Derek Ross (@wikiDerek) header
Derek Ross (@wikiDerek) profile picture
Nova Scotia, Canada
Joined December 2013
Photo by Derek Ross (@wikiDerek)Photo by Derek Ross (@wikiDerek)Photo by Derek Ross (@wikiDerek)Photo by Derek Ross (@wikiDerek)Photo by Derek Ross (@wikiDerek)Photo by Derek Ross (@wikiDerek)
One of the greatest and most haunting poems ever written, by Wilfred Owen:
31
Agreed. The principles of #MMT are straightforward. Most people are able to grasp the basics without trouble. The more advanced principles require a little more thought but most high school graduates should have no trouble understanding them with a little study.
I repeat, I'm not exclusively #MMT. But why do none of the professional economists on this thread apart from Itamar understand it even at a basic level? For instance, MMT does advocate tax increases in specific circumstances. It's basically a description of the operation of fiat currency systems, influenced by but not limited to older positions such as Chartalism, functional finance, endogenous money creation, sectoral balances and financial instability. It's certainly related to post-Keynesianism, which can help remedy some of its flaws such as trade balances, international currency valuation etc. I'm just a lowly all-rounder - economic history, sociology, social psychology - who worked in criminology departments. If I can understand it and summarise it why can't professional economists? Spoiler - the basic reason is that they have to straw-man it to fit their ideologically bound off-the-peg criticisms. Empirically grounded and theoretically sophisticated reformulation of provisional knowledge just isn't their forte. Paradigm-changing ideas are out of the question - disallowed. I block these people because there's no point in debating with them. You might as well argue with scientologists. I'm not trashing the intellectual capabilities of individuals I don't know outside their orthodox writings, but simply stating the incontrovertible truth that thus far the mainstream neoclassical position has been ideologically locked, that's all. Press any of them hard enough and you'll find its dual root is a deep fear of the state, socialism, collectivism, totalitarianism etc. and an equally deep belief in the individual's right to enter markets to aquire and bequeath unlimited assets. Professional/institutional advocates are not allowed to stray from these principles.
2
4
208
History has the answers if you only look.
Replying to @Handre
The US froze prices in WWII By 1941–42 the US was pouring unprecedented sums into the war. Deficits hit 13–27% of GDP. Factories were converting, workers were flooding into cities, and civilian demand was colliding with military demand for steel, rubber, food, and fuel. In WWI the same pattern produced a price explosion. Officials remembered that. Uncontrolled bidding would have driven the cost of the war itself through the roof, created windfall profits in scarce goods, and risked civilian unrest. Price controls were not a peacetime ideology. They were an emergency tool to keep the mobilisation from eating itself. The institutional answer: Roosevelt created the Office of Price Administration. John Kenneth Galbraith, then a young economist, became deputy administrator in charge of prices. Early selective “scientific” ceilings on individual commodities proved too slow. Inflation kept rising. In April 1942 they switched to the General Maximum Price Regulation - a near-economy-wide freeze at March 1942 levels. In April 1943 came the “Hold-the-Line” order. Complementary rationing (meat, sugar, gasoline, tires) and wage guidelines followed. Taxes and war-bond drives soaked up purchasing power. How inflation was actually contained: Official consumer prices for working-class households rose about 12% from the May 1942 freeze to January 1946 - roughly 3.3% a year. After Hold-the-Line the rise slowed to 1.4% a year through early 1946. That was far below the WWI trajectory. Wholesale prices and the cost of living rose much less than in the corresponding months of 1917–18, even though real output more than doubled and unemployment fell below 2%. Galbraith’s later explanation: many prices were already “administered” by large firms rather than set in auction markets. A freeze plus public compliance plus rationing could hold the line within a “margin of tolerance” of excess demand. Patriotism and local volunteer boards did a lot of the enforcement work. What made them useful: The point was never perfect price stability. It was to stop prices of war-critical and household goods from exploding while resources were redirected. • The government paid less for munitions and ships. • Civilian real consumption still rose 50% even as the military took a huge share of output. • Labour’s share of income increased. • Windfall profits in scarcity were limited, which helped political legitimacy. • Time was bought for fiscal measures (withholding tax, bond sales) to catch up. Galbraith later wrote that the General Maximum Price Regulation “worked.” He considered the OPA years one of his principal achievements precisely because prices stayed relatively stable while the economy quadrupled in size. What they did not do: They did not abolish shortages. Quality often deteriorated. Black markets appeared, especially in meat. A large bureaucracy was required. Official indices missed some hidden inflation (skimpflation, forced substitution). When controls were lifted abruptly in 1946, prices jumped 20%. Those costs were accepted as the price of running a command-mobilisation economy at full stretch. Galbraith himself later favoured only limited, strategic restraints on large firms and unions in peacetime - not a full wartime apparatus.
38
Heads up, folks!
The next financial crisis is not coming from the banks. It is coming from the physical economy. I demonstrate the data in my latest video, link in comments. Most commentators are still watching credit spreads. Here is what they are missing: I saw 2008 in the debt numbers. American private debt was 150% of GDP by 2005. The growth of credit peaked at the equivalent of 15% of GDP in 2006. I said that rate could not be sustained. When the level of private debt stopped rising, credit did not just slow. It turned negative, down to minus 5% of GDP in 2009. That is what caused the downturn. This time the trigger is supply, then debt service. Households pay mortgages out of wages. Firms pay corporate debt out of profits. Until the war, that was just about feasible. Close the Strait of Hormuz and you do not only lose oil. You lose fertilizer for American crops, helium for MRI machines and high-tech lines, and about half the world’s sulfuric acid. Sour crude from the Persian Gulf is where that sulfur comes from. No sulfuric acid, no copper. No copper, data centers and a long list of factories stall. Volume falls faster than price can save you. Then the interest cannot be paid. Energy and output move one for one. I plotted energy from the IEA against gross world product from the World Bank in Ravel©. They sit on the same line. A 4% rise in one is a 4% rise in the other. COVID proved it in reverse. Mainstream models treat energy as about 4% of GDP, so a 10% energy shock becomes a 0.4% story. That is not the real world. A 10% fall in energy availability implies a 10% fall in gross world product. You cannot put more workers in the petrol tank.
31
This is true #Science. Love it!
I’m a physics teacher, and quite a few stories have stayed with me throughout my career. In my class, there’s an unwritten rule: For every final research project, students must submit a lab notebook recording all raw measurement data. Missing data or fabricated results mean an automatic F, in science there’s simply no room for dishonesty. At the end of the term that year, a girl came to turn in her reversible pendulum project which was meant to measure the acceleration due to gravity. The data in her notebook was all over the place, and her graph was wildly off from the theoretical value of 9.8 m/s². "My results are... completely ruined," she said. "Everyone else got nice numbers close to 9.8. I guess I'm getting an F". I looked at her densely packed notebook, filled with meticulous notes: measurements taken at 2:00 AM, the humidity in her bedroom, even the exact times the string snapped and had to be retied. Having taught for over a decade, I can easily tell who fakes their numbers to match the textbook and who stays up all night putting in the real work. "Why didn't you just tweak the numbers a bit to get closer to 9.8, like the others?" I asked. She looked up, her eyes rimmed with red, but her voice was steady: "Because the data is what it is. You taught us that a scientist never lies about their data." I silently flipped to the next page and marked a big red A. She was stunned. "Wait... but my experiment completely failed?" "Your experiment didn't fail. It just proved that your pendulum had air drag and a wobbly pivot" I said. "Science isn't about manufactured perfection, it's about the pursuit of truth. You stood up for the truth, and that's the true mark of a researcher." Starting that semester, I created a small award in the corner of the lab: "The Best Failed Lab Report", given to the experiment with the most skewed results, but the most honest logs and thorough error analysis. I want these kids to understand that having the courage to acknowledge mistakes and confront reality matters far more than faking a perfect score just to please someone else.
2
48
The graph only starts in 1950 but the figures go right back to 1920 when the council housing programme began.
Councils stopped building houses...and basically nobody took their place.
1
75
An unsung hero of our modern age. #ThankYou
A Japanese engineer invented the QR code for one job, tracking car parts on a Toyota line, then his company chose to give the patent away for free, which is the only reason it ended up on every restaurant table on Earth. His name is Masahiro Hara. The company was Denso Wave, a parts supplier owned by Toyota. In 1992 the problem landed on his desk, and it was not glamorous. Workers on the factory floor were drowning. Every car part had a barcode, but a barcode can only hold about twenty characters, so to track one component they had to stick five or ten barcodes on it. A worker would stand there scanning a single part ten times in a row. Some of them were scanning close to a thousand barcodes a day. The job had stopped being about building cars and turned into pointing a scanner at stickers all day long. And there was a second problem nobody upstairs cared about. This was a factory. Oil got on everything. A smudge of grease across a barcode and the whole thing became unreadable, and the line stopped. Hara was asked to make the scanner faster. He looked at it for a while and realized the scanner was not the problem. The barcode itself was the ceiling. A line of black bars can only hold information going one direction, left to right. He decided to build something that held information in two directions, up and down as well as across, so it could store hundreds of times more in the same little square. Then came the part that sounds made up but is not. Hara played Go on his lunch breaks, the old board game with black and white stones sitting on a grid. He was staring at the board one day and it clicked. The grid of black and white stones was already a way to store information in two directions. That was the shape of his code. But building the code was the easy half. The hard problem was speed, because the whole point was to be fast, and a scanner wastes most of its time just trying to figure out where the code is and which way it is turned. The fix came to him on a train. He was looking out the window at buildings, and one building stood out from all the others because of its shape against the sky. That was the idea. He put three little square targets in three corners of the code. The moment a scanner sees those three squares, it knows instantly where the code is and how it is rotated, even upside down, even at an angle. Now here is the detail that shows how far he was willing to go. Those three corner squares only work if nothing else on the page looks like them. If a magazine ad or a cardboard box happened to have the same black and white pattern nearby, the scanner would get confused and grab the wrong thing. So Hara and his tiny two-person team went and surveyed printed material. Magazines. Flyers. Cardboard boxes. Piles of it, for days, reducing every picture down to its ratio of black to white area, hunting for the one ratio that almost never shows up in print anywhere. They found it. One to one to three to one to one. That exact rhythm of black and white is baked into every corner square of every QR code on Earth, and it is there because it is the pattern the printed world almost never produces by accident. Then he solved the oil. He built the code so it carries a backup of its own information, spread mathematically across the whole square. You can tear off, smudge, or scratch out up to thirty percent of a QR code and it still scans perfectly, because the code rebuilds the missing piece from the copy it kept of itself. A worker could get grease on a third of the label and the line would keep moving. This is the same math that lets a scratched CD still play and lets a spacecraft send data back across the solar system without asking to repeat itself. He finished in 1994. He named it Quick Response, after what it does for the person using it, not after what it is. And then Denso made the decision that actually mattered. They held the patent. They could have charged a fee on every single scan, and given how many billions happen now, that would have made someone unimaginably rich. Instead they announced they would not enforce their rights to collect royalties, and they published the specification openly so anyone could use it. Hara later said it was not even a big argument inside the company. That one choice is the whole story. A code that costs nothing to use is a code everyone builds on. Airlines put it on tickets. Phone makers built readers into cameras. Then a pandemic hit and the world needed a way to hand someone information without touching anything, and the free little square that a Toyota engineer built for greasy factory workers was suddenly on every menu, every payment, every door. Hara still works there. He has said, more than once, that he never imagined it would spread this far, and that the part he is proudest of is that it got used to keep people safe. The man built it to survive oil on a factory floor. It ended up surviving everything else too. You have scanned his work a hundred times this year. Now you know whose it was.
2
67
China today. The World tomorrow? #Robots
so "companion humanoids" are starting to become a thing in China. one of them just pulled in 13,000 orders on its first day of sales. (for context Unitree, the biggest humanoid robot maker in the world, shipped around 5,500 humanoids in all of 2025. this robot just booked more than double that in 24 hours.) it's called the U1, built by UBTech in Shenzhen, the first humanoid robot company to ever go public. most humanoids are built for factories and warehouses, but this one was built for keeping people company. and the whole design follows from that job. it comes as a 6-foot man or a 5'6" woman. the skin is silicone, stretched over 88 motorized joints, enough to reproduce about 90% of human movement. the speed matters as much as the range. when you talk, the face reacts in under 20 milliseconds, faster than a blink. any slower and the reactions would start to feel fake. the AI underneath was trained to read emotion. UBTech says it recognizes more than 20 emotional states with over 90% accuracy, so it adjusts to how you're actually feeling. there's no wake word either. you talk, it answers, the same way a conversation with a person works. and it remembers. your routines, your stories, how your week went. the longer you live with it, the better it knows you. everything it learns stays stored on the robot, nothing gets sent to the cloud. the demand comes from a real problem. China has 118 million empty-nest seniors, parents whose kids grew up and moved away. another 90 million adults live completely alone. for a huge share of the country, there's nobody home to talk to. the U1 was built to fill exactly that gap. a presence in the house that talks back, reads your mood, remembers your life. and the custom orders push it further. UBTech will scan a real person's face, clone their voice, build the robot to match. so a family can order one that looks and sounds like someone who died (remember that black mirror episode btw??) however, none of it is fully there yet... > top models cost over $135,000. > the battery only runs 2 to 4 hours, which UBTech admits is just where full-size humanoids are today. they're also donating 100 units this year to seniors living alone and kids separated from their parents. loneliness is becoming a market. and the Chinese are buying like crazy. i'm curious to see if this would catch on as easily in the West?
1
1
63
Council housing worked wonders for rents between 1919 and 1979. It could do so again.
22
This is the intersection between #Georgism and #MMT.
Yes, I’m posting about this again, because people keep attacking a strawman. Condon is not saying “building houses mechanically raises prices.” He is saying that in markets like Vancouver, the value created by density is often capitalized into land prices first. That is a Georgist argument, not economic illiteracy. Land is not a normal commodity. Its value comes from location, public investment, zoning rights, population growth, infrastructure, and expected future rents. When a city upzones or demand rises, landowners can capture that expected future value through a higher land price. Add the PK piece and it becomes even clearer: banks create mortgage credit, that credit raises bidding power, higher bids validate higher land values, and higher land values force developers to build whatever still pencils. That is how you get a city that builds a lot but still becomes less affordable. The stock is inflated land value. The flows are rent, mortgage credit, interest payments, wages, taxes, infrastructure spending, and construction. If the flows keep capitalizing into the land stock, “more supply” does not automatically become affordability. It can just become a more expensive land market with more towers on it.
1
43
The Great Data Heist. #UBI
In the 1700s, landlords fenced off the land. Today, tech giants are fencing off our data. We funded the research. We provided the data. Now, AI is generating record wealth while firing humans. We aren't asking for a handout; we're asking for our share.
33
Uh oh!
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
24
And #PrivatedDebt pigeons are coming home to roost.
While everyone is distracted there is a snowball rolling downhill gathering steam getting bigger and bigger. Feedback loops are in process. Liquidity in credit doesn’t matter until it does. Financial reflexivity works both ways.
20
This is the secret for achieving reliable taxation.
This doesn't account for deadweight loss. Tax his non reproducible assets like land and patent monopolies. Taxing his reproducible capital just will result in capital flight and production decline. Taxing capital is avoidable but not land
1
34
And as a result taxing the production of goods raises prices whereas taxing raw materials (or the land that produces them) does not. This is the fundamental case for #Georgist tax reforms.
"Generally speaking, changes in the prices of finished goods are cost determined while changes in the prices of raw materials inclusive of primary foodstuffs are demand determined". -Michał Kalecki
3
64
Peter Smith writing about the astounding impact of #LandTaxation on #JapaneseHistory and the #JapaneseEconomy from the 1870s onwards. Excellent, and very readable, case study.
Japan proved twice that taxing land rent produces miracles. It proved twice that privatising it produces catastrophe. The US housing crisis is radicalising a generation. We have seen this film before. #MAGA #LandValueTax open.substack.com/pub/peeta4…
1
2
53
This is a crucial point. #MMT doesn't say we need to tax rich people for the money. MMT says we need to tax rich people for the resources.
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
1
41
Not exactly. What happened is that $7 trillion was transferred from gold buyers to gold sellers. Nothing was erased except some wishful thinking. There is the same weight of gold and number of dollars now as there was last week. Just in different hands.
THE LARGEST CRASH IN DECADES. Over $7 TRILLION has been erased from the precious metals in just 36 hours. Silver is down 30% and has dropped below $85, wiping out $1.96 trillion. Gold is down 13.6% and has dropped below $4,900, wiping out $5 trillion. Platinum is down 27.25% and has dropped below $2,100, wiping out $215 billion. Palladium is down 21.5% and has dropped below $1,700, wiping out $85 billion.
36
History may not repeat but it does rhyme.
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
81