Reviewer Number 3 (@thirdreviewer) profile picture

Reviewer Number 3

@thirdreviewer

Your paper sucks

Joined October 2015
  • Tweets637
  • Following3.9K
  • Followers15.7K
73Media
Photo by Reviewer Number 3 (@thirdreviewer)Photo by Reviewer Number 3 (@thirdreviewer)Photo by Reviewer Number 3 (@thirdreviewer)Photo by Reviewer Number 3 (@thirdreviewer)
This paper is more appropriate for a speciality journal. Like, one that specializes in terrible papers.
8
202
23
785
i've been saying this for a while now
Brian Leiter (@BrianLeiter) profile pictureBrian Leiter@BrianLeiterApr 10
that was not a good paper
8
2,035
Reviewer Number 3 retweeted
Hadas Weiss (@weiss_hadas) profile picture
Hadas Weiss@weiss_hadas29 Jan 2025
body dysmorphia but for the body of my paper
1
27
2
221
8,797
it’s not impostor syndrome your work is actually bad
1
1
1
34
3,018
submitting your paper to nature, only to have it desk rejected immediately nitter.cf/JebraFaushay/status/18…
1
2
15
4,209
it me
Image from Reviewer Number 3 (@thirdreviewer)
4
42
3,163
the personal insults i hurled at you in my review were actually “official actions” taken as a reviewer and so you are not allowed to complain about them, sorry i don’t make the rules here
1
4
21
4,394
also your paper was terrible
1
1,517
each @hubermanlab paper has only a 20% chance of being accepted by me, but he submits them 6 times so I have no choice by the end
12
3,951
Image from Reviewer Number 3 (@thirdreviewer)
Trevor Branch (moved to Bluesky) (@TrevorABranch) profile pictureTrevor Branch (moved to Bluesky)@TrevorABranch20 Mar 2024
Does tweeting increase citations? We conducted an experiment with 110 tweeted papers and 440 controls, waited 3 years for citations to accumulate... and found no significant increase in citations journals.plos.org/plosone/ar…
Image from Trevor Branch (moved to Bluesky) (@TrevorABranch)
1
3
39
7,322
your paper after incorporating my feedback
Image from Reviewer Number 3 (@thirdreviewer)
3
17
1
88
15,997
the review process
Abdel Abdellaoui (@dr_appie) profile pictureAbdel Abdellaoui@dr_appie2 Apr 2023
The door to academic success
Image from Abdel Abdellaoui (@dr_appie)
5
45
11,634
when you realize it’s me reviewing your paper nitter.cf/HumansNoContext/status…
1
2
19
5,801
When the editor does nothing as I trash your paper
1
34
6,858
when Reviewer 1’s comments are just as fierce as mine
3
1
33
11,588
me, the reviewer of your paper
20
183
49
1,778
344,444
h/t @aemonten
13,752
using this in my next review
Eliezer Yudkowsky ⏹️ (@ESYudkowsky) profile pictureEliezer Yudkowsky ⏹️
@ESYudkowsky12 Jan 2023
Replying to @mealreplacer
you are trying to solve the wrong problem using the wrong methods based on a wrong model of the world derived from poor thinking and unfortunately all of your mistakes have failed to cancel out
1
9
67
14,135
your paper after the revisions I requested
10
236
47
2,016
289,576
revise and resubmit #speakervote
1
16
7,847
turning the review process into a discussion of my completely irrelevant work (world cup edition)
3
34
8,204
Load more