Narmdeshwar Tiwari (@tiwitiger1) header
Narmdeshwar Tiwari (@tiwitiger1) profile picture

Vision without execution is hallucination. Former Vice Chief of IAF. Military Aviator, Test Pilot, interest in geopolitics and matters military.

Joined May 2023
Photo by Narmdeshwar Tiwari (@tiwitiger1)Photo by Narmdeshwar Tiwari (@tiwitiger1)Photo by Narmdeshwar Tiwari (@tiwitiger1)Photo by Narmdeshwar Tiwari (@tiwitiger1)Photo by Narmdeshwar Tiwari (@tiwitiger1)Photo by Narmdeshwar Tiwari (@tiwitiger1)Photo by Narmdeshwar Tiwari (@tiwitiger1)Photo by Narmdeshwar Tiwari (@tiwitiger1)Photo by Narmdeshwar Tiwari (@tiwitiger1)
FlightGlobal should re-evaluate their sources. The same sources gave specific tail numbers, which since have been flying in various exercises including international ones. The same sources said that Sqn Ldr Shivangi Singh was taken as a PoW. We all know how that turned out.
23
95
13
413
34,318
This is a norm in every city in India. In most other countries, building permissions are NOT given till water, sewage and power is in place. In our country it seems to be the other way around. That’s why citizens are left to fend for themselves.
Living in Hyderabad, one thing is becoming increasingly frustrating Water tankers, delivery delays and fixed water supply timings are becoming part of everyday life We are building massive IT parks, luxury apartments and a fast growing city But residents are still planning their daily lives around when water will arrive Water is not a luxury. It is a basic necessity A city can grow at a rapid pace, but without reliable water supply, how sustainable is that growth? Hyderabad residents, how is the water situation in your area?
1
4
24
1,769
I think we should just hold our horses and not get ahead of ourselves. This is only an RFI. Request For Information is only to understand the technological landscape.
Can't imagine that the IAF is considering ToT, licensed manufacturing and MRO arrangements for the KAI T-50 or Leonardo M-346 for its requirement of approximately 150 Stage III advanced jet trainers when HAL's Tejas SPoRT offers an opportunity to build a sovereign indigenous LIFT ecosystem.🤦 Why invest billions in foreign-designed platforms when we can own the design, technology and future upgrades? 🔹 Performance: Tejas SPoRT offers a compelling indigenous design pathway. Its proposed performance and capabilities should be evaluated rigorously against the T-50 and M-346 across speed, manoeuvrability, payload, avionics and growth potential. 🔹 Commonality: Leverage the Tejas ecosystem, including avionics, components, maintenance infrastructure, supply chains and manufacturing capabilities. 🔹 Indigenous IP: Retain design authority and control over software, flight-control systems, avionics integration, mission systems and future upgrades. 🔹 Cost advantage: Avoid creating another foreign-dependent manufacturing, spares and MRO ecosystem. 🔹 Combat potential: Develop a platform with secondary light-combat and lead-in fighter training capabilities. 🔹 CATS MAX mothership: Explore SPoRT as a future manned-unmanned teaming platform to control CATS Warrior loyal wingmen, ALFA-S drone swarms and other autonomous assets. 🔹 Continuous upgrades: Integrate indigenous AESA radars, EW suites, weapons, data links and AI-enabled mission systems without perpetual dependence on foreign OEM approvals. The T-50 and M-346 are proven aircraft, but ToT and local MRO are not equivalent to sovereign design authority or ownership of intellectual property. India should not merely buy an aircraft to train its pilots. It should develop an indigenous platform that can evolve alongside its fighter fleet and future autonomous combat ecosystem. Tejas SPoRT deserves a serious, fully funded development pathway and a transparent technical evaluation against foreign alternatives. Own the design. Own the IP. Own the upgrades. Build the ecosystem! m.ajupress.com/view/20261116…
6
12
66
2,429
The problem is that the earlier bodies have all been empowered only in name. Unless, we give them a clear mandate and allow them to take decisions, I am afraid the file will follow the same path as always, with an additional layer in between. We need a different mindset first.
Quite true. However, given the history of empowered bodies, it may be wise to allow the users, the three services to select and fund the R&D efforts. IDEX shall be upscaled with higher budget & greater operational freedom. Higher the level of decision making, slower the decision.
1
11
741
That’s why deep tech innovation is a long game. It requires national focus, perseverance and the willingness to learn from failures and move on. R&D cannot be seen through the lens of an accountant. An empowered body which understands this is required to drive the changes.
Anyone who believes Safran, RR or GE are going to hand over proprietary single crystal super-alloy tech, turbine disks or key 'hot sections' of state of the art turbofans need to get serious. No one hands over the family jewels. Would India share, for example, our hypersonic glide vehicle tech or dual pulse missile motor tech with a third party? No. Lets get real. We need a revolution in indigenous manufacture governed by profound tech research - where R&D is lucrative and encouraged across fields. It will take us years, perhaps a decade or more to develop an engine as capable as the M-88. And that's being optimistic. Till 'Made in India' matures, the best we will get are MRO facilities and transfer of non-critical tech for domestic manufacture. We shouldn't shun this - a lot of this is equally valuable and will generate jobs in India, encourage downstream component manufacturers and establish an ecosystem for defence manufacture. And yes, this will cost us - no one is transferring anything unless you are willing to pay.
5
20
2
98
4,942
Fifth gen and sixth gen are mere phrases. AMCA needs to be an effective member in a robust network and for that platform is only a small part. Talent and resources are available. But we need to fix Programme Management first to get anywhere. @VishnuNDTV
➡️Can India build a 5th-gen stealth fighter before China’s next-gen capabilities widen the gap? 🇮🇳✈️ On Ep 65 of #CtrlAltDefence, @VishnuNDTV & Gp Capt (Retd) Ajay Ahlawat unpack the delays, private-sector bets & tech hurdles facing India’s AMCA programme. 🔗 Watch now: youtu.be/f-5IZBLfnQ4 ➡️ Key takeaways: ⏳ Decades of Delay: How bureaucratic hurdles & institutional rivalries stalled AMCA's progress. 🏭 Private Sector Bet: Can Tata, L&T & Bharat Forge meet the 30-month prototype deadline? 🇨🇳 The China Factor: Will AMCA stay relevant against Beijing’s rapid 6th-gen advancements? 🤖 Beyond Stealth: Why AI, sensor fusion, electronic warfare & long-range missiles will decide future air battles.
5
20
2
96
6,166
The primary responsibility for the state of affairs is with the government which has not prioritised this in their scheme of things. The fact that the AMCA development and production model has been talked of for the last seven years and yet we are where we are is only symptomatic
"Disastrous project management.” “Lack of faith in indigenous tech.” “Bad decisions & priorities.” Brutal report card on HAL by ex-IAF Chief ACM Bhadauria in the new episode of #CtrlAltDefence: youtu.be/XXm0An3QVG4?si=ekDh…
2
14
3
77
9,728
Visited Delhi yesterday. Spent considerable time on the road. Gridlock on practically every roundabout in Lutyens Delhi. Was wondering why we can’t put traffic lights at the roundabouts. It can’t be that difficult.
2
16
688
Narmdeshwar Tiwari retweeted
#WIONDefencePulse | Pakistan has test-fired the Fa’az air-to-air missile from a JF-17 fighter jet. What does this mean for Pakistan’s air combat capabilities, and what did India learn about the aircraft during Operation Sindoor? Air Marshal Narmdeshwar Tiwari (Retd.), former Vice Chief of the Indian Air Force during Operation Sindoor, joins @ShivanChanana to discuss Pakistan’s missile test, the JF-17 versus Rafale, and India’s operational preparedness @tiwitiger1
1
2
5
3,470
I couldn’t agree more.
Rashtriya Indian Military College (RIMC), Dehradun mogs all of them. Unparalleled legacy in every aspect.
28
799
In my talk at the DSSC and at CAW, I have been emphasising how our institutional framework needs to evolve to keep pace with the speed of innovation. Today, the innovation cycle is in weeks while we take much longer just to formulate requirements. This really needs to change.
#NDTVWorldSummit2026 | "They are Nobel laureates in terms of brainpower": Gen. David Petraeus, US Army (Ret.), Former Director of the CIA, to @ShivAroor on role of AI in warfare @rahulkanwal | @VishnuNDTV | #NDTVWorldSummit
3
14
1,137
Glad for the opportunity to share my views on the subject of ‘Operational Accountability and Decision Making’ with the Higher Air Command Course. My own experiences of Op Sindoor provided an important context. If the insightful Q&A is any indication, it was well received.
2
28
2,281
Our fundamental problem in procurement is that we are unwilling to back potential. We want finished products meeting all specs. If the GoI is so risk averse, how can you expect pvt sector to invest in R&D in this country? @ShivAroor @VishnuNDTV
🚨 Is India’s Zorawar light tank sinking? Could it go the Arjun way? The designer & key driver of the Zorawar project joins us on Episode 60 of #CtrlAltDefence Premiers at 6PM here: youtu.be/4ci6SYVAyKk
4
48
2
147
5,662
There are thousands of flights that traverse this world daily and many report technical issues, some big but mostly small. I am sure the crew is in touch with the required Control, oblivious of the fact that it has become a BREAKING NEWS in India. Surely, our media can do better
#BREAKING: British Airways flight BA295 from London to Chicago has declared an emergency over Ireland, squawking 7700. The aircraft descended to around 9,000 feet while over Ireland. More details are awaited.
2
2
19
1,241
This is symptomatic of our propensity to take short cuts and shoddy town planning. The terrible infrastructure and lack of civic amenities in our cities is largely because there’s hardly any accountability from top to bottom.
We Indians really are a hardworking breed. We’ll spend decades building infrastructure and then start thinking about how traffic will merge after opening it!
4
328
Glad to see it reach it’s logical conclusion. Hopefully, this is just the beginning for many more projects in the future.
1
1
8
491
It was a great privilege to speak to the officers at DSSC on how convergence of technologies is changing the nature of warfare by the day. Our greater challenge is institutional inertia and the inability to bring that technology to the fighting man in a reasonable timeframe.
Air Marshal Narmdeshwar Tiwari (Retd) addressed the 82nd Staff Course and faculty at #DSSC, Wellington. An insightful and enriching lecture on "Contemporary Evolution of Aerospace Power: Imperatives for India" enlightened the course officers with the new paradigms of aerial warfare. Lessons drawn from Op Sindoor and recent global conflicts highlighted the importance of indigenous capabilities and war stamina. #ProfessionalMilitaryEducation @DefenceMinIndia @SethSanjayMP @SpokespersonMoD @MIB_India
3
21
732
I am not really sure that the big technology companies understand the products that they are creating. Difficult to believe that no one flagged the serious issues with privacy that Meta Glasses create. Meta, what do you pay the folks so much for? Crazy times we are living in!
1
20
1,767
Had a great interaction yesterday with youngsters at GITAM, Hyderabad. Shared some life truths from my own experiences in the Air Force. Hopefully, some things will stick with them. To grow in life you need to be resilient. @GITAMUniversity
1
2
27
1,318