Replying to @durand_pau1220 @kirawontmiss
Wait, you can’t possibly be the same person who posted this within the same hour? nitter.cf/durand_pau1220/status/…
8
Replying to @IgorKaratayev @simongerman600
@grok estimate the relative spending to help Ukraine against Russia by each EU country in terms of GDP per capita, include the US for comparison. Assess the accuracy of the “whole Europe is helping” claim.
15
Replying to @durand_pau1220 @simongerman600
Absolutely, and this is the number one reason I want my own nuclear armed nation as uninvolved in this inter-Slavic conflict as possible. Absolutely reckless to extend to the nuclear deterrent threat to Ukraine. They must be kept out of NATO. Very good point. Minimizing the risk of WW3 is most important here.
14
Replying to @adamcarolla
The useful idiot’s order (if they respond)
1. racist!
2. Fascist!
3. Zionist!
4. Patriarchy!
5. racist!
18
427
I think you reveal your real agenda in the last two sentences.
You deplore HK (though you seem to know very little about it) but are happy to equate Germany and the UK to it if it allows your Euro bureaucratic “managed democracy”.
So what you’ve learned from your past is that you can never limit migration because that would be “racist”. Have I got that wrong? Are there other reasons to annul the vote of establishment dissenting voters? The excuses they have here sound pretty good to the establishment narrative believers too you know. What’s the difference?
1
15
Replying to @DanClarkSports
I don’t know about netball, but in pickup basketball, it’s reasonable for men to play with women, you just need an even number of them so they can be on opposite teams and guard each other. You can have a reasonably competitive fun game where nobody has to “go easy” on anyone else. Odd numbers or “boys vs girls” not so much.
2
305
I’m concerned about press freedom as well, and I don’t argue that it hasn’t deteriorated in HK in recent years. It has. They closed a major (Western intelligence allied, way more extreme in its accusations against the government than any Western government would tolerate) newspaper here, and several smaller outlets. That hasn’t really happened in the west. But it’s also not the most important story here, which is self censorship. And that’s very much a problem in the West.
In Germany you have a political party that has electoral support yet all other political parties exclude them coalitions because the establishment dictates that they are beyond the pale. We have that here. If you aren’t allowed to vote for them or somehow votes for them are annulled, you will have “perfected” your democracy exactly like same way Hong Kong did.
These organizations that rank Western countries at the top of their lists for press freedom and expressive freedom, where do they come from? Who funds them? Do they have any ties to unelected EU bureaucracies?
1
19
So you’re not a “Democratic Socialist”? My apologies, but it’s very difficult to tell the satirical accounts from the genuine ones in this space.
6
The German thought police do punish differently to the UK or HK thought police.
Your display would be more persuasive if it were about a particularly sensitive local politician. Of course Mertz knows it’s counterproductive to go after a random guy for something as innocuous as you did. But I don’t have the knowledge necessary to verify whether you are brave to say it or not.
Similarly you misidentify what HKers self-censor over (it’s more local than Taiwan) and there are lines I would be scared to cross. But in terms of my freedom (as an American), I feel freer to say what I want from here than I would from the UK or Germany. A lot of that has to do with what I care about and want to express about. I think HK is at an equilibrium that’s much better than most of Europe right now and I see no point wasting my breath on mainland politics. So I speak about the decline of my civilization, which I lament. And this happens to be a safe place to do that from. Safer than yours.
1
12
I mean if you actually think “being an asshole” (by whose subjective standard?) should be illegal, then we just aren’t coming from the same liberal tradition and so I would have to ask you why you think JS Mill is wrong about such and such before we could even have a discussion and that just doesn’t work in this format.
I’m sure you’re a nice person and all, but there’s just not enough mutual agreement for us to even disagree productively.
I would humbly ask that you consider the possibility that there could be unexplored nuance in some of these areas that you might explore, even if it provokes some temporary cognitive dissonance, it can make you healthier and less angry in the long run.
1
21
Taiwan is not China.
Now get someone in the UK to post “stop the small boats! I’m worried about the migrants raping our girls!”
Oh wait they “muted” me for criticizing their government. How convenient.
Since you’re German and haven’t (yet) muted or blocked me, you go:
Insult a German politician currently in government.
1
18
Replying to @tommylotto66 @charlesmurray
You mean his “Haram”?
Yes, too many words for a relatively simple point. Still, interesting that even in that time and place there was a taboo on applying what was known about animals to what straightforwardly extended to humans.
The Greek references show how far back this realization and the attendant uneasiness with it go.
27
Replying to @kees_k56958 @simongerman600
When I mature and grow my brain, I will someday evolve to the zero substance ad hominem attack that you have so effortlessly mastered here.
Until then, I’ll be forced by my small brain to only consider substantive responses.
3
Replying to @cara_do_face @CatholicSat
Yes and I guess he does wear the more dramatic hat at times.
17
Replying to @svatyDyndy @simongerman600
What’s the argument you think I’m making that you think this argues against? Or are you not arguing with me at all?
Genuinely curious. Because I don’t see it.
I love these multinational conversations, but I suspect much is still being lost in translation.
1
28
Replying to @Runanode @simongerman600
@grok assess the accuracy of this claim.
When did most of the western assistance arrive relative to the failed Russian attack on Kyiv?
Is it not true that the US offered Zelenskyy a way out of Kyiv because the US thought a Russian takeover was imminent?
2
54
Explain what you think I’m doing to “deny you the right to defend” anything. Or maybe it’s a mistranslation?
I don’t have a “narrative on Ukraine”. I can barely tell which side you’re on, and don’t much care. I would prefer my country (the US) be much less involved in both inter-Slavic conflict and inter-Semitic conflicts. But clearly our “allies” and political elites have other interests.
1
10
Replying to @PillePa47535599 @simongerman600
Yes Russia is using other tactics, like activating your Muslims and propagandizing your people to shout down anyone who doesn’t want more of them.
6

