NamedAfterMyDad (@JSPtheSecond) header
NamedAfterMyDad (@JSPtheSecond) profile picture

I wish I had a deep quote I could steal from someone so I can sound smart and stuff.

Salt Lake City, UT
Joined October 2015
Photo by NamedAfterMyDad (@JSPtheSecond)Photo by NamedAfterMyDad (@JSPtheSecond)Photo by NamedAfterMyDad (@JSPtheSecond)Photo by NamedAfterMyDad (@JSPtheSecond)Photo by NamedAfterMyDad (@JSPtheSecond)Photo by NamedAfterMyDad (@JSPtheSecond)Photo by NamedAfterMyDad (@JSPtheSecond)Photo by NamedAfterMyDad (@JSPtheSecond)Photo by NamedAfterMyDad (@JSPtheSecond)Photo by NamedAfterMyDad (@JSPtheSecond)
First, Amazon literally dumped half the entire season all at once on premiere day, dropping Ep1 through ep4 together on 11/11. When a streaming platform drops four episodes on a single day instead of spacing them out any viewer who tunes in automatically generates four times the page visits, episode lookups, and review clicks in a single week. Second, imdb's most popular chart doesn't actually measure streaming viewership or how many people love a show. It measures imdb page traffic, search volume, and engagement spikes. A big premiere dump combined with controversial lore changes like Eru showing up in a burning bush or Sauron needing help to forge the One Ring naturally drives millions of people to look up cast lists, episode summaries, and user scores, regardless of whether they hated what they saw or didn't even watch the show on Prime. Third, imdb has literally been an Amazon subsidiary since 1998. Bragging that an Amazon show hit number one on an Amazon owned website during the exact week Amazon dumped half the season at once isn't the flex this post thinks it is.
'Los Anillos de Poder' ocupa el puesto nº1 en IMDb como la serie más popular del mundo actualmente. ¿Cómo es eso posible, si nadie la ve? Un saludo a todos aquellos que no dejan de echar mierda sobre ella pero que con sus visualizaciones (a escondidas) la ven y apoyan igualmente.
48
NamedAfterMyDad retweeted
Applying purity tests to talent and filmmakers is tricky when almost everyone in this business is a degenerate. Maybe just review the movie based on the movie itself.
52
163
5
2,056
31,449
Successful shows that actually work don't tell viewers they can skip the first two seasons and treat season 3 like a brand new jumping on point. When showrunners openly call their 3rd season a soft reboot, cut out entire storylines like the Harfoots, rush through the Gandalf mystery box, and suddenly pivot the tone, they're quietly admitting the foundation they spent a billion dollars building didn't work. You don't need a fresh start if people are actually invested in the characters and plot you already established. It's a classic case of actions speaking louder than words. Defenders of the show will swear up and down that the first two seasons were misunderstood masterpieces yet the creators themselves felt forced to hit the reset button just to try and get more people to watch the series and to bring back the ones who left.
Amazon is Calling Rings of Power Season 3 a “Soft Reboot” “I think our goal for Season 3 is really to blow the doors off the hinges... We’re really proud of Seasons One and Two, but… for us, now, in some ways, we’re starting a whole new story. This is turning the page on the show.” -Patrick McKay, Rings of Power co-showrunner
32
So much praise for Rings of Power (RoP) comes down to people mistaking a superficial checklist of Tolkien references for actual depth and good storytelling. When viewers see something like an orc family, Sauron acting deceptive, or Celeborn nicking a strand of Galadriel's hair, they give the writers automatic credit just for bringing it up, regardless of how poorly it's done or whether it completely contradicts the books. It creates an illusion of sophistication because the show is gesturing at deeper ideas from Tolkien's notes without actually understanding them or doing the writing work to make them fit the world. Tolkien wrestled in his private letters with the moral question of whether orcs could ever be redeemed, since evil in his world can only corrupt life rather than create it. Even so, in the actual reality of middle earth he made it clear that orcs were so thoroughly twisted by Morgoth and Sauron's malice that they functioned as hateful, destructive creatures incapable of peaceful domestic life, irredeemable by the powers of elves, men, or themselves, and would take divine intervention to change their nature. Amazon's writers basically skimmed the cliff notes of that debate, slapped a suburban nuclear family onto an orc dad who wants to avoid war and raise his baby, and patted themselves on the back for being deep. Worse yet, that whole subplot breaks the basic logic of the story, because two episodes later that exact same orc dad is gleefully burning down cities and slaughtering elves without a second thought. Ultimately, tossing out half baked nods to obscure lore doesn't make a show smart. Good writing means weaving those ideas naturally into the world and how characters actually behave, whereas RoP just drops them in as shiny distractions so fans can point at the screen and claim the showrunners are Tolkien geniuses.
Bon alors qu’avez-vous pensé de ces 4 nouveaux épisodes de The Rings of Power ? Plutôt satisfait ou déçu ?
1
1
135
Oof. Talk about a contradiction that proves my exact point. In other words, the series is relying on memberberries from the PJ movies is one of the show's biggest crutches and OPer basically admitted it without realizing it. For starters, appealing to PJ's trilogy to justify a scene in Amazon's show is just another form of outsourcing the worldbuilding. Even though the two productions aren't in the same continuity a show still has to establish meaning inside its own story rather than relying on viewers remembering a movie from 25 years ago. Second, and more importantly, OP completely misreads what Jackson's scene with Gimli actually does. Jackson's films never establish any cosmic or sacred lore behind Galadriel's hair. The emotional weight of that scene has little---->nothing to do with hair lore at all and everything to do with character development. Gimli spent the entire movie openly hostile and distrustful toward elves so asking an elven queen for a humble keepsake and her graciously giving him three strands is the payoff to his personal prejudice softening. It works purely on basic human emotion without needing a single ounce of lore. Third, OP's fallback claim that the Rings of Power scene simply shows Celeborn respecting her autonomy makes zero sense on its own terms. Cutting someone's hair off during a sword fight without asking and then handing it back isn't an intuitive universal symbol of respecting autonomy. Without the external Silmarillion context about Feanor demanding her hair and being refused, a guy slicing off a lock of a woman's hair and giving it back is just weird. Also, claiming that accidentally nicking someone's hair while sparring and handing it back somehow screams respecting her autonomy is a stretch. If you don't bring in outside book lore or rely on memberberries from a better movie it's literally just a guy being polite after a practice mishap.
unavailable
4
197
A good thing to practice is when someone says they like a character who is written poorly and that's have them describe the character without just describing what they look like or what the plot has them do. You have to describe *who they are*: personality, motivations, wants, needs, how they think, etc. This could apply to Arondir. If you ask someone to describe Arondir without mentioning his appearance, his fade haircut, his puke green armor, or the plot actions he performs like catching arrows and doing martial arts flips most fans run into a brick wall since you can't describe his actual personality because he doesn't have one. He's just a stoic stone faced action figure who stares intensely into the middle distance while delivering flat and solemn dialogue. When you look at his wants, needs, and internal worldview, there's almost nothing there. His entire motivation across two seasons is simply being vaguely in love with Bronwyn, despite never seeing why they fell in love, what they actually talk about, or what shared values connect them. Once Bronwyn is killed offscreen, Arondir loses even that thin anchor and just wanders around acting as a generic sword fighter wherever the plot needs extra muscle... even surviving a fatal stabbing without it having any psychological or physical impact on him. Compare that to a well written character like Aragorn or Boromir. Even if you strip away their outfits and every single action scene they are in you can easily spend 10 minutes talking about their internal conflicts, flaws, sense of humor, insecurities, and how their worldview shapes every choice they make. With Arondir, once you take away the costume and the stunt choreography, there's literally nobody home, which is a big reason his death scene carried very little emotional weight.
THE ENDING BROKE ME! Theo k!lled Arondir by the order of Sauron without any mercy as Galadriel escapes, Theo i hate you. #TheRingsOfPower #LOTR
62
Might want to look up what whataboutism actually means. Responding directly to someone else who brought up PJ's movies isn't whataboutism, especially when my entire point is that defenders of RoP can't defend the show on its own merits without pivoting to the trilogy. Also, claiming Jackson's films had even worse internal problems without naming a single one is just a lazy dodge. And nobody said changing abundant source material gets a free pass, I literally said I criticize Jackson's missteps too. The difference comes down to basic storytelling craft. Jackson's films still worked as cohesive narratives where stakes, geography, and character motivations made sense. RoP can't even keep its own rules consistent from one episode to the next, which is why you still haven't actually defended any of the writing flaws I listed.
And PJ's movies were full of even worse internal problems. You must be an olog of highest order to accuse of whataboutism with a piece of the most blatant whataboutism in a while. In your mind, is it somehow a lesser crime to pervert things you have abundant material for?
27
When book readers celebrate a scene like Celeborn cutting Galadriel's hair as proof of how faithful the writers are to Tolkien they are doing the heavy lifting for the script by mentally importing decades of external lore that never actually exists on screen. A story has to stand on the worldbuilding it actively establishes within its own narrative as opposed to relying on a small fraction of the audience filling in the blanks from an outside textbook. Because RoP spent 0 time establishing the light of the Two Trees or why Galadriel's hair was sacred enough to deny Feanor, the show didn't earn that moment at all. Basically thebsake fans aren't praising good storytelling in the show itself, they're just rewarding the writers for dangling a recognizable reference in front of them projecting the depth and history of Tolkien's books onto a scene that's completely empty on its own.
unavailable
1
2
162
NamedAfterMyDad retweeted
Replying to @LostHistory9
It's funny, they're killing off the "filler" characters, which would be fine except some of them were barely in the show anyway so it's very hard to really feel it in the way you ought to.
1
2
210
Watching someone try to defend the idea that Nazi Germany was capitalist by pointing to business ledgers and empty property titles is painful. They lean entirely on textbook semantics and academic buzzwords like "authoritarian capitalism" (which they refuse to define), completely ignoring the basic mechanics of how an economy actually functions. When a totalitarian state holds absolute veto power over what you produce, what you charge, and where you buy your materials, keeping a nominal title means nothing. It's just state command with a fresh coat of paint. The whole confusion stems from a fundamental refusal to understand structural economics. They think that as long as wage labor and exchange exist on paper, you have capitalism, which completely breaks the definition. By that logic, ancient slave plantations and feudal manors were just early free markets. They wave away the Gestapo, universal price fixing, and forced acquisitions as minor administrative details, missing the point that a command economy where the state dictates every resource allocation is socialism under a different name. The best part is watching them try to dodge their own evidence. They bring up Nuremberg documents to look rigorous, but completely sweep under the rug the explicit anti private property and anti capitalist blueprints baked right into the Nazi party platform. When you corner them on their vague definitions and ask them to establish boundary conditions that don't accidentally include feudalism, they just accuse you of cherrypicking and ask how much longer they have to do this. They can't defend the logic, so they ultimately try to pack up and walk away.
unavailable
1
41
No, I'd actually argue reality is basically the opposite. The more I find myself becoming aware of the people behind the camera (or behind the animation, as it were), the less immersed I am in the story. A great film is one where I'm totally bought in on the characters and I follow them through the story because I'm engaged with them in a way comparable to the way I would engage with a friend. For instance, when I watched The Whale, I wasn't sitting there thinking about Brendan Fraser or Darren Aronofsky, I was just immersed in the story of this guy named Charlie who was failing to reconnect with his daughter, and burning his last remaining relationship while slowly dying of a self-inflicted destruction of his own health. I rooted for him to survive. To reconnect. To get better. Even once it's clear that's not an option, I hoped he could at least find peace and make amends. If I sat there really paying attention to Fraser's decisions as an actor, or Aronofsky's decisions as a director, I wouldn't have been immersed in the story. Now... As a filmmaker myself, I can kind of do both (I can't really avoid it), but what that normally means is that I'm *more* attuned to what's happening behind the camera than most people so I especially appreciate it when a story is so good that I'm transfixed by it instead of thinking about the techniques involved, that's usually a sign of an exceptional film. All this is to say, the techniques directors and performers use to get to the final result aren't particularly relevant to most audiences. The audience cares about how they feel when they experience the story. AI is often too stilted and inconsistent to induce people to immerse themselves into a long-form story, but it's just a tool. And it will get there.
So much of cinema's power comes from believing that theres another human mind on the other side of the screen conversing with you. Someone who made hundereds small, big, deliberate, specific choices in every single frame. The tragedy of AI art isn't even that it looks bad, it's that it forces you to become a skeptic. The moment you start wondering if a gesture, a certain pacing, a duration of pause was intentional or just a program hallucinating, calculating probabilities,...the immersion dies, the magic disappears.
2
1
6
395
You're a good man, Arthur Morgan.
66
Who's gonna tell this guy that this isn't how good storytelling works?
Replying to @RealMOlaleye
They literally announced that Avengers: Endgame will be re-released in September and will have added scenes explaining Doom and Doomsday. Again, y’all should legit chill.
2
71
NamedAfterMyDad retweeted
Yeah, Luke didn't need help. The Jedi Academy was going well. Ben turned out to be a great student. And Palpatine was long dead and not secretly still alive. Luke's life was going along great.
Or maybe they visit those who need help? Anakin had no relationship with his son. He spent a few hours with him until he died unlike Ahsoka. But carry on with your shitty YouTuber grift.
5
9
132
2,688
NamedAfterMyDad retweeted
"By the way, have you heard from your son recently?" "I'm sure he's fine."
First look at Anakin and Ahsoka in ‘AHSOKA’ Season 2.
25
108
1
3,591
73,965
Not really, no.
Are you guys enjoying every sanctimonious douchebag who lectured you about Covid, bend themselves into pretzels trying to defend Fauci
1
4
10
308
If you think that the debate is between people who want "affordable food" and those who want it to be expensive, you are not only utterly incorrect, you are also a blithering idiot who isn't cut out for discussions about public policy. *EVERYONE* wants food to be affordable, high quality, accessible, and so forth. The disagreement is not about intent. It is about which policies will actually lead to the desired result, and which will not. Mamdani's will not. They never have, and never will.
Mamdani: I want people to be able to afford to eat. MAGA:
1
3
158
This is a real pet peeve of mine. People who disagree with communism often throw it a bone by saying "it works in theory, just not in practice" or "it sounds good but doesn't work" or even "right ideas, wrong species". No. No, no, no. 1. It does *not* work in theory! It's incoherent nonsense, and it is a hellish nightmare in practice. 2. Destroying crucial incentives for wealth building and innovation while obliterating market signals in order to empower a centralized bureaucracy to take everyone's stuff and dictate what people are allowed to buy, trade, or sell... what they can do for a living... what they're allowed to own... which businesses succeed or fail, etc., sounds goddamn awful in every respect. It's a totalitarian bureaucratic horrorshow straight out of the movie Brazil, but with way more starvation. And... 3. No species on the planet has ever or will ever be able to make communism work. No, not even ants. Wrong ideas. Wrong planet. Wrong reality.
Completely agree with Rubio and have for years: Communism does not “sound good in theory.” It sounds bloody awful. nitter.cf/JoelWBerry/status/2077…
2
1
13
704
Replying to @UnwelcomeTruth1
What of Rand have you actually read?
1
7
109