Anodos retweeted
AI headlines often focus on platforms. $NRAM focuses lower in the stack: memory and storage companies addressing the AI memory wall. Learn more about the ETF and risks.
Anodos retweeted
what an awful take
Anodos retweeted
Gosh, I’d love to attend this debate. But I’m pretty sure I have a MAGA rally to attend that night…
If you have any doubt that the German Catholic academy has fallen into clownish irrelevance, look no further than this inane and ginned-up “controversy.”
Last summer, the vaunted “protest” consisted of 25 desultory septuaginarians holding signs and a statement from the theological faculty of the University of Munster, which was at an undergraduate level of sophistication and which betrayed not the slightest indication of any familiarity with my work.
And yes, that sound you hear in the background is Josef Pieper turning in his grave.
The senseless animus and hysterical schadenfreude for @skdh is bizarre. She is by far the most consistent, substantive and serious popular communicator of material science.
Her guilt seems to be in noticing that a swath of accredited scientific contributions are fake/dumb. nitter.cf/bahramshakerin/status/…
1
188
Anodos retweeted
I thought it'd be a good idea to do a quick summary of the points I have made about the problems in the foundations of physics, just to make it more difficult for the offended physicists on X to pretend misunderstanding me:
(A) The problem with the foundations of physics is that physicists continue to use methods that demonstrably do not work. They have made tens of thousands of so-called "predictions" for new particles, forces, extra dimensions etc etc, that were simply wrong. You can check this yourself. The literature is full of this nonsense. It has come to the point where a "prediction" in this field no longer means anything. It's embarrassing. And they're not doing anything about it.
I have NOT said that the problem is that it takes them a long time to make progress. It is true of course, that that theory development in the field has basically stalled since the completion of the standard model. But who is to say whether this is just because the questions are difficult.
If you think I have said that it is taking too long, you are confusing me with someone else.
I have said instead that the problem is that they are using methods that evidently do not work. And that they do not update these methods is hugely worrisome because it demonstrates a failure of science to self-correct. It shows that the self-correction in this community is broken.
(B) I have been very clear with saying that the problem is theory development in the foundations of physics. Not the foundations of physics per se (clearly experiment has made progress), not physics per se (clearly there is more to physics than the foundations), but theory development in the foundations of physics.
(C) In my book Lost in Math, I explain that historically the method that has worked best (for theory development in the foundations) has been requiring mathematical consistency. This is why I argue physicists in these areas should prioritize solving problems of mathematical consistency and/or inconsistency with experiments. Examples: quantum gravity, measurement problem in quantum physics, dark matter. This is not an exhaustive list.
(D) I did not say that mathematical consistency is either sufficient or necessary for a successful new theory. I made a much weaker point, which is that historically it has worked well. Evidence speaks for it.
Obviously just because a theory is mathematically consistent doesn't mean it also correctly describes nature. Meaning: Physicists must also make sure their theory can, and will be tested. If they work on a theory without thinking about how to experimentally test it, that is not scientific.
(E) People who haven't read my book sometimes think I say physicists use too much maths. This could not be farther from the truth. I argue they need to take maths more seriously.
(F) Because of the above, I have repeatedly said that string theory has a good motivation. If you think I am a big critic of string theory, again, you are confusing me with someone else.
(G) I have said that while these issues seem specific to the foundations of physics, they are symptoms of a bigger underlying problem that affects all of academia, which is that scientists get rewarded for producing papers that they themselves call progress. Progress in academia has no tangible external measure, hence they are optimizing irrelevant goals. It's a systemic problem that has been much discussed by sociologists and economists and many, if not most, academics are to some extent aware of it.
In the foundations in particular, physicists have hit on the rather obvious simple fix of producing theories that simply have no relation to the real world and then discussing them forever, claiming that paper production counts as progress in some sense. I'm not having it and neither should you. This nonsense needs to stop.
(H) I have been writing and speaking about this for about 20 years. Indeed it's how I got to know @ericweinstein , because I organized a conference about this a long time ago. The idea that either of us is going on about this because it is somehow "popular" contradicts facts. Rather what has happened is that at last at least the more informed public is paying attention to what we have been pointing out for a long time is a huge problem.
This claim that I misunderstood clearly calls for socratic discussion, but I suspect none will be allowed.
I think the avg person, as well as the avg well-educated person, will immediately observe the same bizarre confusion which he claims was only a misunderstanding.
Replying to @Anad0s
You’re misunderstanding what I’m saying, I’m not claiming the AI is conscious, I am simply saying it is explicitly aware of the position it is putting itself and me in by reaching out.
1
2
160
This guy is supposedly a top researcher but unfortunately he is undergoing “AI psychosis.”
When you preclude that self-reflexive language implies “self-aware” you are the same as the guy who thinks they are on the cusp of cracking all physics bc the bot congratulated them etc
By any metric—even omitting the publication of Bibles—more has been written & preserved about Christianity than any other religion or topic whatsoever & nothing else comes even close.
For this & many other reasons, it is VERY idiotic to gawk at an LLM “saying”Christian stuff.
The repetitive rhetorical flourish of “not needing x” is so ironically misplaced, erroneous, and stupid—the whole thesis and post are manifestly the claptrap of an LLM.
The only thing evidently “not needed” here was the conscious faculty of intellect.
Replying to @Biblicalman
Five realities. All sitting in your King James Bible.
I didn't need a concordance. Didn't need a seminary degree. Didn't need some dead language to "correct" the English.
I needed to shut up and let the Book teach me.
That's what I did. And I wrote down everything I found.
THE MAP OF THE DEAD - the full guide:
biblicalman.gumroad.com/l/fk…
2
454
The lady doth pander too much.
Replying to @Veralitra
Blue collar men tend to have common sense. Working with your hands has that effect.
2
519











