
ALT This was the ‘socialist compassion’ mocked by Nietzsche (supra, 8 §5), and viewed with suspicion or hostility by critics of the revolution of all sorts. But, once again, the German philosopher was distinguished by his rigour. We have already seen how Tocqueville critically emphasised the role of eighteenth- century sentimentalism in the ideological preparation of the revolution. But, in another context, he assessed the feeling of compassion positively, seeing it as the common thread of progress or of the progressive construction of the unity of humankind. On the occasion of a popular revolt in Brittany in 1675, which had been repressed ‘with unexampled cruelty’, which Madame de Sévigné talked about in a letter to her daughter in a serene and almost amused tone, the French liberal commented that the noble lady ‘had no clear idea of what it meant to suffer, if one was not an aristocrat’. In a rigidly hierarchical society, not even feelings could overcome the barriers of class...

ALT We have seen how Engels, in criticising Carlyle’s theory of genius, commented ironically on the claim of the ‘whip’ to be a ‘genius’ (supra, 2 §5). The young Marx presented a variant of the metaphor when he spoke of the ‘knout’ legitimised by the historical school of law as ‘time-honoured, ancestral, historical’. To a certain extent availing itself of Enlightenment doctrine, the historical school of law made a great show to all and sundry of a ‘ruthless method’ and adopted a sceptical rather than a fideistic stance (infra, 16 §4). The result was paradoxical. A critique of ideology that destroyed the ‘flowers’, the attempts to legitimate the oppression and violence perpetrated by the ruling class, was transformed into an ideology that treated this violence and this oppression as if it did not even need to seek legitimation. One might say that Nietzsche conferred rigour and consistency on the procedure criticised by Marx in Hugo.

ALT But the philosopher’s way of arguing and his attitude were not synonymous with ‘untimeliness’ as such. Rather, what was ‘untimely’ was the ambition of conferring rigour and coherence on themes widespread in the culture of the time: if these themes were thought through in all their radicality and consistency, they ended up in hopeless conflict with the dominant ideology and religion that, despite everything, continued to be Christianity.

ALT In the three different situations, this social class embodied the cruel truth, upon which Nietzsche tirelessly insisted, that slavery in its various forms was of the essence of culture. On the other hand, this class continued to profess a religion that, at least in Nietzsche’s eyes, hopelessly contradicted the truth on which rested its own existence and success. In the expression ‘Christian Junker’, it was the adjective that horrified; and particularly because it was tied to a noun, to a social layer, that could have and should have put an end to Christian and socialist subversion. Again, Nietzsche’s attitude was defined not so much by ‘untimeliness’ as by the attempt to lend rigour and consistency to a trend already under way.

























