Pinned Tweet
I don't understand how the process of gaining knowledge or understanding of a skill could be the same for every individual. This requires thinking, and no one thinks the same.
2
6
1,332
Colby Lyons retweeted
Replying to @bryan_caplan
coercion was always the wrong way to educate kids. ai just makes that more true
now you can cheat on virtually anything when you're not interested. but you can also learn virtually anything when you really want to
Colby Lyons retweeted
Can you imagine learning to ride a bike by spending hours in lectures?
Aren't most of the valuable things we learn visceral, demanding the same sorts of balance, judgment, and developed habits as bike riding?
I'm making my way through Les Miserables. I don't have much background knowledge of the history of France. I'm sure it would be helpful to gain more understanding of the story. However, I can still gain a lot from it, regardless.
1
47
Colby Lyons retweeted
Most people don’t take John Taylor Gatto seriously when he claims higher literacy rates in MA before public education than after. But the Protestant commitment to Biblical literacy, prior to government schooling, was a more potent force for learning than schooling has been. The Jewish commitment to Talmudic study was even more potent.
On MA literacy before public schools,
skeptics.stackexchange.com/q…
"The constant reading of the bible in hundreds of thousands of humble families kept a basic floor of literacy under literature as a whole, and under the English language. The variety of styles of writing so admirably represented, the relative complexity of many of the ideas involved and the range of ethical levels to be found in that great compendium of ancient Hebrew culture demanded, in its reading and in its exposition to the children, a certain mental activity, and provided for the poorer classes the same sort of cultural groundwork that the study of Greek and Latin provided for the sons of the rich. A mind accustomed to the Old and New Testaments could easily admit Shakespeare and the entire range of Victorian writing: poetry, novels, historic and scientific essays, up to the saturation point of that particular intelligence. Today the English-speaking peoples have no such common basic classical education. The bottom level is the visual and aural culture of the movies, not a literary level at all. Above that appear all sorts of gradations of illiteracy, from those who, though they may have learned to read in school, are now barely able to spell out the captions in the pictures, to those who can take in, with the help of the photographs, a few simple sentences out of the daily tabloids, right through to the several millions of actively literate people who can read right through The Saturday Evening Post or The Reader’s Digest and understand every word of it. This is the literal truth. Every statistical survey that has recently been made of literacy in this country has produced the most staggering results. We have to face the fact that the number of Americans capable of reading a page of anything not aimed at the mentality of a child of twelve is not only on the decrease but probably rapidly on the decrease."
John Dos Passos
An over simplification but some truth here. Albert Jay Nock had the same idea - being able to read is not the same as being literate. Brings to mind Lincoln whose formal schooling lasted about six months, perhaps a year. He succinctly summed up his educational background in 1858, when he filled out a brief biographical sketch for the upcoming Dictionary of Congress: “Education defective,” it read. Primarily self-taught he read the Bible & Shakespeare avidly.
In an 1860 biography of candidate Lincoln, journalist William Dean Howells wrote that Mr. Lincoln was “a diligent student of Shakespeare, to know whom is a liberal education.” There's no denying this. Historian William E. Gienapp: "Lincoln’s gift for language was marvelous, even poetic, so much so that he is the only American president other than Thomas Jefferson whose writings can be considered literature.”
As for the King James Bible:
"The King James Bible came at the end of the Elizabethan age, between Shakespeare and Milton, when Englishmen were using words more passionately, richly, vigorously, wittily, and sublimely than ever before or since."
Dwight Macdonald
We're told that compulsory schooling is necessary for people to understand our government and preserve our Constitution. However, government continues to grow, we get further in debt, and candidates keep getting worse. Clearly it's not working.
1
8
154
Good plan.
Replying to @educator4ever36
Here's an idea: end compulsory attendance. Make schools a place someone would want to go to instead of depending on forced captivity.
37
Learning doesn't require a structured curriculum. Curriculum can be a useful resource, but it doesn't need to be followed explicitly for effective learning.
1
4
135
We keep kids in the artificial environment of school, tell them they have to focus on what we want them to learn. They lose their curiosity and desire to pursue their own interests. And apparently the solution is "knowledge rich" scripted curriculum?
I think the biggest issue here isn't that we learned a bunch of stuff in school that we don't use directly, but that we were forced to learn a bunch of unnecessary stuff that we didn't want to learn in the first place.
4
158
Am I understanding the argument of the scripted knowledge rich curriculum advocates correctly, that kids who aren't read to at home need to be explicitly taught background knowledge through scripted curriculum so they can learn to read?
1
83
Colby Lyons retweeted
The process of getting “order” in a classroom of six-year-olds requires convincing them that they have no agency, no sense, that they can do no real work, and that their curiosity is meaningless.
Is it any wonder that the schools fail to graduate responsible adults?
This seems to challenge the notion that innovative people need a great deal of direct, explicit instruction before they can innovate and create. To me, it looks like self-education is more important in cultivating innovation.
4
150
It's an odd coincidence. Suddenly, scripts are becoming trendy, just as science of reading legislation across the states is leading to the implementation of scripted "knowledge-rich curriculum." Who is pushing this and why?
31
I don't understand using "actors use scripts" as a justification for making teachers use them. Actors use scripts because they have to follow a predetermined storyline. Their fellow actors also use scripts, and the audience doesn't ask questions.
Colby Lyons retweeted
You know how frustrating it is when you ring the bank, a tech support line etc & you're stuck with someone reading a script & not really engaging? It's maddening on a 10 minute call. So now imagine having to put up with that all day, every day as a pupil with scripted lessons 🤦♂️
Colby Lyons retweeted
1,000 signatories protest against scripted lesson plans in Fort Worth, TX. Their letter reveals a sorry state that apply to schools beyond Ft. Worth.
Reading the letter (pictured) is a great opportunity for parents and educators to reflect.
Throughout the country, lesson plans and curriculum are created by faceless committees and delivered by overwhelmed and unaccountable teachers who are also paid for tenure over talent.
Yet, there are also schools that are just so bad, the best intervention possible given existing structures and rules might be a scripted lesson plan. 🤦♂️


























