Jack Miller (@twrjack) header
Jack Miller (@twrjack) profile picture

Husband, father, grandfather; Calvary La Mirada OPC (RE); MA Biblical Counseling 1983 Grace Theological Seminary, Ps 25:14

Joined September 2021
Photo by Jack Miller (@twrjack)Photo by Jack Miller (@twrjack)Photo by Jack Miller (@twrjack)Photo by Jack Miller (@twrjack)Photo by Jack Miller (@twrjack)Photo by Jack Miller (@twrjack)Photo by Jack Miller (@twrjack)Photo by Jack Miller (@twrjack)Photo by Jack Miller (@twrjack)
Sanctification by the Law
6
10
2
91
Jack Miller retweeted
The longest run of Ron Jaworski's career The Eagles' "Polish Rifle" flashes the wheels on a 44-yard naked boot against the Redskins at The Vet. November 13, 1977
13
33
10
404
22,820
Jack Miller retweeted
If the internet ever goes down one of the unintended consequences will be a tremendous improvement in the mental health of the population. 🤣😂
260
690
47
7,448
82,005
One of the very best from the seventies
Imagine living in 1978 and hearing this amazing Song for the first time!
1
3
159
Jack Miller retweeted
Imagine living in 1978 and hearing this amazing Song for the first time!
41
47
8
435
49,846
Another excellent uplifting post…
The Fields Are White "Do you not say, 'There are still four months, and then comes the harvest'? Behold, I say to you, lift up your eyes and look on the fields, that they are white for harvest" (Jn 4:35). Four months is the farmer's arithmetic: seedtime here, harvest there, the interval fixed by the ordinary course of the age. Christ interrupts the arithmetic. The fields are white already. In Scripture's register, harvest belongs to the end of the age (Mt 13:39): the assize and the gathering, sickle and separation. The whiteness at Sychar means that the end has entered the field ahead of its calendar. Amos saw the day when the plowman would overtake the reaper, sowing and harvest compressed into a single act of divine abundance (Amos 9:13). That day stands present in John 4 because the Lord of the harvest is standing in the field. Ripeness follows his presence. And what is the field? Samaritans stream out of the town toward him and soon confess him as "the Savior of the world" (Jn 4:42). The crop is the nations. Under the Noahic administration, the woman's seed and the serpent's seed grow together in one Adamic world. Seedtime and harvest remain guaranteed by divine oath while the earth endures (Gen 8:22). Yet within that patience another gathering is already underway. The firstfruits order governs it (1 Cor 15:20, 23). Christ is the first sheaf. The field follows its firstfruits. The field is white because he is in it. John never mentions Rome. The occupation structured every life in the chapter: the taxed marketplace where the disciples purchased food, the roads they traveled, the garrison standing behind every discussion of kings and kingdoms. Yet the empire receives no place in the harvest's record. Why? Because Rome was only a tenant in the field it garrisoned. The Adamic world belongs to the great Suzerain. Its empires administer portions of it under his patience, holding leases but never title. The harvest ripens in occupied territory and answers to another Governor. The occupation itself ends exactly where Daniel placed its end: before the Ancient of Days at the final assize, never by the reapers' hands. Hiding is the posture of the first Adam. "I was afraid ... and I hid myself" (Gen 3:10). The bunker descends from Eden. The second Adam stands at noon, at the sixth hour, in full daylight, at a public well, in enemy territory, openly speaking with a Samaritan woman while his disciples marvel. Later he will say, "I have spoken openly to the world ... I said nothing in secret" (Jn 18:20). Daniel prayed with his windows open under Babylon's decree (Dan 6:10). Christ sends reapers into the field (Jn 4:38), not away from it. Citizenship in Zion licenses public presence in the Adamic world. The calling is reaping, not retreat. Presence, not withdrawal. The goal of the gathering is the house. "My house shall be called a house of prayer" (Mt 21:13; Isa 56:7). Isaiah employs the divine passive: κληθήσεται, shall be called. God names the house before the nations arrive in it. And Isaiah continues: "for all the nations." Then the Gatherer adds his own promise: "I will gather yet others besides those already gathered" (Isa 56:8). The house of prayer is the harvest housed. Against God's future passive stands man's present active. "You are making it" (ποιεῖτε) "a den of robbers." Jeremiah's phrase, σπήλαιον λῃστῶν, is not a hideout for ordinary thieves but a brigands' cave (Jer 7:11). The den serves a purpose. Men steal, murder, commit covenant treachery, and then stand in the temple saying, "We are delivered!" (Jer 7:9-10). The den is a refuge between raids. Immunity with a temple address. That is why the Vassal-King cleansed the Court of the Gentiles. The Court of the Gentiles was the nations' court. It was the appointed place for the gathered field to pray. By cleansing it, Christ cleared the cave out of the gathering place. The logic is simple. The field is white. The nations are coming. The house they are coming to is a house of prayer. And the Lord of the harvest has ruled out the bunker. #John4 #Matthew21 #CovenantTheology #Kline #KingdomOfGod #SecondAdam
1
3
140
Although a post that invites digging more deeply into its meanings and connections in Scripture.
24
"I desire to confess that my unfaithfulness has been exceeding great; my sins still greater; God's mercies greater than both." - Augustus Toplady
1
3
11
442
Jack Miller retweeted
The Law Did Not Annul the Promise — and Could Not Dr. Bryan Estelle's essay "The Covenant of Works in Moses and Paul" (in R. Scott Clark, ed., Covenant, Justification, and Pastoral Ministry, P&R, 2007) deserves its standing as a standard defense of the classic Westminster construction. It is learned, careful, and exegetically serious, and it represents the Confession's view at full strength: one divine claim for perfect obedience, published in Eden, never withdrawn, failed by the first Adam, and satisfied by the Last. On Galatians 3:10 Estelle states his thesis in a single sentence: the verse "teaches the necessity of perfect obedience to the law, albeit only hypothetical, since all mankind descending from Adam by ordinary generation is under its curse and unable to keep the law" (p. 124). The system coheres around a standing claim: "Since God's claim for obedience on his creatures has not ceased since the fall," Christ's obedience meets that claim, so that the covenant of works "has displayed the penalty-paying substitution and probation keeping of the Last Adam in the wake of the failures of the First Adam" (pp. 133, 135). In his later chapter in The Law Is Not of Faith (P&R, 2009), Leviticus 18:5 and Deuteronomy 30 are read as setting forth what is required for "entitlement to heaven or eternal life." The construction is Westminster's, and Estelle carries it as well as it can be carried. The question is whether Meredith Kline's architecture exposes joints the construction cannot see. First, location. In the Westminster handling, Christ satisfies the first covenant's unceased claim: Adam's probation, reopened in effect, is run to its finish by the second Adam. Kline locates the obedience in the Pactum. The Vassal renders His obedience under the covenant He accepted from the Father, on stipulations sworn between the Father and the Son. The covenant of works with Adam lies under its own execution: its curse fell on the covenant's Head in the church's place and was exhausted there. Christ fulfills the covenant of works in the Pactum; Adam's broken probation is never reissued to anyone. Second, office. Estelle builds Eden's cult with real precision — Adam the priest-guardian set in the sanctuary to serve and to keep — and then sets the question down: "Which takes precedence — the priestly or the kingly — will have tremendous ramifications for one's overall system of theology and one's view of the relationship of cult to culture; but this is not an issue immediately in view in this essay" (p. 109 n. 42). The set-down question is the architecture. The stipulations laid on Christ differ from Adam's because His office differs: the Vassal's work is the priestly consummation itself, the self-offering, the true temple work, the circumcision of Christ executed on the Head. A generic obedience meeting a generic claim cannot state what the Son actually performed. Third, Galatians 3 itself. Estelle's law in 3:10 is hypothetical: a demand suspended over fallen man, operative nowhere since Eden, its curse the shadow of an unmet abstraction. Kline reads Paul reading administrations. The Mosaic economy, he writes, "while an administration of grace on its fundamental level of concern with the eternal salvation of the individual, was at the same time on its temporary, typological kingdom level informed by the principle of works. Thus, for example, the apostle Paul in Romans 10:4ff. and Galatians 3:10ff. (cf. Rom 9:32) contrasts the old order of the law with the gospel order of grace and faith" (Kingdom Prologue, p. 109). The curse of Galatians 3:10 is Deuteronomy 27's curse, sworn at Ebal, executing inside a real administration on a real nation. Hypotheticals have no tenures; administrations do, and Paul dates this one: the law was added "until the offspring should come" (3:19). Fourth, the sanction's content. Where the Westminster reading eschatologizes Moses — Leviticus 18:5 as an offer, however hypothetical, of entitlement to heaven — Moses glosses his own "life": Deuteronomy 30:20 defines it as "dwelling in the land that the LORD swore to your fathers," and Leviticus 18 closes its sanctions with the land vomiting out its inhabitants (18:24–28). Kline keeps the type a type: "Paul, perceiving the works principle in the Mosaic law economy, was able to insist that this did not entail an abrogation of the promises of grace given to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob centuries earlier (Gal 3:17), precisely because the works principle applied only to the typological kingdom in Canaan and not to the inheritance of the eternal kingdom-city promised to Abraham" (Kingdom Prologue, p. 237). Sinai's sanctions disposed of Canaan. Heaven was never on Sinai's table, in either direction: its blessing was land-life, and its curse was exile, the typological shadow of the judgment it pictured. Here is the joint where everything turns. Paul says the law "does not annul a covenant previously ratified by God, so as to make the promise void" (Gal 3:17). Kline's explanation is architectural: "The old covenant order was composed of two strata and the works principle enunciated in Leviticus 18:5, and elsewhere in the law, applied only to one of these, a secondary stratum" (Kingdom Prologue, p. 321). The law could not annul the promise because it never held the promise's goods. Annulment requires jurisdiction; the typological administration had none over the eternal inheritance. Kline said it in one line decades ago: "On the classic covenantal understanding, the law that came 430 years later did not disannul the promise (Gal 3:17) — not because the old covenant did not really introduce an operative works principle, but because works and faith were operating on two different levels in the Mosaic economy" ("The Gospel until the Law," p. 436). And Paul forecloses the hypothetical outright: "if a law had been given that could give life, then righteousness would indeed be by the law" (3:21). No law capable of making alive was ever given — not under Moses, not in the abstract, not as a standing alternative for creatures as such. Moses never eschatologized his sanctions. Paul never did. Kline never did. The law did not annul the promise, because the promise was the inheritance, and the inheritance was never the law's to give or to take. #Galatians3 #CovenantOfWorks #CovenantTheology #Kline #WestminsterConfession #SecondAdam
2
5
474
Jack Miller retweeted
Born Under the Law "But when the fullness of time had come, God sent forth his Son, born of woman, born under the law, to redeem those who were under the law, so that we might receive adoption as sons" (Gal 4:4–5). Everything in the verse turns on what a reader hears in "under the law": an obligation, or an administration. The two hearings produce two doctrines of the incarnation. The classic Westminster hearing takes the law as the standing moral claim of the Creator on the creature. Estelle states its ground plainly: "Since God's claim for obedience on his creatures has not ceased since the fall," the Son's birth under the law is His subjection to that unceased claim, and His life is the claim satisfied at last (Estelle, "The Covenant of Works in Moses and Paul," p. 133). On this hearing the law has no address and no tenure. It is a principle suspended over mankind as such, the same in Eden, at Sinai, and in the manger, and Galatians 4:4 records the moment the timeless requirement arrived at its payment. Born of a woman: born a man, owing what men owe. Born under the law: owing it in full. Kline heard an address. "In accordance with the terms of his covenant of works with the Father he was to come as the second Adam in order to undergo a representative probation… It was therefore expedient, if not necessary, that Christ appear within a covenant order which, like the covenant with the first Adam, was governed by the works principle (cf. Gal 4:4)" (Kingdom Prologue, p. 352). The law under which the Son was born is the Sinai administration in its historical hour: an actual covenant order, placed in a land, carrying dated sanctions, set to expire at the date the Father appointed (Gal 4:2). The stipulation He came to fulfill was sworn in the Pactum — His covenant of works with the Father — and the Mosaic order was the theater appointed for the probation, the one covenant order on earth governed at its typological level by the works principle, as Eden had been governed in truth. Born of a woman places Him inside the arena: Adam's line, Israel's household, under the administration from within. What the administration had done by the time He entered it is the next link. The typological law condemned Israel, and the condemnation was real history. At its typological level the Mosaic economy was "an administration of condemnation as a consequence of sinful Israel's failure to maintain the necessary meritorious obedience" (Kingdom Prologue, p. 109). Exile is a sanction executed, a probation failed by a nation in a land. A hypothetical law condemns nobody; Israel was condemned by an operative one, under oath, in time. Romans 2 tells the reader where that condemnation points. Paul places the Jew, condemned by the law he possesses, beside the Gentile, condemned by the work of the law written on his heart (2:14–15), and runs both lines to a single day on which God "will render to each one according to his works" and judge the secrets of men (2:6, 16). Israel's national sentence is the exhibit of the race's. Kline's sentence on the Law's pedagogy names the exhibit's caption: Israel's tragic history under its covenant-of-works probation exhibits "the situation of all mankind, fallen in and with Adam in the original probation in Eden" (God, Heaven and Har Magedon, pp. 128–29). The type condemned a nation in the land. What it displayed was Adam's race under Adam's condemnation. Then the Son obeyed the type. Inside the administration Israel had failed, He rendered the obedience the works principle demanded, under the sanctions the administration actually carried, born under the law to redeem those who were under the law. The obedience rendered in the type points to the redemption accomplished in the reality: the curse exhausted on the cross was Adam's curse, the probation completed was the Pactum's, and the adoption purchased in Galatians 4:5 is the eschatological inheritance itself, entering the heirs' hands as gift because their Head earned it as reward. He fulfilled the type from inside it, and in fulfilling it He reached what the type was given to picture — a race redeemed from the Adamic condemnation, not a nation retained in a land. Flatten the administrations into one standing claim and the whole sequence dissolves: no real condemnation of Israel, no exhibit for Romans 2 to read, no arena for the probation, nothing for "born under the law" to mean beyond the bare fact of obligation. Keep the registers where Paul and Moses put them, and the history itself becomes the argument — a nation condemned in the land, a race condemned in its first head, a Vassal born under the dated administration to obey the type and accomplish the redemption the type was built to show. #Galatians4 #CovenantOfWorks #PactumSalutis #CovenantTheology #Kline #SecondAdam
1
6
246
Moderna's wicked new flu product (mFLUSIVA) just came out two months ago. Already there are 48 reports of injury in VAERS, representing a small fraction of the whole. They read very much like the early reports of the Covid poisons. Same signs. V-Safe entries clock the decline from fatigue to injection-site pain to headaches to rashes to GI issues to limb dysfunction and on and on, like a poisoning, ending in disability and sometimes death. You can see all the signs that this is happening right now with this new injection. Will no one at the FDA stop the madness before it is too late? openvaers.com/search-vaers?q…
119
889
66
2,233
86,479
“I have been young, and now am old; Yet I have not seen the righteous forsaken, Nor his descendants begging bread. He is ever merciful, and lends; And his descendants are blessed” Psalm 37:25-26
4
67
Jack Miller retweeted
“I am persuaded that love and humility are the highest attainments in the school of Christ and the brightest evidences that He is indeed our Master.” (John Newton)
1
7
192
Jack Miller retweeted
You can’t win an argument with your husband or wife. Peterson’s point is simple. If you win, you’ve defeated your spouse, and you two are one, so you’ve defeated yourself. Now you live with someone who’s defeated and bitter. So what do you do if you’re the better arguer? Help your partner make their case. They might be right, and it’s in your interest to hear it. He connects this to loving your enemy and giving the devil his due. Being good at talking doesn’t make you correct, and stomping around insisting you’re right fixes nothing. One of the wisest things anyone has said about marriage.
62
353
22
2,369
106,614
Jack Miller retweeted
@TexasPreacher Antinomianism is the rejection of the moral law being the continued rule for the Christian life. Clark affirms the “third use” and has written at length on all aspects of the law (and the gospel). Your mislabeling of his refusal to ground our assurance in our works instead of Christ’s finished work is slandering, detracting, misconstructing intentions, words, and actions, raising false rumors, and evil suspicion (WLC 145). Either cite Scott’s rejection of God’s law (without telling me to buy your buddy’s 50 pg book) or retract in true repentance. Any other response, or lack of response, is deflection.
5
3
2
22
1,354
“faithfulness as the shape of gratitude inside an inheritance received, never as the price of the King's word”
Cheap Pastoring "Well done, good and faithful servant" is not an assignment. It is the commendation the Master speaks at his return, over servants who traded with what was his. And in the architecture of the covenant it has an address before it has an echo: "This is my beloved Son, with whom I am well pleased" is the Father's commendation of the one faithful Servant, the Head in whose house every heir stands. The heirs will hear "well done" because they are in the One of whom it is eternally true. The word is a promise before it is anything else. Watch the standard pulpit operation performed on it. The commendation is lifted out of the return scene and reissued in the present tense as capacity: you cannot be perfect, but you can do well; you cannot force fruitfulness, but you can be faithful; it is within the reach of every Christian to please God with their life. Every clause sounds gentle. The operation underneath is a conversion — an eschatological promise transformed into a present imperative, the ground of the word quietly relocated from the Head's receipt to the hearer's reach. It is cheap pastoring, and the cheapness is exact. Grounding the commendation costs an architecture: the covenant of works and its faithful Vassal, the Pactum in which the Son undertook the house, the inheritance received whole by the heirs in Him. Skip the architecture and the application is free — for the preacher. The hearer pays the bill all week, measuring his reach against a commendation that was never placed within it, and coming up either despairing or self-satisfied. Both are the covenant of works administered to the heirs of grace, in a gentle voice. Preached as the Scripture gives it, the "well done" sends no one home to earn it. It sends the household to its work as men and women who live under a commendation already secured by their Head — faithfulness as the shape of gratitude inside an inheritance received, never as the price of the King's word. A promise preached as an imperative is the law with the sanctions removed and the demand left standing. That is not the gospel applied. It is the gospel replaced. #Matthew25 #Preaching #CovenantTheology #Kline #SecondAdam
1
67
Given this would take both houses voting for this (60 votes in the Senate) how do you propose to push this through?
The national debt now costs $362,000 per taxpayer. The way to address this crisis is with the Six Penny Plan. Make even, across-the-board cuts, and we will balance the budget in 5 years. It’s that simple.
1
170
Yes, we need a much more Christocentric reading of the Psalter before immediately leaping to our own piety—which does describe us in union with him. They are the prayers of Christ, after all. It would clear up a lot of confusion.
Why must we choose between Christ’s perfect righteousness and the believer’s obligation to pursue righteousness? Psalm 15 does not begin by asking how believers ought to behave, but who may dwell in God’s holy presence. Psalm 24 asks essentially the same question: Who shall ascend the hill of the Lord? Who shall stand in his holy place? Surely we ought to ask who ultimately satisfies these qualifications before reducing the passage to a prescription for Christian piety. Christ’s fulfillment of the righteousness described in these psalms does not negate their ethical demands upon believers. But neither do those ethical demands negate their fulfillment in Christ. There is no one who has ascended the hill of the Lord on the basis of his own obedience save the Lord Jesus Christ. He alone has clean hands and a pure heart in the fullest sense. This does not negate the believer’s obligation to pursue holiness, but neither should we confuse the righteousness by which we are accepted before God with the righteousness that necessarily follows from that acceptance. Why must Christ’s fulfillment of these psalms be set against their application to Christian piety? “For this is the love of God, that we keep his commandments. And his commandments are not burdensome. For everyone who has been born of God overcomes the world. And this is the victory that has overcome the world—our faith. Who is it that overcomes the world except the one who believes that Jesus is the Son of God?” 1 John 5:3-5
4
7
43
1,424
Jack Miller retweeted
Read Colossians 2:11–12 in the Greek and the sentence will not split. It is one sentence. Every verb is passive: περιετμήθητε, you were circumcised; συνταφέντες, buried with Him; συνηγέρθητε, raised with Him. The Colossians perform none of it. They receive all of it, and all of it is located ἐν ᾧ — in Him. Two συν-compound verbs weld their burial and their resurrection to Christ. Regeneration in verse 11 and baptism in verse 12, two events in two subjects, is a reading imposed on the punctuation of English translations. Paul's syntax knows one movement in one place: in Christ. "The circumcision of Christ" is Christ's. Paul calls it ἀχειροποίητος, made without hands — Daniel's word for the stone cut without hands that shatters the kingdoms (Dan 2:34), the Lord's word for the temple made without hands that is His risen body (Mark 14:58). The register is God's own climactic deed, not an inward experience. And Paul defines the event himself, in this same letter: the stripping off is ἐν τῇ ἀπεκδύσει τοῦ σώματος τῆς σαρκός, "in the putting off of the body of the flesh." In 1:22 that phrase is Christ's — reconciliation accomplished "in the body of His flesh through death." The rare root appears once more, at 2:15, where Christ at the cross is the one stripping — ἀπεκδυσάμενος — the rulers and authorities. Body of flesh, stripping, cross: Paul's vocabulary locates the circumcision of Christ where Kline located it, in the covenant cutting executed on the federal Head. Baptism seals to the believer what was cut away on Christ. "Through faith" will not do the work assigned to it either. Grammatically it hangs on the raising: συνηγέρθητε διὰ τῆς πίστεως τῆς ἐνεργείας τοῦ θεοῦ — raised through faith in the working of God who raised Him. The baptism clause carries no faith condition; Paul simply addresses baptized people and tells them where their burial and resurrection lie. Faith in this sentence is the hand that receives the benefit, and faith has never been the sign's gate in either administration. Circumcision sealed the righteousness of faith to a household whose infants exercised none (Rom 4:11; Gen 17). The sign follows the promise's address, and the address never changed: "to you and to your offspring" becomes "the promise is for you and for your children" (Gen 17:7; Acts 2:39). Kline assumes nothing here. The administration itself assigns the sign. On 1 Corinthians 7:14: Paul's word for the children is ἅγιος, holy — the covenant's own consecration vocabulary, the status of a people set apart inside the administration. And the mixed administration rests on texts, not appearances. Hebrews 10:29 speaks of a man sanctified by the blood of the covenant who then profanes it. The standing is real, it is covenantal, and the man perishes under eschatological judgment. The new covenant community in its visible administration is wider than the elect because its own apostasy texts say so. Every step of the counter-reading runs on one equation: covenant membership equals election, and the sign therefore waits on regeneration. That equation is the subject of the post. Restating it does not answer it. #Colossians2 #Paedobaptism #Baptism #CovenantTheology #Kline #SecondAdam
4
1
37
2,178
Crazy(?) but true… “Democracy is the theory that the common people know what they want and deserve to get it good and hard.” H. L. Mencken
2
163