Reporter: How do you define socialism personally? JD Vance: I think in reality what it actually means in the American context is you want to replace American workers with foreigners workers, and you want boys to play in girls' sports

Oct 8, 2026 · 7:37 PM UTC

505
170
320
3,173
621,345
RelevantRecentLikes
"I think in reality, what it actually means in the American context is that you want to replace American workers with foreign workers, and you want boys to play in girls' sports." Read more: unusualwhales.com/news/vance…
JD Vance gives unusual definition of socialism at press conference

JD Vance gives unusual definition of socialism at press conference

Asked to define socialism, JD Vance said it means replacing American workers with foreign workers and letting boys play in girls' sports.

unusualwhales.com
5
1
15
41,279
oh yes, the economic theory of boys in girl sports. he so smrt
7
1
1,206
19,527
I've heard some creative definitions of socialism, but this is the first one that contains absolutely no socialism
1
4
525
15,370
He has no fucking clue bro that's crazy
4
2
518
12,612
Reporter: How do you define capitalism personally? JD Vance: I think in reality what it actually means in the American context is you want to replace the American government with a foreign one, and you want our boys to bomb girls' schools.
9
17
1
366
13,406
@grok what is the definition of socialism?
2
1
5,490
Government owning everything is socialism. BlackRock owning everything is apparently fine.
2
2
124
6,133
So “workers owning the means of production” turns into “foreign workers & trans people in sports.” For the majority of Americans that don’t understand, socialism is collective ownership of the means of production in an attempt to resolve the contradictions caused by capitalism. Its objective is more important than how it achieves this, which is to create a better society using markets, whereas capitalism prioritizes creating better markets using society. America is a colony, its primary purpose is extraction of wealth. The government and the corporations who own the media have brainwashed you to think that any alternative to capitalism won’t work. They do this by artificially impoverishing socialist countries and shaping your perception of socialism and communism by omitting key details of what actually happened (such as their involvement in the conditions).
5
4
1
70
5,150
Sounds like JD needs to go back to school
2
38
3,695
@unusual_whales
Image from Deep River (@AGorania)
2
1
22
1,526
This is why no one should take that fake spineless retard seriously
18
1,474
nitter.cf/guneaglefreedom/status…
Gun Eaglefreedom™ (@GunEagleFreedom) profile pictureGun Eaglefreedom™
@GunEagleFreedomOct 8
He’s literally right, what are we even talking about here?!
Image from Gun Eaglefreedom™ (@GunEagleFreedom)
8
564
What a disingenuous asshole 🤣
2
952
If he describes socialism accurately he knows he can't make it sound bad.
1
4
432
@unusual_whales
3
1,816
But government wealth redistribution programs are what JD calls capitalism
2
238
Socialism is a lotttttt worse than this dumb shit he said
8
2
1,468
Medical care, food, subsidized housing. The poor are supposed to die in the streets so nobody has to support them. (according to American conservatives)
2
988
Those are tertiary issues that the socialist in America happen to support. And you shouldn’t have a personal definition of socialism. Socialism is when a radical revolutionary Vanguard usurps the government by any means possible.
1
1
2,206
Nihilism and social decay, are what most socialist movements promote to undermine stable nations without existing instability to exploit. Ultimately, descending elites push for upheaval, because socialism is never a proletarian movement.
4
1
2,159
Wut.. that’s literally globalistic capitalism.
2
941
"in the American context" is a huge tell he doesn't know or is straight up bullshiting – at Ardsley, NY
1
85
So essentially we need to make sure he’s impeached as well.
2
165
Welp, blew that one. Better luck next time
1
783
That’s almost too dumb to believe. We have to be missing context from the question or answer.
1
1
896
Asked for a definition of socialism, the answer was foreign workers and sports. Those are live fights. They are not a definition. Words still have to mean something.
2
2,302
What an idiot. He is a perfect match to Trump for dumbest or, as Trump likes to spell it, dum’est.
11
That is indeed what stupid leftists want.
75
“ you want to replace American workers with foreigners workers, and you want boys to play in girls' sports” @grok is this a good definition of socialism by Vance?
1
8
And hundreds of thousands of people will say “YEAH!” We cooked
579
That sounds about right for republicans. Socialism has nothing to do with economics for them
2
284
This is one of the dumbest things I’ve ever heard
498
From the United States side, it is a must to expand to the foreign countries, helping others to have higher employment rates, overcoming crisises rather than substitute your own with foreigners or let your business down to switch to imports rather than exports or outsourcing.
1
183
American employees cannot be substituted with foreign workers, meaning outsourced relations cannot progress. I also do not comprehend why would men get themselves involved with “female sports”.
1
1
197
@809trader Are we making up definitions now?
1
1,545
JD’s contorted answer? A non-sequiter. The sooner conservatives expunge JD and his type from their party, the better.
1
1,793
Load more replies