flannery O’Connor is Dostoyevsky for girls!” But what if Dostoyevsky is also Dostoyevsky for girls and O’Connor is also O’Connor for boys? What if we all grew up a little bit?
19
234
14
2,742
54,138
Roberto Bolaño, from '2666'
3
26
1
197
5,357
most responses to the criticisms voiced in this article seem to be hostile because they think they're women voicing an innate resentment of young boys but that's a misreading imo, what they're really saying is that Hatchet doesn't encourage any intellectual growth by design
The first novel I ever loved was the survival classic Hatchet, but recently I’ve learned that a *lot* of women despise this book, and see it is as something they were forced to read in school to entice the idiot illiterate boys in their English class. I dove into that tension!
77
17
8
502
33,166
Georgia O'Keeffe, Purple Leaves (1922) #WomensArt
3
216
8
1,172
16,856
Attacking non-critical consumer-facing infrastructure - like grocery stores - with pre-warned and limited scope cyber attacks is the best way to convince your population they need to harden their society. It's really classic Ender's Game - you only get to use the weapon once, it has to destroy the enemy completely. Real catastrophe is not spoiling meat, its multi-megawatt turbines that go beyond safe RPM, critical valves in chemical refining that report the wrong position, air traffic control networks. Destruction of hard infrastructure that is replaceable on a year-to-decade timescale. Like a water treatment plant, transformer station, airport, and so on. Food is the most high throughput thing in our society besides gasoline. It has a residency time of a few days on shelves, and so any total loss of inventory is recoverable on the scale of a week.
UPDATE: The European refrigeration cyberattack has now reached Italy and Romania, bringing the total to at least 10 countries affected across Europe. In Italy, several Coop stores in Sicily were hit, including at least three in Catania and one in Palermo. In Romania, at least six stores have reportedly been affected. Some affected businesses have yet to publicly disclose the incidents, meaning the actual number of countries and locations impacted could be even higher. The full scale of this cyberattack remains unknown. Countries affected so far: 🇸🇪 Sweden 🇧🇪 Belgium 🇱🇺 Luxembourg 🇪🇪 Estonia 🇮🇪 Ireland 🇳🇱 Netherlands 🇫🇮 Finland 🇩🇰 Denmark 🇮🇹 Italy 🇷🇴 Romania
24
41
4
425
22,195
We hate editor halloween, what do you mean your a typo??
25
71
11
1,433
50,177
Rachel Ruysch (1664 – 1750), still-life painter from the Northern Netherlands who specialized in flowers, achieving international fame in her lifetime #WomensArt
6
145
6
844
12,912
Re: the perpetual “how do people read so many books?” discourse: Average person reads 1 page per minute and if we call the average book 365 pages (it’s probably less) then you will average 1 book per year for each minute you devote to reading each day. Pretty simple.
6
7
10
125
43,167
We often talk about literacy in relation to art, and yes, very important for that. But also important for more prosaic things like leases, contracts, and policies.
4
35
1
338
3,412
I can’t wait to read everyone’s secret poetry
Delete your search history, delete your bookmarks, delete your reddit, medical records, 12 yr old tumblr, delete everything. Every photo on the cloud, every message on every platform. None of it is safe. It will all become public in the next year Local storage and compute 📈
149
100
12
2,221
196,441
Technically, a dictionary is a book of spells.
371
4,935
525
29,825
655,981
me staying home all day: The world is evil and nobody deserves anything me after 30 minutes on the train and 10 minutes walking outside: Evetybody in the world is Beautiful
15
1,788
81
12,969
110,902