Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton (@BroOfHoppers) header
Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton (@BroOfHoppers) profile picture

Environmental activist for 50 years. Married to the best partner in the world. In a fossil fuel-free house since 2011 on Boon Wurrung land.

Hoppers Crossing, Australia
Joined March 2012
Photo by Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton (@BroOfHoppers)Photo by Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton (@BroOfHoppers)Photo by Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton (@BroOfHoppers)Photo by Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton (@BroOfHoppers)Photo by Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton (@BroOfHoppers)Photo by Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton (@BroOfHoppers)Photo by Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton (@BroOfHoppers)Photo by Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton (@BroOfHoppers)Photo by Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton (@BroOfHoppers)Photo by Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton (@BroOfHoppers)
Agree with Hodgson's assessment of the actions of deliberate disruptor candidate Finnigan in the District of Prahran. By what components of logic and truthfulness does a "Greens-value candidate" issue a Greens' mimicking How-to-vote card that puts the Greens dead last? #WhatsTheGame ?
Fair. In 2022, the VEC threatened independent campaigns with 6 months imprisonment if they used an open ticket HTV showing the full ballot. They claimed it was "likely to mislead or deceive an elector in casting the vote of the elector" (s 79(3)(a)). The VEC already has the power to act here. They have chosen to exercise that power on FAR more trivial matters (which were overturned by VCAT). VCAT even noted that brand mimicry is a more serious deception than the weird hill to die on of open ticket HTVs showing full ballots - with Quigley J commenting that (unlike open tickets) mimicry “clearly demonstrate[s] real potential to deceive a naïve or gullible voter”. Instead, the VEC approved what (on the surface) appears to be an intentional attempt to mislead or pass-off in a HTV - ruling that the s 79(3)(a) question (whether the HTV is “likely to mislead or deceive” a naive or gullible voter) - in favour of Finnigan. This is not a failure of any individual VEC staffer doing the best they can at an exceedingly chaotic and stressful time, but rather a reflection on the organisation itself - and its ability to effectively absorb and manage a HIGHLY complex, high-stakes and high-pressure task. In my personal view, The Greens are right to pursue this matter - and in my lay opinion post-Torney v VEC, have a VERY strong case. I would expect the ruling to favour The Greens - but cost them perhaps $50-100k that they would otherwise spend campaigning. (An expensive challenge - but given Prahran’s three cornered contests have previously come down to 31 votes - one The Greens can’t afford to ignore.) It’s important that these decisions are well-resourced and consistent - noting there’s a substantial, complex, and rapidly growing body of case law that needs to be taken into account when approving every HTV - and the only way for the VEC to perform consistently on this is through substantial (and expert) resourcing. We also need proper, well-thought-out electoral legislation that addresses these matters in advance - rather than the expedient and self-serving politicised bullshit we have seen passed through parliament in recent years. I would hope to see this (and other matters) raised and acted upon in the post-election review - rather than leaving it unaddressed, requiring expensive legal action to plug gaps, and eroding trust in elections. Sadly, I don’t have a lot of confidence that those who will hold the power to act on this after the election will choose to act. theguardian.com/australia-ne…
3
1
3
152
Great to see this vid going the rounds again 🤣
12
43
4
141
2,691
Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton retweeted
‘Only the Greens, David Pocock and Fatima Payman opposed.’ @DavidShoebridge called it a ‘war against your fellow Australians’. Labor, the Coalition & One Nation doing the bidding of the US. Mearsheimer warned us years ago - there is only one thing worse than being an enemy of the US, and that is being its ‘friend’. They are creating the scene for subservience in a terrifying future - anywhere can be Gaza. open.substack.com/pub/deepcu…
55
679
20
1,349
12,765
“A Chinese battery-electric commuter aircraft designed to carry 19 passengers completed its first crewed flight on Saturday, 14 November, after 19 uncrewed autonomous test flights. The CE-25A spent 16 minutes and 38 seconds in the air, covering 60.4 km over Binzhou in eastern China’s Shandong province. “The 10-tonne battery-electric aircraft is the CE-25A, which is designed to carry 19 passengers and boasts a cruising speed of 300 km/h, a cruising altitude of 2,400 metres, and a range of 400 kilometres.” thedriven.io/2026/11/20/chin…
1
2
54
Thing almost 5000 or so you read on the internet. Thanks Terry
1
3
10
202
Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton retweeted
Note re the usual Murdoch press "exit polls" of prepoll - they're very unreliable because of small sample size, prepoll generally breaking right, early prepoll being more likely to do so, and journalists are not trained pollsters. So always treat with much caution #springst
6
14
91
4,600
Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton retweeted
Tosh-Jake Finnigan formerly of Sack Dan Andrews has drawn top of the ballot in Prahran and issued a Greens-mimicking how to vote card. Preferences are an actual donkey vote which benefits Liberals
9
46
3
166
6,782
Labor wants to detain children for a year on low-level charges. The Coalition wants a boot camp at an old prison farm. Neither plan will fix anything. Indeed, both will manufacture Victoria’s adult offenders of the 2030s — at $7,304 per child, per day. crikey.com.au/2026/11/18/you…
6
22
2
48
675
The Herald Sun’s “experts” (ie its paid propagandists Deery and Campbell) pontificate on who won last night’s Political Leader’s (goodness, how I dislike that term) Debate On Sky News, which has stolen the ABC’s moniker of News24. Deery: “the winner of the night was Warren Pickering”. How odd then that Sky’s selected studio audience rated him 3rd out of 4 presenting politicians you might think. Campbell: “Ellen Sandell was talking to about three tram lines who probably weren’t watching”. Strange then that the handpicked Sky audience ranked her 2nd and 9% clear of Pickering. Never mind the data, just look at who’s providing the bags of silver and what they’re buying with it ☹ heraldsun.com.au/news/victor…
6
8
16
335
“Worst government we’ve seen in 50 years” says ridiculous hyperbolist Andrew Bragg. 😂 Fancy him forgetting Ms Credlin’s Gerry Gee, Mr Abbott, the 2014 “unity ticket” Budget and the 30 losing Newspolls in a row, eh Mr Turnbull? And this still qualifies as “news” and fit for publication. 😡 heraldsun.com.au/news/breaki…
2
13
28
432
God grief 🤣🤣
The Herald-Sun has been dragged sobbing and screaming into releasing some more actual details of their Lighthouse poll (still not enough but something). It's an online poll conducted through a large panel called the Lighthouse Consumer Tracker. #springst
1
1
132
Dr Bro Sheffield-Brotherton retweeted
One Nation has registered a statewide how to vote that lists the now disendorsed candidate for Preston as someone One Nation voters should vote 1 for. There is precedent for this to be declared illegal. #springst vec.vic.gov.au/api/sitecore/…
10
93
6
427
21,270
There are definitely people in the City of Wyndham familiar with the shenanigans of Mr Bauch, particularly the 2016 Wyndham City Council Election: “A Victorian One Nation candidate has been exposed as an administrator of a pro-One Nation Facebook group with ties to an account producing racist and offensive AI slop material… “The official Facebook page of One Nation's candidate for the outer-Melbourne seat of Sydenham, Joh Bauch, has been revealed as one of two administrators of a pro-Pauline Hanson Facebook group with ties to an account publishing racist material.” abc.net.au/news/2026-11-16/o…
1
53
"Bail “It’s a free country.” — Ben Roberts-Smith "The alleged war criminal defends attending a Remembrance Day service alongside Pauline Hanson. A free country is what the diggers fought for but not against one-legged civilians."
1
80