It may not be the biggest selling Bitcoin book (yet 😂), but I didn’t see any others at 18,000 feet!
1
29
1,149
Replying to @principal635172
“There is no wealth but life.”—JOHN RUSKIN. Opening quote from my book.
9
Rethinking the narratives. Chapter 17 moneyloveandbitcoin.com
I'm going to close the "ecological transition" debate once and for all.
Next time someone lectures you about degrowth and "saving the planet", here's the full genealogy. Bookmark this.
It starts with the Frankfurt School. Their problem: the Western working class never revolted, because capitalism kept making it richer. So Marcuse and co. changed the target. The enemy was no longer poverty. It was abundance itself. Consumer society. Growth.
Add Gramsci's playbook on top: don't seize the factories, seize the culture. Win the schools, the universities, the media, and politics will follow.
In 1972, the Club of Rome publishes The Limits to Growth. An MIT computer model telling the world that growth will hit a wall, resources will run out, collapse will follow. Fun detail: the Club was founded by an industrialist and a technocrat, and the study was funded by the Volkswagen Foundation. That's the trick. The anti-growth idea leaves the radical campus and puts on a lab coat and a suit.
Same year, the Marxist philosopher André Gorz picks it up and gives it a name: "décroissance". Degrowth. The loop is closed: a Marxist critique of abundance, wrapped in a scientific-looking doom model.
Fifty years later, the doom calendar keeps slipping. Extreme poverty has collapsed. Food per capita is up. France, the UK and the US all emit less CO2 than in 2005 with a bigger GDP.
So the narrative needed a new face. Enter Greta Thunberg. Not a scientist. Not an engineer. A teenager on a sailboat telling adults "how dare you". You can't debate a crying child. That's the whole point.
And here's the core sleight of hand: they welded growth and capitalism to the destruction of the planet. As if the solution was to produce less, consume less, build less, live less.
It's exactly backwards.
What decarbonized French electricity? Nuclear. A massive engineering project, not a sobriety campaign. What made solar ~90% cheaper in a decade? Markets, scale and innovation. Poor countries burn their forests. Rich countries replant them. Wealth is what pays for a clean environment.
Today it's dressed up in Davos language. "Great Reset". "You'll own nothing and be happy". Eat bugs. Fly less, drive less, have fewer kids. Rationing sold as virtue, preached by people who fly private to tell you about it.
And it trickles down into French politics. Even the "center" now calls water "the common good of humanity", and the answer to drought is... a new ministry. Always the same reflex: the world is finite, so the State must manage scarcity.
Our answer is the opposite. Scarcity is not a law of nature, it's an engineering problem. Abundant energy. Nuclear. Desalination. Space.
Degrowth isn't ecology. It's a death drive with a green coat of paint.
There is NO limit to growth. 🚀
35
What I found most disturbing about the entire discussion is how deeply embedded this nonsense is.
Unfortunately, from my experience, I see how the tropes against capitalism and the lofty goals of a democratic allocation of “society’s resources” appeal to so many people. There is heart in some of their stated the goals, and that is not to be dismissed, but if you follow the wrong road no matter how hard to walk, you won't get to your goal.
But failing to understand and acknowledge how this proverbial “we” of the representatives of a “democratic polity” that are the centralized allocators of capital to achieve social goals has led to the most egregious violence, destruction, and human suffering is unfathomable. Sorry, I don’t think this time will be different. As I state in my book, I don’t think fixing the money = fixing the world, but better technologies of money are likely to provide a foundation for better outcomes. Upon that foundation, we can rebuild a model of integrity and values that can help “fix the world” and Create a Path to a Freer, Fairer, and More Peaceful World.
1
4
52
Replying to @ProofofMindBTC
Hard to believe it’s been over a year since we met at Bitcoin Canada. Be well.
14
What I found most disturbing about the entire discussion is how deeply embedded this nonsense is. Unfortunately, from my experience, I see how the tropes against capitalism and the lofty goals of a democratic allocation of “society’s resources” appeal to so many people. There is heart in some of their stated the goals, and that is not to be dismissed, but if you follow the wrong road no matter how hard you walk, you won't get to your goal.
But failing to understand and acknowledge how this proverbial “we” of some centralized allocators of capital to achieve social goals has led to notorious violence, destruction, and human suffering is unfathomable. Sorry, I don’t think this time will be different. As I state in my book, I don’t think fixing the money = fixing the world, but better technologies of money are likely to provide a foundation for better outcomes. Upon that foundation, we can rebuild a model of integrity and values that can help “fix the world” and Create a Path to a Freer, Fairer, and More Peaceful World.
Thank you @saifedean for honorably and intelligently arguing the points against this brick wall. Your comments in response about housing--the real economy that matters--went totally unacknowledged and unrebutted. Profoundly inspiring and disturbing debate
34
Replying to @ProofofMindBTC
What I found most disturbing about the entire discussion is how deeply embedded this nonsense is. Unfortunately, from my experience, I see how the tropes against capitalism and the lofty goals of a democratic allocation of “society’s resources” appeal to so many people. There is heart in some of their stated the goals, and that is not to be dismissed, but if you follow the wrong road no matter how hard to walk, you won't get to your goal.
But failing to understand and acknowledge how this proverbial “we” of some centralized allocators of capital to achieve social goals has led to notorious violence, destruction, and human suffering is unfathomable. Sorry, I don’t think this time will be different. As I state in my book, I don’t think fixing the money = fixing the world, but better technologies of money are likely to provide a foundation for better outcomes. Upon that foundation, we can rebuild a model of integrity and values that can help “fix the world” and Create a Path to a Freer, Fairer, and More Peaceful World.
Thank you @saifedean for honorably and intelligently arguing the points against this brick wall. Your comments in response about housing--the real economy that matters--went totally unacknowledged and unrebutted. Profoundly inspiring and disturbing debate.
1
22
378
Replying to @natbrunell @JeffBooth
No. What’s off is the focus and attention on all the fiat players, traders, and macroeconomic prognosticators, who are playing a game inside the fiat world only making it stronger as Jeff clearly says.
While most of us have to live part of our lives in the fiat world, celebrating Bitcoin-related fiat behavior and consciousness distracts us from the objective of creating and living in a new system. The more we do that, the less likelihood we will move faster into the Freer, Fairer, and More Peaceful World that’s possible for us to create on a true sound money Bitcoin standard.
144
Replying to @natbrunell @JeffBooth
I hope you really heard what he was saying about the two systems and trading in the fiat world and how it only makes it stronger. This was my point in a past exchange we had. I hope you consider reflecting on it more deeply. Best wishes to you.
1
97
👇👇👇
Replying to @macrojack21
This isn't an opinion; it's an indispensable technical fact. If bitcoin doesn't go up in value it can't work because nobody wants to willingly hold a money that drops in value, and even more importantly, we can only increase its liquidity, market cap, scalability and moneyness by increasing its price, since the supply is fixed. At a price of $1 bitcoin is a $20m joke among nerds online, practically useless for everyone as there's no liquidity. At a price of $10m bitcoin is the biggest money on earth, and necessary for everyone. If you want bitcoin to work you need NGU. Virtue-signaling "tech, not price" is as silly as saying you like car technology but don't care if the car moves.
30
Replying to @matteopelleg
I’d put it this way. The value of information is going to zero. The value of knowledge is decreasing. The value of wisdom will exponentially increase as it continues to be more scarce.
This is all discussed, btw, in my book. 📕
1
18
Honored to be in the Nakamoto Library. Check it out at @nakamotolibrary for a full list of Bitcoin books.
2
76















