When cold email results dropped, my old instinct was more contacts and more campaigns
That's almost never it
It's usually sender health
When we see results start to drop, we replace 20% to 40% of our sender infrastructure
Results come back in a few days
1
2
187
Buy a nice watch and suddenly you notice everyone's wrist
Cold email works the same way
If you use AI to write cold emails, you start thinking every email you get was written by AI
Most people don't write cold emails
They just see one that's relevant and reply
7
8
276
Customer stories in cold email are overrated going into 2027
We matched one to each niche in our clients' campaigns
Replies stayed at 5% to 6%
Our own outreach stayed at 3% to 4%
Great for your website and social proof
In cold email, it's mostly just variation in the copy
1
1
139
Cold email isn't about volume
It's about reaching the right person at the right time
Volume just gives you more chances to get that right
How I'd rank what matters in cold email, after delivering over 15,000 meeting-ready leads this year:
1. Sender accounts
2. List quality
3. Email copy
4. Nurturing and recontacting
Open to hearing if you'd rank it differently
This is a thread
7
10
567
3. Email copy
A long email can work just as well as a short one
Our commercial insurance copy runs 2-3x longer than cleaning and does as well, if not better, because it has a case study
For cleaning, a case study only works if it's relevant to the place they want cleaned
1
31
The companies you most want to reach run email security on top of Google or Microsoft
Unhealthy senders get quarantined there
Your email sits waiting to be released because it was flagged as risky
Trust is already low before they even read it
1
2
158
Everyone worries their cold email looks like AI
Doesn't matter as much as you think
Right person, or it gets forwarded to the right person. Right timing
They'll still reply, even if they wonder "is this AI?"
That's how we delivered over 15,000 meeting-ready leads this year
4
3
223
The hardest lesson from running cold email for cleaning companies:
The copy matters the least
Healthy sender accounts and a targeted list matter most
Great emails from unhealthy senders land in quarantine
Average emails to the right list from healthy senders get replies
Buying cheap domains for cold email?
Turn off auto-renewal
Especially on TLDs that work just as well as .com
The renewal price can be 7-10x what you paid
Just own the domain for the year, then use a different one next year
1
1
170
A bounce spike doesn't mean your sender accounts are burnt
Our Mimecast campaign hit 15% bounces, Google and Outlook stayed under 4%
Same list, same validation
Mimecast flagged our domains as risky, so we pulled them from that campaign
Most people would've killed all of them
3
3
277
Spamhaus listed domains are a no-no for us
SURBL I'm not so sure about
So before buying all new domains, we're going to test SURBL listed ones we already own against clean ones
Even at $3 a domain on a few new TLDs we've been using, 1,000 new ones is $3,000
2
3
221
We don't end our cold emails with "Would you be open to a quote?"
They'll say "Yeah, send me one via email"
So we ask "Would you be open to talking and discussing a cleaning quote for your facility?"
That ask has worked for us for two years
3
5
405
What nobody notices about unhealthy sender accounts in cold email:
They wreck your timing
Their emails land in quarantine, and prospects only see those in an end-of-day digest
They rarely release them
It also makes them more skeptical. They already are. I am too
9
10
380

